Fundamentals SuperTAPP SG_Technical Manual
Fundamentals SuperTAPP SG_Technical Manual
Registered names, trademarks, etc., used in this document, even when not specifically marked as
such, are protected by law.
This document is one part (highlighted in bold below) of the complete user documentation set, which
comprises three parts in total:
Fundamentals Limited
Unit 2, Hillmead Enterprise Park
Marshall Road
Swindon
SN5 5FZ
UK
Scope
This document is applicable to SuperTAPP SG relay types with Basic, Advanced and Ultimate function
levels.
The relay type is printed in the form ‘FP1034-XXXXXXXXXX-Xnn-FX’, and the digit in the position ‘F’
represents the function level.
Version Information
Document Issue
Issue Issue Date Description of Main Changes Applicable relay version
Published as part of FP1034-U-2 User Manual
1.0 April 2016 First issue h/w 00, s/w v4.x
2.0 September 2016 Substantial changes to section 15. Subsections h/w 01
renumbered and subsections 15.6, 15.8 and 15.9 s/w v5.x
added to support new features. Improved
description in most other subsections with
function diagrams added.
Minor updates throughout.
2.1 January 2017 17 Settings lists updated to reflect new h/w 01,02
functionality s/w v5.x
18.1.3 ENA TS 48-6-5 reference added
18.2.1 Frequency response h/w version clarified
2.2 June 2017 Hardware and software version tables added h/w 03,04
15.1.1 Description of time delays extended and s/w v6.0, v6.1
consolidated from 15.3
15.4.3 Description expanded
15.4.8 New section on power calculations
15.10 New section added: general inputs and
outputs
17 New settings added (Tables 2-14, 2-16,
2-17, 2-18, 2-19, 2-20, 2-21, 2-25)
Converted to separate document FP1034-U-11 Technical Reference
3.0 May 2018 14.2 Table 2-2 clarifies VT/CTs at basic h/w 04,05
function level s/w v6.6 – v6.8, v7.3, v7.4
15.3.3 Added description of motor current sense
15.3.4 Added section for step-by-step function
15.8.2 Clarified reset and pickup times on
Voltage Offset B
15.10.3 Added description for setting group
selection
15.10.8 Added description for I/O timers
17 New settings added (Tables 2-15, 2-20,
2-21, 2-24)
Hardware Version
Version Release Date Description of Main Changes
00 April 2016 First release
01 September 2016 Module type P Tap position input connections changed
Module type S Orientation of Ethernet ports changed
Serial communication terminating resistor moved
02 January 2017 Module type D Frequency measurement response time reduced
03 May 2017 Module type G Ability to reject AC signals added (selectable in software)
04 June 2017 Case height marginally reduced to meet 4u cutout standard
SFP removal warning added
05 June 2018 Real time clock lithium backup battery replaced with capacitor
Module type A Voltage range of tapchanger interface extended
Note. The hardware version of the relay may be determined from the label in the bottom left-hand
corner of the front panel. The relay type is printed in the form ‘FP1034-XXXXXXXXXX-XHH’,
and the digits in the position ‘HH’ represent the hardware version.
Software Version
Version Release Date Description of Main Changes
v4.0 April 2016 First release
v5.0 December 2016 New features added:
General voltage offset group B
Load response
Frequency response
Tap stagger
Frequency tripping
Note. The software version of the relay may be determined from within the menu structure in
‘Instruments/Diagnostics/Relay Info (7/xx)’. The software version is the displayed on the first
line of the display.
Table of Contents
Sections 1 to 12 can be found in part 1 of the user manual.
Scope ........................................................................................................................................ 2-3
Version Information .................................................................................................................. 2-3
Conventions and Definitions ...................................................................................................... 2-9
13 Introduction to SuperTAPP SG .......................................................................................... 2-12
13.1 Purpose .......................................................................................................................... 2-12
13.2 Physical Overview .......................................................................................................... 2-12
14 Ordering Options and Configuration ................................................................................. 2-12
14.1 Function Levels .............................................................................................................. 2-13
14.2 Ordering Options and Product Codes ............................................................................ 2-13
15 Description of Functions ................................................................................................... 2-15
15.1 Voltage Control for 2-Winding Transformers ................................................................ 2-15
15.2 Integrated Control Panel ............................................................................................... 2-24
15.3 Tap-changer Control, Monitoring and Runaway Prevention......................................... 2-25
15.4 Measurement of AC Voltage and Current ..................................................................... 2-36
15.5 Distributed or Embedded Generation ........................................................................... 2-46
15.6 Busbar Configurations ................................................................................................... 2-48
15.7 AVC for 3-Winding Transformers (Double Secondary Winding) ................................... 2-50
15.8 Adjustments to Target Voltage ...................................................................................... 2-51
15.9 Functions Acting on Multiple Transformers .................................................................. 2-56
15.10 Transformer temperature monitoring and control ....................................................... 2-61
15.11 General Inputs and Outputs .......................................................................................... 2-67
15.12 Communications and Data Storage ............................................................................... 2-74
16 Application Guidance........................................................................................................ 2-78
16.1 Fundamentals Application Support ............................................................................... 2-78
16.2 Basic Control Scheme Design......................................................................................... 2-78
16.3 Determination of Settings ............................................................................................. 2-85
16.4 Feeder Current Measurements ..................................................................................... 2-88
17 Settings List .................................................................................................................... 2-100
18 Specifications ................................................................................................................. 2-118
18.1 General ........................................................................................................................ 2-118
18.2 Functional Characteristics............................................................................................ 2-118
18.3 Electrical Characteristics .............................................................................................. 2-119
18.4 Electromagnetic Characteristics .................................................................................. 2-120
18.5 Mechanical and Atmospheric Characteristics ............................................................. 2-120
19 Connection Diagrams...................................................................................................... 2-122
20 Locations........................................................................................................................ 2-126
Text Conventions
Important information in the text may be in the form of either Warnings or Notes:
NOTE: A note gives significant additional information about the use of the product.
Glossary
Primary (VT, CT related) refers to the winding of a VT or CT which receives the
voltage or current to be measured
Pseudo-VT Feature which calculates the voltage and current on the opposite side of
the transformer from that on which it is measured.
Secondary (VT, CT related) refers to the winding of a VT or CT which produces the
transformed voltage or current
Abbreviations
AVC Automatic Voltage Control
AT Ampere-turns
CT Current Transformer
DSS Directional Sequence Switch – signals whenever a raise or lower operation
occurs at the tap changer
ESD Electrostatic Discharge
HV High Voltage (see Voltage Conventions)
IED Intelligent Electronic Device – a device that monitors components of
electrical power supplies and issues control commands based on the data
received
LSS Local Selector Switch – controls whether the tap changer is operated locally
(at the mechanism itself) by an operator, or remotely by the AVC system
RFI Radiofrequency Interference
Voltage Conventions
There are a variety of phrases indicating particular voltage levels in use in different contexts, such as
low voltage (LV), medium voltage (MV), high voltage (HV) and extra high voltage (EHV). Some of these
have IEC definitions attached to them and some are accepted as ‘industry standard’ for a particular
situation.
Since the SuperTAPP SG relay can be applied at many voltage levels and in different countries we have
avoided the use of any of these phrases to indicate an absolute level or a part of a transmission or
distribution network.
However, since SuperTAPP SG is primarily concerned with transformers, it is useful to identify different
voltage levels connected to the transformer and for this we use the following convention:
HV (or high voltage) is used to indicate the higher (or highest) voltage level connected to a
transformer, or the winding itself.
LV (or low voltage) is used to indicate the lower voltage level(s) connected to a transformer, or
the winding itself (ignoring any auxiliary windings). In a 3-winding transformer all the windings
(again ignoring auxiliary windings) may have different voltage levels in which case the phrase LV
will be applicable to all but the HV winding.
The flow of real and reactive power will usually be given context by directional arrows within a
diagram. If the arrow is pointing towards a resistive load the real power flow will be a positive number,
while if it is pointing towards a generator the real power flow will be a negative number. Similarly if
the arrow is pointing towards an inductor the imaginary (or reactive) power flow will be a positive
number, while if it is pointing towards a capacitor the imaginary (or reactive) power flow will be a
negative number.
In the absence of explicit directional arrows the implicit directional sense will be towards the busbar
on transformer incomers, and away from the busbar on all other feeders, as per Figure 2-1.
Power is defined as P + jQ = V.I* where V and I are complex numbers and * is the conjugation
operator.
13 Introduction to SuperTAPP SG
The SuperTAPP SG is the fourth generation of AVC relay designed by Fundamentals, building on a rich
history and heritage gained from direct experience of working with the fundamentals of power system
operation. Previous relays in the line of succession include the original TAPP, SuperTAPP, MicroTAPP
and SuperTAPP n+.
13.1 Purpose
The SuperTAPP SG is designed for automatic voltage control of power systems via transformers with
on-load tap-changers. It can cater for all voltage control applications from the straightforward to the
complex and difficult to solve. Situations which it can handle include two-winding transformers, three-
winding transformers, distributed or embedded generation, fluctuating load power factors, differing
voltage sources, transformers and tap spacings, paralleling across networks, transfer taps and many
more.
Note. ‘v v’ in the product code is a 2-digit number indicating the hardware version. This issue of the
manual is applicable to the hardware versions indicated in the Version Information on page ii.
15 Description of Functions
The measured voltage (VVT) is compared with the target voltage of the relay (Vtgt). If the difference
exceeds the bandwidth setting, a tap changer operation is initiated to adjust the transformer voltage
to a satisfactory level.
where
VT = transformer measured voltage of LV winding
Vbasic = relay basic target voltage setting
Vadj = voltage target adjustments (see section 15.8)
VLDC = load drop compensation bias voltage (see section 15.1.2)
Vgen = embedded generator bias voltage *
VNCB = network circulating bias voltage
VSCB = site circulating bias voltage
Figure 2-3 Function diagram for calculation of target voltage and voltage deviation
Calculations /
Wdg 1 volt biases Calculations /
VT Measured voltage
Wdg 1 volt biases
+ Deviation Vdev
Calculations / -
S SCADA point
Wdg 1 volt biases
Vbasic
Vadj
S Set target
S Calculations /
Wdg 1 volt biases
Effective target
VLDC
Effective voltage
target
Vgen
VNCB
VSCB
Deadband
The bandwidth or deadband setting, Vbw in
On SuperTAPP Advanced and Ultimate SG function levels, the “Bandwidth 2” setting can be used to
temporarily reduce the bandwidth after the measured voltage has gone outside the deadband. This
has the effect of increasing the hysteresis (from the default of 0.1 %). The setting value must be less
than that of the “Bandwidth” setting and its function is controlled by the “Bandwidth 2 type” setting.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “On”, when the deviation exceeds the bandwidth the relay will
continue tapping until the deviation returns inside the Bandwidth 2 value.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “Target change only”, the bandwidth is reduced to the Bandwidth 2
value when the basic voltage target is changed. This is useful if a definite change in tap position is
required when the voltage target is changed. The bandwidth is reset when the measured voltage
returns within the deadband.
Figure 2-4, defines the sensitivity to voltage fluctuations. Reducing the bandwidth setting will maintain
the voltage closer to the target level (i.e. increase the voltage control accuracy), but will increase the
number of tap changer operations. It is represented by a ±% value based on the system nominal
voltage.
If the deviation of the measured voltage from the target voltage (Vdev) is less than the bandwidth (i.e.
within the deadband), no tap changes will occur.
On SuperTAPP Advanced and Ultimate SG function levels, the “Bandwidth 2” setting can be used to
temporarily reduce the bandwidth after the measured voltage has gone outside the deadband. This
has the effect of increasing the hysteresis (from the default of 0.1 %). The setting value must be less
than that of the “Bandwidth” setting and its function is controlled by the “Bandwidth 2 type” setting.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “On”, when the deviation exceeds the bandwidth the relay will
continue tapping until the deviation returns inside the Bandwidth 2 value.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “Target change only”, the bandwidth is reduced to the Bandwidth 2
value when the basic voltage target is changed. This is useful if a definite change in tap position is
required when the voltage target is changed. The bandwidth is reset when the measured voltage
returns within the deadband.
Voltage
deviation +Vbw+Vft
+Vbw
Vdev
-Vbw
Monitoring / Tap
Changer monitoring
-Vbw-Vft Status
Direction
AUTO_RAISE
Time to tap tinit
Tap Raise
Initial delay timer
tinter Status
AUTO_LOWER
Direction
Inter-tap timer
Time Tap Lower
On SuperTAPP Advanced and Ultimate SG function levels, the “Bandwidth 2” setting can be used to
temporarily reduce the bandwidth after the measured voltage has gone outside the deadband. This
has the effect of increasing the hysteresis (from the default of 0.1 %). The setting value must be less
than that of the “Bandwidth” setting and its function is controlled by the “Bandwidth 2 type” setting.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “On”, when the deviation exceeds the bandwidth the relay will
continue tapping until the deviation returns inside the Bandwidth 2 value.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “Target change only”, the bandwidth is reduced to the Bandwidth 2
value when the basic voltage target is changed. This is useful if a definite change in tap position is
required when the voltage target is changed. The bandwidth is reset when the measured voltage
returns within the deadband.
Figure 2-4.
If the inter tap time delay is configured to be less than the tap operation time, successive taps are
delayed until the previous tap operation completes. As long as the measured voltage is still out of band
the SuperTAPP SG will display ‘Time to tap 0s’ until the tap occurs.
Fast Tap
Under some circumstances the normal initial time delay is bypassed and a corrective tap changer
operation is initiated after a fast tap time delay. The conditions under which fast tapping can take place
are as follows:
High voltage above fast tap threshold
Low voltage below fast tap threshold
Following a change to the relay basic target voltage or application of the voltage target
adjustments (-3%, -6% etc.).
When preparing for switch-out
The fast tap threshold is a configurable setting. It is specified as an addition to the bandwidth setting,
and is also selectable as applying to high voltages only, or high and low voltages, or off. If a bandwidth
of ±2% and a fast tap threshold of ±0.5% are set then the fast tap occurs at ±2.5%, see
On SuperTAPP Advanced and Ultimate SG function levels, the “Bandwidth 2” setting can be used to
temporarily reduce the bandwidth after the measured voltage has gone outside the deadband. This
has the effect of increasing the hysteresis (from the default of 0.1 %). The setting value must be less
than that of the “Bandwidth” setting and its function is controlled by the “Bandwidth 2 type” setting.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “On”, when the deviation exceeds the bandwidth the relay will
continue tapping until the deviation returns inside the Bandwidth 2 value.
If the Bandwidth 2 type is set to “Target change only”, the bandwidth is reduced to the Bandwidth 2
value when the basic voltage target is changed. This is useful if a definite change in tap position is
required when the voltage target is changed. The bandwidth is reset when the measured voltage
returns within the deadband.
Figure 2-4.
The delay used for fast tap is also configurable using the fast tap time delay setting.
The settings relating to basic voltage control are listed in Table 2-22. Advice on the selection of
appropriate setting values is provided in the Applications section 16.
The voltage bias for LDC (VLDC) is applied in proportion to the load current (Iload in Figure 2-6) and is
expressed as a percentage boost at full load. For example, an LDC setting (KLDC) of 10% means that at
full load the voltage boost applied to the relay will be 10% of nominal. At half load, the boost will be
5%. Full load is defined by the LDC rating setting (ILR)
LDC is applied according to the assumed load power factor to minimise the effects of purely reactive
network components such as capacitor banks, heavy industrial loads etc. The effect of this is shown in
Figure 2-6. The applied LDC voltage bias is capped at the setting level; it cannot exceed the setting level
even if the LDC load is above the LDC rating.
The related settings can be found in Table 2-22.
The circulating current voltage bias is made up of two components: a bias arising from site circulating
current, and a bias arising from network circulating current. The site circulating current is calculated
using the ‘true circulating current’ method, which is dependent on the individual transformer load and
the summed load of paralleled transformers, as exhibited in Figure 2-7.
Figure 2-8 shows a situation involving paralleling across the network and includes site circulating
current ISC and network circulating current INC. The network circulating current is calculated using the
‘TAPP’ method (Transformer Automatic Paralleling Package). This is the circulating current exported
from (or imported to) the site. Since it is not possible to measure an overall load setting across the
network, the network power factor setting is used as the basis for the calculation (typically around
0.96 lagging). The network circulating current is the circulating current of the site, with respect to the
network power factor, INC in Figure 2-8.
The logic diagram of Figure 2-9 includes the circulating current calculations. The related settings can
be found in Table 2-23 and Table 2-24.
Wdg n impedance
(ZT)
Wdg n source
impedance (ZS)
Network circ curr.
factor (Kcirc)
15.1.3.3 Master-Follower
In a very few circumstances SuperTAPP SG may be applied to parallel transformers when it is not
possible to use the TAPP method to keep transformers in step, for example if there are no CTs which
are able to provide transformer current measurements. For these circumstances SuperTAPP SG is
equipped with master-follower mode.
Fundamentals do not recommend the use of master-follower mode except in situations where it is
unavoidable, because it is an inferior method of keeping transformers in step and the constraints it
imposes:
Transformers (capacity, impedance, tap spacing) must be identical; and
They must be fed from the same voltage source, with the same source impedance and no tees on
the incoming lines.
If master-follower must be used it is selected with the Voltage control mode setting (Table 2-22). A
setting is also available to define the delay for the follower after the master taps.
The master-follower behaves as follows:
When a relay is set in master-follower mode, or is powered up in master-follower mode it looks to
see if there are any other relays in the same busbar group (and also in master-follower). If not, it
will become the master; if there are it will become a follower of the master.
When a follower relay is switched from manual to auto, or is powered up in auto, it will tap to the
same tap position as the master.
If a master relay taps, whether it is in auto or manual, all follower relays in the same busbar group
which are in auto will tap to maintain the same tap position, following a short delay as defined by
their ‘Follower delay’ settings.
Whenever one of the follower relays has a different tap position to the master, the master and
the relevant follower will indicate out of step, and the master will inhibit further automatic
tapping until the follower relays have caught up.
If, for any reason, a follower remains out of step for the defined Alarm time (Table 2-29), an alarm
will be generated (on SCADA comms and on binary outputs as defined by the ‘Out of step alarm’
setting - Table 2-32). When the situation is corrected further automatic taps will be allowed again.
The master relay can be selected locally or through SCADA as follows:
When in This Panel mode by pressing and holding the ‘Auto’ button for 3 seconds on the relay
which is required to be the master;
When in SCADA mode using SCADA communications; or
In either mode using the ‘Select master’ binary input.
The currently selected master is indicated locally on the main screen and to SCADA by the SCADA
communications, and also a binary output as defined by the ‘Master’ setting (Table 2-32).
Figure 2-11 Connection arrangements for the power supply and scheme logic module
Indicated HV LV
Position
Voltage(V) Current (A) Voltage(V) Current (A)
1 36776 358.9
2 36304 363.6
3 35832 368.4
4 35360 373.3
5 34888 378.4
6 34416 383.5
7 33944 388.9
8 33472 394.4
9 33000 400
12 32528 405.8
13 32056 411.8
14 31584 417.9
15 31112 424.3
16 30640 430.8
17 30168 437.5
18 29696 444.5
19 29224 451.7
In this example the tapchanger performs an automatic transfer tap when tapping up from indicated
positions 8 or 10 or when tapping down from indicated positions 12 or 10. Tapping from 9 to 10 or
from 11 to 10 does not result in a change in voltage ratio and positions 9 and 11 are transitory,
where the tapchanger, under normal operation, never remains in these positions. . The use of the
setting “number of consecutive transfer taps” (as seen in Table 2-7 and Table 2-9) defines the
number of additional transitory tap operations allowed which if exceeded will result in a runaway
being issued.
Table 2-7 shows the relevant settings for TPI customisation for the example. The TPI customisation
menu lists the TPI inputs labelled as “TPI tap” against the expected winding ratio tap position. The
winding ratio tap setting describes the distinct transformer ratio step between the configured top
tap voltage and bottom tap voltage in the transformer settings. Each TPI tap input setting can be
configured with its corresponding ratio position. The number of tap positions setting determines the
number of tap positions expected on the TPI input. The minimum and maximum tap position setting
relates to the displayed tap position (see 15.3.4) and represents where tap blocking should be
applied.
Table 2-8 Typical (9a, 9b, 9c) HV Rating plate example for customised TPI settings
Indicated HV LV
Position
Voltage(V) Current (A) Voltage(V) Current (A)
1 36776 358.9
2 36304 363.6
3 35832 368.4
4 35360 373.3
5 34888 378.4
6 34416 383.5
7 33944 388.9
8 33472 394.4
9 a 33000 400
10 32528 405.8
11 32056 411.8
12 31584 417.9
13 31112 424.3
14 30640 430.8
15 30168 437.5
16 29696 444.5
17 29224 451.7
As seen in Table 2-8 position 9 will be indicated on nominal taps 9a, 9b and 9c. The transformer ratio
does not change over these positions and the sender will indicate no TPI position change even though
tapping has occurred. Table 2-9 then shows that by using the “transfer position” setting (Xfer pos) we
can signify that we accept additional taps as defined by “Number of consecutive transfer taps” entering
and leaving this position.
Within the TPI customisation menu any tap position indication setting that is not configured with an
associated Xfer setting is expected to only take one tap operation. If the associated Xfer setting is
configured, then the maximum number of tap operations expected at the Xfer position is set by the
“Number of consecutive transfer taps” setting. This setting signifies the maximum taps allowed
through the discrete positions but if the setting is too high it will result in inefficient detection of
runaways throughout the transfer. Whereas fewer taps will not generate a runaway or tap incomplete
error and the setting may be increased to allow for correct functional in asymmetric tap changers.
Where no associated Xfer setting is configured against a winding ratio tap value then the number of
tap operations as set by the “Number of consecutive transfer taps” is expected anywhere within the
tapping range before a lockout due to runaway is issued. Where TPI failures occurs, a lack of tap
position indication causes tap customisation to be not applicable. The relay will then regress to the
“Number of consecutive transfer taps” expected anywhere within the tapping range.
The relay will detect if the transfer and tap customisation has been entered incorrectly. An error
message will be displayed on the relay LCD screen indicating “TPI Settings error”. This should be
observed through commissioning or setting changes and does not have any application to comms.
Runaway prevention
The runaway prevention function includes within it monitoring of
the control signals (raise, lower, in progress),
the tap position, and
tapchanger motor current.
These are combined with the expected characteristics of the tapchanger such as operating time to
detect if the tapchanger is running away (i.e. carrying out more than one tapping operation for a single
instruction). If a runaway, or an incomplete tapchange is detected a ‘lockout’ output can be generated
to trip the tapchanger, and settings are provided for this in Table 2-27.
The ‘motor current sense’ inputs on the Tap Position Inputs module type P allows the tap changer
motor current to be monitored using a standard SuperTAPP interposing CT (type FP1030). This is a
more robust method of determining if the tapchanger motor runs for an excessive period, and if it is
available it is used as the definitive indication of operation of the tapchanger.
If the voltage cannot be corrected (e.g. tap changer mechanism fault or end of range), the relay will
stop issuing raise/lower signals and may additionally trip the tapchanger motor MCB. Additionally after
a common alarm time the associated AVC alarm will be raised. A list and description of each monitored
condition is given in Table 2-10 and the associated settings can be found in Table 2-24,Table 2-28 and
Table 2-32.
Reverse current limit – blocks tapping when the current exceeds the tapchanger rating in the
reverse direction. Some tapchangers (particularly those with an asymmetrical pennant cycle) can
have a lower rating when current flow is in the reverse direction. The limit level is specified by
setting (Table 2-24).
Voltage high limit – blocks tapping in the raise direction when the voltage is higher than the
setting less half the bandwidth (Table 2-28)
Voltage low limit – blocks tapping in the lower direction when the voltage is lower than the
setting plus half the bandwidth (Table 2-28)
Low volt inhibit level – inhibits automatic tapping when the voltage is lower than the setting level
since this indicates a dead bus (Table 2-28).
External blocking – an external digital input can be used to manually block tap operations, or to
generate the block from another relay, as specified by the Tap block setting (Table 2-31).
** No blocking, but further auto tapping of the master is inhibited until the out of step is corrected
Voltage
Figure 2-13 assumes that a 3-phase VT is available. If this is not the case alternative connection
arrangements are possible with some reduction in functionality. The SuperTAPP SG provides complete
flexibility over which voltage inputs to use with which VT and which phases. The relevant settings are
provided in Table 2-25.
Current
The current is measured with the use of an interposing CT. The primary CT should have a nominal 0.2A,
0.5A, 1A or 5A secondary winding. This is wired through an interposing CT which is supplied with the
SuperTAPP SG relay, ICTx as shown in Figure 2-13. It is the secondary windings of the interposing CT
which are wired to the relay terminals.
There are a number of advantages of using the interposing CT method of current measurement.
Since the output and rating of the interposing CT is very low (mA) it removes the dangers
associated with open circuit CTs.
No CT shorting is required if it is necessary to remove the SuperTAPP SG relay for any reason.
The interposing CTs have low burden and can be installed around protection secondary cores of
existing CTs. This is useful when measuring currents in feeders which do not have spare CTs.
Voltage
VT and phase
* * * Voltage V&,VT3
3rd
ph., PPS,
jp NPS, Line x
V.I.4
e VT4 (secy.) VT4 (prmy. & %)
V4 VT4 Measured
* * * Voltage V&,VT4
3rd
ph., PPS,
jp NPS, Line x
e
VTs & CTs / V& = Line volts V
VTs & CTs / VT1:
Voltage Input 1: Connected to * Vab, Vbc, Vca Ratio & Vab Vbc Vca
Phase PPS, NPS (Va Vb Vc)
Repeat for: Reversed connect. Line voltage Repeat for: Vpps Vnps
...
A single ‘line voltage’ is also determined, which is used in all voltage control algorithms. The following
methodology is used to determine the line voltage:
If two or three phase-phase voltages are measured, the line voltage is the average of the three
(after calculation of the third if necessary).
If one phase-phase voltage is measured, it is used as the line voltage
If two or three phase-earth voltages are measured the line voltage is the average multiplied by
root three.
If one phase-earth voltage is measured it is assumed to be a single phase system and will be the
line voltage (no multiplication by root three)
The positive phase sequence angle is used as the reference for load angle calculations.
Measurements /
AC Card 1 secondaries Measurements /
C.I.1 AC Card 1 primaries CT1 Current Real
C1
F C1 CT1 Current Magnitude CT1 Current Reactive ICI1
select x ejq
C.I.2
ejp T
CT2 Current Real
C2
F C2 CT2 Current Magnitude CT2 Current Reactive ICI2
select x ejq
C.I.3
ejp T
CT3 Current Real
C3
F C3 CT3 Current Magnitude CT3 Current Reactive ICI3
select x ejq
ejp T
Measurements /
AC Card 2 secondaries Measurements /
C.I.4 AC Card 2 primaries CT4 Current Real
` C4
F C4 CT4 Current Magnitude CT4 Current Reactive ICI4
select x ejq
e jp T
...
...
...
C.I.10 CT10 Current Real
` C10 F C10 CT10 Current Magnitude CT10 Current Reactive ICI10
select x ejq
ejp T
...
...
C.I.10 / CT Ratio
C.I.10/No. of interposer turns
Correct selection of the voltage/current phase relationship is critical for operation of the relay.
Comprehensive instrumentation is available to aid this including:
Secondary values of all current measurements with magnitude and angle with respect to the
voltage reference
Primary values of all current measurements with magnitude and power factor
Figure 2-18 Function diagram for voltage measurement mapping to transformer winding and bus
group
Calculations /
Trfrmr Wdg 1 Voltage (%)
VT,wdg1
...
wdg1
wdg2
BS15
BS1
BS2
... Transformer
Wdg1 bus section
... Calculations /
Busbar group A Voltage (%) VGpA
m
Busbar group B Voltage (%) VGpB
Bus m
Group
Map
...
...
The ‘Connected to’ setting for each VT (Figure 2-18) has options of:
‘Transformer winding 1’ – the main option used for the transformer under control of this
SuperTAPP SG,
‘Transformer winding 2’ – used to specify a second secondary winding on 3-winding (double
secondary) transformers,
‘Bus section 1’ to ‘Bus section 15’ – for all other connections, using the relevant bus section
number to indicate where in the substation the VT is connected.
Separate settings (in the ‘Transformer’ menu) tell the SuperTAPP SG which bus section the transformer
windings are connected to.
Figure 2-19 gives an example, with the relevant settings for each SuperTAPP SG in Table 2-11.
If the current input is used for any other function it is allocated to a bus section but each function type
is kept separate for further calculation. The SuperTAPP SG allocates each bus section’s currents to the
appropriate bus group and carries out further calculations according to the current input functions,
indicated by the fn block in Figure 2-20.
Figure 2-20 Function diagram for current calculations and mapping to transformer winding and bus
group
Calculations /
Trfrmr Wdg 1 Load IT,wdg1
...
wdg1
wdg2
BS15
BS2
Calculations /
Busbar group A * I&,GpA
fn I& =Transformer load Iload
Busbar group B * I&,GpB Generation Igen
Bus fn Total load Itotal
Group as vectors
Map
...
...
Advice on when and how to use and apply these options is given in the Application Guidance in section
16.4.
15.4.9 CT Trimming
Applies to: SuperTAPP Advanced and Ultimate SG function levels
Figure 2-13 and Figure 2-14 show the use of SuperTAPP SG with inputs of voltage from VTs, and inputs
of current from CTs employing the use of interposing CTs. In most instances the SuperTAPP SG makes
use of the ring-core CT Fundamentals type FP1030 delivered with the SuperTAPP SG relay. This CT has
an inherent phase shift which changes with current magnitude and the SuperTAPP SG is calibrated
assuming this.
On occasion an alternative interposing CT may be required to be used and, to maintain accuracy, the
measured current angle can be adjusted to accommodate different phase shifts using a 3-piece linear
curve. The settings related to measurement trimming can be found in Table 2-25. The defaults for
these settings are for the Fundamentals CT type FP1030 so in most cases no further adjustment will be
required, although they can be trimmed on site if required.
The piece-wise curve is defined using three points, specified in terms of an angle adjustment at a
particular Ampere-turn (AT) input to the interposing CT. The curve is linearly interpolated between the
specified points. The impact of this phase correction is shown in Figure 2-21 for the default setting
values.
The major impact on SuperTAPP SG of different CT characteristics is in angle measurement, but
another factor in measurement accuracy is the constancy of CT transformation ratio across the
measurement range. The SuperTAPP SG is tuned for the type FP1030 interposing CTs (with a
transformation ratio of 1000:1 when one primary turn is used) and a feature to adjust it for other CTs
is provided through settings of magnitude zero offset (Ioffset) and magnitude gradient (Ik,grad), with
effects as follows (referring to Figure 2-13 and Figure 2-14):
10, 1.5
0
2.5, 0.25
Angle Adjustment (°)
-2
0.5, -2
-4
-6
-8
0.06, -8
-10
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Current Magnitude (AT)
15.4.10 Pseudo-VT
Applies to: SuperTAPP Ultimate SG function level
SuperTAPP SG is capable of calculating the voltage and current on the opposite side of the
transformer to the VT and CT, taking into account the tap position and voltage drop due to load
through the transformer.
If the configured controlled voltage location or busbar location is on one side of the transformer and
the VT and CT are on the other side then the Pseudo-VT function is activated. The voltage or current
on the opposite side of the transformer is calculated and used as if it was measured at that location.
The mimic on the main data screen is updated to show the new locations, with the VT and CT drawn
dotted to indicate that the values have been calculated using the Pseudo-VT function. The controlled
side of the transformer can be changed as necessary using setting groups.
When using Pseudo-VT it is critical that the tap position is measured accurately. If a problem is
detected with the tap position indicator, tapping is blocked and an alarm is raised.
Generator current IG is added to the transformer current IT to determine the total load current Iload for
the bus group, and it is this total load which is used for LDC bias in Figure 2-6.
Figure 2-22 LDC boost profiles with Reverse LDC off and on
Figure 2-23 LDC boost profiles with Reverse LDC off and on
Figure 2-24 Function diagram for manual allocation of bus sections to bus groups by setting
Busbar grouping
Busbar grouping
ctrled by = Settings Bus Group
Map
Bus section 1 is in
busbar group BS1
Bus section 2 is in
busbar group BS2
...
...
Bus section 15 is in
busbar group BS15
...
GpA
GpB
GpO
Figure 2-25 Function diagram for automatic allocation of bus groupings from circuit breakers
...
...
CB8 Status
CB8 connects bus
Busbar CB 8 closed sections
...
GpA
GpB
GpO
In order to implement voltage averaging, each VT and current input must be configured as being
connected to the correct winding in the settings, see Table 2-25. The biases, targets and deviations for
each winding are calculated separately. The deviations are then averaged and compared against the
bandwidth.
Where the measured voltage on a VT input falls below 80% nominal voltage (for example in the event
of a fuse failure), the relay will automatically revert to using the remaining VT for voltage control.
Averaging will resume once the other VT input recovers back to above the 80% level.
Vinc_adj
VVO_A
S
VVO_B Vadj
VVO_L
VVO_F
Figure 2-33 demonstrates the effect, where the ratio of the two transformers are n:1 and (n+s):1,
where s is the amount of the stagger. The total load Iload seen on the transformers’ LV windings is
reflected through to the HV windings, with the average of the two ratios. There is also an additional
term, reflecting a proportion of the circulating current ISC. Since circulating current is almost entirely
reactive this results in an additional reactive load on the network which is a function of the
transformers and the tap difference, and immune to load current.
Four different tap stagger levels (S1, S2, S3 and S4) are provided of which only one can be active at a
time. A tap stagger level can be activated through digital inputs or through SCADA communications. If
the activation is through SCADA communications it remains active until it is subsequently deactivated
(although not through a restart). If the activation is through digital inputs it remains active until the
input is removed.
Only one tap stagger level may be applied at a time. If multiple levels are selected the priority order is
S4, then S3, S2 and S1; activation of lower priority levels will be ignored until higher priority levels have
been deactivated. SuperTAPP SG requires multiple transformers in parallel to operate, and if not tap
stagger will be unavailable. The SuperTAPP SG requested to provide the stagger will communicate with
the other SuperTAPP SGs in order to deliver the function and maintain voltage regulation.
The setpoint for the stagger level is in terms of no. of taps, and the SuperTAPP SG converts this into
equivalent offset which it adds to the site circulating bias used by the voltage control algorithm.
If necessary (e.g. the end of the tapping range is reached) the requested tap stagger will be delivered
at the expense of maintaining the dead band, however the upper and lower alarm levels will never be
breached.
Tap stagger S4, the highest priority level, has an additional activation input from the fast frequency
response function, and this is described in section 15.9.3.
The winding “hot-spot” temperature can either be measured or be calculated from the oil temperature
and measured load current in accordance with IEC 60076-7:2018.
Pumps Model
running parameters
x y k11 k21 k22 to tw ϴor ϴhr
If a measurement of winding hotspot is available, it is used directly for cooling and monitoring
If a measurement of oil temperature is available, but no winding hotspot measurement, the
model will estimate winding hotspot temperature from transformer current.
If neither oil nor winding measurements are available, the model will use ambient temperature
together with transformer current to estimate oil and hotspot temperatures.
The model can also forecast a short-term future temperature and the final temperature for the current
flowing using the ambient temperature.
Winding
Temperature Model
now qw,meas *
meas Hotspot temp qh,0
select
calc Calculations /
IT
Temperature Thermal mgmnt
qa
q>
qo,0
q>
qh,0
q>
qo,st C1_ACT
q> &
qh,st
q>
qo,fin
q>
qh,fin
q>
Cx xxxxxxx cooling
stage C2_ACT
Item Description
Ambient temperature The measured ambient temperature currently
(qa)
Oil temperature (qo,0) The measured or calculated oil temperature currently
Winding temperature The measured or calculated winding temperature currently
(qh,0)
Forecast oil and winding The oil and winding temperature it is forecast the transformer will reach in
temperatures (qo,st) the number of minutes specified by the Short term forecast time setting
(assuming no change to the current or cooling stage) using the IEC
thermal model
Final oil and winding The oil and winding temperature it is forecast the transformer will stabilise
temperatures (qo,fin) at (assuming no change to the current or cooling stage) using the IEC
thermal model
Oil and winding Dependency on previous temperatures.
temperature hysteresis
(qh,fin)
BO 1 2 ... n
Digital outputs
Cx_ACT
Cooling fans
Sequencer
Cooling pumps
Cx xxxxxx
cooling stage
Number of pumps *
Number of fans
Yes VO_L1activate
select C2
No C3
Cx xxxxxx
cooling stage *
Repeat for:
Activate L1 voltage offset * C2 medium cooling
stage and C3
maximum cooling
stage
Within each cooling stage, there are sequences to ensure different pumps and fans are activated each
time. This is done automatically by the relay as described below:
When a new cooling stage is activated, outputs which have not been selected during the previous
active cooling stage will be favoured by the sequencer.
Similarly, the sequencer will de-energise the longest running devices when a decrease in cooling
devices is requested by exiting a cooling stage.
In the case of a long-lasting cooling stage; a max runtime timer for each pump and fan device type
will energise the next idle output(s) and de-energise the original one(s).
The number of configured output(s) for each fan and pump in a cooling stage will always be
satisfied unless the number of digital outputs configured does not allow it. For instance, for a
given cooling stage requiring 4 pumps to run but only 2 digital outputs have been configured for
pumps, only 2 pumps would be selected by the sequencer.
The sequencing is suitable for sites with multiple fans or pumps and provides alternation in the
deployment of equipment.
Terminal block A B C D E F G H I J
Type F
Additional AC 7I
Type K or L
DC analogue * AI
AO
RTD
Type S
SCADA CAN
communications +
comms
* Module type K has 2AI, 3AO and 1RTD; module type L has 1AI, 1AO and 3RTD.
The type K or L module would normally be expected to be located at terminal block F, as per Figure
2-44 and Figure 2-45. However, if terminal block F is required for digital I/O, then it could be located
in terminal block G. Therefore, this diagram should be used indicatively and reference made to the
wiring diagram for the actual relay type for the correct allocations.
The mA inputs are passive and require an external source to energise the loop. The mA outputs are
active, i.e. they provide the energisation for the loop, in addition to controlling the current flow.
Therefore no other sources should be added to the loop to avoid overvoltages and potential damage
to the relay and other equipment.
The RTD inputs is of the 3-wire type which provides compensation for lead length between the sensor
and the SuperTAPP SG.
Figure 2-44 Connection arrangements for type Figure 2-45 Connection arrangements for type
K DC analogue I/O module L DC analogue I/O module
SCADA inputs
Most of the input functions are ‘activation’ or ‘enable’ type which would typically be received from
SCADA using hardwiring from a substation RTU. As an alternative to this, all of these functions can also
be accessed using SCADA communications (see section 15.12.2).
Plant inputs
Most of the interface with substation plant is carried out via the dedicated scheme I/O card (see
section 15.3.1) which does not require any configuration. However additional plant input functions
may be allocated to the general purpose digital inputs. These are limited in number and listed below.
T/C motor overload – an input typically driven from the tap change motor MCB to indicate that
the tap change motor has tripped
Winding 1/2 CB closed – indicates the position of a transformer circuit breaker and is required for
some functions such as frequency tripping (ultimate function level only) which needs to be certain
about circuit breaker position.
Busbar CB n closed – indicates the position of a bus section circuit breaker and is required for
some functions such as frequency tripping (ultimate function level only) which needs to be certain
about circuit breaker position.
For the input functions which relate to circuit breaker position it is possible to create a double point
input using two inputs, one wired to the circuit breaker ‘a’ or NO contact and one wired to the ‘b’ or
NC contact. The input wired to the ‘b’ contact should be inverted and all inputs indicating circuit
breaker position should be supplied from DC and their inputs set to reject AC. An example of how this
should be set up is given in Table 2-14.
Functions 1 2 3 4 5
Invert input x x
AC Rejection x x x x
Winding 1 CB closed x x
Busbar CB 1 closed x x
When the inputs are set in this way, if the two inputs are inconsistent then the input will be flagged as
invalid and any functions which make use of this signal will “fail safe”. The behaviour of individual
functions in the event of an invalid input is included in the description for that function.
SCADA outputs
Most of the outputs are reporting the status of functions or alarms which would typically be received
by SCADA using hardwiring to a substation RTU. As an alternative to this, all of these functions can also
be accessed using SCADA communications (see section 15.12.2).
Plant outputs
Most of the interface with substation plant is carried out via the dedicated scheme I/O card (see
section 15.3.1) which does not require any configuration. The only additional plant output functions
which may need to be allocated to the general purpose digital outputs are:
Winding 1/2 CB trip/close – trip and close commands to circuit breakers as part of the frequency
tripping function (ultimate function level only).
15.11.5 mA Inputs
Applies to: relays with optional module type K or L
Milliamp inputs are mainly used for transformer thermal monitoring and control functions and to
facilitate the connection of measured temperatures to the relay. SuperTAPP SG then uses this
information for display and calculation purposes. There is always at least one mA input (Input 1)
located on the TPI module (type P). If a type K DC Analogue module is fitted, three additional mA inputs
(2, 3 and 4) are available. Similarly, if a type L DC Analogue module is fitted, one additional mA input is
available.
For each one of the milliamp input three settings are presented:
the function of the input,
the real world value at the minimum and associated mA input (0 to 24 mA), and
the real world value at the maximum and the associated mA input (0 to 24 mA).
Each one of the milliamp inputs can be assigned to any of the temperature measurements. Table 2-16
lists the functions which are available for milliamp input, and the real world values which can be
applied to the minimum and maximum value settings.
15.11.6 mA Outputs
Applies to: all function levels and options
There is always at least one mA output (Output 1) located on the TPI module (type P). If a type K DC
Analogue module is fitted, three additional mA outputs (2, 3 and 4) are available. It is generally
assumed that output 1 (on the TPI module) will be used for tap position, but this isn’t fixed and the
user can choose otherwise.
For each output three settings are presented:
the function of the output,
the real world value at the minimum and associated mA output (0 to 24 mA), and
the real world value at the maximum and the associated mA output (0 to 24 mA).
Table 2-16 lists the functions which are available for milliamp output, and the real world values which
can be applied to the minimum and maximum value settings.
15.11.8 Timers
Applies to: SuperTAPP Advanced and Ultimate SG function levels
Three general purpose pickup and dropoff timers are provided which can be mapped to digital inputs
and outputs. When a mapped input is activated for the pickup time then the timer output is activated,
which can be mapped to a digital output. After the digital input is deactivated for the dropoff time
then the timer output is deactivated.
The settings to map the digital inputs and outputs are shown in Table 2-31 and Table 2-32 respectively.
The time delay settings are shown in Table 2-35.
The inter-relay communications system is used to exchange a number of information types, for
example:
Transformer and feeder currents for LDC and minimisation of circulating current
Checking that voltage measurements and targets are consistent across the busbar group
Sharing of target adjustments to ensure correct operation across the busbar group
Group load
Each relay reports measurement and status information which is received by all relays connected by
inter-relay communications. Each relay has a transformer ID and a busbar no. which are configured in
the settings. Relays connected to the same busbar will use measurement data to calculate the group
load as follows:
The group load is important for operational calculations and is displayed with the individual
transformer measured current on the default screen of the relay.
Each unit on the CAN bus should have a unique transformer ID, otherwise there will be communication
errors which could result in load summation inaccuracy.
16 Application Guidance
16.2.2 Interposing CT
The interposing CT designed for use with the SuperTAPP SG provides a high level of electrical isolation
between the source current circuitry and imposes virtually no burden upon the measurement current
transformer.
Figure 2-48gives an external view of the interposing unit, shown from each side. The enclosure is
mounted on a reversible universal foot that will allow fixing onto either a G-rail or top hat rail mounting
arrangement. Screwed terminal output connections are available from either side of the unit.
The primary conductor (S1 from the primary CT) is passed through a central hole in the casing as shown
in Figure 2-48 and Figure 2-49.
CT isolation unit
Type FP1030
Ratio 10 : 0.01
S2 Max Burden 30 mVA S2 S1 Ser. No. Ser. No. S1
Fundamentals Ltd
www.fundamentalsltd.co.uk
P2 P1
The interposing CT should be mounted in a convenient position such that the distance between the
unit and the SuperTAPP SG is at a practical minimum. If there is substantial distance between the unit
and the device, a twisted-pair cable should be used. This may be the case where a protection CT is
utilised. In this instance the interposing CT should be mounted as close as possible to the primary CT
secondary wiring and in any event in the same panel. The electrical specification for the interposing CT
is shown in Table 2-17.
The maximum current that the device can measure with accuracy is 10 amps. Depending on the use of
the interposing unit, turns can be added to the primary side in order to increase the sensitivity of the
output. It is recommended that the number of turns should give ‘5 Amp turns’ at rated current as
shown in Table 2-18 and Figure 2-49.
5A 1
1A 5
0.5 A 10
In situations where the loading on the CT is low compared to the rating, accuracy can be compromised.
The number of turns on the interposer can be increased to improve the accuracy, but care is required
and in any case it is not recommended to increase the number of turns above 5 Amp-turns at the
normal maximum loading level. The maximum non-fault overload level should be less than 10 Amp-
turns.
For example, a feeder breaker CT (ratio 1000:5) would normally have a single interposer turn. If the
maximum loading of the feeder is 200 A, the number of turns could be increase to 5 to give more
accuracy.
The settings for each CT input need to be configured appropriately in order that the relay can convert
the measurements into the correct primary values (see CT settings in section 0).
The Inter-relay communications can accommodate a maximum of eight SuperTAPP SGs. Previous
relays MicroTAPP and SuperTAPP n+ also use CAN as a means of providing inter-relay communications,
however the implementations differ and a mix of relays cannot be used on a single CAN network.
The alternative settings may be particularly useful for the more ‘advanced’ applications where extra
CT and VT measurements are in use and where ‘safe AVC’ can be applied in the event of abnormal
conditions.
16.4.1 Implementation
The feeder current measurements are facilitated by feeder protection CTs. In order that this does not
compromise the protection scheme, very low burden interposing CTs are used to interface with the
SuperTAPP SG relay. These CTs are 1000:1 ratio wedding ring type with burden < 0.05 VA. The CTs are
described in detail in section 16.2.2.
All relay measurements are transmitted on the CAN bus to make them available for peer units.
Functions which make use of these measurements must be applied in the same way to all relays in the
busbar group, otherwise the desired effects will not be realised and voltage errors can occur. Special
attention therefore needs to be given to relays which are configured for feeder current measurements
so that the data can be available even when the transformers to which they are connected are
switched out (e.g. for maintenance), namely:
Power supply
The relay must be powered to continue transmitting measurement data. Normally the auxiliary AC
supply for tap changer control is used to power the control relays and this may be disconnected if the
transformer is switched out, so an alternative is required. The best solution is to use the DC supply (if
available) to power the relay. The SuperTAPP SG has a flexible AC/DC power supply available with an
input range of 88 – 253 V AC/DC.
Voltage reference.
The relay uses the VT input as a reference for calculation of real and reactive components of current.
The second VT input of the relay can be configured to use a VT from another transformer in the group
as a voltage reference when the main VT input is lost due to a transformer switch out. This will be
considered in detail in section 16.3.5, ‘VT Switching’.
16.4.1.1 Definitions
The important relay definitions are as follows:
Measured currents – transformers and feeders.
Non-measured load – sum of the load on feeders which are not being measured.
These values can be understood by reference to Figure 2-55which shows an application with feeder
measurements on two of the six feeders.
In this case both relays would show the following values in the instruments screens (see section
11.3.1):
Summed transformers = 600 A
Summed feeder measurements * = 130 A
Non-measured load = 470 A
*this data will be presented according to how the CT inputs are configured (see below).
Each CT input used for feeder current measurement must be configured in the settings for a specific
use. There are many uses to choose from, but broadly they can be split into three types, relating to:
Embedded Generation
Reactive Sources / Loads
Special Applications
Each of these types is described in detail in individual sections below.
where
3. Enhanced TAPP circulating current control using the ‘true’ group load.
All of the above-mentioned functions rely on the real-time calculation of the ‘true’ group load and the
generation output. There are two methods for this in respect of how the generation itself is connected
and how the corresponding feeder current measurement inputs are configured in the relay:
Direct generator connection – CT input configured as ‘generator’.
Indirect generator connection – CT input configured as ‘generator feeder’.
Relay 1 Relay 2
Transformer current = 320 A Transformer current = 80 A
Summed transformer currents = 320 A Summed transformer currents = 80 A
Summed feeder measurements = 0A Summed feeder measurements = -200 A
Non-measured load = 320 A Non-measured load = 280 A
Generator output = 0A Generator output = 200 A
Group Load = 320 A Group Load = 280 A
* the group ID of the relays must change to reflect the new configuration (see section 16.2.4.2 for
‘alternative settings’).
In order to accommodate all applications to include any number of transformers and generator
connections, the above calculations can be summarised as follows:
Summed transformer currents = ∑(ITn )
Generator output = ∑(IG )
Group Load = ∑(ITn ) + ∑(IG )
The generator feeder has connected load and generation but the feeder current measurement, IF,
cannot discern between them. The example network shows this where the measured feeder current
is -150 A, with 50 A of load and 200 A generation present.
The relay has a generation estimation function which can calculate load and generation present on the
network. The generator estimation function depends on the following:
Current Measurements
- Summed Transformer
- Generator Feeders
Load Ratio
The Load Ratio is a relay setting which is expressed as a percentage and defined as follows:
'true' load on generation feeders
Load Ratio =
load on 'non-measured' feeders
The load ratio of the example network shown in Figure 2-57 is 9% (50 A / 550 A).
The relevant calculations for the two relays shown in the example network are as follows (all data
presented in the relay instruments to aid troubleshooting):
Relay 1 Relay 2
Transformer current = 320 A Transformer current = 80 A
Summed transformer currents = 320 A Summed transformer currents = 80 A
Summed feeder measurements = 0A Summed feeder measurements = -150 A
Non-measured load = 320 A Non-measured load = 230 A
Estimated load † = 0A Estimated load † = 50 A
Estimated generation = 0A Estimated generation = 200 A
Group Load = 320 A Group Load = 280 A
* the group ID of the relays must change to reflect the new configuration (see section 16.2.4.2 for
‘alternative settings’).
†
this is dependent on a new load ratio of 0% for T1 and 22% for T2 in the new settings group
In the event of a network configuration change or fault, it is possible to switch the relay to use
‘alternative settings’. This gives added flexibility so that the relay can be configured appropriately for
abnormal operating conditions. Some examples of how the relay could be configured for abnormal
situations are as follows:
Revert to ‘safe’ operating mode where feeder current measurements and generator estimation
are ignored
Adopt a new load ratio for a specific configuration
In order to accommodate all applications to include any number of transformers and generator
connections, the above calculations can be summarised as follows:
Estimated load = Non-measured load x Load Ratio
Estimated Generation = Estimated load – Generator feeder current
Group Load = Non-measured load x (1 + Load Ratio)
The load ratio can be determined from historical load data or from direct measurements. If historical
data is used, the load ratio should be taken as an average value from a period of time over which the
extent of seasonal variations can be observed. If direct measurement is used to determine the load
ratio it must be ensured that the generation is not running so that the measurement represents the
‘true’ load.
Once the load ratio has been calculated it is configured into the relay settings. It is clear that the actual
load ratio will vary over time due to seasonal variations and network events (outages, faults etc.). For
this reason, the relay settings should be regularly checked to ensure that errors associated with these
variations are kept to a minimum.
The accuracy of the generation estimation algorithm will vary throughout a year and across a network.
Each application will demand an extent of network analysis to optimise the system and minimise
errors.
Generation estimation can be adversely affected by ‘troublesome loads’ connected to the non-
generation feeders. The effect can be mitigated by the use of functions associated with reactive loads
and sources which are described in the next section.
Examples of such loads are capacitor banks, heavy industrial loads and embedded generators. Figure
2-58shows the power factor effect of a capacitor bank.
In order to solve these problems the relay has functions available which utilise feeder current
measurements to calculate the ‘true’ load power factor as accurately as possible and thus minimise
errors. There are options for how these current measurements are configured and used in the relay:
Excluded Load
Corrected Load
In this way, the voltage accuracy of the relay is not impaired by the troublesome load, and also the
load information (if any) is maintained for LDC purposes.
If the relay is configured for generator estimation, the load ratio calculation must exclude feeders
configured as corrected loads.
16.4.4.1 Interconnector
This type is used where it is not possible to calculate the summed loads using Inter-relay
Communications, for instance if there is a strongly interconnected, but remote, parallel transformer.
The ‘Interconnector’ measurement enables the summed load calculation as shown in Figure 2-61.
In some situations it may be that the non-measured load is not truly representative of the load on the
generator feeders. An alternative is to select the most representative feeder(s) to use to calculate the
load on generator feeders. This is shown in Figure 2-62for the same example network.
16.4.4.3 Monitor
This feeder measurement type is used for monitoring purposes only. The CT input measurements are
displayed in the instruments and are available as SCADA measurands but are not used for any
operational purposes.
16.4.5 VT Switching
Each current measurement requires a voltage reference for calculation of the real and reactive
components. Normally this comes from the VT on the transformer which the relay uses for regulation.
Relays which are configured for feeder current measurements require an alternative voltage source to
use as a reference for when the transformer to which it is connected is switched out (for maintenance
etc.) and the regulation VT input is lost. It is possible to use the VT from another transformer (if
available) for this use, where it is wired to the second VT input of the relay and configured as ‘Busbar
2’. If no back-up voltage source is available, the feeder current measurement information will be lost
during a transformer outage and a corresponding error message and alarm will result.
Figure 2-63 shows an example scheme where each relay uses the VT from the paralleled transformer
as a back-up voltage reference. Table 2-20 shows how the voltage inputs are configured on each relay.
Table 2-21 shows which voltage source is used on each relay according to the transformer status. The
voltage level at which the voltage source switches from one VT input to another is 80% nominal.
SuperTAPP SG 1 SuperTAPP SG 2
Connected to Which is connected to Connected to Which is connected to
Voltage Input 1 & 2 VT1 (T1 VT) Transformer wdg 1 (T1) VT1 (T2 VT) Transformer wdg 1 (T2)
Voltage Input 3 & 4 VT2 (T2 VT) Busbar 2 VT2 (T1 VT) Busbar 1
17 Settings List
Reverse LDC level * Use fwd LDC, 0.0 – 20.0 % 0.0 % 15.5.4 (KVRC)
Wdg1 rev LDC rating * Wdg1 fwd rating, 50 – 10000 A Wdg1 fwd rating 15.1.2 (IRR)
Wdg2 rev LDC rating * Wdg2 fwd rating, 50 – 10000 A Wdg2 fwd rating 15.1.2 (IRR)
* This setting or submenu will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
†
These setting values will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
‡
This setting will not always be visible, depending on the associated connection or function settings
* This setting or submenu will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
* This setting or submenu will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
This menu and these settings and submenus will not always be visible, depending on relay
configuration
Setting Range Default Section
Tap stagger submenu
Tap stagger controlled by Current, Voltage Current 15.9.2
Tap stagger 1 offset 0.0 – 50.0 % 5.0 % 15.9.2
Tap stagger 2 offset 0.0 – 50.0 % 10.0 % 15.9.2
Tap stagger 3 offset 0.0 – 50.0 % 15.0 % 15.9.2
Tap stagger 4 offset 0.0 – 50.0 % 20.0 % 15.9.2
Frequency based voltage offset submenu
Volt offset F1 pickup freq Disabled, 45.0 – 65.0 Hz Disabled 15.8.4
Volt offset F1 dropoff freq 45.0 – 65.0 Hz, Disabled 46.00 Hz 15.8.4
Volt offset F1 pickup delay 0 – 7200 s 60 s 15.8.4
Volt offset F1 reset time Disabled, 30 – 7200 s 60 s 15.8.4
Volt offset F1 offset -10.0 – +10.0 % -3.0 % 15.8.4
Load based voltage offset submenu
Load offset capacity 1.0 – 1000.0 MVA 30.0 MVA 15.8.3
Volt offset L1 pickup load 50.0 – 200.0 %, Disabled Disabled 15.8.3
Volt offset L1 dropoff load 50.0 – 200.0 % 90.0 % 15.8.3
Volt offset L1 reset time 0 – 3600 s 900 s 15.8.3
Volt offset L1 voltage offset -10.0 – +10.0 % -5.0 % 15.8.3
Frequency based tripping submenu
Pickup frequency 1 Disabled, 45.00 – 65.00 Hz Disabled 15.9.3
Pickup frequency 2 Disabled, 45.00 – 65.00 Hz Disabled 15.9.3
Pickup frequency 3 Disabled, 45.00 – 65.00 Hz Disabled 15.9.3
Pickup frequency 4 Disabled, 45.00 – 65.00 Hz Disabled 15.9.3
Activation delay 1 0.00 – 1800.00 s (step 0.25 s) 15.00 s 15.9.3
Activation delay 2 0.00 – 1800.00 s (step 0.25 s) 15.00 s 15.9.3
Activation delay 3 0.00 – 1800.00 s (step 0.25 s) 15.00 s 15.9.3
* This setting or submenu will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
‡
This setting is only visible if the relevant output function is selected
†
These setting values will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
This setting menu will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
Setting Range Default Section
Timer1 pickup delay 0 – 240 s 60 s 15.11.8
Timer1 dropoff delay 0 – 240 s 60 s 15.11.8
Timer2 pickup delay 0 – 240 s 60 s 15.11.8
Timer2 dropoff delay 0 – 240 s 60 s 15.11.8
Timer3 pickup delay 0 – 240 s 60 s 15.11.8
Timer3 dropoff delay 0 – 240 s 60 s 15.11.8
*,† The setting identified by the symbol is only visible if the setting value identified by the same symbol
is selected
‡
This setting is only visible if a transformer winding or feeder measurement is allocated to the bus
section
⌂
This setting value will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
This setting menu will not always be visible, depending on relay configuration
Setting Range Default Section
1,
Enabled protocol IEC 61850, IEC 60870-5-103 DNP3 15.12.2
DNP3 2
Station address 1,2 0 - 65519 0 15.12.2
Destination address 2 0 - 65519 1 15.12.2
Allow unsolicited msgs 2 No, Yes No
Comms medium 2 Serial †, Ethernet ‡ Ethernet 15.12.2
† ‡ ⌂ 1 2
, , , , The setting identified by the symbol is only visible if the setting value identified by the same
symbol is selected
Note. The settings in this table are not applied until ‘APPLY’ is selected from the bottom of the
settings menu. At this point the settings will be applied and the communications card
restarted.
18 Specifications
18.1 General
18.2.2 Communications
18.2.1 Functional Accuracy
Characteristic Specification
Characteristic Accuracy
Physical layer RS485 over serial twisted pair,
Timers ±250 ms options ethernet 100base-T, ethernet
Frequency ±0.05 Hz 100base-F
Frequency response 400 ms * Data link layer RS485, TCP/IP
options
* hardware version 02 onwards Application IEC 61850, DNP3, IEC 60870-5-103
layer options
19 Connection Diagrams
The diagrams which follow show typical connection arrangements for the various modules which the
SuperTAPP SG can contain.
The input and output numbering shown in the diagrams is typical, with the exact allocation being
dependent on the number and location of other modules fitted. Please refer to the wiring drawing,
provided with each SuperTAPP SG, to determine the exact configuration for your unit and do not rely
on the numbering in these diagrams.
The user must refer to the relay code, printed on the front of the relay, to determine which module is
in each location, and hence connected to which terminal block.
Note. Numbering of current and voltage inputs is typical only. Refer to the correct SuperTAPP SG wiring
diagram for complete allocation.
Figure 2-66 Typical connection diagram for power supply and scheme logic module
Note. Numbering of digital inputs and output relays is typical only. Refer to the correct SuperTAPP SG
wiring diagram for complete allocation.
Fundamentals Ltd
Swindon Belfast
Unit 2, Hillmead Enterprise Park City East Business Centre
Marshall Road, Swindon 68-72 Newtownards Road
Wiltshire, SN5 5FZ Belfast, BT4 1GW
United Kingdom United Kingdom
Tel: +44 (0)1793 847163
Fax: +44 (0)1793 847245
www.fundamentalsltd.co.uk
[email protected]
Australia
Power Economy Middle East Co. LLC JET Engineering Solutions Sdn. Bhd.
U.A.E. Malaysia
Industrial City of Abu Dhabi (1284649-K) R-03A-22, Emporis,
P.O.Box 6072 Persiaran Surian, Kota Damansara,
Tel: +971-(0)2-5501077 47810 Petaling Jaya, Selangor.
Email: [email protected] [email protected]
www.powereconomy.net