Introduction To Total Productive Maintenance: ECS Limited in Collaboration With WCS International, U.K
Introduction To Total Productive Maintenance: ECS Limited in Collaboration With WCS International, U.K
Focused Improvement-SGA
Shutdown Effectiveness
Process Effectiveness
Large Scale Alignment
Planned Maintenance
Energy Management
Office Effectiveness
Early Management
HSE Management
Skill Development
House Keeping
CANDO
PRODUCTION MAINTENANCE
DRIVEN AS EQUAL DRIVEN
PARTNERS
Customer driven manufacturing organisations use TPM to
respond effectively to customers needs.
Necessary
Customers Drive the Business Company
TPM
Responses
To Satisfy/ Exceed
Expectations
COST, QUALITY, DELIVERY & PERFORMANCE
Make
Make itit Easy
Easy to
to Do
Do Things
Things Right
Right
……
…… and
and Difficult
Difficult to
to Do
Do Things
Things Wrong
Wrong
TPM forms a continuous improvement habit on the floor by
harnessing cherished values and involving all players.
Harmony Partnership
Motivation
Teamwork
Production Maintenance
Winning
Self esteem
Support functions
Helping
Ownership
Pride
7/8th of the Plant Costs are hidden.
Labour
Easy to Materials
Low impact
Measure Outside contractors
on profit
Overheads
Labour
Easy to Materials
Low impact
Measure Outside contractors
on profit
Overheads
Maximising
Eliminate Losses Measurement
Overall Plant due to Cycle
Effectiveness Unplanned Shutdowns
Breakdowns
BY Cleandowns
Delays
Establishing and Slow processing
Condition
sustaining the optimal Increased consumption
Energy loss Cycle
relationship between Off-spec.
people and their Give away
Reduced Yield
equipment
Problem
Prevention Cycle
Improve
Equipment
Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) integrates all
manufacturing functions through a common measure.
AVAILABLITY PERFORMANCE QUALITY
RATE X RATE X RATE
OEE
Shutdowns / Start-up
Changeovers Slow Processing
Losses
Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) & 6 Major Losses
1. Equipment
Loading time failure Availability = (loading time – downtime) / (Loading time) X 100
e.g., Availability = 450 min –120min / 450 min X 100 = 73%
2. Setup and
adjustment
Operating time
Performance efficiency = theoretical cycle time X
3. Idling and minor processed amount / operating time X 100
stoppages
Net operating e.g., Performance efficiency = 1.2 mins / unit X
time 170 units / 330 min X100 = 62%
4. Reduced Speed
Valuable Rate of quality = processed amount – defect amount/ processes amount X 100
operating 5. Defects in process
time e.g., Rate of quality products = 170 units –5 units / 170 units X 100 = 97%
6. Start up Loss
The gap between the ‘Average’ and ‘Best of the Best’ provides
achievable targets that have a high belief level.
FIX
1 2
OPERATE DEFECT
their co-operation
Healthy equipment like a healthy body… to create a factory
with a future.
Measure Inject before
Daily Prevention Deterioration breakdown
By Operators &
By Operators Maintainers By Maintainers
Maintenance Technician provides judgement and support and
responds rapidly to Operator requests.
• The Maintenance Technician will carry out the Planned Maintenance
Programme, where a technical judgement is required. He will strive to
improve the quality of maintenance.
• Every job the technician does is recorded and analysis carried out in
departmental teams. The trends are then used in Continuous Improvement
activities
• Technician trains the Operating Staff to carry out Operator Asset Care
activities
• As part of his induction process he spends time on the line / process,
making the product. This is to develop empathy.
• Reacts quickly to feedback on abnormalities detected by Operating Staff
Production Technician uses his ownership and his senses to
detect abnormalities before they become problems.
• The Operator predicts a problem before it happens and fixes them
during running / breaks / end of shift
• Operator carries out check and inspections of process and those
areas of equipment where a specialised judgement is not required.
He rectifies minor abnormalities and reports major ones to
Maintenance or Specialist Technicians.
• Operator carries out process change-overs and is fully aware of
the start-up, shut-down and quality requirements
• Operator responds initially to all breakdowns before involving the
Maintenance Technician.
Cleaning with meaning enhances pride in the workplace.
CLEANING
DISCOVER ABNORMALITIES
(Event
RESTORE & ELIMINATE ABNORMALITIES
Review)
POSITIVE EFFECTS
“CANDO” spirit to develop pride and ownership of the
workplace and equipment.
IMPLEMENTATION AS A-N-C-O-D
CANDO improves the evidence on the shop-floor , that is an
essential foundation for a world class performance.
5. Discipline - Standardise
• One critical element which is not in its ideal condition. What is the
actual condition?
• One major source of contamination
• One hard to clean area
• One unsafe condition
• One hard to access area
Pay attention to minor flaws, unfulfilled basic conditions and
sources of quality defects.
Abnormality Description Example
Minor Flaw Contamination Dust, dirt, powder, oil, grease, rust, paint
Damage Cracking, crushing, deformation, chipping, bending
Slackness Belts, chains
Shaking, falling out, tilting, eccentricity, wear, distortion,
Play corrosion
Unusual noise, overheating, vibration, strange smell,
Abnormal phenomenon discoloration, incorrect pressure
Blocking, hardening, accumulation of debris, peeling,
Adhesion malfunction
Unfulfilled basic condition Lubrication Insufficient, dirty, unidentified, unsuitable, leaking lubricant
Dirty, damaged, deformed lubricant inlet, faulty or squeezed
Lubricant supply pipes
Oil level gauges Dirty, damaged, leaking, no indication of correct level
Nuts and bolts : slackness, missing, cross-threaded, too
long, crushed, corroded, washer unsuitable, fitted upside
Tightening down
Quality defect sources Inclusion, infiltration, entrapment of dust, chips, wire scrap,
Foreign matter insects etc.
Shock Dropping, jolting, collision, vibration
Moisture Too much, too little, infiltration, defective elimination
Abnormalities in screens, centrifugal separators, compressed
Grain size air separators
Inadequate warming, heating, compounding, mixing,
Concentration evaporation, stirring etc.
Viscosity
Pay attention to unsafe places and unnecessary items.
Abnormality Description Example
Unsafe places Unevenness, ramps, projections, cracking, peeling, wear
Floors (steel decks), torn or worn out mats
Too steep, irregular, peeling anti-slip covers, corrosion,
Steps missing handrails
Dim, out of position, dirty or broken covers, not explosion
Lights proof
Rotating equipment Displaced, fallen off or broken covers, no emergency stop
Lifting equipment Wires, hooks, brakes and other crane parts in poor condition
Special substances, solvents, toxic gases, insulating
materials, danger signs, protective clothing, helmets,
Other goggles, gloves, aprons etc.
Unnecessary items Pumps, fans, compressors, tanks, columns, other equipment
Machinery etc.
Piping Pipes, hoses, ducts, valves, dampers etc.
Temperatures, pressure gauges, vacuum gauges, ammeters
Instruments etc.
Electrical equipment Wiring, piping, power leads, switches, plugs etc.
Jigs & Tools General tools, cutting tools, jigs, moulds, dies, frames etc.
Makeshift repair Tape, string, wire, metal plate etc.
Standby equipment spares, permanent stocks, auxiliary
Spare parts materials etc.
Pay attention to inaccessible places and sources of
contamination.
Abnormality Description Example
Inaccessible places Machine construction, covers, layout, footholds,
Cleaning space
Covers, frame, construction, instrument position and
Inspection orientation, operating-range display
Position of lubrication inlet, construction, height,
Lubrication footholds, lubricant drain, space
Tightening Covers, layout, size, construction, foothold, space
Machine layout; position of valves, switches and
Operation levers; footholds
Position of pressure gauges and setting knobs,
thermometers, flowmeters, vacuum gauges, humidity
Adjustment gauges etc.
Contamination Sources Product Leaks, spills, spurts, scatter, overflow
Raw materials Leaks, spills, spurts, scatter, overflow
Oils / liquids Leaking, spill, seeping
Gases Leaking air, gas, steam, vapour, exhaust fumes etc.
Flashes, cuttings, packing materials, runner scrap,
Scrap broken cores, rejected product
Dirt brought by people, material handling equipment,
forklifts, roof and building leaks and cracks,
Other maintenance work
These key learning points capture the message of TPM. Each
and every one in the plant must appreciate these.
• We need to be aware of the hidden cost caused by the ‘quick
fix’ approach to equipment problems
• Don’t accept equipment problems, break the cycle
• Use our senses to detect equipment problems
• Our operators and maintainers are the experts so they can
(with training) decide how to run and maintain equipment in
the best way
K.C
• We must improve teamwork between them T
Problem Prevention
Cycle
Implementing TPM
Our 9 - Step Process improves Equipment & Process Capability
Measurement Cycle Condition Cycle Problem Prevention Cycle
7. Develop future
1. Collect
Asset care & 8. Develop SOPs
Equipment History Inspection lists
and Performance
information
6. Plan the
9.
Refurbishment,
Spares and 5 Why / Fishbone /
Manpower P-M Analysis
2. Define KPIs
5. Carry out a Solutions
Condition
Appraisal (& Initial
Low Cost/ No
Clean Up)
Cost
Feedback
The step by step TPM implementation process involves
introducing the basics before plant-wide roll-out.
Focused Improvement
Pilot Projects, CANDO
Senior TPM Daily P-D-C-A,
Feedback / Maintainer Asset Care
Scoping Study Mgmt. Workshop Data logging
Work Initial Prioritisation
Management. Skill Development
Review Quality Improvement
-shop Training Training
Communication. Shut Down
Working Capital
1 5 Months 6 - 24
Month Months +
Phase I Phase II Phase III Phase IV
Typically 3 to 5 years
The implementation process involves gradual capability and
ownership building.
Milestone-1 Milestone-2 Milestone-3 Milestone-4
Introduction, Refine Best Build capability Strive for Zero
Trials & Prove Practice & losses
Capability
Operator as a Technician
Maintainer as an Engineer
Supervisor as a Manager
Manager as an Entrepreneur
Institutionalization of Continuous Improvement needs a
structured framework with Milestones.
MEASUREMENT CYCLE CONDITION CYCLE PROBLEM PREVENTION
CYCLE
Milestone 1 • Equipment history • Refurbishment • Known Problems
INTRODUCTION • Set B of B Targets • Planned Maintenance • No/Low cost solutions
3 to 6 months • Identify Accelerated • BPR Proposals
Deterioration • Visual help
• Early Warning systems • Identify Design Weakness • Visual Management
Milestone 2
REFINE BEST PRACTISE • Quantify Link to • Stop Accelerated Deterioration • Improvement Methods
AND STANDARDISE Commercial Drivers Forward action • Support Solutions
6 To 12 months • Achieve consistent B of plan
• Quantify Technical Problems
B • Maintainability Issues
• Set Zero Targets • Eliminate Accelerated • Define Hidden Problems
• Forward Business Deterioration / Sources of Dust • Technical Solutions
Milestone 3
plans & Dirt
BUILD CAPABILITY AND • Integrated Structure and systems
STANDARDISE • Performance improvement • Establish Optimum conditions
12 To 18 months Quality Maintenance • Train & Develop Skills
• Forward Training Plan
Milestone 4 • Strive for Zero Targets • High level poka yoke • New Technology improved
STRIVE FOR ZERO LOSSES Equipment design
• Commercial, bottom line • Designed in Maint. Prev
18 to 24 results • Performance ‘Better than New’
• Equipment Strategy Plan
months • Flawless Operation
implemented
Problems are not single or several-independent, but complex
and several-interrelated.
1 PROCESS SUPERVISOR
6 7 OPERATOR
2 MAINT. SUPERVISOR
8 9
TPM Team of Supervisor/
3 1 2 3
Maintainer/ Operator
4 MAINTAINER 9 4
5 8 5
7 6
Minor &
Frequent
No. of
B/D’s
Must be tackled with Engineering
Support to get at more complex
problems for long lasting solutions
MILESTONE
I II III IV
0 T
MAINTENANCE ENGR
AREA EFFECTIVENESS TEAM
INSPECTOR
SUPERVISORS
TPM FACILITATOR
PROCESS MAINTENANCE
TECHNICIAN TECHNICIAN TPM TRAINER
TECHNOLOGIST
CANDO TEAM
UNION REP
The TPM journey must be profitable and must bring about
physical changes for sustenance of interest.
IMPROVEMENT PRIORITIES
Rs
Measurement Cycle
Problem Prevention
Rs
Cycle
TEAMWORK PROFIT
1% improvement in OEE can provide the same benefit as a 5%
reduction in Maintenance cost.
80%
Cost of Losses
OEE
65%
Direct Cost of Maintenance
1 yr 2 yr 3 yr
TPM Results
TPM helps most where the strategic objectives need ambitious
Operating response targets .
Benchmark (STARTING POINT)
18.3/M
5
3.0/M
30
20
10
0
Year 1 Year 2
Expect drastic reduction in breakdowns.
Unplanned failures
6000
Reduced from 4,800 per year
To 110 per year over 2 years
5000
(1/40 of previous level)
4,800
4000
3000
2000
110
1000
0
Year 1 Year 2
Improvement in OPE results in increase in production and
reduction in power consumption per tonne
Liquid Metal
•Seven fold increase in lining life
Index
Monthly Tonnage •Zero accidents
•Zero breakdowns in Pump
100 House
Power Consumption 75 •Flawless operation from
Production Day 1 of Channel
Furnace
Nov 97 Jan 99 Total Benefit Rs 1 Million (£150k)
pa
Casting
Index
•Reduced management
OPE 150 intervention needed.
Daily Tonnage 130 •Mould change time reduced by
100
25%
Cement Lining
Index
OPE 128 • Spills and leaks eliminated
• Dosing system refurbished
100
• Improved tank cleanliness
Breakdowns
• Hoist system asset care improved
Zero Defects • Nozzle care improved
Sept 97 Feb 99
Truck manufacturer
Improved asset care moves Breakdowns towards zero
from 90 hours per month in extruding machine.
Extruder
185 •Machine Productivity increased by 85% .
Productivity Index •Material yield improvement by 10 %
4 kg/cons.
Jan00 Apr00
Power Cable manufacturer Feb00 May00
Plan and carry out Asset Care to preserve the ideal conditions
attained after refurbishment.
Criticality Condition Refurbishment
Spares List Assessment Appraisal Plan
MES
Asset Care Time
Condition
table (machine
Monitoring
side)
Time table
Asset Care
Asset Care Visual
Control (machine side) Overall Plan
Operator/Maintainer
Training Records
Transparent Workplace through Visual Controls
Shadow boards
ON
SPZ 1600
Opportunities for application of
Visual Controls
EQUIPMENT
Normal running
Scheduled stop or breakdown
Workload of major equipment for next period
Routine equipment maintenance procedure
Maintenance routine for tools, jigs, measuring instruments
Checking frequency and person in charge
Routine measures for minor repairs and adjustments
Location of frequently used tools
QUALITY / PRODUCTIVITY
Daily report on quality defects
Daily production output
Mistake Proofing: make it impossible to do wrong.
Avoid deploying operators to wait for trouble.
AUTOMATIC ANDON
FEED (TROUBLE LIGHT)
AUTOMATIC
EJECTION
AS ENGINEERING AS CONSTRUCTION
DESIGNED IT INSTALLED IT
•
- ERP • Ownership/Highly
Time & Place to work in
Teams to solve our Motivated
5. TO ENCOURAGE THE FOLLOWING :
problems for - A MODEL FACTORY (ROADS, WORKPLACE, • Minimum Supervision
TPM BOARDS) •
permanently Proud to be part of
- SMILING FACES
• Resources to adhere to - COMPLETELY SAFE Company
Master Plan - NO OIL, WATER OR AIR LEAKS • Discipline to work the
• Delegate day to day 6. TO DELIVER THE FOLLOWING :
whole shift using Best
running to front-line - CUSTOMER SATISFACTION WITH QUALITY Practice Routines
supervision and PRODUCTS
- ZERO WASTE, BREAKDOWNS, 90% OEE
operatives - QUOTED BY OTHERS AS WORLD CLASS
• Timely and adequate
Communication
WORLD CLASS
The TPM Master Plan defines the learning milestones to
deliver.
Milestone 4: Milestone 1:
Strive for Zero Targets (Introduction)
Level 3B Level 2A
Milestone 3: Checklist Milestone 2:
(Build Capability) (Refine Best Practice
& Standardise)
Level 3A Level 2B
Define Optimum Conditions
Use P-M Analysis
Define Training Needs
Improve Equipment Precision
Make it Easy to Do
Improve the Quality of
Involve Support Departments
Maintenance
Set up Early Warning System
Achieve skill levels for zero
Achieve Adherence
targets
The Audit / review must help link team objectives to the TPM
Master Plan which is linked to Strategic Objectives.
M = Manager
TL = Shift CANDO Team Leader
PLANT MANAGER MS = Milestone
To Reflect Site
Specific Customised TPM Master
Organisation Plan for Site
Job Description to
Reflect
MS1 MS2 MS3 MS4
}
CANDO Teams
GENERIC
PILLARS
1
A IZ
B IZ
2
IZ
SPECIFIC
PILLARS }
C Delivery
AUDIT
- Local CANDO
- Self Assess
- Best of Best BOTTOM UP
At advanced levels TPM is no longer a project . It is a way of
life.
85% +
OEE
Refine Strive for
Build
Best Zero
Intro Capability
Practice Targets
50%
100%
90%
Dec-99
"Soft" Cultural Aspects
80%
70%
60% 4 year
50% Standard
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100
%
"Hard" Management Aspects
Management audit helps actualise the Master Plan. It provides
coaching to achieve world class results.
TPM - TOP DOWN ASSESMENT
80%
40%
20%
0%
RCM
PLANT CANDO SKILL QUALITY
Development Cross
EFFECTIVENESS Champion Champion
Champion Functional RCA
Champion Champion
Factory Head- Head- (QA)
Head - HR Champion
Manager Head-Production Maintenance
Area Effectiveness Team / Sectional Heads (This month, this Quarter, this Year)
Organisational
Learning
CANDO Teams
Plant TPM infrastructure.
FACILITATORS
PLANT STEERING COMMITTEE (STRATEGIC MASTER PLAN)
PLANT EFFECTIVENESS COMITTEE TPM MASTER PLAN)
(BREAK BARRIERS AND ENCOURAGE)
A shopfloor Supervisor’s key role it to co-ordinate
implementation, and ensure that lessons leant are applied
Standardisation Process
Activity Flow 2 (Min 5%
Commitment)
Improvement Team Activities/Analysis
The Daily Management Process helps in supporting and
sustaining the gains Best Practices
Analysis • Modifications
• 5-Why, Fishbone • Mistake Proofing
• 9-Step Process • Feedback to
• P-M Analysis •Improvement Teams
• Criticality •Design
assessment •Engineering
• Condition Appraisal •Projects
Infrastructure
• Data Recording
Standardization
• Data Visibility
• Daily Inspection and Planned
• Communications
Maintenance
• Knowledge
• CANDO & Housekeeping
Management
• Single Point Lessons & SOPs
A very strong inter-functional Improvement Zone Partnership
is developed.
Production + Maintenance