eScholarship provides open access, scholarly publishing

services to the University of California and delivers a dynamic

research platform to scholars worldwide.
Peer Reviewed
Title:
How Languages are Learned
Journal Issue:
Issues in Applied Linguistics, 15(2)
Author:
So, Youngsoon, University of California, Los Angeles
Publication Date:
2007
Publication Info:
Issues in Applied Linguistics, Department of Applied Linguistics, UC Los Angeles
Permalink:
http://escholarship.org/uc/item/95n3d84b
How Languages are Learned (3rd ed.) by Patsy M. Lightbown and Nina Spada.
OxIord: OxIord University Press, 2006, xviii233 pp.
Reviewed by Youngsoon So
University oI CaliIornia, Los Angeles
In the introduction to a collection of articles on second language acquisition
(SLA), Doughty and Long (2003) pointed out that 'second language acquisition -
naturalistic, instructed, or both has long been a common activity for a majority
of the human species and is becoming ever more vital as second languages them-
selves increase in importance (p. 4). Considering the diversity of SLA contexts
and different factors/variables involved in these contexts, a single teaching method
is unlikely to guarantee the best results. Therefore, language teachers need to be
fexible enough to adopt and/or adapt different teaching methods according to the
demands of their immediate teaching context. In this respect, Patsy Lightbown
and Nina Spadas How Languages are Learned is a good resource for all language
teachers, those in SLA in particular, in that it provides a comprehensive overview
of what factors have been proven, disproven, or still left unproven to infuence
SLA processes and outcomes and how variable the effects of different factors can
be in each language learning/teaching context.
Although not segmented in this way by the authors, the book can be divided
into three parts, not including a separate introduction and conclusion (Chapter 7).
The introduction serves as a general guideline to provide readers with an overview
of the topics to be discussed in later chapters. The authors also provide an informal
survey asking the readers beliefs about a range of SLA processes and outcomes,
issues the authors ask readers to keep considering while reading the rest of the
book. In the closing chapter, Chapter 7, they revisit the survey and summarize their
positions by elaborating each survey point. This circular format is a good way to
help readers actively relate their own thoughts and experience to the reading and
see whether there is any difference between their thoughts and the opinions sup- there is any difference between their thoughts and the opinions sup- their thoughts and the opinions sup- thoughts and the opinions sup- opinions sup-
ported by literature.
The frst part, Chapter 1, discusses the stages of frst language develop- develop-
ment. Understanding the processes and stages of frst language acquisition has
been thought to be the foundation on which SLA processes can be explained, if
similarities and differences of frst and second language acquisition are taken into
account. As such, the authors begin with a chapter outlining and evaluating three
perspectives of frst language acquisition: the behaviorist, innatist, and interactional/
developmental perspectives. At the end of the frst chapter, the authors argue for
childhood bilingualism.
The second part consists of four chapters (Chapters 2-5) dealing with different
aspects of SLA: SLA theories (Chapter 2), individual learner differences in SLA
Issues in Applied Linguistics ISSN 1050-4273
2007, Regents of the University of California Vol. 15 No. 2, 169-172
(Chapter 3), the characteristics of second language learners` developing language
(Chapter 4), and the effects of language learning contexts on SLA (Chapter 6).
Even though all four chapters are important in understanding SLA as a quite intri-
cate process, Chapter 2 is of particular importance in that it provides a foundation
for better understanding different but related aspects of SLA, which become the
topics of the next three chapters (Chapters 3-5). Additionally, the updates from
the previous edition (Lightbown & Spada, 1999) are particularly noteworthy in
Chapter 2 including more useful discussion on psychological and sociocultural
perspectives of SLA.
In discussing the four perspectives the behaviorist, innatist, psychological,
and sociocultural perspectives proposed to explain SLA, the authors highlight
that SLA is a complex phenomenon diffcult to account for by a single perspective.
The complexity of SLA explains why even researchers sharing a general perspec-
tive have differing opinions. That is, it is understandable for researchers to have
proposed different perspectives to explain SLA, depending on which aspect(s)
they believe most important to successful language learning. In addition, the
complex nature of SLA is also related to why SLA studies have found mixed or
inconclusive results about the effects of individual learner variables on SLA, the
topic of the next chapter.
In Chapter 3, 'Individual differences in second language learning, the au-
thors summarize the mixed results of research focusing on the effects of learner
variables such as personality. The interaction among individual variables and the
interaction between individual and contextual variables is suggested as an explana-
tion for the inconclusive results. In other words, a variables interaction with other
contextual and individual variables makes it very diffcult or unrealistic to separate
out its independent effect on SLA. At this point, a reader may question whether
it is worthwhile to strive for one general SLA theory, despite variable effects of
individual variables in different contexts. The next chapter, Chapter 4, addresses
such skepticism by stressing the commonality of SLA processes.
Reviewing studies on the development of second language knowledge and
the ability to use the knowledge, the authors underscore that learner language has
been found to develop following a similar sequence, regardless of native language
or learning context, especially at the earlier stage of development. This common
pattern, although surprising considering the numerous variables discussed in
Chapters 2 and 3, might be the main impetus for SLA researchers to keep search-
ing for one satisfactory SLA theory. I would like to point out, however, that this
common pattern is primarily reported in studies focusing on morpho-syntax. To
fll this research gap, researchers have started looking at relatively less researched
areas. This important shift in the feld is refected in the new edition of How Lan-
guages are Learned which has added a section on the development of vocabulary,
pragmatics, and phonology.
Chapter 5 addresses the issue of learning context, focusing frst on the
similarities and differences between learning in natural and instructional settings,
170 So
and then on the research methods used to study language classrooms. Although
noting that the term instructional setting is problematic because it can conceal non-
negligible differences across classrooms, as argued by Watson-Gegeo and Nielson
(2003), the authors nevertheless adopt the term. They suggest that investigating the
differences across classrooms is needed to avoid a misleadingly simplistic interpre-
tation of the term, and they note two ways in which a classroom can be examined: by
using an observation scheme or by ethnographic observation. The main difference
between the two approaches is whether an observer starts a study with or without
a predetermined set of observation points. Whichever method is chosen to study
the language classroom, the bottom line is the assumption that instruction plays a
certain role in SLA, which naturally leads to the last part of the book.
In the last part of the book, Chapter 6, the authors present six second language
teaching methods/approaches along with empirical studies researching the effec-
tiveness of each method. The reader is guided to critically evaluate the strengths
and weaknesses of each teaching method by following the three steps the authors
take in their discussion: an explanation of the characteristics of a teaching method,
presentation of selected empirical studies examining its effectiveness, and inter-
pretation of these studies. Through these three steps, a reader can develop critical
eyes for reading literature in SLA and evaluate its implications for her own teaching
context. In short, this chapter succeeds in helping the reader build an evaluative
position in determining the applicability/adaptability of each teaching method to
her own teaching and therefore how likely it would be for her and her students to
gain outcomes similar to those reported in the study.
One strength of this book is its focus on instructed SLA, as seen in the al-
location of space to classroom language teaching (Chapters 5 and 6). Given that
language teachers will be the major audience of the book and many SLA contexts
involve some form of instruction, it is appropriate that this resource suffciently
emphasize instruction. A weakness, however, is the lack of qualitative studies used
to examine the effectiveness of teaching methods in Chapter 6. As the authors point
out (p. 138), their discussion is mainly focused on experimental studies; however,
there are many complexities in SLA (as shown in Chapters 2 and 3) that are dif-
fcult to thoroughly investigate by experimental approaches alone. Therefore, a
more balanced discussion of experimental/quantitative and qualitative studies
would be benefcial.
Overall, I found this book useful for readers with different purposes and
various levels of teaching experience and background knowledge in SLA. For
readers with relatively little teaching experience and background, it is a solid in-
troduction to SLA theories and teaching methods. For more experienced teachers
and researchers, this book contains valuable updates of the current studies and
discussions in SLA. It may also serve as a useful reminder about which areas are
being currently debated and are therefore in need of further research. To this end,
'Sources and suggestions for further reading, provided at the end of each chapter,
will be a good supplement.
Book Review 171
REFERENCES
Doughty, C. J., & Long, M. K. (2003). The scope of inquiry and goals of SLA. In C. J.
Doughty & H. M. Long (Eds.), The handbook of second language acquisition (pp.
3-16). Malden, MA: Blackwell publishing.
Lightbown, P. M. & Spada, N. (1999). How languages are learned (2nd ed.). Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Watson-Gegeo, K. A., & Nielsen, S. (2003). Language socialization in SLA. In C. J.
Doughty & H. M. Long (Eds.), The handbook of second language acquisition (pp.
155-177). Malden, MA: Blackwell publishing.
172 So