Quantitative Investigation of Wood Composition by Integrated Ft-Ir and Thermogravimetric Methods
Quantitative Investigation of Wood Composition by Integrated Ft-Ir and Thermogravimetric Methods
INTRODUCTION The development of non-invasive techniques for the investigation of cultural heritage pieces was a real challenge for scientists. The relationship between the restoring/preserving protocols and the scientific methodological approaches of the archaeological objects requires the cooperation of researchers from different areas of science, such as archaeology, chemistry, physics, textile technology, and history of art.1 Particularly by ageing and weathering, wooden artefacts undergo profound changes in their physical, chemical and structural properties, when fiber degradation causes a decrease in thread and
fabric strength, or even distortions of the whole object. As generally known, fiber degradation means a sharp decrease in the content of cellulose and lignin wood components, consequently, the cellulose/lignin ratio and the decay mechanisms of cellulose and lignin are most important issues for both scientific investigators, in order to understand the degradation processes undergone by wooden objects, and for restorers, to develop suitable consolidation and preserving procedures.2-3 The accurate methods reported by literature data4-6 for determining the cellulose/lignin ratio in wooden materials are mainly based
Table 1 Parameters of non-isothermal thermo-oxidative degradation in static air atmosphere for fresh wood species Fresh wood % m Lime 4.00 Oak 5.55 Horn beam 5.66 Maple 3.52 Beech 3.41 Poplar 7.06 Cherry tree 3.03 Fir 6.99 Pine 13.10 Dehydration Tmin (C) Tmin (C) DTG DTA 70.4 76.4 70.8 81.0 68.8 80.9 71.1 82.2 69.1 81.1 71.7 82.7 71.5; 81.6 83.8 71.8 83.0 67.6 78.7 Thermo-oxidative process II % TII TII mII (C) (C) 63.76 292.9 325.5 55.47 291.0 320.3 66.02 287.9 324.1 67.60 290.1 327.0 66.43 292.8 327.7 55.06 297.0 329.8 63.72 290.7 328.8 62.74 328.0 331.1 56.42 323.8 328.9 Thermo-oxidative process III Tmin (C) % RTG DTG mIII 22.05 458.1 2.89 29.61 473.8 1.87 23.63 449.5 2.79 3.28 20.64 449.4 21.23 449.4 3.13 25.10 482.9 2.19 2.73 23.33 458.8 27.54 468.1 2.28 26.17 461.5 2.16
%m = total mass loss at dehydration; Tmin (DTG) = minimum temperature of gravimetric decay; Tmin (DTA) = minimum temperature of the endothermic process
580
Wood
Table 2 Parameters of non-isothermal thermo-oxidative degradation in static air atmosphere for dried wood species Dried wood Lime Oak African pole Walnut Balsa Sycamore maple Fir Pine % m 4.49 3.97 5.80 5.68 5.97 5.66 4.65 5.56 Dehydration Tmin (C) Tmin (C) (DTA) (DTG) 70.9 74.3 70.1 72.7 70.5 75.4 82.2 87.0 66.9 73.3 69.4 80.7 68.8 82.6 64.9 69.9 Thermo-oxidative process II % TII TII mII (C) (C) 69.04 292.7 329.4 62.90 287.0 318.2 50.11 288.7 332.4 56.85 320.3 323.4 70.54 286.3 314.0 67.46 292.5 331.5 61.05 336.1 339.5 60.41 331.4 334.5 Thermo-oxidative process III % Tmin (C) RTG mIII DTG 20.07 473.4 3.44 29.35 477.6 2.14 31.15 480.91.61 30.08 451.8 1.81 4.20 16.97 422.2 20.76 459.6 3.25 26.82 512.1 2.28 2.18 27.70 473.9
A vertical sliding mechanism allows positioning of the crystal out of the field of view, to provide visualization of the sample, which can be enhanced by the use of visible polarization and fluorescence illumination to increase contrast. A remote aperture is used for further reducing the mask size, to meet the dimensions and orientation of the specific area of interest. The lowest contact pressure level available (0.8 N) has been used for all measurements. Spectra were acquired in the 4000-600 cm1 range with 4 cm1 resolution and automatic background subtraction. Finally, for each spectrum, an ATR correction was applied, followed by Kubelka-Munk, for correcting the diffusive component and for normalizing the band with maximum intensity (KnowItAll(R) Informatics System 8.2-Bio-Rad laboratories). TG/DTG and DTA: A Netzsch 409 PC equipment has been employed (temperature range 25 C to 600 C, heating rate 10 K/min-1; working atmosphere static air; crucibles Pt-Rh).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION FTIR Spectra Due to the high number of spectral curves collected from the 13 samples, two representative ones were selected for softwoods (fir, pine) and for hardwoods (lime, oak), respectively. The FTIR ratios (RFTIR) of all wood species are summarized in Table 3 and Figure 4, for correlation with thermogravimetric analysis (RTG). The wood of different species, in fresh or dried state, has many similarities and specific features, localized in the fingerprint area. In the valence band area, the ATR-FTIR spectra of all wood types exhibit common features in the 3500-2500 cm-1 range: a band at 3300 cm-1, assigned to the O-H stretching vibration, for the water molecules absorbed in the wood lumen cells, and a prominent band at 2881 cm-1, corresponding to the CH stretching vibration of organic moiety.17-18 In the 1800600 cm-1 fingerprint area, specific and common bands appear, assigned to cellulose,
hemicelluloses and lignin moieties, as follows: 1724-1736 cm-1 assigned to unconjugated keto C=O in xylan, 1594-1602 cm-1 conjugated CO; 1510-1501 cm-1 a band specific to aromatic skeletal vibrations (this band depends on the wood species and is assigned to the total content of the lignin components); 1450-1456 and 1417-1424 cm-1 the bands of CH in lignin; 1363-1370 cm-1 of CH in cellulose and hemicelluloses; 1320-1328 cm-1 the band of CH in cellulose and C1O of syringyl derivatives (characteristic of hardwoods); 1264-1270 cm-1 vibrations of the guaiacyl rings and stretching vibrations of the C-O bonds (observed in softwoods); 1226-1234 cm-1 syringyl ring vibration; 1150-1156 cm-1 CO in lignin and xylan; 1116 cm-1 C OC in cellulose and hemicelluloses, 10241034 cm-1 CO in cellulose and hemicelluloses, and 895-900 cm-1 CH in cellulose (Figs. 1-2). The 1724-1736 cm-1 band, assigned to unconjugated keto C=O in xylan, remains very weak in softwoods (Fig. 1), but well-defined in hardwoods (Fig. 2). The water content in wood can be assessed from the 1660-1590 cm-1 region. In this region, the bands corresponding to keto conjugated carbonyl C=O with benzene ring in lignin at 1662 cm-1 are localized, as well as the bending vibration of H-O-H from the water molecules absorbed at 1645 cm-1 (fresh wood, Figs. 1-2). In fresh lime and oak wood samples (Fig. 2), a large and more intense band lies in the 1650-1600 cm-1 domain, considered to include both C=O and H-OH. In the dried lime and oak samples, this band decreases in intensity and splits into a band at 1594 cm-1, belonging to C=O, and a very weak peak at 1640 cm-1, belonging to H-O-H. In softwoods (Fig. 1), the dried state still maintains a high water content, which is a specific feature, related to the water content in
581
Table 3 Ratios of cellulose and hemicelluloses to lignin determined by FTIR (RFTIR) and thermo-gravimetric analysis (RTG) for fresh and dried wood species Wood Fresh RFTIR RTG | R| Dried RFTIR RTG | R| Softwoods Fir Pine 2.31 2.28 0.03 Fir 2.71 2.28 0.43 2.18 2.18 0 Pine 2.28 2.18 0.1 Maple 3.34 3.28 0.06 Balsa 4.35 4.20 0.15 Beech 3.19 3.13 0.06 Lime 3.71 3.44 0.27 Hardwoods Horn Cherry Poplar Oak beam tree 2.95 2.85 2.79 2.21 2.11 2.89 2.79 2.73 2.19 1.87 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.02 0.24 Sycamore Oak Walnut African maple pole 3.40 2.27 2.01 1.82 3.25 2.14 1.81 1.61 0.15 0.13 0.2 0.21 Lime
582
Wood
Figure 1: FTIR spectra of fresh and dried fir and pine in the fingerprint region
Figure 2: FTIR spectra of fresh and dried lime and oak in the fingerprint region
Figure 3: Representative wood thermograms (TG, DTG, SDTA) with dehydration and thermo-oxidation characteristics of hemicelluloses (II), cellulose (II), lignin (III)
Figure 4: Correlation of the two ratios, RFTIR and RT, in fresh, dried softwood and hardwood series
A comparison of the FTIR and TG ratios (Table 3, Fig. 4) evidences slightly positive differences between RFTIR and RTG, corresponding to an average of +0.015 in fresh softwood and of +0.065 in fresh hardwood, together with less than the average of +0.265 in dried softwood and of +0.18 in dried hardwood, respectively. This may be an imminent consequence of the difference in sensitivity of the quantitative thermal analysis method and of the qualitative FTIR spectroscopic method. It is only by coupling certain peak areas of the
FTIR spectra with the mass loss values of the thermal diagrams that FTIR spectroscopy becomes a complementary quantitative method for evaluating the cellulose and hemicelluloses to lignin ratios in wooden pieces from different species. On the other hand, the RTG ratios (Tables 1 and 2) are in good agreement with the literature data20 related to the percent composition of cellulose and hemicelluloses (78.76-67.84%) and of lignin (32.15-21.32%) in hardwoods. Slight differences were found for softwoods, in which cellulose and hemicelluloses
583
REFERENCES
584