Fall Detection 2
Fall Detection 2
sensors and machine learning algorithms. The goal will be to identify gaps in the current
research, explore the strengths and limitations of existing sensor and algorithm approaches,
and shape potential research questions.
SHAP Calculation: SHAP values are derived by evaluating each feature's marginal
contribution across all possible combinations of features, attributing importance based
on cooperative game theory principles.
LIME Calculation: LIME builds a locally interpretable model by minimizing the
difference between the original model and the surrogate, focusing on the data points
closest to the prediction being explained.
Feature Importance Calculation: This technique measures the importance of each
feature by observing the effect on the model’s predictions when the feature is removed
or permuted, highlighting the most influential factors.
Partial Dependence Plots (PDPs)
Overview: PDPs show the relationship between a feature and the predicted outcome,
holding all other features constant. This provides insight into how changes in a specific
feature affect model predictions.
Strengths: Useful for visualizing the global effect of a feature on the prediction, helping
to understand non-linear relationships.
Applications: Often applied in risk assessment models to examine how certain
features (e.g., gait velocity or postural sway) impact fall risk.
Accumulated Local Effects (ALE)
Overview: ALE plots show how feature values influence predictions, similar to PDPs,
but without the assumption of feature independence. ALE addresses some of the
limitations of PDPs, especially in models with correlated features.
Strengths: Provides more accurate interpretation in cases where features are
interdependent, common in biomechanical data.
Applications: Applied in healthcare to understand complex interactions between
features, like age and balance, in fall risk predictions.
Counterfactual Explanations
Overview: Counterfactual explanations provide instances that would change a model’s
prediction. For example, “If the gait speed were slightly higher, the fall risk prediction
would change.”
Strengths: Helps users understand what minimal changes are needed to alter a
prediction, making it actionable for clinical recommendations.
Applications: Useful in scenarios where a slight change in behavior or environment
could reduce fall risk, helping individuals and caregivers understand preventative
measures.
Saliency Maps
Overview: Saliency maps highlight the parts of input data that are most influential for
the model’s predictions. Often used with image data, these maps show which pixels or
regions the model “pays attention to.”
Strengths: Provides a visual explanation, particularly effective for image-based
models, such as those using vision sensors for fall detection.
Applications: Used in vision-based fall risk models to highlight areas of interest (e.g.,
body posture, head position) in camera data, helping users understand the focus of the
model.
Prototypes and Criticisms
Overview: This method identifies representative samples (prototypes) and outliers
(criticisms) within the data. Prototypes are examples that best represent the typical
patterns learned by the model.
Strengths: Simplifies the interpretation of complex data by showcasing typical cases
and deviations, making it easier to grasp the model’s decision logic.
Applications: In fall risk assessment, prototypes could represent typical gait patterns
of fall-prone individuals, while criticisms highlight unusual patterns that the model
struggles with.
Global Surrogate Models
Overview: Global surrogate models are interpretable models (like decision trees) that
approximate the predictions of more complex models. These surrogates provide an
overall view of model behavior.
Strengths: Allows for a general understanding of complex models, making them more
accessible for clinicians and healthcare providers.
Applications: Used to approximate deep learning models in fall risk prediction, where
the surrogate can help illustrate overall trends without detailing every individual
prediction.
Integrated Gradients
Overview: Integrated gradients are used in neural networks to attribute feature
importance by calculating gradients along the path from a baseline input to the actual
input.
Strengths: Useful for understanding complex, non-linear models and explaining how
each feature contributed to the final prediction.
Applications: Applied in deep learning models for fall risk assessment, where they
provide insights into which features (e.g., certain movements or postures) contributed
most to a prediction.
Summary
These methods offer a range of insights, from visualizing feature effects and understanding
minimal changes needed to alter predictions, to offering actionable explanations in clinical
settings. They add layers of transparency, which is essential in building trustworthy fall risk
models for healthcare.
Concluding Thoughts
This literature review plan will yield a comprehensive understanding of the state-of-the-art in
fall risk detection and assessment using sensors and machine learning. By categorizing the
literature in this way, it should be possible to identify the most promising research directions
and questions that could advance both the technological and practical aspects of fall risk
assessment.
Scholar Ai
Title Authors Publication Type Fall Type ML
Date Algorithm
Used
Identification Kyasarin Fors, 29/06/2016 Study Fall Not spec
of the risk of Eretz Lieberman Prediction
falls by using Aiden
a machine
learning
algorithm
Fast and A. Dubois, A. 11/06/2019 Study Fall Machine
automatic Mouthon, Ranjith Prediction learning (
assessment Steve specified
of fall risk by Sivagnanaselvam,
coupling J. Bresciani
machine
learning
algorithms
with a depth
camera to
monitor
simple
balance tasks
Sensor-Based Guangyang Zhao, 27/10/2021 Literature Both Various
Fall Risk L. Chen, Review Prediction
Assessment: Huansheng Ning and
A Survey Classification
This review underscores the potential of sensor technology and machine learning in
mitigating fall risk but highlights the need for ongoing research, particularly in deployment
and interpretability, to facilitate wider acceptance and integration into healthcare practices.
Datasets
Here are the links to the public datasets mentioned:
1. SisFall Dataset: This dataset includes data on falls and activities of daily living,
collected using wearable sensors. It is widely used for developing and testing fall
detection algorithms. https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/17/1/198
MDPI
2. UP-Fall Detection Dataset: This multimodal dataset comprises data from wearable
sensors, ambient sensors, and vision devices, capturing various activities and
simulated falls. It is designed to aid in the development of fall detection systems.
3. https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/19/9/1988
MDPI
These datasets are valuable resources for researchers focusing on fall detection and
prevention.
Here’s a list of public research datasets focused on fall risk assessment through
prediction or classification, suitable for use with machine learning (ML) methods:
1. SisFall Dataset:
Focus: Contains simulated falls and daily activities data using wearable
accelerometers.
Sensors: Accelerometers.
Link
2. UP-Fall Detection Dataset:
Focus: Provides multimodal data, including wearable sensors, ambient sensors,
and video, capturing falls and other daily activities.
Sensors: Accelerometers, gyroscopes, cameras, and floor sensors.
Link
3. MobiFall Dataset:
Focus: Designed for fall detection studies, contains accelerometer and gyroscope
data from a smartphone attached to subjects.
Sensors: Smartphone-based IMU sensors (accelerometer, gyroscope).
Link
4. TFall Dataset:
Focus: Collects data from older adults to predict fall risk in elderly populations,
primarily with wearable accelerometers.
Sensors: Accelerometers.
Link
5. FARSEEING Falls Repository:
Focus: Includes real-world falls data collected from wearable sensors in free-living
conditions, focusing on older adults.
Sensors: Wearable sensors (accelerometers).
Link
6. Daphnet Freezing of Gait Dataset:
Focus: Gait analysis to assess freezing episodes, which are often linked with fall
risk in Parkinson’s patients.
Sensors: Accelerometers.
Link
7. Falls in Aging Gait and Technology (FAT):
Focus: A collection of data from older adults to study fall risk in aging populations,
including balance and gait parameters.
Sensors: Multiple wearable sensors.
Link
8. Kinect-Based Fall Detection Dataset:
Focus: Video-based dataset using the Kinect sensor, with data on simulated falls
and normal activities.
Sensors: Depth cameras.
Link
9. UR Fall Detection Dataset:
Focus: Includes video and accelerometer data capturing both falls and daily
activities in a controlled environment.
Sensors: Cameras, wearable accelerometers.
Link
10. CogAge Dataset:
Focus: Cognitive assessment and gait parameters from elderly individuals, aimed at
identifying fall risk factors.
Sensors: Wearable sensors and questionnaires.
Link
These datasets provide diverse sensor data (accelerometers, gyroscopes, depth cameras)
that can support ML-based fall prediction and classification research, offering both simulated
and real-world scenarios.