Minto Pyramid Principle: Session 5 Sanket Sunand Dash
Minto Pyramid Principle: Session 5 Sanket Sunand Dash
PRINCIPLE
Session 5
Sanket Sunand Dash
Summary of Session 2
• Design an issue tree for controlling your personal expenses
• Expenses = No. of items * Qty of Items * Price per item
• Issue 1: Reduce no. of items to be purchased
• Issue 2: Reduce quantity of purchase
• Issue 3: Reduce price per unit
• Issue 4: Make units of consumption last longer
Objectives
Understanding the principles behind Minto Pyramid Principle
Applying the Minto Pyramid Principle in the case on InterfaceRAISE
Consulting.
3
Communication
What is the objective of communication by consultants?
Helping clients assimilate insights and recommendations effectively while
minimizing their information processing requirements
Minto Pyramid aims to achieve the same purpose
Assumptions Behind Minto Pyramid
Human mind tends
Humans comprehend
to group
content objects
better when it is
presented as a pyramid
into pyramids
Eff
ec
tiv
e
Wr
iti
ng
sh
ou
ld
gr
ou
p
ide
as
int
o
py
ra
mi
ds
Key Points for Ordering Content
Put the bottom line at the top
The key line summarizes your understanding of the situation and gives
actionable suggestions
Tailor the pyramid to the requirements of the audience
Remember the magic number 7
Average human mind can hold only 7 items in its short-term working memory
An idea is defined as a statement that raises a question in the
reader's mind because it presents him/her new information
How to Group Ideas
Ideas at any level must be summaries of ideas below them
Ideas in each grouping must be of same kind
Can they be expressed using a plural noun
Ideas is each grouping must be logically ordered
Ways to Logically Order Ideas
Mind performs four types of analytical activities:
Reasoning deductively
Working out cause-and-effect relationships
Dividing a whole into its parts
Categorizing
Therefore ideas can be logically ordered in only four ways:
Deductively
Chronologically
Structurally
Comparatively
Analyzing Content: Substructures of Pyramid
Vertical relationship between point and sub-points
Sub-points answer questions raised by the immediately higher-level point
Horizontal relationships between sub-points
They answer the question raised by the point in an logical manner
Logical manners implies deductive method or inductive method
Narrative flow of introduction
Readers read documents to seek answers to question(s)
Introduces the Situation, Complication and Question
Source: The Pyramid
Principle by Barbara
Minto (pg. 19)
Source: The Pyramid
Principle by Barbara
Minto (pg. 20)
Analyzing a Case
Situation
Complication
Question
Solution
Assumption
Justification
Limitation
Structure of the Minto Pyramid
Source: The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking (pg. 26)
Structure of the Minto Pyramid
Source: The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking (pg. 29)
Homework
Analyze the InterfaceRAISE case using the SCQA framework with
rationale
Based on the Issue Tree prepare a Minto Pyramid to present your
recommendations
Tips for Beginners
Always try top-down first
Use situation as the starting point for thinking through the
introduction
Don’t omit to think through the introduction
Put historical chronology in the introduction
Limit the introduction to what the reader would agree
Support all key lines
APPENDIX
Reasoning Methods: Deductive
All statements have a subject and a predicate
Arguments have following form
Major premise: Shared predicate with conclusion
Minor premise: Shared subject with conclusion
Conclusion: Outcome of argument (higher-level point)
Example
Major premise: All IIM Rohtak students are intelligent
Minor premise: X is a student of IIM Rohtak
Conclusion: X is intelligent
Reasoning Methods: Inductive
Inductive is a bottom-up approach while deductive is a top-down
approach
Ideas can be grouped together inductively if they can be described
by a common plural noun
Example
Premise 1: Lion, a member of cat family, is a carnivore
Premise 2: Tiger, a member of cat family, is a carnivore
Premise 3: Leopard, a member of cat family, is a carnivore
Conclusion: Members of the cat family are carnivores (Higher-level point)
Thank You