Sts Report Group5 1
Sts Report Group5 1
GROUP SELECTION
• Human groups exceling at cooperating and upholding moral norms gains
an advantage over other groups
• So while the evolutionary basis for altruism has
it's merits, it also has it's limitations. And our
evolutionary inheritance comes with a dark
side. Humans have a strong tendency to
separate into "in" and "out" groups, and
experiments show that the thresholds for group
loyalty can be very low.
• It is clear, then, that nature endows us with both
pro-social and anti-social instincts. Human beings
are capable of the heights of kindness and the
depths of brutality. They are capable of being
"primed" to act in certain ways. This demonstrateS
the limits of basing moral decisions on mere
sentiments or gut feelings.
• Sentiment must be tempered by the exercise of
reason. This after all, was the insight of Aristotle,
whose theory of flourishing is founded on the
notion that the exercise of reason is proper to
humans, what distinguishes us from animals, and
from untutored children, too. Stephen Pinker
argues persuasively that reason alone can extend
the reach of empathy beyond favored groups to the
whole of humanity.“
• Martin Seligman, one of the leaders of the "positive
psychology" movement, argues that human flourishing is
related to five distinct factors:
1. Positive emotion
2. Engagement
3. Relationships
4. Meaning and purpose in life
5. Accomplishment and achievements.
Similarly, "self-determination theory" posits that three basic
psychological needs are fundamental to eudaimonia—
autonomy, competence, and relatedness.
• PHILOSOPHIES OF THE GOOD LIFE: A
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK FOR CATEGORIZING
CONTENT
What is the Good Life?" Responses to this question can be
roughly classified as either Perfectionistic or Hedonistic.
Perfectionist theories define good living as the development
and expression of inherent human talents and capacities.
Hedonist theories define good living as the successful
acquisition and appreciation of pleasure— the ultimate
intrinsic value. In Hedonism, the means to pleasure are
secondary. Achieving the result, drawing pleasure from an
object or activity, is key.
• Hedonism>the pursuit of pleasure, sensual-self indulgence.
>hedonists Epicurus and mill claim that the experience of
pleasure or happiness, and the absence of pain, should be the
universal objects of human desire. >Epicurus constructs an
essentially self-centered philosophy of the Good Life, concerning
himself with individual pleasure. ( CLASSICAL HEDONISM)
>according to Mill he rejects the egoistic aspect of Epicurus
thought and argues that the Good Life takes place in a social
rather than individual context in which the consideration and
maximization of all person's pleasure is paramount. ( SOCIAL
HEDONISM)
The Good Life stage Model brings together the Philosophy and
Psychology of good life. These are:* Cultural* Historical* Ideological*
MethodologicalParticularly when focusing on adult reasoning at the higher
stages of develipment, the philosophy and developmental psychology of
the Good Life appear more similar than tdifferent containing core elements
that have remained central for thousand of years. Good Life is combined
set of values that person's affirm in normative, ideal-evaluative
judgements about the good life, in general, and about good work, good
friendship or reelationship and the good person in particular. The domain
of the Good Life is conceptualized as broad including the:* Moral
Good(e.g. ethical dimensions of persons, relationship) * Nonmoral Good
(e.g. nonmoral aspects of work, family and community) On ocassion,
subject also produce judgements concerning the Moral Right in describing
the good life such as judgements mus also be counted for.
Distinctions Between the Good and the Right