Models of HRM Class Presentation One
Models of HRM Class Presentation One
Competitiveadvantage through
excellence syndrome
The HR model
Provide an analytical framework for
studying HRM
Describes the way HR is organized & its key
goals & objectives
Establish variables & relationships to be
researched
Legitimates certain HRM practices
Is a heuristic device
Key job descriptions and key deliverables
Models of HRM
Harvard Model
Fomburn Model /Michigan model
Warwick Model
5 P Model
GUEST Model
The Michigan School Model
The human resource cycle
Michigan model /matching
model
Developed by Fombrum, Ticy and Devanna
Congruency with organizational strategy (matching
model)
inclined towards the harder side
It is more strategic approach with a unitarist
outlook
Tight fit between the HR strategy and the business
strategy
Based on the product market logic which
demands that to gain high profit labor must be
cheaply obtained and exploited fully.
To improve performance at all levels, a company
must directly align its corporate & HR strategies &
structures.
It proposes that
Individual should be treated as resources.
HR viewed as passive just to be deployed rather
than source of creative energy
Fit should be achieved between the individual
& organizational strategies by selecting the most
suitable person and achieve optimum
performance.
Monitoring & appraising performance &
feedback.
Rewarding
Developing knowledge , skills & competence
Strategic aspects of managing headcount
Human asset accounting
Harvard Model
Proposed by Beer,Walton & Spector
Congruence
Cost effectiveness
Turnover
Absenteeism
Grievances
Benefits
Competence
Characteristics of HRM in
Harvard framework
1) line managers accept more
responsibility for ensuring the alignment of
competitive strategy and personnel
policy
2) personnel has the mission of setting
policies that govern how personnel
activities are developed and
implemented in ways that make them
more mutually reinforcing
David Guest Model
Strategic integration
Flexibility
Quality
A simple model of HRM &
performance
Productivity Sales
Employee
HR practices Financial
commitment Quality Performance
Warwick Model
Developed in the 1990s at the centre of
corporate strategy and change ,university
of Warwick.
Extends
the Harvard models analytical
framework for studying HRM
Analysis of model
Strengths Weaknesses
Maps the connection Internal HR practices links
between inner and outer with business outputs and
contexts performance are not
developed
Adapts to changes in
context
Organization learning
Alignment of internal and
external contexts for success
Five Ps Model
Technology matters
Quality mgt
Organizational Assessment
Change mgt
Strengths of the model
Applicable to all types & sizes of
organization
It is timeless ,not outdated
Limitation
Understand not only basic leadership and
mgt concepts but also
Needs to apply the concept of strategic
management ,process management
Basic philosophy of HR
approach
People do not like inherently dislike work.
They exercise a great deal more self direction
, self control & creativity.
To use the untapped human potential in the
service of org.
Encouraged to participate in all important
matters
Expanding subordinates influence , self-
direction & self control will lead to direct
improvements in operating efficiency.
Generic HR strategies
talent acquisition HR strategy (emphasises
attracting the best human talent from external
sources);
effective resource allocation HR strategy
(maximises the use of existing human resources
by always having the right person in the right
place at the right time);
talent improvement HR strategy (maxims the
talents of existing employees by continuously
training them and guiding them in their jobs
and career); and
cost reduction HR strategy (reduces
personnel costs to the lowest possible level).