Scribd
Upload
2 views

Chapter 15 - Mixed Economic System

A mixed economic system combines private sector and government roles in economic decision-making, balancing market efficiency with social welfare. Governments intervene through maximum and minimum price controls, taxation, subsidies, regulation, privatization, nationalization, and direct provision to correct market failures. While such interventions can reduce inequality and ensure public goods, they may also lead to inefficiencies, unintended consequences, and high administrative costs.

Uploaded by

aadya.chakravorty
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
2 views

Chapter 15 - Mixed Economic System

A mixed economic system combines private sector and government roles in economic decision-making, balancing market efficiency with social welfare. Governments intervene through maximum and minimum price controls, taxation, subsidies, regulation, privatization, nationalization, and direct provision to correct market failures. While such interventions can reduce inequality and ensure public goods, they may also lead to inefficiencies, unintended consequences, and high administrative costs.

Uploaded by

aadya.chakravorty
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 8

Chapter 15: Mixed Economic System

Definition: A mixed economic system is one where both the private sector and the
government play a role in economic decision-making. It combines elements of a
market economy (private ownership, profit motive) and a planned economy
(government intervention to correct market failures).

Key Features:

-​ Private firms produce most goods and services, but the government regulates
and provides essential services
-​ Prices are mostly determined by market forces, but the government may
subsidize, tax, or control prices to correct imbalances.
-​ Aims to balance efficiency and social welfare by allowing competition while
addressing inequalities.

Government Intervention: Maximum & Minimum Prices in Product and Labour Markets

Governments intervene in markets to fix market failures by setting maximum and


minimum prices in both product and labour markets. These interventions help
protect consumers, producers, and workers while ensuring fair and efficient
economic outcomes.

1. Maximum Price (Price Ceiling)

A maximum price is a legally set upper limit on the price of a good or service,
preventing firms from charging beyond that level.

Why:

-​ To make essential goods/services affordable


-​ To prevent monopolies from exploiting consumers with high prices.

Eg:

-​ Rent controls (limits on how much landlords can charge for housing).
-​ Caps on life-saving drugs to ensure accessibility.
-​ Food price controls during crises to prevent inflation.

Impact & Problems:

1.​ Consumers benefit from lower prices.


2.​ Reduces inequality, making essentials more accessible.

1.​ Excess demand & shortages (Low prices encourage demand but discourage
supply)
2.​ Black markets may emerge, as sellers illegally charge higher prices.

I’m too lazy to draw the graph online, so here’s one I found online:
2. Minimum Price (Price Floor)

A minimum price is a legally set lower limit that prevents prices from falling
below a certain level.

Why:

-​ To protect producers from very low prices.


-​ To ensure workers earn a fair wage.

Eg:

-​ Minimum wage laws in labour markets to ensure fair pay.


-​ Agricultural price floors to support farmers (e.g., guaranteed minimum price
for wheat).
-​ Alcohol price controls to discourage excessive consumption.

Impact & Problems:

1.​ Producers/workers benefit from higher incomes


2.​ Prevents exploitation of workers and farmers

1.​ Excess supply & unemployment – Higher wages may discourage hiring,
causing job losses.
2.​ Government intervention needed to buy surplus goods or support
unemployed workers.

I’m too lazy to draw the graph online, so here’s one I found online:
Maximum & Minimum Prices in Labour Markets

Labour markets also face price controls:

-​ Minimum wage (price floor) ensures fair worker pay.


-​ Wage caps (price ceiling) may limit executive salaries in public sectors.

Effects:

1.​ Higher wages improve living standards but may cause unemployment.
2.​ Low wage caps prevent excessive inequality but may discourage skilled
workers from entering certain professions.

Government Measures to Correct Market Failure

1.​ Taxation
-​ Used to discourage goods with negative externalities (e.g., pollution,
smoking).
-​ Helps internalize external costs by making firms/consumers pay for damage.
-​ Generates revenue for government services.

Egs: Carbon tax, cigarette tax, congestion charges.


Issues: Can be regressive, difficult to set the right level.

2.​ Subsidies
-​ Encourages production/consumption of goods with positive externalities
(e.g., education, healthcare).
-​ Reduces costs for firms and consumers.

Egs: Solar panel subsidies, education grants, vaccine programs.

Issues: Expensive for the government, can lead to overreliance.

3.​ Regulation
-​ Sets legal limits to control harmful activities.
-​ Ensures quality, safety, and fair competition.

Egs: Pollution caps, labour laws, consumer protection.

Issues: High enforcement costs may discourage business growth.

4.​ Privatisation
-​ Transfers state-owned enterprises to private ownership.
-​ Aims to improve efficiency and reduce government burden.

Egs: Air India sale, telecom sector liberalization.

Issues: Risk of profit-driven exploitation, essential services may become


expensive.

5.​ Nationalisation
-​ Government takes control of key industries to ensure public welfare.
-​ Prevents monopolistic abuse and ensures affordability.

Egs: Public transport, healthcare systems

Issues : Can be inefficient, costly for taxpayers.


6.​ Direct Provision
-​ Government directly provides essential goods/services.
-​ Ensures accessibility and affordability for all citizens.

Egs: Public schools, government hospitals, national rail services.

Issues: Can strain government budgets, lack of competition may lower quality.

Effectiveness of Government Intervention in Correcting Market Failures

Strengths of Government Intervention -

1.​ Corrects Externalities


-​ Taxes on negative externalities (e.g., carbon tax) reduce harmful activities.
-​ Subsidies for positive externalities (e.g., education, renewable energy)
promote beneficial activities.

2.​ Reduces Income Inequality


-​ Progressive taxation helps redistribute wealth.
-​ Welfare programs (e.g., unemployment benefits, healthcare) support
low-income groups.

3.​ Ensures Public Goods Provision


-​ Direct provision of essential services (education, healthcare, infrastructure).
-​ Prevents under-provision by the private sector.

4.​ Prevents Monopoly Power


-​ Anti-trust laws and regulations promote fair competition.
-​ Price controls on necessities prevent consumer exploitation.
5.​ Stabilizes the Economy
-​ Monetary and fiscal policies control inflation and unemployment.
-​ Government spending boosts demand during economic downturns.

Limitations of Government Intervention -

1.​ Government Failure


-​ Poorly designed policies can worsen inefficiencies (eg: excessive subsidies
creating dependency).
-​ Bureaucracy and corruption may reduce effectiveness.

2.​ High Administrative Costs


-​ Implementing and enforcing regulations require significant resources.
-​ Misallocation of funds can lead to inefficiency.

3.​ Unintended Consequences


-​ Price controls may create shortages or black markets.
-​ High taxes may discourage investment and productivity.

4.​ Political Influence


-​ Policies may favor certain industries or interest groups rather than the public
good. {Plenty of case studies to choose from but one’s the 2G spectrum
scam from 2008)
Private sector Public Sector

Ownership Government-controlled Individuals, firms, and


corporations

Main Aim Welfare and economic Profit maximization and


stability efficiency

Sources of Funds Taxes, government Private investments,


borrowing, state sales revenue, loans
revenues

Spending Priorities Public goods (like Consumer goods,


infrastructure, capital investment,
healthcare, education, innovation
defence)

Decision Makers Influenced by Market-driven based on


government policies supply and demand
and social needs

Accountability Subject to public Accountable to


scrutiny, audits, and shareholders and
regulations consumers

Efficiency May suffer from Generally, more


bureaucracy and cost-efficient and
inefficiency profit-oriented

You might also like