WD-23 final draft(1)
WD-23 final draft(1)
Government of India
Ministry of Railways
SPECIFICATION
FOR
FITTED WITH
WAGON DIRECTORATE
RESEARCH DESIGN & STANDARDS ORGANISATION
MANAK NAGAR, LUCKNOW-226 011
Page 1 of 15
Preamble
Indian Railway’s quest for development of Bogie mounted Brake systems (BMBS) for
Freight Stock of Indian Railways has been continuing since the year 1991. The first
attempts at indigenous BMBS systems were made by M/s Sundaram Clayton and M/s
Escorts and thereafter by RDSO. However, limitations of non-automatic slack adjusting
system as also unsafe conditions arising out of Slack adjuster being below the lower
spring plank of Bogies were noted in such trials. Thereafter in June, 2001, Railway
Board placed developmental orders on 2 sources for BMBS based on RDSO
Specification No WD-15-BMBS-2000. Further, to gain more experience and based on
RDSO’s recommendations, Railway Board, in December 2006, placed further
developmental orders on 4 Sources on RDSO Specifications WD-15-BMBS-2000(Rev
II). In December, 2008, Railway Board, following recommendations of a committee for
adoption of BMBS in IR Freight stock, decided the standardization of BMBS on basis of
which RDSO issued Specifications WD-23-BMBS-2008. RDSO was instructed to
consider approval of other designs subject to meeting requirements and submitting final
report for Board’s approval. Based on progress made on the alternate designs of the
BMBS under the Railway Board’s Developmental orders, after deliberations on the
report submitted by RDSO, it has been decided to bring about revised specifications
WD-23-BMBS-2008. This shall enable IR to consider other alternate designs of BMBS,
including those under field trials and development if and when they are successful, with
a broader multisourcing perspective.
The intent of this revision is to ensure that the private incentive for technology providers
dovetails with the overall perspective of public good. This revision has been cast with an
overall objective that the BMBS technologies adopted by IR meet the functional
requirements of braking on the Indian Railway freight stock, and yet open up avenues
for healthy cost competition amongst alternates. At the same time, keeping in view the
safety aspects of the application, rigorous regimen for indigenous capability in terms
design, manufacturing, testing and evaluation, at par with those on established
international freight Railroads, has been retained. In addition, elements, identified over a
period of time with experience, that may have restricted the broader perspective of
multisourcing in future, have been removed and/ or suitably modified.
Till now, the process of development of BMBS for Freight stock has followed a process
of adoption of proposer’s technologies. A slew of designs have been evaluated in the
process and shall be adopted for use on IR, if found successful in development and
trials. The next step would be to bring about an element of interchangeability to the
order established on other Rolling stock of Indian Railways. RDSO, in future, shall
endeavour to achieve this objective, apart from other efforts to ensure good technology
Brake products with minimum public cost implications.
Page 2 of 15
1. SCOPE
This specification covers the technical requirements of bogie mounted air brake
system (BMBS) for wagons fitted with Casnub Bogies. This specification is
applicable for fitment of BMBS during manufacturing of new wagons as well as
for retrofitment of BMBS on existing in-service wagons (with minimum axle load
of 20.32 T and maximum axle load of 22.9 T).
2.1 The bogie mounted brake system shall be suitable for existing wagons fitted with
all variants of Casnub bogies. These bogies are provided with spring plank. Other
parameters of the casnub bogies are as follows: -
1. Wheel diameter
a) New 1000mm
b) Condemning 906mm
2. Type of brake block ‘K’ type non-asbestos composition
brake block with 58mm thickness &
condemning size 10 mm
3. Brake Block Force (per wheel) 2110 Kg (±50 Kg)
2.2 General arrangement of Bogie mounted brake system shall be as per RDSO’s
drawing number WD- 08093-S/2.There will be one brake cylinder with one
double-acting slack adjuster per bogie.
2.2.1 The brake system shall be suitable for working with single/twin pipe graduated
release air brake system conforming to RDSO specification No. 02-ABR-
02(latest) except for Brake Cylinder and Automatic Brake Cylinder Pressure
Modification device (hereinafter called APM). Brake cylinder can be of
manufacturer’s design, the details (drawings, etc.) of which will be furnished by
the manufacturer. In case BMBS system or any of it’s subcomponents are
patented items, the supplier will furnish the patent details along with current
status and validity date etc.
2.2.2 Brake system shall be provided with brake cylinder and double acting automatic
slack adjuster. The minimum slack take up capacity shall be adequate to take up
the complete slack arising out of a wheel wear of 47 mm and Brake Block wear of
48 mm.
2.2.3 The brake head and other accessories for fitment of ‘K’ type composition brake
blocks shall be in accordance with RDSO specification No. WD-22-Brake head-
97 (rev.1) or latest amendment and brake block as per WD-14-ABR-2007 or
latest amendments.
2.3 The bogie mounted brake system shall be compatible with air brake equipment as
per RDSO Specification No. 02-ABR-02(latest). Any changes to be made in the air
brake equipment shall be specifically indicated by the supplier.
Page 3 of 15
2.4 Air Brake Pipe layout and fitment of Air Brake Equipment shall be as per respective
drawings of individual wagons, which will be issued by RDSO, Lucknow.
2.5 All air brake pipes and fittings shall be of stainless steel as per specification no. 04-
ABR-2002(latest).
2.6 A major objective in the development of BMBS in freight stock being
interchangeability across vendors at core component level, the proposer may be
asked by IR/RDSO to share technical details of their design with RDSO for multi
sourcing on freight rolling stock of Indian Railways.
3.1 Wagons on which bogie-mounted air brake system shall be provided are fitted
with Casnub type bogies. Details of these bogies i.e. drawings etc. can be
obtained on payment basis from RDSO, Lucknow.
3.2 The complete weight particulars per wagon of offered bogie mounted brake
system shall be furnished by the supplier.
4.1 One number of Brake beam mounted brake cylinder (two numbers per wagon)
shall be used on each bogie. These brake cylinders shall be provided along with
double acting slack adjusters. Mounting of the brake cylinders shall be done on
one of the two brake beams fitted in each bogie. Each brake cylinder shall control
the braking on two wheel sets of a bogie.
4.2 One brake cylinder shall have provision for hand brake cables and the other shall
be without hand brake.
4.3 Design of the brake cylinders shall be as per firm’s own design.
4.4 The BMBS system of the proposer should have adequate minimum clearances
as defined in RDSO Drawing no WD-08093-S/2. The proposer shall detail these
clearances in their design proposal through suitable 3D/2D Drawings pertaining
to their product. These shall be ratified by physical measurements in the
developmental inspection of the product. Notwithstanding the above mentioned
clearances, the system shall be designed such that no infringements shall take
place with any other member of the system or Bogie, in the worst condition,
during the entire range of operation of the BMBS system
4.5 Minimum brake cylinder piston travel of the bogie mounted brake cylinders must
be sufficient to provide proper brake shoe clearance when brakes are released.
The piston stroke, as specified by the proposer, in both empty and loaded
condition shall be within a tolerance range of +/- 10 mm.
4.6 The brake cylinder must generally meet the requirements of Leakage test,
Environmental test, Cycle test and Vibration test as per the test scheme given in
Annexure-II.
Page 4 of 15
4.7 The brake cylinder shall give trouble free service without any attention for a
period of six years. The vendor shall submit detailed maintenance instructions of
the brake cylinder. These maintenance instructions shall be followed at the time
of overhauling of the brake cylinders.
4.8 Brake beams (outline) shall be as per RDSO’s drawing number WD-08093-S/2.
The brake beam manufactured by the firm shall be subjected to load-deflection
and fatigue testing as per test scheme given in Annexure-I.
4.9 High friction composition brake blocks of “K” type to RDSO’s specification WD-
14-ABR-2007(latest) has been used in the BMBS.
4.10 Two stage Automatic Brake Cylinder Pressure Modification Device (APM)
whose functioning based on the gap between underframe and bogie side frame
of the wagon shall be as per firm’s own design. APM should sense the gap only
at the time of air brake application. During remaining time it should not be in
contact with the bogie side frame. APM shall be a proven design and must meet
the space envelope shown in RDSO’s drawing number WD-08096-S-01.One
number of APM shall be used per wagon. No human intervention shall be
required for operation of APM.
4.11 APM shall ensure brake cylinder pressure of 3.8 + 0.1 Kg/cm2 when the gap
between wagon underframe and bogie side frame is as prescribed in applicable
Wagon drawings. After the gap between underframe and bogie side frame
becomes more than as prescribed in the applicable drawings, the brake cylinder
pressure shall be reduced to 2.2+0.25 Kg/cm2. The tolerance of operation of
changeover point in the APM from empty to loaded condition shall be +/- 1 mm.
4.12 Performance testing of APM shall generally conform to AAR standard S-4002
(Latest). Specific procedure and parameters for testing shall be prescribed by the
contractor/manufacturer and will be approved by RDSO.
4.13 Complete arrangement of hand brake shall also be part of BMBS. Hand brake
shall be provided on one of the two bogies. The hand brake shall be operated as
shown in the general arrangement drawing of the wagon fitted with BMBS.
4.14 Complete BMBS shall be generally tested as per AAR standard S-4005 [Latest
revision]. Specific procedure and parameters for testing shall be as per the
scheme given in Annexure-II. This testing shall be carried out after installing the
entire BMBS in a suitable bogie or in a suitable test fixture that duplicates the
dimensions and geometry of the bogie.
4.15 Air Brake Pipe layout arrangement and fitment of air brake equipment which are
fitted on the underframe may vary from one type of wagon to another. Such
drawings of different type of wagons shall be issued by RDSO separately.
4.16 All pins connecting to brake cylinder, bell crank levers, push rods and brake
beams shall be secured by a suitable anti pilferage device (APD). A proper APD
Page 5 of 15
for Automatic Brake Cylinder Pressure Modification Device (APM) is also to be
provided.
5.1 The manufacturer willing to supply the BMBS system shall have in-house
Infrastructure facilities for design, manufacture and testing of Bogie mounted
Brake system in line with STR G-104 or latest for Bogie mounted Brake systems
for Freight Rolling Stock. The firm shall submit a compliance of the same at the
time of proposing their system to RDSO.
5.2 Such manufactures, who will be called “Principle manufacturers”, should agree to
provide technology to at least two or more manufacturers, who will be called
“Licensee manufacturers” .The vendor approval for all manufacturers will be as
per Vendor Approval Procedure of RDSO.
5.3 The licensee manufacturer shall have the certificate of approval from the principle
manufacturer and the same shall be submitted to RDSO. The principle
manufacturer will also give a certificate certifying that the licensee manufacturer
has the same testing/manufacturing facilities (machine and plant) as those with
the principal manufacturer. The purpose of having licensees is to broaden the
vendor base by induction and subsequent graduation of licensees into
independent sources. With these view, the prospective sources desirous for
registration under this specification shall be required to submit a copy of the
detailed licensee agreement entered into by them with their principal.
5.5 If the applicant satisfies the Qualifying Requirements as laid down in Para 5.1 to 5.5
as also the technical provisions of BMBS system advised in this specification to the
satisfaction of RDSO, development Inspection as mentioned below shall be carried
out.
6.1.1 The inspecting authority shall verify and ensure that the manufacturer has
Infrastructure as per the relevant STR for BMBS system for Freight Rolling Stock
of Indian Railways, strictly following a well documented system of the Internal
Quality Assurance Plan.
Page 6 of 15
6.1.2 The manufacturer shall offer FIVE BMBS sets complete in all respects. The
procedure for all the tests for testing of BMBS has been listed in Annexure I&II.
6.1.3 In case samples offered fail in any of the test/check, the firm shall be advised
accordingly.
6.2.1 Once the developmental tests have been cleared, prototype fitment of BMBS
shall be done by the supplier on a single bogie in their premises. After
demonstrating satisfactory working of the system, the supplier shall make
arrangements for the fitment of the above equipment on a complete wagon
6.2.2 Field Trial shall be conducted for a period of 18 months. Field trial shall be
conducted to assess the system reliability of proposed BMBS design.
6.2.4 Only on successful completion of all the above steps the firm will be accorded
technical clearance for becoming a vendor for BMBS. The vendor approval will
be done after this as per Vendor Approval Procedure of RDSO in vogue.
6.3.1 The inspecting authority shall make audit checks of the manufacturing
procedure / Internal Quality Assurance system to ensure that the BMBS
offered for inspection is manufactured strictly as per internal quality assurance
system and the manufacturer has carried out all tests / inspection during
manufacturing stage to ensure that BMBS offered are strictly to the
specification. During such audit checks, the inspecting authority shall also check
the records of internal quality assurance.
6.3.2 The inspecting authority shall conduct the checks/tests as given below from the
offered lot.
Page 7 of 15
6.3.3 Components of 2% of the offered lot of BMBS subject to minimum two BMBS
randomly picked up shall be checked for dimensions with respect to assembly
drawing.
6.3.4 1% of brake cylinder of the offered lot subject to minimum one brake cylinder shall
be dismantled and dimensions and general workmanships of each component
shall be checked as per the component drawings.
6.3.5 The manufacturer shall ensure that all the brake beams are subjected to Static
Tests of para 1.1 & 1.2 as laid down in test scheme (Annexure-I). During the
purchase inspection 1% brake beams (picked up randomly) of the offered lot
subject to minimum two number will be subjected to these tests under the
supervision of the inspecting authority.
6.3.6 Safety factor test (para 1.3 of Annexure –I), Bend tests (para 2 of Annexure-I),
Dynamic test (para 3 of Annexure –I) on brake beams shall be conducted under
the supervision of inspecting authority at periodic interval of one year. Same
brake beam may be used for para 1.3 and 2. Separate brake beam shall be used
for dynamic test. The brake beams tested under 6.3.6 shall not be allowed to use
on IR and shall be scraped. Record of last test conducted shall be given by the
manufacturer to the inspecting authority during purchase inspection.
6.3.7 The manufacturer as a part of its internal testing scheme shall conduct Leakage
Test at room temperature for all the brake cylinders on routine basis as given in
Annexure-II. During the purchase inspection one brake cylinder out of every
2000 brake cylinders being manufactured will be subjected to Leakage Test (for
the complete temperature range as given in Annexure-II) under the supervision
of the inspecting authority. If a manufacturer manufactures less than 2000 brake
cylinders in a year than the test is to be conducted at least once(for the complete
temperature range as given in Annexure-II) in that year.
6.3.8 Environmental Test, Endurance Test, Vibration Test of brake cylinder and
Function test of BMBS shall be conducted under the supervision of inspecting
authority at periodic interval of one year. Record of last tests conducted shall be
given by the manufacturer to the inspecting authority during purchase inspection.
.
6.3.9 Manufacturer shall ensure that all APM’s shall be subjected to RDSO approved
tests as laid down in Para 4.11. During the purchase inspection 2 % APM’s
(picked up randomly) of the offered lot subject to minimum two number will be
subjected to this test under the supervision of the inspecting authority.
6.3.10 In case the component samples picked up fail in any of the tests / checks
indicated in para 6.3.3 to 6.3.9 the reasons for such failure shall be
Identified. The inspecting authority shall verify the reasons by conducting
audit check on internal quality assurance system. If it is found that such failures
are due to non implementation of internal quality assurance system, the entire lot
of BMBS shall be rejected. In case the failures are on account of reasons other
than non implementation of internal quality assurance system, the manufacturers
may re-offer the lot after rectifying the defects. However, in such cases, double
Page 8 of 15
the quantity of samples shall be picked up and tests/checks shall be conducted.
In case the samples again fail in any of the tests/checks, the entire lot shall be
rejected.
6.3.11 The manufacturer will maintain a list of all internal acceptance tests being carried
out at various stages of manufacturing of the product. Proper record of such
internal acceptance tests shall be maintained and also included in the QAP.At the
time of inspection of the product, these records shall be put to the inspecting
authority for scrutiny and countersign.
7.0 TRAINING
8.1 Each major component of the bogie mounted brake system should have
prominent and durable marking as follows: -
· Manufacturer’s name (initials/trade mark can also be marked)
· Month and the year of manufacture.
· Country of origin (in case of imported components)
· Serial No.
8.2 The components shall be suitably packed to make them fit for transit by
Rail/Road/Sea/Air without any damage and also for storage.
9.1 The manufacturer/contractor shall arrange for adequate service engineers at his
own cost to ensure that the equipment supplied performs satisfactorily.
Manufacturer/Contractor shall also depute his staff on request by the Purchaser /
RDSO, to investigate and attend to specific problems that may come up during
actual operation of Air Brake Equipment.
9.2 The manufacturer/contractor shall arrange to supply along with the equipment
maintenance manuals, wall charts and cut models for proper maintenance of his
own proprietary equipment. Two numbers of manuals and wall charts per 100
number of BMBS or part thereof and cut model one each per 2000 number of
BMBS or part thereof shall be supplied against every contract free of cost. The
consignee for these shall be nominated by RDSO. Manuals shall be illustrated,
containing information pertaining to the principle of operation, maintenance
schedule of all the proprietary items of equipment being supplied. The Manual
shall also contain information on the following: -
a) Details of attention during various schedules of Examination.
b) Test equipments.
Page 9 of 15
c) Special tools
d) Trouble shooting
e) List of spares required during various schedules of Examination.
f) Updated position of modifications carried out.
9.3 The manufacturer/contractor shall supply revised Maintenance Manuals and Wall
Charts incorporating necessary changes in the Manuals and Wall Charts already
supplied by them for earlier contracts. The copies of maintenance manuals and
wall charts are meant for wider circulation on Railway and fresh copies shall be
furnished as stipulated even if there are no changes in the manuals & wall charts
furnished against earlier contract.
10. GUARANTEE/WARRANTY
The firm shall stand guarantee, unless otherwise specified in the specification of
individual component/sub assembly, for a period of 36 (thirty six) months form the
date of fitment of the system.
In case of any premature failure of any components due to design/manufacturing
deficiency, firm will be liable to make free replacement within reasonable time to
the depot where failure has been reported. Whenever repeated failures are
reported, firm shall investigate and come up with satisfactory reasons for failure
and take remedial action. The failed component/sub assembly (within the
warranty period) shall be taken back by the supplier for repair and re-supply to
the Railways after RDSO Inspection along with an extended warranty period as
applicable to the new supply.
This will not exclude satisfactory performance of brake cylinders for a time
period of six years in Indian environmental and working conditions.
Page 10 of 15
ANNEXURE-I
The following tests are to be carried out on both the brake beams (Primary
and Secondary) for BMBS application on Indian Railways.
1. STATIC TESTS.
2. BEND TESTS OF BRAKE BEAM ENDS
3. DYNAMIC TEST.
1. STATIC TESTS
The test fixture shall have suitable supports to represent the back of brake
shoe, so that the brake beam can be mounted in the fixture, supported on
brake heads.
The brake beam is to be loaded for a load of 10.8t at load application points
of the brake beam for three consecutive load cycles. At the end of third
cycle the load is to be reduced to 500kg to set the deflection reading to
zero. Then the deflection load of 10.8t is to be re-applied and deflection
reading at center is to be taken which should not be more than 1.8 mm.
Set test
After deflection test, the beam shall be loaded for a set load of 16.2t and
then released to 500 kg. The brake beam shall not show a set more than
0.25mm.
Page 11 of 15
2. BEND TESTS OF BRAKE BEAM ENDS
The brake beam shall be supported in a fixture with the brake heads against
dummy brake shoes and a deflection load of 10.8t is to be applied on it to
hold the brake beam in position. Then by means of a clamp fixture attached
to the brake beam end, a load of 2t at each end is to be applied through a
distance of 110mm from brake head centre.
After this the load of 2t is to be reduced to 200 kg and measure the set as
zero. Then apply a load of 3t at each the ends and measure the set by
reducing the load to 200kg, which shall not be more than 0.18mm.
After successful set test, a load of 4.5t is to be applied for safety factor
test. There shall not be any type of failure of brake beam ends.
3. DYNAMIC TEST
The beam shall be loaded for one million cycles at a frequency range
between 1Hz to 3 Hz
Page 12 of 15
3.1 The beam shall be mounted in a suitable cycle machine capable for 10.8t
deflection load at push rod connections on brake beam.
3.3 The tangential load must alternate in direction with each normal load
cycle.
********
Page 13 of 15
Annexure-II
a) Install the system in the suitable text fixture that duplicates the complete set of
system and make sure all the adjustments are correct.
b) For the minimum slack clearance use max. thicknesses of brake block and keep
the brake cylinder between the mounting holes/pins. Retract the system back
until max. show clearance is obtained.
c) Apply 0.7 Kg/Cm2 air pressure to the brake cylinder and note that all the brake
blocks are touching the wheel.
d) Apply 3.8 Kg/Cm2 air pressure to the brake cylinder and record the brake block
force at each brake head with-out rapping the rigging. Then rap each friction
point of the system and again record the brake block force at each brake head.
These reading will be used to compute the efficiency of the bogie mounted brake
system in the static and simulated dynamic conditions.
e) Removing a brake block, apply and release 0.7 Kg/Cm2 air pressure to the brake
cylinder until the brake heads touch the wheel with correct piston stroke. Repeat
the procedure until all brake blocks have been removed.
f) Install a brake block, apply and release 0.7 Kg/Cm2 air pressure to the brake
cylinder until the brake heads are brought up against the wheel with correct
piston stroke. Repeat the procedure until all brake blocks have been installed.
Apply 0.7 Kg/Cm2 & 3.8 Kg/Cm2 air pressure and wait 5 minutes after application
and observe that the leakage is not more than as given in table below.
Environmental Test
Measure brake cylinder force output and efficiency at 3.8 Kg/Cm2 in room
temperature (21o C), 55o C and -10o C or below. Efficiency shall be measured by
comparing the air pressure force on the piston to the total brake block force. If
efficiency is measured in a test fixture the air pressure force on the piston will be
Page 14 of 15
compared to the piston push rod force. All readings will be made after the friction
points of the system have been rapped. Under no circumstance should the brake
rigging be rapped in a manner that might artificially increase or reduce the brake
block forces.
a) Leakage test for brake cylinder complete and Environmental test at room
temperature must be completed successfully both prior to and after completion of
Cycle test/ Endurance test. Efficiency at the completion of Cycle test/ Endurance
test must not decrease more than 2% if forces are measured at the pushrod, or
5% if forces are measured at the brake block heads, for the efficiency measured
prior to the cycle test.
b) Cycle the brake cylinder with in built slack adjuster at a brake cylinder pressure of
at 6.2 Kg/Cm2 for 200,000 cycles.
c) Remove one brake block every 25,000 cycles until 125,000 cycles is reached
and then add one brake block every 25,000 cycles for remainder of the test.
d) Repeat the leakage test and Environmental test at room temperature (21OC).
e) Install the brake cylinder with built in slack adjuster in the text fixture with all
associated components and perform a function test as described in System
functional test.
Vibration Test
a) Leakage test for brake cylinder complete and Environmental test at room
temperature must be completed successfully both prior to and after completion of
the Vibration tests.
b) Brake Cylinder with built in slack adjuster must be subjected to a vibration test at
no less than 30 or more than 60 cycles per second at + 3g for Five million cycles.
c) Repeat the leakage test and Environmental test at room temperature (21OC).
Efficiency at the completion of Vibration test must not decrease more than 2% at
push rod from the efficiency measured prior to the Vibration test.
d) Install the brake cylinder with built in slack adjuster in the text fixture with all
associated components and perform a function test as described in System
functional test.
Page 15 of 15