Hsc Topic One Desktop 3am1n90
Hsc Topic One Desktop 3am1n90
Protection
reasons for protection – infant industry argument, domestic
employment,
dumping, defence
methods of protection and the effects of protectionist policies on the
domestic
and global economy – tariffs, subsidies, quotas, local content rules,
export incentives
GWP is the monetary value of all goods and services that have been
produced by individual countries collected together.
- Gross World Product (GWP) refers to the sum of total output of
goods and services by all economies in the world over a period of
time.
Globalisation
In the past the decades, Globalisation has become a dominant economic,
political and social theme.
- Globalisation is the integration between different countries and
economies and the increased impact of international influences on
all aspects of life and economic activity.
- Globalisation is the breakdown of man-made and natural barriers to
the movement of labour, investment, technology, finance and trade,
allowing an increase of cross-border transactions.
- Previous times in world history, one major empire often dominated
economic relationships, in recent decades globalisation has involved
layers of influence in all directions.
- financial flows
Financial Flows:
- International finance plays a leading role in the global economy,
because finance is crucial to so many aspects of how modern
economies work, a major impact in terms of linking economies
around the world is through the globalisation of finance. Money
moves between countries more quickly than goods and services or
people because finance is the most globalised sector of the world.
- There is no single measure of international financial flows, there has
been an exponential growth of financial flows since globalisation.
- Derivatives are financial contracts whose value depends on an
underlying asset like stocks, bonds, or commodities. They are used
internationally for managing risk or hedging, and common types
include futures and options.
- While global financial flows can boost investment and economic
growth in countries with low savings, speculative activity often
causes volatility, leading to risks like currency crises.
- Causes of growth in financial flows:
Reduction of man-made barriers:
i) Financial deregulation has played a significant role in
increasing global financial transactions. Governments
have removed restrictions on international capital
movements, central control over exchange rates, and
limits on bank lending.
Reduction of natural barriers:
i) Technological advancements have transformed the
speed and ease of moving money globally. The
introduction of computers and global communication
networks has enabled instant transactions, overcoming
previous challenges like time zones and distance.
- Effects of globalisation on financial flow:
Composition and value:
i) Direct Investment: Involves purchasing at least 10% of a
foreign business’s shares to exert control. Global FDI
flows have increased due to fewer restrictions on foreign
ownership.
ii) Portfolio Investment: Refers to buying less than 10% of
shares or bonds for profit without controlling the
business. Financial deregulation has allowed individuals
and institutions to invest globally through foreign stock
markets and superannuation funds.
Direction (reasons for change):
i) Trade blocs: Organizations like the EU promote intra-
member investment, often offering incentives like lower
taxes to encourage financial flows between member
countries.
ii) Regionalism: Like trade blocs but within broader
regions, increasing investment within specific
geographical areas.
iii) Political shifts in the world: The rise of major economies
like China and India has redirected global investments
towards these countries. With large trade surpluses,
they have become major global investors, financed
foreign projects and purchased foreign securities.
Bilateral Agreements:
- Bilateral agreements are trade deals between two countries
focusing on reducing trade barriers exclusively between them.
- These agreements are often termed preferential trade agreements
since they provide favourable treatment to the involved nations
while excluding others.
- While bilateral agreements support free trade, they have a limited
impact as they apply only to the two participating countries.
However, a large number of bilateral agreements worldwide
collectively contribute to reducing global trade barriers.
- Bilateral agreements offer flexibility, enabling two countries to
negotiate and agree on mutually beneficial terms more rapidly than
in multilateral settings.
- Increasingly, bilateral agreements are also formed between a
country and a trade bloc, or between two trade blocs, adding
complexity to international trade arrangements.
Multilateral Agreements: Case studies of trading blocs - APEC,
ASEAN:
- Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC): Focused on promoting
free trade and economic cooperation throughout the Asia-Pacific
region.
- Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN): Aims to promote
economic growth and regional stability among Southeast Asian
countries.
- Other significant agreements include the Comprehensive and
Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) and the
Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP).
- While CPTPP and RCEP may not be directly included in some syllabi,
they are crucial in the context of multilateral agreements.
- Mentioning these agreements can enhance responses in exams
about multilateral agreements, showcasing an understanding of
current economic frameworks and their global impact.
Advantages of multilateral and bilateral agreements:
- Increase in trade and economic growth:
Trade blocs and agreements are designed to foster global
economic growth by decreasing protectionist barriers, which
can improve resource allocation and enhance overall
efficiency.
By reducing tariffs, quotas, and other restrictions, these
agreements help stimulate trade among member countries,
facilitating the movement of goods, services, and
investments.
Despite their potential benefits, the economic advantages
have been unevenly distributed across nations. Some
countries have managed to negotiate more favourable
agreements, securing greater access to key markets and
economic benefits.
For instance, countries like Australia face limitations as they
cannot join major trade blocs such as the United States-
Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), the European Union
(EU), or the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN),
which restricts their access to these powerful economic zones.
Typically, large trade blocs inspire a network of additional
bilateral agreements, which can further boost trade. For
example, the European Union (EU) has entered into numerous
bilateral agreements to expand its trade relationships with
individual countries outside the bloc.
- Political benefits:
Trade agreements are generally quicker and more flexible to
negotiate than agreements through international
organizations, such as the World Trade Organization (WTO),
which can take years to finalize a single trade deal.
Bilateral and multilateral trade agreements allow countries to
tailor the terms of the agreement to meet each country’s
specific needs. This flexibility makes them especially
appealing because countries involved in these agreements
usually have similar political systems, economic goals, or
strategic interests.
Bilateral agreements are often simpler and faster to negotiate
than multilateral agreements, as only two countries need to
reach a consensus. This efficiency makes it easier for nations
to achieve favourable trade conditions swiftly.
- Increased ties with countries outside the box:
Multilateral agreements often encourage members to
establish trade and diplomatic ties with countries outside their
immediate region.
For example, the European Union (EU) has established
numerous trade agreements with countries outside the bloc,
strengthening global economic interdependence.
This external engagement expands economic partnerships
and creates a network of alliances that can foster political
stability and cooperation beyond the regional bloc itself.
Disadvantages of multilateral and bilateral agreements:
- Trade diversion:
One of the significant drawbacks of trade blocs and
agreements is trade diversion, which occurs when trade shifts
away from more efficient, lower-cost producers outside the
bloc to less efficient producers within the bloc.
While trade agreements often promote stronger trade within a
specific region, they can inadvertently reduce global trade
efficiency by limiting free trade to within the bloc. This
restricts the benefits of global free trade, as countries may
prioritize trading within their bloc rather than sourcing goods
from the most cost-effective global suppliers.
Trade diversion can lead to inefficient resource allocation
since products might be sourced from regional producers
within the bloc rather than from more competitive or cheaper
sources in other parts of the world.
This is a considerable disadvantage for countries that lack
access to extensive trade agreements, like Australia, which
may be excluded from key trade networks and thus miss out
on the benefits of these trade arrangements. However, it’s
worth noting that concerns about trade diversion may
sometimes be overstated, depending on the context and
specific trade policies involved.
Protection
reasons for protection – infant industry argument, domestic
employment,
dumping, defence
Methods of protection:
Tariffs:
- A tariff is a government-imposed tax on imports, making imported
goods more expensive and domestic producers more competitive.
- Tariffs protect local industries by raising the price of imports,
encouraging consumers to buy domestic goods. For example, a 10%
tariff on imported cars increases their price, allowing local producers
to compete.
- The economic effects of tariffs include stimulating domestic
production and employment, but also attracting resources to less
efficient industries. Tariffs raise prices for consumers, reducing their
purchasing power and lowering living standards.
- Although tariffs raise government revenue, this isn't the primary
goal. Revenue decreases as fewer imports come in due to the
tariff’s effectiveness.
- Tariffs can provoke retaliation from other countries, leading to trade
wars, as seen in Australia’s tariff on Chinese steel in 2014, which led
China to retaliate with tariffs on Australian barley and wine.
- Tariffs are often discouraged by the WTO, and new tariffs are
typically banned or limited. Some exceptions include countervailing
measures (e.g., 240% tariffs on Australian wines by China) and
carbon tariffs, used to discourage imports that contributes to
pollution
Quotas:
- A quota limits the amount or value of goods that can be imported,
protecting domestic industries by restricting foreign competition.
- Quotas, like tariffs, stimulate domestic production but can lead to
higher prices and fewer choices for consumers. Unlike tariffs, they
do not generate direct revenue for the government.
- A tariff quota combines tariffs and quotas: goods imported beyond
the quota limit are subject to higher tariffs.
Quotas are generally seen as more restrictive than tariffs, and the
WTO prohibits the introduction of new quotas.
- Quotas reallocate resources toward protected industries, as seen in
the EU's quota on high-quality beef, which has led to 95% of beef
consumed being domestically produced.
Subsidies:
- A subsidy is a financial grant from the government to domestic
producers, allowing them to lower their production costs and sell
their goods at more competitive prices, both locally and globally.
- Subsidies stimulate domestic production and employment, while
lowering prices for consumers. However, they impose a cost on
government budgets, reducing funds available for other priorities
like education or healthcare.
- Economic effects include an increase in domestic production,
reallocation of resources, and indirect costs for consumers through
higher taxes.
- While subsidies are seen as less restrictive than tariffs or quotas,
they still limit international trade and can make it harder for
developing countries to compete. The WTO discourages subsidies
for this reason, and they are often subject to international criticism.
- The EU, USA, and Japan, for example, provide large agricultural
subsidies, making it difficult for poorer countries to compete in
global markets.
Local Content Rules
- These rules require a percentage of a good to be made locally. For
example, Australian free-to-air TV must have 55% Australian-made
content, and some industries like construction may require the use
of a minimum percentage of local materials.
- Local content rules protect domestic producers by guaranteeing
them a market share and reducing the market for imports.
- In some cases, governments provide tax concessions to businesses
that comply with local content rules.
Export Incentives:
- Export incentives aim to encourage domestic businesses to export
their goods by offering financial assistance, such as grants or tax
cuts, or providing support like marketing advice.
- By supporting exports, governments aim to bring money into the
economy and improve the nation's global reputation.
- Export incentives do not protect businesses from foreign
competition domestically but help them capture a larger share of
global markets. Australia's Export Market Development Grant
(EMDG) program, for instance, has helped over 51,000 businesses
promote their exports globally.
- While not directly a form of protectionism, export incentives can act
as a trade barrier by giving domestic businesses an advantage in
international markets.
Additional Information:
- Protectionism reduces global trade and economic growth by
encouraging inefficient production and limiting countries' ability to
specialize in industries where they have a comparative advantage.
- High tariffs and quotas lead to trade retaliation, making goods more
expensive and reducing living standards.
- Protectionist policies disproportionately affect developing countries,
which rely on exports to richer nations. The WTO and World Bank
emphasize that free trade promotes economic growth and poverty
reduction, as seen in the increased share of global exports by
developing countries from 16% to 30% between 1990 and 2017.
Economic Growth:
- Definition: Economic growth is the increase in a nation’s output,
specifically measured by an increase in real GDP. This is a
quantitative measure reflecting the rise in goods and services
produced within an economy over time.
- Example: A country achieving higher production levels each year
signifies an improvement in its economic capacity, demonstrating
growth.
- Economic growth is the main reason globalisation is supposed to be
helpful (and why it is promoted so much by governments and
business)
- More trade opportunities + more investment sources = more
production = higher GDP growth.
Economic Development:
- Definition: Economic development goes beyond mere growth,
encompassing improvements in the standard of living and quality of
life. It is a qualitative measure assessing factors like health,
education, and overall well-being.
- Example: An increase in the Human Development Index (HDI) can
reflect economic development, as it takes into account life
expectancy, education levels, and adjusted GNI per capita
(accounting for purchasing power and foreign debt).
Developing economies:
- Alternate names:
Third World, less developed countries (LDCs),
underdeveloped, non-industrialised.
- Characteristics:
Low GDP per Capita and HDI: Developing economies typically
struggle with low-income levels and minimal social
infrastructure, leading to low rankings on the HDI.
Poor Living Standards: Most citizens in these nations face
limited access to basic needs such as healthcare, clean water,
and education.
Labour-Intensive Production: Many developing economies rely
on labour-intensive industries like agriculture and low-value-
added industries, which generate lower profit margins.
Trade Barriers: Often, wealthier nations impose high trade
barriers and subsidies on sectors where developing nations
could be competitive, such as agriculture. This limits trade
opportunities and can impede growth.
Unstable Governance: Developing economies often
experience political instability, undemocratic governance, or
both, which can further limit economic development.
- Examples:
Many countries in Sub-Saharan Africa face challenges like high
foreign debt, inequality, corruption, and weak governance,
trapping them in low-growth cycles.
- Subcategories:
High-Growth Developing Economies:
i) Characteristics: These economies are growing rapidly
and undergoing industrialisation, gradually moving
towards higher value-added industries.
ii) Example: Countries like China have experienced rapid
development, benefitting from industrialisation and
integration into global trade networks.
Low-Growth Developing Economies:
i) Characteristics: These economies make up most of the
developing category and face persistent poverty due to
issues like high foreign debt, economic inequality,
crime, corruption, and resource exploitation by foreign
interests.
ii) Example: Countries like Zimbabwe continue to face
these obstacles, struggling to achieve sustained growth
and development.
Emerging Economies:
- Alternate names:
Newly industrialised economies (NICs), emerging markets,
transition economies (for countries moving from communism
to capitalism, e.g., Russia).
- Characteristics:
Rapid Economic Growth and Development: Emerging
economies are typically experiencing high growth rates and
significant improvements in living standards and
infrastructure.
Transition from Developing to Advanced: These economies are
moving beyond low GDP per capita and low HDI, though they
are not yet at advanced levels.
Utilizing Globalisation to Their Advantage: Many emerging
economies have embraced global trade, foreign investment,
and technological advancements to accelerate their
development.
Low GDP per Capita and HDI but Rising Quickly: While they
still face challenges like low HDI and GDP per capita, these
indicators are improving more rapidly compared to developing
nations.
- Examples:
BRICS Countries: Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa
represent some of the most prominent emerging economies.
These nations have leveraged globalisation, improved
infrastructure, and growing industries to position themselves
as influential players in the global economy.
Other Notable Emerging Economies: Turkey, Mexico, and
Indonesia, among others, are also seeing rapid development
and are expected to transition to advanced status in the near
future.
Advanced Economies:
- Alternate names:
High-income economies, developed economies, First World
countries.
- Characteristics:
High GDP per Capita and HDI: Advanced economies enjoy high
income levels and social standards, with citizens typically
experiencing greater economic security and quality of life.
Highly Industrialized: Advanced economies have strong
industrial sectors, especially in high-tech manufacturing. They
are also increasingly focused on the service industry, including
sectors like finance, healthcare, and information technology.
Democratic Governance: These countries generally operate
under stable democratic governments, ensuring political
stability and consistent economic policy.
Comprehensive Health and Welfare Systems: Most advanced
economies have robust health, education, and welfare
systems that support citizens, although exceptions like the
U.S. exist where certain social supports may be limited.
Influence in Global Organisations: Advanced economies
dominate key international institutions such as the World Bank
and the IMF. This influence enables them to shape global
economic policies, often making globalisation work in their
favour.
- Examples:
Regions: North America, Western Europe, Japan, Australia, and
New Zealand are among the leading advanced economies.
Asian Tigers: Singapore, Hong Kong, South Korea, and Taiwan,
known as the "Asian Tigers," transitioned from newly
industrialised countries to advanced economies between the
1960s and 1980s due to strategic investment in technology,
education, and global trade.
OECD Nations: Many advanced economies are members of the
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
(OECD), which promotes policies to improve economic and
social well-being worldwide.
effects of globalisation
environmental sustainability
Advantages Disadvantages
Globalisation offers opportunities Low-income countries may engage
to protect environment by forcing in economic behaviour that harms
nations to take global the environment to attract foreign
responsibility for environmental direct investment and high export
protection. revenue.
For example, deforestation.
Increased scrutiny of High levels of agricultural subsidies
environmental practises of TNC’s in advanced economies promotes
exports which contribute to the
overuse of agricultural inputs,
causing environmental damage
It has facilitated the transfer of Increased trade using non-
new technology to improve energy renewable transport fuels.
efficiency and reduce pollution
Globalisation creates international Depletion of resources with very
institutions with powers to enforce limited quantities when businesses
orders to stop damage to the are striving for high profits.
environment.
the international business cycle.
Case Study: Trump trade war could force the RBA to jack up rates (could
include in HSC)
tariffs 9syl