Pearson Edexcel a Level Economics a Fifth Edition Sample Pages 9781398374713
Pearson Edexcel a Level Economics a Fifth Edition Sample Pages 9781398374713
Contents
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vi
iv Contents
Contents v
ME 1
THE INTRODUCTION
TO MARKETS AND
MARKET FAILURE
Welcome to economics. Many of you opening this book will be meeting economics
for the first time, and you will want to know what is in store for you as you set out
to study the subject. This opening chapter sets the scene by introducing you to
some key ideas and identifying the scope of economic analysis. As you learn more
of the subject, you will find that economics is a way of thinking that broadens your
perspective on the world around you.
In this chapter
This chapter will introduce you to:
➜ the nature and scope of economic analysis
➜ the role of models and assumptions in economics
➜ positive and normative statements
➜ the importance of scarcity and choice
➜ the concept of opportunity cost
➜ the notion of factors of production
➜ the distinction between renewable and non-renewable resources and the idea of sustainability
➜ the production possibility frontier
➜ the concept of the division of labour
➜ how specialisation can improve productivity
➜ the role of markets and what is meant by a mixed economy
➜ alternative ways of coordinating the allocation of resources in society
➜ the distinction between microeconomics and macroeconomics
What is economics?
As its name suggests, economics deals with all aspects of economic behaviour.
It explores the way that individuals, businesses and governments take economic
decisions. For example, it highlights the factors that influence the decisions made
by households in choosing what to consume, and the decisions made by firms
about what goods and services to produce. It also examines the decisions made by
governments about taxation and expenditure.
All these decisions interact with each other — and human behaviour is not always
easy to understand — so economics faces a substantial challenge in trying to deal
with the complexity of the real world.
If economists are to cope with this complexity, it is essential to simplify reality in
Key term some way; otherwise the task would be overwhelming. Economists therefore work
model a simplified with models. These are simplified versions of reality that are more manageable for
representation of reality analysis, allowing economists to focus on some key aspects of the world.
used to provide insight into
Often this works by allowing them to focus on one thing at a time. A model almost
economic decisions and
always begins with assumptions that help economists to simplify their questions.
events
These assumptions can then be gradually relaxed so that the effect of each one of
them can be observed. In this way, economists can gradually move towards a more
complicated version of reality.
Chapter 2 considers the demand for a good, and the factors that affect how much of a
good is demanded by consumers. Trying to analyse all the possible influences on these
decisions would be difficult, so it is common to start by exploring how the price of a
good affects the quantity demanded, under the assumption that all other influences stay
the same. This is a common assumption in economics, which is sometimes expressed
by the Latin phrase ceteris paribus, meaning ‘other things being equal’. Given the
complexity of the real world, it is often helpful to focus on one thing at a time.
Key terms
Economics as a social science ceteris paribus a Latin
A question that is often raised in relation to economics as a subject is whether it can phrase meaning ‘other
be regarded as a ‘science’, given that it deals with decisions taken by human beings. things being equal’; it is
Economics attempts to study economic aspects of society using a scientific approach, used in economics when
and as such can be seen as a social science. we focus on changes in
one variable while holding
In many physical sciences, investigation can proceed by testing hypotheses in the other influences constant
laboratory through carrying out experiments. Experimental economics is a rapidly
social science a subject
expanding area in the subject, but although this allows economists to improve their
involving the scientific
understanding of individual behaviour, there are still many areas of economics
study of human beings
where it is not possible to rely on experiments to advance knowledge.
Economists can stage experiments in which they ask a sample of individuals how
they would act in various situations — for example, what they would pay for a good
or service. This can provide insights into economic behaviour. However, there are
situations in which it is simply not possible to set up an experiment. A government
cannot decide to double the rate of income tax to find out what would happen. A
firm would be wary of making a substantial increase in the price of its product just
to see what happens.
Astrophysics faces similar challenges, as it cannot move stars and planets around to
see what happens! Instead it relies on observations to develop its theories. Economics
also relies on observation and assumptions to interpret the way in which economic
Key terms decisions are taken. It then attempts to apply logic and scientific reasoning to build
on assumptions in order to explain behaviour.
positive statement a
statement about what is
(i.e. about facts) Positive and normative economic statements
normative statement a Economics aims to look at the causes and consequences of choices in an objective
statement that involves way. However, some of its subject matter requires careful attention if we are to
a value judgement about remain objective. To achieve this, it is important to be clear about the difference
what ought to be between positive and normative statements.
value judgement a In short, a positive statement is about facts and in principle is testable. A normative
statement based on your statement is about what ought to be. Another way of looking at this is that a statement
opinion or beliefs, rather becomes normative when it involves an opinion or value judgement.
than on facts
Suppose the government is considering raising the tax on cigarettes. It may
legitimately consult economists to discover what effect a higher tobacco tax will
Study tip have on the consumption of cigarettes and on government revenues. This would
Notice that the word be a positive investigation, in that the economists are being asked to use economic
‘positive’ here is not used analysis to forecast what will happen when the tax is increased.
in the sense of being A very different situation will arise if the government asks whether it should raise
opposite to ‘negative’. the tax on cigarettes. This calls for an opinion to be expressed (a value judgement).
A positive statement that For example, a response might be to say that the tax on cigarettes ought not to be
is found to be false is raised because it discriminates against smokers. This would be a normative statement.
still a positive economic There are some words that indicate normative statements, such as ‘should’ or ‘ought
statement, as it is a to’ — watch for these.
statement about facts.
Most of this book is about positive economics. However, you should be aware that
positive analysis is often called upon to inform normative judgements. If the aim
Synoptic link of a policy is to stop people from smoking (which reflects a normative judgement
The effect of a tax on about what ought to happen), then economic analysis may be used to highlight the
cigarettes is examined in strengths and weaknesses of those alternatives in a purely positive fashion.
Chapter 5. Critics of economics often joke that economists always disagree with one another:
for example, it has been said that if you put five economists in a room together,
Test yourself 1.2 they will come up with at least six conflicting opinions. However, although
economists may arrive at different value judgements, and have differences when
Is the following statement
it comes to normative issues, there is much greater agreement when it comes to
a normative or a
positive analysis. Nonetheless, value judgements do influence economic decision
positive statement? ‘The
making and policy because different people — and political parties — may have
government ought to raise
different views about what is desirable for society, even if they agree on how
unemployment benefits.’
policies may work.
Economic agents
In analysing the process by which choices are made, it is important to be aware of
the various economic agents that are responsible for making decisions. In economic
analysis, there are three key groups of decision makers: consumers, producers and
government.
■ Consumers (individuals and households) make choices about their expenditure.
In this role, they are consumers who demand goods and services. In order to be
able to buy goods, consumers need income, so they also take decisions about the
supply of their labour, which is discussed in the next section.
■ Producers (firms or businesses) exist in order to produce output of goods or
services. Producers also make choices, particularly about which goods or services
to produce, and the techniques of production to be used. The prices at which they
can sell are also important in economic analysis. Firms also have a dual role, as
they need to purchase machines and raw materials if they are to produce goods
and services.
■ Government fulfils several roles in society. It undertakes expenditure, and influences
the economy through its taxation and regulation of markets.
Opportunity cost is crucial for each of these economic agents, because they each
face constraints on their choices. As soon as they choose one course of action, they
forgo the possibility of taking an alternative decision.
Factors of production
People in a society play two quite different roles. On the one hand, they are the
consumers, the ultimate beneficiaries of the process of production. On the other
Key term
hand, they are a key part of the production process in that they are instrumental in factors of production
producing goods and services by supplying labour. The production process requires resources used in the
not only labour but other resources as well. These productive resources are known production process;
as the factors of production. The main types are outlined in Table 1.1. inputs into production,
particularly including
Table 1.1 The factors of production labour, capital, land and
enterprise
Labour The most obvious human resource, labour is a key input into production.
There are many different types of labour, encompassing different skill levels
and working in different ways, from unskilled labourers to web designers or
brain surgeons.
Capital The term ‘capital’ covers inputs such as plant and machinery, transport
equipment and factory buildings.
Enterprise Enterprise is another human resource. An entrepreneur is someone who
organises production and identifies projects to be undertaken, bearing the
risk of the activity. This is an important role in the modern economy, where
firms need to be alert for market opportunities.
Management is also sometimes classified as a human resource, although it
might be seen as a particular form of labour.
Land Land covers the inputs provided by nature — both the land itself and the
natural resources that nature provides in the form of raw materials.
The way in which these inputs are combined in order to produce output is another
key part of the allocation of resources. Firms need to take decisions about the mix of
inputs used in order to produce their output. Such decisions are required no matter
what form of economic activity a firm is engaged in.
Labour Households supply their labour in return for wages and salaries. The wage is
therefore the reward for the labour services that they supply, for which they
must give up their leisure time.
Capital Interest is the return on the use of capital services. It is the return that the
firm gains from using the capital goods in the production process. In doing
this, the firm forgoes the interest that it could have gained from investing in
a financial asset.
Enterprise Profit is the reward for enterprise. By recognising income-earning opportunities
for the firm, the entrepreneur is able to make profit for the business.
Land It is the rental that constitutes the reward for the use of land in production.
Synoptic link
The decisions taken by producers are discussed later, in particular in Chapter 18, but first you
need to understand more about the behaviour of households and firms.
Exercise 1.3
With which of Samuelson’s three questions (what, how, for whom) would you associate the
following?
a A firm chooses to switch from producing laptop computers in order to increase its output of
tablet computers.
b The government reduces the highest rate of income tax.
c Faced with increased labour costs, a firm introduces labour-saving machinery.
d There is an increase in social security benefits.
e The owner of a fish-and-chip shop decides to close down and take a job in a local factory.
Maths 6
problems 5 A
4
C D
3
E
2
1
B
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Economics exercises
Figure 1.1 The production possibility frontier
The line shows the maximum combinations that Asif can tackle — which is why it is called a
‘frontier’. There is no way he can manage to be beyond the frontier (for example, at point D), as
to do 3 maths exercises and 4 economics ones would need more time than he has available.
However, he could end up inside the frontier, at a point such as E. This could happen if he
gives up, and squanders his time by watching television; that would be an inefficient use of his
resources — at least in terms of tackling his homework.
As Asif moves down the line from left to right, he is spending more time on economics and less
on maths. The opportunity cost of tackling an additional economics question is an additional
maths exercise forgone. One way of expressing this is that Asif faces a trade-off between the time
spent on economics and on maths.
A trade-off
In the example discussed in the Quantitative skills box, Asif faces a trade-off
Key term between the time spent on economics and on maths. In other words, Asif can only
trade-off a situation in spend more time on economics by spending less time on maths. He must trade off
which the choice of one one against the other. You will come across many instances of this notion as your
alternative requires the study of economics progresses.
sacrifice of another
Figure 1.2 shows how the PPF provides information about opportunity cost.
Suppose we have a farmer with 10 hectares of land who is choosing between growing
potatoes and onions. The PPF shows the combinations of the two crops that could
be produced. For example, if the farmer produces 300 tonnes of onions on part of
the land, then 180 tonnes of potatoes could be produced from the remaining land. In
Study tip
order to increase production of potatoes by 70 tonnes from 180 to 250, 50 tonnes of Diagrams are an important
onions must be given up. Thus, the opportunity cost of 70 extra tonnes of potatoes way of explaining economic
is seen to be 50 tonnes of onions. concepts, and being able
to integrate economic
diagrams into your analysis
Why might the PPF be curved? is a good way of improving
Notice that the PPF in Figure 1.2 is drawn as a curve instead of a straight line. This your understanding — and
is because the farmer’s land varies in different plots, with some plots being ideal showing examiners that
for potatoes but others being better for onions. The farmer can choose a balanced you understand!
approach, using each plot of land for the use to which it is suited. However, if he
were to choose to produce only onions (or only potatoes), overall the land would be
less productive. In other words, the more onions that are produced, the higher their Test yourself 1.9
opportunity cost in terms of potatoes (and vice versa), reflected in the way that the If a firm buys a computer
PPF gets steeper moving from left to right. to use in its production
Onions 450 process, is this an example
(tonnes) 400 of a consumer or a capital
350 good?
300
250
200
Key terms
150 capital goods goods
100 used as part of the
PPF
50 production process, such
0 as machinery or factory
0 100 200 250 300 400 500
buildings
180 Potatoes (tonnes)
consumer goods goods
Figure 1.2 Opportunity cost and the PPF
produced for present use
(consumption)
Consumption and investment
To move from thinking about an individual to thinking about an
Capital
economy as a whole, it is first necessary to simplify reality. Assume goods
an economy that produces just two types of good: capital goods and per period
consumer goods. Consumer goods are for present use, whereas capital
B
goods are to be used to increase the future capacity of the economy —
in other words, for investment. K1
A
consumer goods, it becomes more difficult to produce still more of these, whereas
those workers producing machinery find they have too few resources with which to
work. In other words, the more consumer goods are being produced, the higher is
their opportunity cost.
It is now possible to interpret points B and C. Point B is unobtainable given present
resources, so the economy cannot produce that combination of goods. This applies
Test yourself 1.10 to any point outside the PPF. On the other hand, at point C society is not using its
resources efficiently. In this position there is unemployment of some resources in the
In Figure 1.3, which
economy. By making better use of the resources available, the economy can move
labelled points represent
towards the frontier, reducing unemployment in the process. However, at any point
productively efficient
on the frontier, production is productively efficient in the sense that all resources are
positions?
being fully utilised.
PPF0 PPF1
In the initial period the production possibility frontier is at PPF 0. However,
in the following period the increased availability of capital resources enables
Consumer goods greater production, and the frontier moves to PPF1. This is a process of
per period potential economic growth, an expansion of the economy’s productive
Figure 1.4 Economic growth capacity through the increased availability of inputs. If the economy were
to go into decline, such that less output could be produced, the frontier
Key term would shift inwards.
potential economic Notice that the decision to produce more capital goods today means that fewer
growth an expansion in consumer goods will be produced today to provide more in the future.
the productive capacity of
the economy An increase in the availability of inputs is not the only way in which the PPF could
shift outwards. An increase in the way in which the inputs are used would also allow
the PPF to shift out. Such a change would be known as an increase in productivity.
Test yourself 1.11 This could happen through technical advance, for example.
Suppose that a firm
There could also be a shift inwards of the PPF if there is a reduction in the
devises a new and more
availability of inputs, or a fall in the productivity of inputs. For example, returning
cost-effective production
to the farmer’s production of onions and potatoes, if part of the land is flooded and
method. How would this
becomes unusable, then the farmer would have less land to work. If the land is over-
affect the PPF?
farmed, it could become less productive. In either case, the PPF would shift inwards.
By calculating the average level of GDP per person in a country, it is possible to derive a
measure of the average amount of resources per person — or average income per head.
Exercise 1.4
Megan has been cast away on a desert island, Coconuts
and has to survive by spending her time either per day
A
fishing or climbing trees to get coconuts. The PPF
E
in Figure 1.5 shows the maximum combinations
B
of fish and coconuts that she can gather during a
day. Which of the points A to E represents each of D
the following?
PPF
a a situation where Megan spends all her time
fishing C
This can be seen in practice in many businesses today, where there is considerable
specialisation of functions. Workers are hired for particular tasks and activities. You
do not see your star striker pulling on the goalkeeper’s jersey at half time because
he fancies a change. Earlier in the chapter, it was argued that ‘labour’ is considered
a factor of production. This idea can be developed further by arguing that there are
different types of labour, having different skills and functions.
Employees at a BMW factory. Each worker specialises in a particular task, creating an efficient
assembly line
focus on assembling the final product. Here again, specialisation enables efficiency
gains to be made.
Specialisation also takes place among nations, simply because some countries are
better equipped to produce some products than others. For example, it would not
make sense for the UK to go into commercial production of pineapples or mangoes.
There are other countries with climatic conditions that are much more suitable for
producing these products. On the other hand, many Formula 1 racing teams have
their headquarters in the UK, and there are benefits from this specialisation.
Specialisation may have disadvantages. A firm that specialises may find that it is
vulnerable in times of recession, or if it supplies another firm that encounters trading
difficulties. If this means that demand for its product falls, it may have to close down.
This might be seen as an incentive to diversify its product range so that it does not
depend so heavily on a particular activity or product.
A nation may face similar issues, especially if it chooses to specialise in a Synoptic link
product that is strategically important. For example, a country that specialises in
The possible gains from
agricultural production may find itself in difficulty if the price of its products falls
specialisation and trade
relative to other goods. If the country is highly dependent on exporting goods, or
are discussed more fully in
on importing key items, then a global disruption of trade could create problems.
Chapter 24 in the context
This was evident during the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic and the war in
of international trade.
the Ukraine.
Markets
You will find that in economics the term ‘market’ is used frequently, so it is
important to be absolutely clear about what is meant by it.
Key term
market a set of
A market need not be a physical location (although it could be — you might regard a
arrangements that allows
local farmers’ market as an example of ‘a set of arrangements that allows transactions
transactions to take place
to take place’). The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the trend towards online
shopping, meaning that everyone has become accustomed to ways of buying and
selling that do not involve direct physical contact between buyer and seller — so the
notion of an abstract market should not be too alien a concept.
In relation to a particular product, a market brings together potential buyers and
sellers. This is explored in the coming chapters.
Synoptic link
Markets are important in the process of resource allocation, with prices acting as a
The role of prices in
key signal to potential buyers and sellers. If a firm finds that it cannot sell its output
influencing resource
at the price it has chosen, this is a signal about the way that buyers perceive the
allocation is explored more
product. Price is one way that firms find out about consumers and their willingness
fully in Chapter 5.
to pay for a particular product.
Market economy
A free market economy is one in which market forces are allowed to guide the
allocation of resources within a society without intervention from government.
Prices play a key role in this sort of system, providing signals and incentives to
producers and consumers. Adam Smith argued that in such a system, resources
would be allocated effectively (and fairly) through the operation of an ‘invisible
hand’. This operates when individuals are free to pursue their own interests. Firms
would produce the goods and services that consumers wish to consume.
Synoptic link
Karl Marx argued that in a capitalist society in which there is private ownership of
The role of prices in
productive resources, the owners of capital would exploit their position at the expense
influencing resource
of labour, eventually resulting in revolution. Although this did not transpire in the way
allocation is explored in
that Marx expected, there was a move in some countries away from private ownership
Chapter 4.
of capital and towards state control of resource allocation through central planning.
Command economy
A command economy is one in which the government undertakes the coordination
Key terms
role, planning and directing the allocation of resources. Given the complexity of
modern economies, reliance on central planning poses enormous logistical problems. free market economy an
In order to achieve a satisfactory allocation of resources across the economy, the economy in which market
government needs to make decisions on thousands of individual matters. forces are allowed to guide
the allocation of resources
One example of this emerges from the experience of central planning in Russia after
the revolution in 1917. Factories were given production targets to fit in with the overall command economy
plan for the development of the economy. These targets then had to be met by the an economy in which
factory managers, who faced strong incentives to meet those targets. Factories producing decisions on resource
nails were given two sorts of target. Some factories were given a target to produce a allocation are guided by
certain number of nails, whereas others were given targets in weight terms. The former the state
responded by producing large numbers of very small nails; the latter produced a very
small number of very big nails. Neither was what the planners had in mind!
Micromanagement on this sort of scale proved costly to implement administratively.
The collapse of the Soviet bloc in the 1990s largely discredited this approach,
although a small number of countries (such as North Korea and Cuba) continue to
stick with central planning. China has moved away from pure central planning by
beginning to allow prices to be used as signals.
Incentives
Another important concept that is at the heart of economic analysis is the notion
that individuals respond to incentives. The coordination problem is handled in
Test yourself 1.14 different forms of economy through the operation of different forms of incentive
that influence decision making. In a market economy, prices and profits provide
Name one example of a
incentives, whereas in a centrally planned economy these incentives are replaced by
mixed economy.
state directives.
Exam-style questions
1.1 Nature of economics
Short-answer questions
1 The production possibility frontier can be used to illustrate the trade-off
between consumer and capital goods. An economy is currently achieving
economic efficiency.
a Economic efficiency is best illustrated by any point:(1)
A On the production possibility frontier
B Where more consumer goods are produced than capital goods
C Within the production possibility frontier
D Where more capital goods are produced than consumer goods
b Draw a fully labelled production possibility frontier diagram to illustrate
the opportunity cost of an economy producing more consumer goods. (4)
2 Economics is an example of a social science.
a As a social science, economics is least likely to involve: (1)
A Making assumptions
B Building economic models
C Making value judgements
D Conducting scientific experiments
Global wind generation rose from 1,587 to 1,814 terawatt hours between
2020 and 2021. However, many environmentalists believe the transition to
renewable energy is too slow.
b Explain what is meant by the term ‘positive statement’. (2)
c Calculate the percentage change in global wind generation between
2020 and 2021. You are advised to show your workings. (2)
Data response question: Government spending on HS2
Extract A: The rising cost of HS2
In February 2020, Boris Johnson confirmed the go-ahead for High Speed 2
(HS2). The controversial high-speed railway aims to reduce journey times
between London and cities in the Midlands and the North of England, as well as
increasing the rail network capacity.
Construction began in September 2020 and will employ 22,000 workers in its
first phase. Division of labour is crucial to the success of the project and will be
aided by the use of the most up-to-date technology. Although many of the jobs
created will be directly in the construction of the railway itself, HS2 will also
employ engineers, architects and designers.
However, there are also concerns about the increased government spending on the
HS2 project, with the cost rising from £32.7 billion in 2012 to £56 billion in 2015.
An independent review says the final bill could be as high as £106 billion. There
have also been delays during the COVID-19 pandemic due to social distancing
requirements, staff absences and problems resulting from global supply-chain
disruption.
3 a With reference to Extract A, explain how increased government
spending on the HS2 project will influence its opportunity cost. (5)
b Assess the likely benefit of using division of labour in the HS2
project. (10)
Essay question
4 According to the Index of Economic Freedom in 2022, Singapore is the
best example of a free market economy in the world. The Singaporean
economy is characterised by low levels of regulation and taxation.
Evaluate the likely benefits of scarce resources being allocated by a
free market economy, such as Singapore. Refer to at least one famous
economist in your answer. (25)