UNIT-1

CHAPTER 1.2

Lecture- 2.5 (Comparisons of Models)

What is the Difference Between Hierarchical Network and Relational

Database Model

The main difference between hierarchical network and relational database model is
that hierarchical model organizes data in a tree-like structure while network model
arranges data in a graph structure and relational database model organizes data in
tables.

Database models help to create the structure of the databases. In addition, they also help to
define how to store and access data in DBMS. In other words, it is important to follow a
database model to store data on a database of a DBMS. There are various models used for
logical designing of databases in DBMS, and Hierarchical, Network and Relational are three
such database models.

What is Data Model in DBMS and what are its types?

Data Model

Data Model gives us an idea that how the final system will look like after its complete
implementation. It defines the data elements and the relationships between the data elements.
Data Models are used to show how data is stored, connected, accessed and updated in the
database management system. Here, we use a set of symbols and text to represent the
information so that members of the organization can communicate and understand it. Though
there are many data models being used nowadays but the Relational model is the most widely
used model. Apart from the Relational model, there are many other types of data models
about which we will study in details in this blog. Some of the Data Models in DBMS are:

1. Hierarchical Model

2. Network Model

3. Entity-Relationship Model
 4. Relational Model

5. Object-Oriented Data Model

6. Object-Relational Data Model

7. Flat Data Model

8. Semi-Structured Data Model

9. Associative Data Model

10. Context Data Model

Hierarchical Model

Hierarchical Model was the first DBMS model. This model organizes the data in the
hierarchical tree structure. The hierarchy starts from the root which has root data and then it
expands in the form of a tree adding child node to the parent node. This model easily
represents some of the real-world relationships like food recipes, sitemap of a website
etc. Example: We can represent the relationship between the shoes present on a shopping
website in the following way:

Features of a Hierarchical Model

1. One-to-many relationship: The data here is organized in a tree-like structure where

the one-to-many relationship is between the datatypes. Also, there can be only one
path from parent to any node. Example: In the above example, if we want to go to the
node sneakers we only have one path to reach there i.e through men's shoes node.
 2. Parent-Child Relationship: Each child node has a parent node but a parent node can
have more than one child node. Multiple parents are not allowed.

3. Deletion Problem: If a parent node is deleted then the child node is automatically
deleted.

4. Pointers: Pointers are used to link the parent node with the child node and are used to
navigate between the stored data. Example: In the above example the 'shoes' node
points to the two other nodes 'women shoes' node and 'men's shoes' node.

Advantages of Hierarchical Model

 It is very simple and fast to traverse through a tree-like structure.

 Any change in the parent node is automatically reflected in the child node so, the
integrity of data is maintained.

Disadvantages of Hierarchical Model

 Complex relationships are not supported.

 As it does not support more than one parent of the child node so if we have some
complex relationship where a child node needs to have two parent node then that can't
be represented using this model.

 If a parent node is deleted then the child node is automatically deleted.

Network Model

This model is an extension of the hierarchical model. It was the most popular model before
the relational model. This model is the same as the hierarchical model, the only difference is
that a record can have more than one parent. It replaces the hierarchical tree with a
graph. Example: In the example below we can see that node student has two parents i.e. CSE
Department and Library. This was earlier not possible in the hierarchical model.
Features of a Network Model

1. Ability to Merge more Relationships: In this model, as there are more relationships
so data is more related. This model has the ability to manage one-to-one relationships
as well as many-to-many relationships.

2. Many paths: As there are more relationships so there can be more than one path to
the same record. This makes data access fast and simple.

3. Circular Linked List: The operations on the network model are done with the help of
the circular linked list. The current position is maintained with the help of a program
and this position navigates through the records according to the relationship.

Advantages of Network Model

 The data can be accessed faster as compared to the hierarchical model. This is
because the data is more related in the network model and there can be more than one
path to reach a particular node. So the data can be accessed in many ways.

 As there is a parent-child relationship so data integrity is present. Any change in

parent record is reflected in the child record.

Disadvantages of Network Model

 As more and more relationships need to be handled the system might get complex. So,
a user must be having detailed knowledge of the model to work with the model.

 Any change like updation, deletion, insertion is very complex.

Entity-Relationship Model
Entity-Relationship Model or simply ER Model is a high-level data model diagram. In this
model, we represent the real-world problem in the pictorial form to make it easy for the
stakeholders to understand. It is also very easy for the developers to understand the system by
just looking at the ER diagram. We use the ER diagram as a visual tool to represent an ER
Model. ER diagram has the following three components:

 Entities: Entity is a real-world thing. It can be a person, place, or even a

concept. Example: Teachers, Students, Course, Building, Department, etc are some of
the entities of a School Management System.

 Attributes: An entity contains a real-world property called attribute. This is the

characteristics of that attribute. Example: The entity teacher has the property like
teacher id, salary, age, etc.

 Relationship: Relationship tells how two attributes are related. Example: Teacher
works for a department.

Example:

In the above diagram, the entities are Teacher and Department. The attributes
of Teacher entity are Teacher_Name, Teacher_id, Age, Salary, Mobile_Number. The
attributes of entity Department entity are Dept_id, Dept_name. The two entities are
connected using the relationship. Here, each teacher works for a department.
Features of ER Model

 Graphical Representation for Better Understanding: It is very easy and simple to

understand so it can be used by the developers to communicate with the stakeholders.

 ER Diagram: ER diagram is used as a visual tool for representing the model.

 Database Design: This model helps the database designers to build the database and
is widely used in database design.

Advantages of ER Model

 Simple: Conceptually ER Model is very easy to build. If we know the relationship

between the attributes and the entities we can easily build the ER Diagram for the
model.

 Effective Communication Tool: This model is used widely by the database designers
for communicating their ideas.

 Easy Conversion to any Model: This model maps well to the relational model and can
be easily converted relational model by converting the ER model to the table. This
model can also be converted to any other model like network model, hierarchical
model etc.

Disadvatages of ER Model

 No industry standard for notation: There is no industry standard for developing an

ER model. So one developer might use notations which are not understood by other
developers.

 Hidden information: Some information might be lost or hidden in the ER model. As

it is a high-level view so there are chances that some details of information might be
hidden.

Relational Model

Relational Model is the most widely used model. In this model, the data is maintained in the
form of a two-dimensional table. All the information is stored in the form of row and
columns. The basic structure of a relational model is tables. So, the tables are also
called relations in the relational model. Example: In this example, we have an Employee
table.
Features of Relational Model

 Tuples: Each row in the table is called tuple. A row contains all the information about
any instance of the object. In the above example, each row has all the information
about any specific individual like the first row has information about John.

 Attribute or field: Attributes are the property which defines the table or relation. The
values of the attribute should be from the same domain. In the above example, we
have different attributes of the employee like Salary, Mobile_no, etc.

Advnatages of Relational Model

 Simple: This model is more simple as compared to the network and hierarchical
model.

 Scalable: This model can be easily scaled as we can add as many rows and columns
we want.

 Structural Independence: We can make changes in database structure without

changing the way to access the data. When we can make changes to the database
structure without affecting the capability to DBMS to access the data we can say that
structural independence has been achieved.

Disadvantages of Relatinal Model

 Hardware Overheads: For hiding the complexities and making things easier for the
user this model requires more powerful hardware computers and data storage devices.
  Bad Design: As the relational model is very easy to design and use. So the users don't
need to know how the data is stored in order to access it. This ease of design can lead
to the development of a poor database which would slow down if the database grows.

But all these disadvantages are minor as compared to the advantages of the relational model.
These problems can be avoided with the help of proper implementation and organisation.

Object-Oriented Data Model

The real-world problems are more closely represented through the object-oriented data
model. In this model, both the data and relationship are present in a single structure known as
an object. We can store audio, video, images, etc in the database which was not possible in
the relational model(although you can store audio and video in relational database, it is
adviced not to store in the relational database). In this model, two are more objects are
connected through links. We use this link to relate one object to other objects. This can be
understood by the example given below.

In the above example, we have two objects Employee and Department. All the data and
relationships of each object are contained as a single unit. The attributes like Name, Job_title
of the employee and the methods which will be performed by that object are stored as a
single object. The two objects are connected through a common attribute i.e the
Department_id and the communication between these two will be done with the help of this
common id.

Object-Relational Model
As the name suggests it is a combination of both the relational model and the object-oriented
model. This model was built to fill the gap between object-oriented model and the relational
model. We can have many advanced features like we can make complex data types according
to our requirements using the existing data types. The problem with this model is that this can
get complex and difficult to handle. So, proper understanding of this model is required.

Flat Data Model

It is a simple model in which the database is represented as a table consisting of rows and
columns. To access any data, the computer has to read the entire table. This makes the modes
slow and inefficient.

Semi-Structured Model

Semi-structured model is an evolved form of the relational model. We cannot differentiate

between data and schema in this model. Example: Web-Based data sources which we can't
differentiate between the schema and data of the website. In this model, some entities may
have missing attributes while others may have an extra attribute. This model gives flexibility
in storing the data. It also gives flexibility to the attributes. Example: If we are storing any
value in any attribute then that value can be either atomic value or a collection of values.

Associative Data Model

Associative Data Model is a model in which the data is divided into two parts. Everything
which has independent existence is called as an entity and the relationship among these
entities are called association. The data divided into two parts are called items and links.

 Item: Items contain the name and the identifier(some numeric value).

 Links: Links contain the identifier, source, verb and subject.

Example: Let us say we have a statement "The world cup is being hosted by London from 30
May 2020". In this data two links need to be stored:

1. The world cup is being hosted by London. The source here is 'the world cup', the verb
'is being' and the target is 'London'.

2. ...from 30 May 2020. The source here is the previous link, the verb is 'from' and the
target is '30 May 2020'.

This is represented using the table as follows:

Context Data Model

Context Data Model is a collection of several models. This consists of models like network
model, relational models etc. Using this model we can do various types of tasks which are not
possible using any model alone.

OTHER REFRENCES

• What is Data Model in DBMS and what are its types? (afteracademy.com)

• Types of DBMS | Top 7 Types of Database Management System To Know

(educba.com)

SUGGESTED BOOK REFERENCES

1. Ramez Elmasri and Shamkant B. Navathe,“Fundamentals of Database System”, The

Benjamin / Cummings Publishing Co.

2. Korth and Silberschatz Abraham, “Database SystemConcepts”, McGraw Hall.

3. Pratt,”DBMS”, Cengage Learning.