Argument Essay
Argument Essay
Review
Pre-writing Steps
1. Read the claim and write down your reaction: “agree”;“disagree”;“yes and no, sort of”
2. Re-read the claim. Mark up and identify ALL parts of the claim.
3. Write down any assumptions that stand out to you – stuff the author is assuming or
implying. Write down any fatal, blatantly obvious logical fallacies.
4. Re-evaluate your initial reaction to reading the claim:
*If your initial reaction was to DISAGREE, do you still feel that you have enough to
go on? Is the claim wrong enough? Did the author assume too much or make a logical
error that destroys the claim’s credibility? [If you answered “yes” to all the preceding
questions, then CHALLENGE the claim. If not, then SUPPORT or QUALIFY it.]
*If your initial reaction was to AGREE, does anything from Step 3 prevent you from still
being able to agree? [If not, then DEFEND the claim. If info. from Step 3 overwhelms your
initial impression, then QUALIFY or CHALLENGE.)
* If you were unsure in your initial reaction, which way are you now leaning? If you still
feel that you only agree with the claim to a certain extent then go ahead and QUALIFY
the claim. [Qualifying requires your thesis to clearly state to what extent the claim is true
and what the author should’ve said to make it a better/more accurate claim.]
5. Write a clear thesis statement that includes why you are defending, challenging, or
qualifying the author’s claim (this may take a couple of quick revisions to make it sound
good).
6. Now that you’ve decided whether to defend, challenge, or quality, jot down 3-6
examples you can use to support your thesis. These must be examples that you can
thoroughly discuss, giving relevant details that can easily link to your thesis.
Formatting Options
Intro. Intro
Refutation Support
Support Refutation
Conclusion Conclusion
Intro Remarks:
* Discuss things that will establish your credibility
on the issue including possibly giving some
background info. on the subject:
-Such as the history of it’s importance to
society, or even it’s current importance to society, etc.
* Or perhaps use a quick anecdote
Whatever your intro. remarks are, they should work as a
smooth set-up to your thesis statement.
Thesis Statement
Refutation
and experience!
It would be best to have 1 really in-depth