ROHIT RAJ ( 20201BAL097) DISSERTATION
ROHIT RAJ ( 20201BAL097) DISSERTATION
INTRODUCTION
This research project looks into different elements of child sexual abuse
treatment under the law specifically examining the POCSO Act. The core
objectives include:
2. This study examines both Indian and global legal approaches toward
child sexual abuse for the protection of children against sexual violence.
The POCSO Act of 2012 protects which rights of child victims who
experience sexual abuse in India at what level of effectiveness?
2.The courts and law enforcement along with other stakeholders need to
address what obstacles stand in the way of implementing provisions from
the POCSO Act.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Definition of a Child
Different international organizations have committed to developing a
whole understanding of Child Sexual Abuse. UNICEF proposes a widely
regarded definition describing Child Sexual Abuse as any contact
between children and knowledgeable individuals who seek satisfaction of
their sexual desires. Child sexual abuse takes place when perpetrators
coerce children or deceive them or use bribery to carry out these actions
as well as making threats.
Customs of sexual assault consist of three main categories: encouraging
children into sexual displays for production of visual material and active
sexual or molesting acts between guardians and their care or in families
and adult sexual exploitation of children through prostitution and incest.
Child sexual exploitation involves the possession and distribution of
pornographic child material well as sexual acts conducted online with
minors and physical attacks against children. Such painful emotional
wounds from these actions result in trauma according to this definition.
Contrasting with child abuse, sexual assault describes all nonconsensual
sexual encounters wherein rape and other serious offenses belong.
Meaning of Child Abuse:
Children who are essential national human capital demonstrate optimal
development when they receive appropriate affection and proper care
and love. The reality proves to be harsh because numerous children face
different abusive forms that include physical mistreatment as well as
emotional abuse and psychological mistreatment alongside sexual
exploitation. This segment evaluates child sexual abuse (CSA) and child
pornography through a study of their legal aspects alongside how Indian
laws manage this severe concern. The worldwide acknowledgment of
child sexual abuse and sexual harassment issues still meets resistance
due to social reluctance and cultural constraints that block conversations
about them. The silence about this issue in society grows worse because
of Indian laws that were not thorough enough combined with weak
punitive sanctions across the country.
Nature of Child Abuse:
Child abuse represents an exploitative teaching because it attacks the
basic rights of children to experience safety and protectorate and
nurturing care. Child abuse appears in different forms so its expressions
depend greatly on social conditions together with cultural customs and
family background. Gaslighting alongside physical attacks and
psychological coercion makes up any harmful action toward a child that
threatens their physical condition or mental stability or growth progress.
Children suffer from abuse when their fundamental rights encounter
violation through both Indian Constitutional and United Nations
Convention on the Rights of the Child frameworks. Child abuse
represents both an illegal action that produces lasting psychological and
emotional wounds which impair children from thriving in society.
Child abuse occurs through systematic action that abusive individuals
with power over children inflict against them including guardians and
teachers or employers as well as parents. Hidden forms of abuse like
emotional neglect alongside psychological manipulation have comparable
detrimental impacts on child development while decreasing the child's
potential success. The obscured characteristics of certain abuse types
create detectability challenges for both society and institutions therefore
demanding them to implement preventative strategies for abuse
recognition.
1
Government of India, National Policy for Children, Ministry of Women and Child Development, 2013.
Among all factors that trigger child abuse incidents parental conduct
together with their life conditions function as the primary significant
causes. People who encountered abuse or neglect in their childhood tend
to continue their abusive ways because they acquired abusive
behavioural patterns. Such parents often do not have suitable parenting
abilities leading to poor supervision together with harsh punishment
approaches and misconduct. The presence of mental health conditions
together with substance abuse issues or pressure in caregivers increases
the likelihood of their abusive behaviour.
1.3.2 Psychological Factors
The occurrence of child abuse heavily depends on psychological
elements. Adults living with mental health disorders including depression
and anxiety or personality disorders often experience difficulties
controlling their emotional and behavioural responses because of which
they exhibit angry or aggressive behaviours. Because they lack
understanding and sympathy for child needs abusive measures occur.
When parents lack proper mental health treatment, they might resort to
using extreme force or emotional abandonment toward their child's
crying or disobeying behaviours.
1.3.3 Societal and Cultural Norms
A combination of existing cultural values and socio-cultural beliefs
maintains child abuse as a widespread issue. Accepting particular
disciplinary methods and child-rearing methods exists as an established
practice throughout different communities. Communities also view these
practices as essential for managing children 2. The practice of physical
discipline as a method to enforce child obedience might transform into
abusive conduct according to societal norms in various cultures. Family
customs that place value on authority respect and family reputation may
approve abusive practices when such actions serve as disciplinary
measures for social control.
Social practices that discriminate against women make a vital
contribution to child abuse occurring in our world. The suppression of
women along with gender-based physical violence across various regions
worldwide causes these regions' female population to become
disproportionately exposed to exploitation and abuse. Girls face
increased risks of physical and sexual abuse at locations where rights
discrimination exists or patriarchal structures rule.
2
International Labour Organization (ILO), Child Labour: Global Estimates 2020, Trends and the Road Forward, Geneva, 2021.
Poverty serves as a leading factor which motivates child abuse incidents.
When economic hardship affects families, they cannot supply their
children with food clothing shelter and quality education and health care
becomes out of reach. When finances remain unstable people tend to feel
stressed out which makes violent behaviour and negligent behaviour and
discord more likely. Children residing in these situations face greater
risks of abusive situations that require them to work since economic
needs push them toward employment.
1.3.5 Lack of Awareness and Education
The absence of understanding about children's privileges and suitable
childcare skills and harmful consequences of abusive practices leads to
accidental abuse. When human rights of children receive insufficient
attention in civil society it becomes common to accept abusive behaviour
and ineffective parent education. Lack of parenting skills due to
insufficient knowledge means some caregivers find it necessary to use
corporal punishment despite its harmful nature.
1.3.6 Environmental Factors
Children who grow up in homes marked by abuse and neglect and
unstable or violent situations face an increased danger of becoming
victims of abuse. When domestic violence or substance abuse exists in
homes it haemorrhages into child neglecters and physical abusers of
children. Children taken care of in institutions or foster care settings face
increased danger of neglect and abuse because agencies lack proper
supervision systems and insufficient training for their caregivers.
3
Committee on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), General Comment No. 13 (2011): The Right of the Child to Freedom from All
Forms of Violence.
1.4.1 Child Labour
Working children endure labour activities which eliminate their
development phases thus blocking their education and drive them into
destitution. Children performing labour find themselves in dangerous
environments which leads to abusive situations mainly within mining and
agriculture sectors and textile industries and household work settings.
Children who work in these environments must perform extended hours
under perilous environments which threatens their bodily safety. Child
labour deprives children of their right to education which prevents their
personal development and causes their families to remain trapped in
poverty. The participation of children in labour-linked activities increases
their risk of sexual abuse and manipulation and emotional mistreatment.
1.4.2 Sexual Exploitation
Children suffer sexual mistreatment as the gravest form of exploitation
when others benefit from forced sexual activities with child victims. Child
prostitution together with child pornography and online exploitation are
among numerous sexual abuse practices included in this definition.
Several situations may cause children to become victims of sexual
violence or sexual abuse from adults or adult traffickers. Sexual
exploitation among children induces enduring adverse mental health
effects together with self-esteem decline and impaired trust building
capacity. This practice breaks fundamental rights of children by denying
their right to dignity alongside protection and control over their own
body.
1.4.3 Trafficking and Smuggling
Child trafficking constitutes an exploitative practice which involves
moving children illegally through national borders to force them into
work or sex work or recruit them for war activities. Most children who
become victims of trafficking experience forced separation from their
homes before suffering cruel treatment. Organizations subject children to
work in three specific sectors: industrial facilities, commercial sex
industry and public panhandling. Trafficking deprivates children of their
rights before subjecting them to severe physical as well as psychological
abuse.
Children who become smuggled through criminal operations face
exploitation since they are easily vulnerable to abuse by both traffickers
and criminal groups.
1.4.4 Child Marriage
Through arranged unions or forced marriages adults can verify children
who are younger than eighteen in marriage scenarios which are
commonly known as child marriage. Child marriages are primarily
sustained by cultural habits together with economic scarcity throughout
Asian and African territories. The marriage of children primarily targets
girls because families use this practice to obtain dowries or reduce their
financial strain. The child’s physical and psychological well-being faces
significant harm during child marriage since this practice restricts their
personal development and educational opportunities and their right to
freedom. Early pregnancy as well as domestic violence and sexual abuse
subject these children to long-lasting detrimental outcomes.
1.4.5 Early or Forced Pregnancy
Existing societies where child marriage occurs face frequent cases of
early pregnancies. The medical complications resulting from young girls'
pregnancy pose risks to baby and child even though the women involved
are physiologically immature at this stage. Health risks emerge from
early pregnancy which results in maternal mortality together with
childbirth injuries and enduring medical complications. Child marriage
creates barriers that stop young persons from finishing their studies and
personal growth which decreases their future options.
1.4.6 Use in Armed Conflicts
Child protection organizations frequently observe the recruitment of
children into armed conflicts for various duties including soldiering
functions as well as spying duties and delivering messages and combat
duties. Under military service children must endure severe psychological
injuries while constantly enduring physical abuse through systematic
violations of their fundamental human rights. The forces of conflict break
children from their family by violence or trafficking to perform hand-to-
hand combat in which they suffer abuse while starving and being
attacked. Children who participate in armed conflicts permanently lose
their chance to develop into fully matured adults while also being denied
educational opportunities along with their basic safety rights which
results in lasting emotional damage. The children become tools of
violence through specialized training that deprives them of
comprehension about the complete results of their ordered actions.
States maintain multiple roles for child care and protection while
legislation serves the fundamental purpose of protecting children from
abuse or neglect or exploitation. The state must provide specific
fundamental services like healthcare and education and nutrition
fundamentals for proper child development.
Few nations have signed the United Nations Convention on the Rights of
the Child (CRC) yet actual enforcement remains inconsistent across
different nations. The intended protective nature of legislative measures
can succeed or fail based on a mixture of government political support
and public institution capability and local authority enforcement abilities.
Child basic needs span across three intersecting areas which include
survival as well as development in addition to protection requirements.
Three main categories define these requirements.
Survival needs: Child survival and health primarily depend on basic
needs that must be met. Children need an adequate quality of
nourishment combined with drinkable water as well as proper shelter
along with suitable clothing and health services. The prevention of any
developmental harm to children from undernutrition and compromised
sanitation and health services must be prioritized. Developing nations
typically fail to address these requirements which leads to high rates of
infant deaths and growth limitations alongside diseases.
Children need their survival needs met first to achieve good physical
health outcomes. Children should never lose their lives due to
preventable diseases or malnutrition which is why all children need
appropriate access to nutrition and healthcare and clean water supplies.
Children from disadvantaged backgrounds together with those living in
rural areas encounter significant hurdles when trying to access proper
services resulting in high child mortality rates. India's government
launched MDM and ICDS feeding schemes to address this need for
proper nutrition services. These projects deliver children essential
nutritional food and well-balanced dietary options. These schemes also
include access to health care services in addition to immunizations and
social welfare programs. The implementation of better water sanitation
protocols has been recognized to contribute to reducing child deaths
caused by preventable diseases.
Educational tools form the most powerful weapon through which poverty
cycles get broken to create better life possibilities for children.
Both schools and caregivers alongside community-oriented services need
to collaborate in building adultism-related mental health and
collaborative capabilities for students.
The National Policy for Children received official approval of the Union
Cabinet on April 18th 2013 to enable children-oriented coding and
programming in all territories of India. The policy establishes children as
individual beings who deserve dignity through self-directed development.
All National State and Local governments must follow the shared
principles presented in the Policy for their programs and activities
toward children.
The Policy declared how the Government will deliver on its promise to
achieve full child rights throughout the nation. The policy states that all
individuals under eighteen qualify as children with childhood being an
essential life stage that deserves dedicated value protection through
multi-sectoral long-term sustainable plans which focus on integration and
inclusiveness.
Recognises that:
1.Any person younger than eighteen years falls under the definition of a
child.
2.The lifespan value of childhood remains essential to human
development
3. Different groups of children have distinct requirements which demand
distinct answers because their vulnerabilities develop through multiple
dimensions based on their particular circumstances.
4. A combination of long-term strategies from multiple sectors with
sustainability and inclusion in mind ensures proper development and
protection of children.
Reaffirms that:
The fundamental right to life together with personal liberty exists under
Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. Courts in India employ a wide
interpretation of this Article that led to recognizing many additional child
protection rights. Every aspect of dignified living as well as school
enrolment and medical services and safety from harm and abuse fall
under the umbrella of life rights.
•Article 39(e): Under this provision the state must take steps to prevent
children from being placed into dangerous or morally damaging work
opportunities. Labor protection works to shield children from exploitation
and child labor in addition to protecting them from physical and mental
harm induced by work. The constitutional protection established by this
right allows for the Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act of
1986 and the subsequent Juvenile Justice Act to be established.
Article 45: Every child has a constitutional right to access early
childhood care services along with education. Through Article 45 the
State holds responsibility to supply cost-free and essential education to
children younger than 14 years combined with early childhood care and
education services. The Constitution initially contained this guiding
principle as part of its Constitution that subsequently evolved into the
Right to Education Act (RTE) 2009 which established children's
fundamental right to education from ages six to fourteen.
The POCSO Act provides complete coverage to deal with sexual abuse of
children through proper court establishment for case trials. The key
features embraced by the Act include:
The court system follows In-Camera Trials based on the provisions of the
POCSO Act. The courtroom remains closed to anyone except involved
parties during trial proceedings to protect the privacy of the child and
their rights.
The BNS Act, 2023 covers child abuse and exploitation and violence
through a unified legislation. The law establishes a protective legal
structure for children that helps existing legislation address gaps which
endanger their safety. The Act integrates two essential objectives from
different important laws including the Protection of Children from Sexual
Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012 both as it strengthens child protection and
adds new security measures.
Under the BNS Act, 2023 it is required that child welfare together with
their rehabilitation must start following any case of abuse.
The district wing child protection service canters offered children shelter
along with comprehensive services including medical services as well as
counselling and legal support and rehabilitation programs inside one
location.
The BNS Act 2023 creates Child Protection Units within state and district
law enforcement to provide specific services for child-friendly sexual
abuse investigations and trials. The units must fulfil the following duties:
The SPECIALIZED handling of child sexual abuse cases falls under the
jurisdiction of these specialized units These units train their personnel to
handle sensitive child cases in order to conduct investigations which
minimize the victim's trauma.
- Fast-tracking investigation and trial: Fast-track courts collaborate with
CPUs through an operational partnership to complete sexual abuse cases
in a prompt manner. The Act requires that investigations be completed
within a set timeframe because delaying action would prevent victims
from obtaining justice.
The Act gives online exploitation prevention a superior position. The Act
requires online platforms to be regulated as a measure to stop child
sexual abuse material from being transmitted or viewed. The removal
process of these harmful contents needs to be part of social media
companies and digital platforms' institutional responsibilities.
The Act advocates for monitoring systems which parents can implement
to supervise their children's online activities. The legislation promotes
the development of systems which offer parents the capacity to supervise
their children's online conduct and obtain protective measures against
digital risks such as online predators and cyber bullying and
inappropriate content.
3.4. ROLE OF SOCIETY AND NON -GOVERNMENT
ORGANIZATION
Demographic Overview
5
Ministry of Labour and Employment, National Child Labour Project, Govt. of India, 2021.
that handle child protective situations involving exploitation and abuse
and neglect.
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child stands as the
most detailed international document that establishes child rights in the
normative framework. It defines a child as any person under the age of
eighteen with an exception for countries where the age of majority
occurs sooner. The Convention specifies children possess civil, political,
economic, social and cultural rights that include education rights besides
health access and protection from exploitation and the right to
participation and access to a secure environment.
Another safety net against sexual exploitation can be found through the
Optional Protocol to the Sale of Children, Child Prostitution, and Child
Pornography (2000) alongside the CRC. It covers three broad issues:
1. Sold children are protected under this agreement along with illegal
adoptions and sexual exploitation.
2. Under the scope of child prostitution falls both sexual exploitation
under scope of sex tourism and any other type of child exploitation.
3. The making or selling or using child pornography constitutes one form
of exploitation that harms children.
The convention sets standards for the elimination of harmful child labour
activities including human trafficking and child prostitution along with
slavery and child pornography and dangerous work. A series of required
actions to eliminate the worst forms of labour and punish perpetrators
was instituted by this convention for states that choose to ratify it.
4.1 INTRODUCTION
The Indian judicial system has proven itself through time by actively
working to protect child rights. In Indian legal terminology judicial
activism refers to courts creating new legislation using landmark
decisions that implement constitutional rights.
This chapter examines special court powers under the POCSO Act
together with judicial orders that protect children's welfare while
preserving their dignity. This chapter evaluates Indian Courts'
interpretation of child protection laws through landmark judgments to
determine if Courts have performed adequately within their
constitutional authority.
2. CONVENTION OF RIGHTS
An instrument dealing with the rights of children and the most
comprehensive and globally accepted is the United Nations Convention
on the Rights of the Child ,1989. It is almost universally feeling that the
term "rights" should stand in for all positive declarations regarding child
protection and welfare.
UNCRC contains 54 articles and two Optional Protocols covering child-
welfare issues. The underlying principals are non-discrimination (Article
2), the best interests of the child (Article 3), the right to life, survival and
development (Article 6), and the right to be heard (Article 12). To
understand and take action on the sexual abuse of children.
Article 19, inter alia, requires state parties to protect children from all
forms of physical or mental violence, injury or abuse, neglect or negligent
treatment, maltreatment or exploitation, including sexual abuse, through
appropriate legislative, administrative, social, and educational measures.
This Article equips states to prepare preventive and rehabilitative
schemes for children who are vulnerable.
Article 34 of the Convention offers direct protection against sexual abuse
and obliges the State Parties to safeguard the child from any form of
sexual exploitation and sexual abuse; this includes using the child in
prostitution or in any unlawful sexual practices or in pornographic
performances and pornographic materials. The Convention also attaches
importance to the rehabilitation and reintegration of child victims. Article
39 states that child victims of exploitation and abuse shall receive
appropriate treatment for recovery, including physical and psychological
treatment and social reintegration; this provision has inspired the
development of several national rehabilitation programs and schemes for
compensation in the member States.
One of the strengths of the term UNCRC has actually been considered its
child-cantered approach, which contrasts with seeing the child as merely
an object of protection and, in other words, as sustaining individual
rights. This conceptual change, therefore, has catalysed legislative and
policy change in many jurisdictions toward domestic laws whose
principles adhere to the Convention.
OTHER MEASURES:
Education functions as an essential method to prevent child sexual abuse
incidents from occurring. A vital concept requires family and community
education to stop child sexual abuse incidents. People responsible for
child protection need to maintain full awareness of their rights as well as
the requirements to protect children who face disadvantages. Many
families lack understanding about parental responsibilities alongside
child responsibilities because of education illiteracy combined with
insufficient resources. These communities would have exercised better
child rights protection if they acquired sufficient sensitivity to those
rights.
Collaborating for Child Well-being: Children's collective welfare
requires joint action by governmental bodies and law enforcement
agencies along with educational establishments and parents alongside
community members. Children need education together with healthcare
and safety coverage to achieve equal opportunities for growth. These
benefits appear possible only through collaborative action.
Awareness for Breaking the Silence: The society must raise its
awareness about child sexual abuse to break down existing silence
around this issue. Societal engagement with child abuse requires formal
education campaigns as the first priority for changing public attitudes.
Despite passing laws the government faces implementation challenges
because the public mindsets require transformation. Through programs
and laws, the government educates people about their rights and
government assistance schemes while maximizing the allocation of child
protection funds.
The application of laws must remain steady while agents responsible for
enforcing these laws demonstrate consistent discipline. These laws
require strict enforcement to protect children correctly. The execution of
laws in India faces major obstacles because legal offenders often receive
protection from punishment. The implementation of stringent laws by the
government faces strong resistance from both practical enforcement
measures and their operational application in real child rights contexts.
The protection of children falls to both their parents and their teachers.
Children receive protection from sexual exploitation and abuse through
their parents and teachers. Parents need to create an environment of
healthy thoughts and actions to foster a child's growth into a mature and
emotionally complete individual. School-age children require education in
morality to transform them into ethical responsible individuals. Teachers
together with parents work to create environments that ensure children's
health and safety throughout their developmental years.
• Awareness workshops: Through the program 'Good Touch Bad Touch'
children will master essential knowledge about sexual abuse together
with predator recognition accompanied by parental trust when abuse
actually happens.
Media plays an essential role in teaching society about these matters.
Through its coverage and publicity, the media must inform society about
laws protecting children while spreading awareness about child abuse
and sexual offenses including the POCSO Act which empowers public
knowledge. Under the POCSO Act the media must protect children's
privacy by seeking court authorization before revealing their identity.
Several Organizations Must Collaborate to Protect Children Each Year.
Children require total community commitment to achieve well-being
safety and growth opportunities. Joint efforts by law enforcement
agencies together with the government and education providers and
parents and community members must unite to extend quality education
along with safety and healthcare and social prospects for children to
achieve fulfilment.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
A. PRIMARY SOURCES
1. Statute
o The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012
(POCSO Act)
o Indian Penal Code, 1860 (as amended)
o The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act,
2015
o Constitution of India (Relevant Articles: 14, 15, 21, 21A, 23,
24, 39, 45, and 47).
2. Commission Report
B. SECONDARY SOUCES
1. Books
2. Journal
1. Indian Journal of Criminology
2. Journal of Indian Law Institute
3. Child Abuse & Neglect – The International Journal
4. Economic and Political Weekly (EPW)
5. Indian Bar Review
6. International Journal of Children’s Rights
7. Law and Society Review
8. Asia-Pacific Journal on Human Rights and the Law
9. Journal of South Asian Human Rights
10. NUJS Law Review
3. Articles
4. Magazines
5. Newspapers
6. Google
1. WEBLIOGRAPHY
ANNEXURES
ROHIT RAJ
SCHOOL OF LAW,
PRESIDENCY UNIVERSITY, YELAHANKA,
ITGALPURA BANGALORE-560054
(2020-2025)