Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status

1- The finish of the steel columns and beams shall be specified.. 1- Noted & Complied
2- Curtain wall glass type shall be specified in detail including color, U-value, shading coefficient and light transmittance. 2- Noted, U-value will be specified in the details desing packge. (Specification is in progress
3- Some dimensions are missing such as the dimensions for the elevated pyramid shape at the top of the roof. form the vendor)
4- The "top of roof" level is not indicated for the highest point of the roof. 3- Noted & Complied
5- Specify the finish for the external base of the building. 4- Noted & Complied
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Rev. 0B: 5- Noted & Complied M.ASAD-
1 AL-TAMIMI 0B Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange B
ELEVATIONS A & B 1- Still the finish not specified in the drawing. TAMIMI
2- Noted, but the curtain wall glass shall be specified , indicating the thickness, it could be tempered or laminated ..etc. Rev. 0B:
3- Comment still valid, for the elevation dimensions should indicate the total height, the levels, and the masses/shades heights, as well as the vertical 1- The finish of the steel columns and beams, kindly refer to material submittal approval.
dimensions should be removed from the elevations. 2- Noted & Complied
4- Comment still valid , as the top of roof should be indicated at the highest point of the building. 3- Noted & Provided
5- Noted. 4- Noted & Complied

1- The finish of the steel columns and beams shall be specified.. 1- Noted & Complied
2- Curtain wall glass type shall be specified in detail including color, U-value, shading coefficient and light transmittance. 2- Noted, U-value will be specified in the details desing packge. (Specification is in progress
3- Some dimensions are missing such as the dimensions for the elevated pyramid shape at the top of the roof. form the vendor)
4- The ""top of roof"" level is not indicated for the highest point of the roof. 3- Noted & Complied
5- Specify the finish for the external base of the building." 4- Noted & Complied
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30002 Rev. 0B: 5- Noted & Complied M.ASAD-
2 AL-TAMIMI 0B Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange B
ELEVATIONS C & D 1- Still the finish not specified in the drawing. TAMIMI
2- Noted, but the curtain wall glass shall be specified , indicating the thickness, it could be tempered or laminated ..etc. Rev. 0B:
3- Comment still valid, for the elevation dimensions should indicate the total height, the levels, and the masses/shades heights, as well as the vertical 1- The finish of the steel columns and beams, kindly refer to material submittal approval.
dimensions should be removed from the elevations. 2- Noted & Complied
4- Comment still valid , as the top of roof should be indicated at the highest point of the building. 3- Noted & Provided
5- Noted. 4- Noted & Complied

1- The distance between the two exits shall be not less than half the diagonal of the space in case of non-sprinklered buildings. 1- Noted and complied.
2- Provide enlarged details to clarify the interface between the steel columns and the adjacent walls to ensure proper alignment and integration. 2- Noted, and We will submit to the detailed desing packages.
3- Provide an accessible ramp at each entrance/exit. 3- Based on Amaala camp the accessible ramp is not required.
4- Provide internal dimensions. 4- Noted & Complied
5- Mention the U-value of the wall. 5- Noted, U-value will be specified in the details desing packge. (Specification is in progress
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30001 M.ASAD-
3 AL-TAMIMI Rev. 0B: 0B Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Red form the vendor) C
GROUND FLOOR LAYOUT PLAN TAMIMI
1- Noted.
2- Noted, further to the next stage. Rev. 0B:
3- As per SBC code section 1009.1, the two exits should be accessible . 2- Noted & Complied
4- Noted. 3- Noted
5- Noted, and will be reviewed in the detailed design stage. 5- Noted & Complied

1- The roof slope has been indicated and water will runoff freely refer to below image.
1- Indicate the roof drainage system and roof slopes on the plan.
2- Noted & Complied
2- Indicate the levels of the highest and lowest points on the roof.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30002 M.ASAD-
4 AL-TAMIMI Rev. 0B: 0B Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Orange B
ROOF PLAN Rev. 0B: TAMIMI
1- The free discharge for the roof drainage system is not recommended, please revisit.
1- The roof slope has been indicated and water will runoff freely, and we have followed
2- Noted.
the same design as per approved Amaala.

1- provide furniture specification and size.

2-Provide light fixture at furniture plan.
3-Check number of AC units, and ensure providing HVAC requirments suitable for the area and function of the space.
1- Furniture specification will provided the detailed desing package.
4- Provide Fire extinguisher at furniture plan.
2-Once the concept layout will approved, the MEP services will be reflected accordingly in
Rev 0B
the reflected ceiling plan.
1-Subject to the detailed design package.
3-Noted & Cordinated with HVAC drawings.
2-As per design ceiling polyster fabric and didnot receive ceiling layout.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30003 4- Fire extinguisher ref. to Fire Fighting drawings. M.ASAD-
5 AL-TAMIMI 3-Noted 0B Cat. 1 ZFP-AMKA Orange Orange B
FURNITURE LAYOUT PLAN TAMIMI
4- Add on furniture plan to coordinate with loose furniture.
Rev. 0B:
1- Furniture specification & sizes will be submittd in next stage.
2-Noted & Cmplied
4- Fire extinguisher at furniture plan has been provided.

Page 1 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status

1- These details will be submitted in the detail desing pacakge (Specification is in progress
1- Specify in detail the type of glass of the door.
form the vendor)
2- Specify the material of the door frames.
2-Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor)
3- Specify the door hardware.
3-Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor)
4- Specify the door STC rating.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SCH-ARC-02-Z00-30001 4-STC rating will be provided in the detailed desgin package. M.ASAD-
6 AL-TAMIMI Rev 0B: 0B Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange B
DOOR AND WINDOW SCHEDULE TAMIMI
1- Comment still valid, a detail of the glass door should be provided.
Rev. 0B:
2- Comment still valid, specify the material of the door frames.
1- 3 These details will be submitted in the next stage pacakge (Specification is in progress
3- Comment still valid, specify the door hardware.
form the vendor)
4- Comment still valid, specify the door STC rating.
4-Noted & provided

1- Clarify carpet type ( Add more specifcation) to be broadloom carpet . 1- Subject to approval matrial submittals.
2- As per drawing there are block wall plaster painted not inculded at finishes schedule.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SCH-ARC-02-Z00-30002 M.ASAD-
7 AL-TAMIMI Rev 0B 0A Cat. 1 ZFP-AMKA Orange Orange Rev. 0B: B
SCHEDULE OF FINISHES TAMIMI
1-Subject to approval matrial submittals. 1-Noted, Subject to approval matrial submittals.
2-Still valid no response 2- Noted & Provided

1- Contractor shall revise the polyester fabric roofing system and confirm its feasibility regarding fire safety, structural safety, thermal insulation and rain
drainage requirements taking into consideration the function of the building.
1- Refer subject to material approval and (Specification is in progress form the vendor).
2- The structural system is not clear in the section. Contractor shall ensure that the architectural drawings are fully coordinated with the structural
2- Noted & Complied.
design.
3- Noted & Complied.
3- The finish of the steel columns and beams shall be specified in the section.
4- Noted & Complied.
4- The flooring layers are not mentioned.
5- Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor).
5- Mention the U-value of the roof.
6-Noted & Complied.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SEC-ARC-02-Z00-30001 6- The building is shown resting on the FGL. Please provide the required base/footing in coordination with structural drawings. M.ASAD-
8 AL-TAMIMI 0B Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Red C
BUILDING SECTION Rev 0B TAMIMI
Rev. 0B:
1- Comment still valid and the related critical issues should be addressed by the contractor in the concept stage.
1- We have followed the same design as per approved Amaala and Refer subjected to
2- The structural elements should be shown in the architectural drawings , while they should be indicated in a separate structural design package
material approval.
coordinated with the architectural drawings.
2- Noted & Complied
3- Still the finish not specified in the drawing.
3-The finish of the steel columns and beams, kindly refer to material submittal approval.
4- Noted.
5- Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor).
5- Noted, and will be reviewed in the detailed design stage.
6- Noted.

1-The Signage plan not required for this building.

2-life safety drawings we will submitted in sperat package.
3-Refer to structure drawing package.
1- Add the missing signage plan.
4-Refer subject to material approval and as per vender specification requirment.
2- Code analysis (life safety drawings) is missing. Contractor shall submit it including analysis of type of construction.
5-Based on the Amaala camp building and the temporary outdoor sitting area, toilets,
3- Structural drawings and calculations are missing. Contractor shall provide it and ensure that the architectural drawings are fully coordinated with the
kitchenettes, and drinking fountains are not required.
structural design.
6-As per the Minutes of Meeting (QRXL103000-TPE-COR-MOM-ARC-00001), Gulf Consult is
4- Contractor shall revise the polyester fabric roofing system and confirm its feasibility regarding fire safety, structural safety, thermal insulation and rain
operating under the Tamimi umbrella. Furthermore, for Worker Village 5-8, we are also
drainage requirements taking into consideration the function of the building.
submitting the Pre-Qualification Document (PQD).
5- The building does not include any toilets, kitchenettes or drinking fountains. Contractor shall clarify how the user requirements related to these
7- Kindly refer to RFI. QDPIN-GENCORR-000123 for submission of building design @ifc
facilities would be fulfilled in the submitted design.
stage.
6- Gulf Consult not approved as sub-contractor (as shown in Aconex), and shall be removed from the title block.
8- Once the concept layout will approved, the MEP services will be reflected in reflected
7- Remove 'Shop Drawings' from the title of the IFC drawings to reflect their correct purpose and designation as issued for construction." ZFP-AMKA M.ASAD-
9 GENERAL AL-TAMIMI 0B Cat. 4 Red Red ceiling plan accordingly. C
8- The reflected ceiling plan shall be provided including the MEP fixtures. ZFP-MOIF TAMIMI
Rev 0B:
Rev. 0B:
1- Comment still valid.
1- Noted & Complied
2- Noted.
3-Noted & refer to structural pacakge.
3- Comment still valid, as the structural package has not been submitted.
4- We have followed the same design as per approved Amaala and Refer subjected to
4-Comment still valid and the related critical issues should be addressed by the contractor in the concept stage.
material approval.
5- The design should explain where the facilities are, that serve users of this building ( wet area/ pantries..).
5- The layout has been approved from the clint, the approved drawing has attach with
6- Comment still valid.
furniture layout plan in pdf.
7- Noted.
6-As per the Minutes of Meeting (QRXL103000-TPE-COR-MOM-ARC-00001), Gulf Consult is
8- The ceiling design should be determined in the concept stage.
operating under the Tamimi umbrella. Furthermore, for Worker Village 5-8, we are also
submitting the Pre-Qualification Document (PQD).
8- The ceiling layout refer to reflected ceiling plan.

Page 2 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status

The CD package has been released with conditional approval, with all comments to be addressed by the contractor in the Design Development stage submittal.

1- Noted & Complied

2- Noted, U-value will be specified in the details desing packge. (Specification is in progress
form the vendor)
3- Noted & Complied
4- Noted & Complied
Rev. 0C:
5- Noted & Complied
1- Noted and subject to material submittal approval. Please add the following statement in the frame notes: "For the finish of steel columns and
beams, refer to material submittal".
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Rev. 0B: M.ASAD-
1 AL-TAMIMI 2- Noted. 0C Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange Orange B
ELEVATIONS A & B 1- The finish of the steel columns and beams, kindly refer to material submittal approval. TAMIMI
3- Noted, but the mentioned slope (1:20) for the main roof and the elevated pyramid shape is incorrect. Furthermore, the vertical dimension reading
2- Noted & Complied
"2671" needs to be "2670" to be matching the levels indicated in the roof plan.
3- Noted & Provided
4- Noted.
4- Noted & Complied

Rev. 0C:
1-Noted, Statement is shown in the layout.
3-Noted and complied the roof slope has been considered as per structrual drawings

1- Noted & Complied

2- Noted, U-value will be specified in the details desing packge. (Specification is in progress
form the vendor)
3- Noted & Complied
4- Noted & Complied
Rev. 0C:
5- Noted & Complied
1- Noted and subject to material submittal approval. Please add the following statement in the frame notes: "For the finish of steel columns and
beams, refer to material submittal".
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30002 Rev. 0B: M.ASAD-
2 AL-TAMIMI 2- Noted. 0C Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange Orange B
ELEVATIONS C & D 1- The finish of the steel columns and beams, kindly refer to material submittal approval. TAMIMI
3- Noted, but the mentioned slope (1:20) for the main roof and the elevated pyramid shape is incorrect. Furthermore, the vertical dimension reading
2- Noted & Complied
"2671" needs to be "2670" to be matching the levels indicated in the roof plan.
3- Noted & Provided
4- Noted.
4- Noted & Complied

Rev. 0C:
1-Noted, Statement is shown in the layout.
3-Noted and complied the roof slope has been considered as per structrual drawings

Rev. 0C:
2- Noted, but please mention the vertical spacing for the installation of the cleat (CL-01) and its material. Also, please clarify the meaning of "YYP"
mentioned in the title of the detail.
3- Noted, but please provide edge protection for the ramps to comply with SBC 201 section 1012.10.1 (a curb not less than 100mm in height) as shown
in the screenshot.
5- The U-value (0.48w/m2.k) specified in the drawing needs to be revised to comply with SBC requirements and the submitted design report 1- Noted and complied.
(document no. QRXL103100-TPE-REP-DSR-ARC-02-Z00-00001). 2- Noted, and We will submit to the detailed desing packages.
6- Mention in the description of the 200mm concrete block wall that it is made of a pre-insulated block. 3- Based on Amaala camp the accessible ramp is not required.
7- Provide a text indication for the ACCU units. 4- Noted & Complied
5- Noted, U-value will be specified in the details desing packge. (Specification is in progress
form the vendor)

Rev. 0B:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30001 2- Noted & Complied
3 AL-TAMIMI 0C Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Red Orange B
GROUND FLOOR LAYOUT PLAN 3- Noted
5- Noted & Complied

Rev. 0C:
2-Noted and Provided
3-Noted and provided.
5- Noted and complied.
6- Noted and complied.
7- Noted and complied.

Page 3 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status
Rev. 0C:
1- According to common practice, it is highly recommended to provide a roof drainage system for sloped roofs to preserve building facades and
protect walkways around the building from flooding. This helps ensure easy access to the building during heavy rain and reduces the risk of slipping
and falling, thereby enhancing user safety. Providing a roof drainage system would also reduce the risk of water getting into the interior of the
building though its entrance by preventing water from collecting on the landing of the entrance steps. However, roof drainage system cancelation is
subject to client approval clearly stated in an official document. 1- The roof slope has been indicated and water will runoff freely refer to below image.
3- The level reading +4.135 is not matching the dimensions indicated in the elevations. 2- Noted & Complied
4- The mentioned slope (1:20) for the main roof and the elevated pyramid shape is incorrect compared to the dimensions mentioned in the elevations.
Rev. 0B:
1- The roof slope has been indicated and water will runoff freely, and we have followed
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30002 M.ASAD-
4 AL-TAMIMI 0C Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Orange Orange the same design as per approved Amaala. B
ROOF PLAN TAMIMI
Rev. 0C:
1- Kindly refer to RFI. No. QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-RFI-PJC-02-Z00-00002 of wavier for rain
water gutter.
3- Noted & Complied the roof slope has been considered as per structrual drawings
4-the roof slope has been considered as per structrual drawings

Rev. 0C:
1-Furniture specification & sizes will be subject to the next stage.
2-Closed
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30003 4-Closed Rev. 0C: M.ASAD-
5 AL-TAMIMI 0C Cat. 1 ZFP-AMKA Orange Orange Orange B
FURNITURE LAYOUT PLAN 1-Noted. TAMIMI

QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30004 Rev. 0A: Rev. 0A: M.ASAD-

6 0A ZFP-AMKA Orange B
REFLECTED CEILING PLAN 1- Check the overlapping of dimensions with the structural elements. 1-Noted & Complied. TAMIMI

1- These details will be submitted in the detail desing pacakge (Specification is in progress
form the vendor)
2-Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor)
3-Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor)
Rev 0C: 4-STC rating will be provided in the detailed desgin package.
1- Noted.
2- Material of door frames is still not specified. Rev. 0B:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SCH-ARC-02-Z00-30001 3- Door hardware is still missing, and it is required in the detailed design stage. A lot of information is missing from the door schedule, such as the 1- 3 These details will be submitted in the next stage pacakge (Specification is in progress M.ASAD-
7 AL-TAMIMI 0C Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange Orange B
DOOR AND WINDOW SCHEDULE panic bar, weather stripping, door lock, number of hinges, threshold, and door closer. form the vendor) TAMIMI
4- Door STC rating is still not provided. 4-Noted & provided
5- Curtain wall details should be provided in this sheet indicating the glass material, frame material, and panel spacing. The sheet should be renamed Rev 0C:
to "Door Schedule and Curtain Wall details". 2-Door is frameless glass door.
3-Noted & Provided.
4-Noted & Provided.
5- Noted & Provided.

QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SCH-ARC-02-Z00-30002 Rev. 0C: Rev. 0C: M.ASAD-

8 AL-TAMIMI 0C Cat. 1 ZFP-AMKA Orange Orange Orange B
SCHEDULE OF FINISHES 2- Paint for block wall provided but kindly provide paint type 2- Noted and provided. TAMIMI

1- Refer subject to material approval and (Specification is in progress form the vendor).
2- Noted & Complied.
3- Noted & Complied.
4- Noted & Complied.
5- Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor).
Rev 0C 6-Noted & Complied.
1- Noted. However, according to common practice, it is highly recommended to provide a roof drainage system for sloped roofs to preserve building
facades and protect walkways around the building from flooding. This helps ensure easy access to the building during heavy rain and reduces the risk Rev. 0B:
of slipping and falling, thereby enhancing user safety. Providing a roof drainage system would also reduce the risk of water getting into the interior of 1- We have followed the same design as per approved Amaala and Refer subjected to
the building though its entrance by preventing water from collecting on the landing of the entrance steps. However, roof drainage system cancelation material approval.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SEC-ARC-02-Z00-30001 is subject to client approval clearly stated in an official document. 2- Noted & Complied M.ASAD-
9 AL-TAMIMI 0C Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Red Orange B
BUILDING SECTION 2- Noted. 3-The finish of the steel columns and beams, kindly refer to material submittal approval. TAMIMI
3- Noted and subject to material submittal approval. Please add the following statement in the frame notes: "For the finish of steel columns and 5- Refer subject to material approval, (Specification is in progress form the vendor).
beams, refer to material submittal". Rev 0C:
5- The comment is still open. 1-Kindly refer to RFI. No. QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-RFI-PJC-02-Z00-00002 of wavier for rain
6- The dimensions for the elevated pyramid shape at the top of the roof are missing. water gutter.
7- The mentioned slope (1:20) for the main roof and the elevated pyramid shape is incorrect. 2- Noted. The note has been added.
5- U-Value for the roof will be provided by the specilist vendor and refer to MTS approval.
6- Noted and provided.
7- Noted and complied the roof slope has been considered as per structrual drawings

Page 4 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status
1-correct ?A?
2-Provide dimensions for the letters (width and height) of the wall and the ceiling mounted exit signs ensuring compliance with SBC 801 section
1013.

QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SNM-ARC-02-Z00-30001 1- Noted and complied. M.ASAD-

10 0A ZFP-AMKA Orange B
SIGNAGE LAYOUT & DETAILS 2- Noted and complied. TAMIMI

1-The Signage plan not required for this building.

2-life safety drawings we will submitted in sperat package.
3-Refer to structure drawing package.
4-Refer subject to material approval and as per vender specification requirment.
5-Based on the Amaala camp building and the temporary outdoor sitting area, toilets,
kitchenettes, and drinking fountains are not required.
6-As per the Minutes of Meeting (QRXL103000-TPE-COR-MOM-ARC-00001), Gulf Consult is
operating under the Tamimi umbrella. Furthermore, for Worker Village 5-8, we are also
submitting the Pre-Qualification Document (PQD).
7- Kindly refer to RFI. QDPIN-GENCORR-000123 for submission of building design @ifc
stage.
8- Once the concept layout will approved, the MEP services will be reflected in reflected
Rev 0C: ceiling plan accordingly.
1- Noted.
3- Noted. Rev. 0B:
M.ASAD-
11 GENERAL AL-TAMIMI 4- Noted. 0C Cat. 4 Red Red Orange 1- Noted & Complied B
ZFP-MOIF TAMIMI
5- Noted. 3-Noted & refer to structural pacakge.
6- Comment still valid. 4- We have followed the same design as per approved Amaala and Refer subjected to
8- Noted. material approval.
5- The layout has been approved from the clint, the approved drawing has attach with
furniture layout plan in pdf.
6-As per the Minutes of Meeting (QRXL103000-TPE-COR-MOM-ARC-00001), Gulf Consult is
operating under the Tamimi umbrella. Furthermore, for Worker Village 5-8, we are also
submitting the Pre-Qualification Document (PQD).
8- The ceiling layout refer to reflected ceiling plan.

Rev 0C:
6- As per the Minutes of Meeting (QRXL103000-TPE-COR-MOM-ARC-00001), Gulf Consult
is operating under the Tamimi umbrella. Furthermore, for Worker Village 5-8, we are also
submitting the Pre-Qualification Document (PQD).

The DD package has been released with conditional approval Code B , with all comments to be addressed by the contractor in the IFC stage submittal.
IFC stage

Rev. 04:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 1- Noted. M.ASAD-
1 AL-TAMIMI 03 Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange Orange Green green A Green
ELEVATIONS A & B 3- Noted. TAMIMI

Rev. 03:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30002 M.ASAD-
2 AL-TAMIMI 1- Noted. 03 Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange Orange Green green A Green
ELEVATIONS C & D TAMIMI
3- Noted.

Rev. 03:
2- The vertical spacing for the installation of the cleat (CL-01) and its material should be indicated in the isometric view.
3- Noted.
5- The current U-value (0.341w/m2.k) specified in the drawing needs still exceeds the maximum allowed by SBC, and is greater than the value used in
the submitted HVAC calculations. Please refer to the below screenshots.
6- Noted.
7- Noted.
Rev. 03:
2- Noted & Complied
5- The U value for the wall mass is 1.191 W/m2.k and we are providing 0.341 W/m2.k.
Rev. 04: kinldy ref to blow image.
2- The installation detail for the block wall with the steel column, as indicated in the isometric view, and the termination between the block wall, steel
column, and curtain wall as indicated in Detail-1 is inadequate and needs to be updated.
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30001 5- Noted, Comment Closed. M.ASAD-
3 AL-TAMIMI 05 Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Red Orange Orange orange B Orange
GROUND FLOOR LAYOUT PLAN TAMIMI
Rev. 05:
2- The installation and termination details are still inadequate and require a more effective solution.

Rev. 03:
2- Noted, the detail-1 has been revised.
5-Noted.

Page 5 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status
Rev. 03:
1- Cancelation of roof gutter & downspout is subject to client approval, and we have not received the document mentioned in the contractor's reply.
3- Noted.
4- Partially complied. Please refer to the screenshot.

Rev. 03:
1-Noted, refer to RFI. No. QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-RFI-PJC-02-Z00-00002 of wavier for rain water
gutter.
4- Noted & Complied
Rev. 04:
1- The mentioned RFI number is not traceable in the system. Please verify and provide valid approval. Rev. 04:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30002 4- Noted, Comment Closed. 1- Please refer to the image below, which may assist you in tracing the related items on Aconex. M.ASAD-
4 AL-TAMIMI 05 Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Orange Orange Orange orange B Orange
ROOF PLAN 4- Noted. TAMIMI
Rev. 05:
1- The mentioned RFI is submitted For Information only, Contractor to provide Client approval reference. (and to extend the Roof limit 50 mm from
the edge of the façade wall to avoid rainwater runoff onto the walls).

Rev. 01:
1-Still valid provide Furniture specification & sizes .

Rev. 04:
1- The TV and waste bin are missing. Additionally, the furniture described in the list is subject to approved samples.
Rev. 05: Rev. 01:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30003 1- Noted, Comment Closed. 1-Noted & Complied M.ASAD-
5 AL-TAMIMI 05 Cat. 1 ZFP-AMKA Orange Orange Orange Orange orange A Green
FURNITURE LAYOUT PLAN TAMIMI
Rev. 04:
1- Noted, The TV and waste bin has been added,

QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-PLN-ARC-02-Z00-30004 Rev. 01: Rev. 01: M.ASAD-

6 01 ZFP-AMKA Orange Green green A Green
REFLECTED CEILING PLAN 1- Complied 1-Noted & Complied. TAMIMI

Rev 03:
2- Noted.
3- The comment is still valid. A lot of information is missing from the door schedule, such as the panic bar, weather stripping, door lock, number of Rev 03:
hinges, threshold, and door closer. This information should not be missing in the IFC stage. 3- Noted & Complied.
4- Door STC rating is still not provided. 4- Noted & Complied.
5- Partially complied. Provide numbering for the curtain wall types. One curtain wall type is missing (the type that has the door at the left side). The 5- Noted & Complied.
sheet name is incorrect (there is no window schedule).
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SCH-ARC-02-Z00-30001 M.ASAD-
7 AL-TAMIMI 05 Cat. 1 ZFP-MOIF Orange Orange Orange Red orange C red
DOOR AND WINDOW SCHEDULE Rev 04: TAMIMI
1- Noted, Comment closed. Rev 04:
4- Noted, Comment closed. 5-Noted. The final layout plan has been shared with the specialist third-party vendor for the
5- The provided information indicates that the 50x50 mm aluminum frame for the curtain wall (C.W.), as shown in the drawing, may be structurally curtain wall design. The vendor will ensure compliance with design standards and structural
unstable for a C.W. with a height of 2500 mm. The contractor needs to recheck the design and provide structural calculations for review. stability. Once we receive the vendor's drawings, we will incorporate them accordingly. Kindly
refer to the MTS for further details.
Rev 05:
5- Comment Still Open

QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SCH-ARC-02-Z00-30002 Rev. 01: M.ASAD-

8 AL-TAMIMI 03 Cat. 1 ZFP-AMKA Orange Orange Orange Green green A Green
SCHEDULE OF FINISHES 2- COMPLIED TAMIMI

Page 6 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status

Rev 03
1- Cancelation of roof gutter & downspout is subject to client approval, and we have not received the document mentioned in the contractor's reply.
3- Noted.
5- Please add a note specifying the maximum U-value mentioning that the final U-value will be provided by the vendor and referring to the MTS
approval.
6- Noted.
7- Noted. Rev 03
1- Noted, refer to RFI. No. QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-RFI-PJC-02-Z00-00002 of wavier for rain
Rev. 04: water gutter.
1- The mentioned RFI number is not traceable in the system. Please verify and provide valid approval. 5- Noted
5- Noted, Comment Closed.
8- The structural bracing (clear hight & The aesthetic appearance ) is not accepted architecturally. Rev. 04:
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SEC-ARC-02-Z00-30001 M.ASAD-
9 AL-TAMIMI 05 Cat. 3 ZFP-MOIF Red Red Orange Orange red 1- Please refer to the image below, which may assist you in tracing the related items on C Red
BUILDING SECTION TAMIMI
Rev. 05: Aconex
1- The mentioned RFI is submitted For Information only, Contractor to provide Client approval reference.
8- The structural bracing has been removed, contractor to update and get approval for the structural drawings / Calculations accordingly, for the
structural aesthetic appearance still in poor level and need more details in terminations connections (gyp. ceiling could be used to cover the steel
structural elemnts and elec. exposed conduits)
8- The structural aesthetic apperance in architectural drawings has been in inhanced.

Rec 01.
1-Complied
2-Complied
QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-SNM-ARC-02-Z00-30001 M.ASAD-
10 01 ZFP-AMKA Orange Green green A Green
SIGNAGE LAYOUT & DETAILS TAMIMI

REV 03:
6-As per the Minutes of Meeting (QRXL103000-TPE-COR-MOM-ARC-00001), Gulf Consult
Rev 03: is operating under the Tamimi umbrella. Furthermore, for Worker Village 5-8, we are also
6- The comment is still valid and will remain until the pre-qualification document of Gulf Consultant is approved. submitting the Pre-Qualification Document (PQD).
9- Remove 'Shop Drawings' from the stage description in title block to reflect the correct purpose and designation of the drawings as issued for 9-Kindly refer to RFI. QDPIN-GENCORR-000123 for submission of building design @ifc
construction. stage.

Rev. 04: Rev. 04: M.ASAD-

11 GENERAL AL-TAMIMI 04 Cat. 4 Red Red Orange Orange B Orange
6 - subject to PQD final approval. ZFP-MOIF 6 - Noted. TAMIMI
9 - The mentioned RFI numbers is not traceable in the system. Please verify and provide valid approval. 9 - Please refer to the image below, which may assist you in tracing the related items on
Aconex
Rev. 05:
6 - subject to PQD final approval.
9- The mentioned RFI is submitted For Information only, Contractor to provide Client approval reference.

All IFC drawings must be stamped by the Contractor designer's office (GC)and signed by the respective discipline designer engineer.
The Tamimi is main Lead Deigners and contractor for this project and signare has
12 GENERAL Tamimi 05 Cat. 1 ZFP-AMO M.ASAD-TAMIMI C
Rev. 05: indorcement in all drawings for proof of the design submission.
Comment still open according to Employer's Requirements - Schedule 3.

red Red

1- The structural bracing (clear hight & The aesthetic appearance ) is not accepted architecturally.
2- The exposed structural connection has poor quality detail.
3- The termination between the steel column, block, and curtain wall is very poor.
4- There is no proper ventilation for the building (the CW shown as fixed windows).
5- The curtain wall profile (50 x 50 mm) is too small for the application.
6- The door width and ramp detail are not accurate and may not be suitable for HC.
7- restudy the carpet flooring suitablity for the building flooring.
1- The structural aesthetic apperance in architectural drawings has been in inhanced.
Rev. 05: 2- The exposed structrual connection details has been updated and coordinatd with strctural
1- The structural bracing has been removed, contractor to update and get approval for the structural drawings / Calculations accordingly, discipline.
2- the structural aesthetic appearance still in poor level and need more details in terminations connections.(gyp. ceiling could be used to cover the 3- Noted and updated the termination details between the steel coloumn, block and curtain
steel structural elemnts and elec. exposed conduits) wall kindly refer to the udpated drawing.
4- The vnetilation for the building has been provided as coordinated with Mechanical
Discipline.
GENERAL 5- The curtain Wall design is specialist vendor kindly refer to the MTS. M.ASAD-
13 Tamimi 05 Cat 3 ZFP-AMO red C Red
6- The door width is cleared1000mm kindly refer to the Door schedule and tha handicapped TAMIMI
Page 7 of 11 ramp details has been incoperated as per ZFP comments in REV-OC, kindly refer below CRS_Rev. 2
3- The terminations details still inadequate and require a more effective solution. image.
4- Comment still opn:
a- The installation of one FA fan is not properly coordinated with the architectural elevation, Fans should be symmetrically located and of the
Sensitive #

Project Name: Design and Build Contract for Camp Accommodation

Contract Ref#: QPMO-410-CT-02177
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE C - Revise and Resubmit OVERALL STATUS red

Document Ref. No. QRXL103100-TPE-DRW-ELE-ARC-02-Z00-30001 Comments Issued on 27-Mar-25 Response Date: 6/14/2025

Document Title W.V 5 TO 8-B30 - MAJLIS BUILDING ARC CRS FILE Document Type Drawing
Date Received Lead Reviewer Mostafa Farahat ZFP-E, Alaa Ashour ZFP-E

Originator AL-TAMIMI CRS Rev. 05 CRS Ref.: QRXL103100-TPE-TEC-CRS-ARC-02-Z00-00110

Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

1- The structural bracing (clear hight & The aesthetic appearance ) is not accepted architecturally. Rev.0A Rev.0B Rev.0C Rev.03 Rev.04 Rev.05
No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator 2- The exposed structural connection has poor quality detail. Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code
Status Status Status Status Status Status
3- The termination between the steel column, block, and curtain wall is very poor.
4- There is no proper ventilation for the building (the CW shown as fixed windows).
5- The curtain wall profile (50 x 50 mm) is too small for the application.
6- The door width and ramp detail are not accurate and may not be suitable for HC.
7- restudy the carpet flooring suitablity for the building flooring.
1- The structural aesthetic apperance in architectural drawings has been in inhanced.
Rev. 05: 2- The exposed structrual connection details has been updated and coordinatd with strctural
1- The structural bracing has been removed, contractor to update and get approval for the structural drawings / Calculations accordingly, discipline.
2- the structural aesthetic appearance still in poor level and need more details in terminations connections.(gyp. ceiling could be used to cover the 3- Noted and updated the termination details between the steel coloumn, block and curtain
steel structural elemnts and elec. exposed conduits) wall kindly refer to the udpated drawing.
4- The vnetilation for the building has been provided as coordinated with Mechanical
Discipline.
GENERAL 5- The curtain Wall design is specialist vendor kindly refer to the MTS. M.ASAD-
13 Tamimi 05 Cat 3 ZFP-AMO red C Red
6- The door width is cleared1000mm kindly refer to the Door schedule and tha handicapped TAMIMI
ramp details has been incoperated as per ZFP comments in REV-OC, kindly refer below
3- The terminations details still inadequate and require a more effective solution. image.
4- Comment still opn:
a- The installation of one FA fan is not properly coordinated with the architectural elevation, Fans should be symmetrically located and of the
appropriate type.
b- The contractor must verify how the connection will be made between the external AC unit and the internal unit in the CW walls. 7- Carpet flooring has been selected as a suitable finish for the Majlis building.
c- provide openable Sliding CW panels Instead of Fixing Panels.
d- provide full door detail (door jamb, head, sill and connection with steel column).
5- Comment Still Open.
6- Ramp level and detail not match with site layout, Comment still open.
7- Noted , But the carbet type shall be Fire Rated Type and subject to MTS approval and the carbet shall have self-leveling substrate such as
screed layer also contractor to provide detail of column steel plate trerminations with the floor finishing.
8- Contractor to address all the above comments and update the drawings and resubmit Full IFC package (Arch / Str./ Mech / Elec.) accordingly.

Producing Comments Responding to Comments

Lead Reviewer: Approved By: Response By: Approved By:
Name: Mostafa Farahat, Alaa Ashour Name: Name: Muhammad Asad Name:
Designation: Sr. Architectural Engineer Designation: Designation: Architectural Engineer Designation:
Sign: Sign: Sign: Sign:
Date: 19-06-2025 Date: Date: Date:

Status

Closed
Agree to Close
Open

Page 8 of 11 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #

Requestor Name Sender Entity Overall Status Code Medium

CLOSED Original
OPEN Source File
Hard Copy
CD/DVD
Other
Sensitive #

Code Status Over All Code

Red A A - Approved
Orange B B - Approved with Comments
Green C C - Revise and Resubmit
D D - Rejected
E E - Review Not Required

Consent to Submissions

The Engineer's Decision on documents submitted for his consent shall follow the
classification below:

Decision A Consented to as submitted, authorised to proceed with the

Proposal
Decision B
Consented to subject to noted comments. The Consultant is
authorised to proceed with the proposal provided the work is
performed in accordance with the Engineer's comments. The
Engineer may at his discretion require the submission by the
Consultant of revised drawings, calculations, documents, etc.
which incorporate the conditions attached to the Decision "B"
consent. Such Submission shall be made to the Engineer within 7
days of request. Provided that the conditions in the Decision "B"
consent have been fully incorporated and adhered to, the
Engineer shall treat such submitted documentation as being for
information only.

Decision C Major comments. Resubmit for Review.

Decision D Rejected. NOT Consented to for the reasons noted in the CRS.
Related design or construction may not continue.
The Consultant shall make a new submission in accordance with
the Engineer's comments. The new submission shall not
proceed beyond Decision "W1" until the Engineer's comments
have been fully satisfied.
Sensitive #

Catogary
Cat. 0
Cat. 1
Cat. 2
Cat. 3
Cat. 4