(SIR HAROON SB) Comparative Analysis of Library Classification System
(SIR HAROON SB) Comparative Analysis of Library Classification System
Haroom Idrees
Name : Ahmed Subhpoto
Contents
▪ Classification Meaning, Definitions.
▪ Notation.
▪ Purpose of Library Classification.
▪ Function of Library Classification.
▪ Concept of Enumerative and Faceted Classification.
▪ Dewey Decimal Classification.
▪ Universal Decimal Classification.
▪ Library of Congress Classification.
▪ Colon Classification.
▪ Comparative Analysis
▪ Conclusion.
Meaning
Latin word which means action or process of classifying something.
1 Main Outline DDC comprised of 10 The field of knowledge has The scheme follows DDC classes are comprised
Main Classes with 9 sub- been divided into 20 except addition of some of Generalia (1 to 9)
classes and 9 sub classes of classes, with an addition new subdivisions and and 26 Main Classes
each sub class. That is class for the general works. signs of combination for (A to Z) of both
beginning with most The letters I, O, W,X and Y indication of relation of Science and
general subjects to more have been left for future subjects. Humanities. The first
specific ones. use. 13 classes comprise the
Science and
applications and the
last 13 comprises of
Humanities.
4 Parts of Scheme Auxiliary tables, Each major class has been The abridge edition It consists of schedule
classification schedules published separately and consist of main tables. of basic subjects,
and an index considered to be Several auxiliary tables Schedules of common
independent of other and an index Distinctive isolates and schedules
classes. Each class has its schedules are also the part of special isolates for
own form and geographical of auxiliary tables compound subjects
division and index. going with respective
subjects.
S.N
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS cont..
Description DDC LOC UDC CC
5 Notation Notation originally was Mixed notation, 26 Mixed notation consists Notation is extremely
pure; later on some letters capitals 10 numerals & of figures letters and other mixed consisting of
have been used. Three decimal fraction. symbols. The decimal Arabic numerals, roman
figure minimum notations point is repeated after alphabet (both capital and
have been used every three figure small)and symbols and
signs including colon.
Arabic numerals (1-9)are
assigned to the Generalia
class and capital letters of
the roman alphabet are
assigned to the specific
main classes. Notation is
faceted. It is synthetic it
uses fraction on principle
for both numbers and
letters and achieves
hospitality in both array
and chain.
6 Form Division DDC uses series of nine Each class have it own Form divisions (01-09) In CC, common
common form divisions form. retain the original Dewey subdivisions use of lower
and these with minor significance but have case letters with decimal
alternatives are used with been redefined and subdivisions where
same meaning throughout greatly expanded. necessary
the scheme
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS cont..
S.N Description DDC LOC UDC CC
7 Nature of Enumerative scheme Enumerative scheme Enumerative scheme 1st to 3rd editions fully
Classification for (with a few exceptions) (with quite some but rigidly faceted
subjects exceptions) schemes for
classification. 4th to 7th
were almost freely
faceted schemes.
8 Theory It is guided by the Its lacks a sound It is guided by the The scheme is based
implicit principles but theory. It has been implicit principles on sound theory.
some general principles tailor made for the vast leading to many
have been given in the collection of Library of subjective decisions
introduction to the Congress. instead of objective one
schemes based on explicitly
stated principles. Some
general principles have
been given in the
introduction to the
abridge edition.
9 Mnemonics The principle No provision for Number building The scheme is faceted
mnemonics features schedules mnemonics devices as well as one and enjoys a
are: Form divisions, auxiliary schedules are considerable mnemonic
Geographical divisions, mnemonics features quality by the use of
and Language divisions same facets and
common facets
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS cont..
S.N Description DDC LOC UDC CC
10 Structure Structure Based on the Based on the scheme Based on the traditional
Structure based on
scheme devised by DDC main classes listed
Bacon and Harris Thomas Jefferson self under four zones. Zone
made schemes 1Generalia Class, Zone
2-Recently recognized
main classes, Zone-3
Traditional main
classes and Zone-4
Newly emerging
methodologies.
11 Species of digits 10 Arabic numerals ( a 26 roman caps 26 Roman caps 24 roman caps
dot is put after the first 10 Arabic numerals 26 roman small excluding I& O except
three digit). At certain A dot (.) 10 Arabic numerals for basic class
places use of roman Hyphen, decimal, numbers,
caps and Roman smalls parentheses brackets 23 roman small i, l, o
is permitted. 10 Arabic numerals
Mathematical symbols
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS cont..
S.N Description DDC LOC UDC CC
14 Read write & Easy Comparatively Difficult Easy for those who
remember are familiar with the
roman letters
15 Length of Base There is restrictive The Base is quite The base is restrictive Extremely broad base
base broad due to inheritance
form DDC
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS cont..
S.N Description DDC LOC UDC CC
16 Terminology Terminology is titled Terms used for Terminology is rather Terminology is
toward the USA headings are precise verbose but in recent precise and brief,
and explicit, being issues terminology provide only core
chosen by authorities has be greatly constituent terms
in various fields. improved.
17 Bias The Scheme is titles Titled toward USA Inclined to west Mostly covers the
toward west but in Indian Libraries
recent edition collection
proprietor are trying
to generalized the
scheme
19 Available form Available in both Available in both Available in both Available in both
format format format format
20 Use Shelf arrangement, The scheme is being Shelf arrangement, Shelf arrangement,
Bibliographies, used for shelf catalogues, indexes, catalogues, indexes,
arrangement bibliographies and bibliographies and
documentations lists documentations lists
21 Index Index Relative Index- Most classes have Alphabetical Index is Shortest index found
tried to locate the their on index but not so exhaustive and in any classification
relative position of there is no developed on the scheme and is
the different aspects comprehensive index basis of chain specific one which
of subject at one in LC procedure does not list
place in the index and composite subject.
is very exhaustive
Conclusion
Classification is the backbone of all library. The library
classification is core instrument for organizing and
retrieval of the documents stored in a library. There are
multiple schemes of library classification but the librarian
should choose the classification scheme based on the
collection size, material in the collection and end users of
the library.
References
Nadeem Nazir (2014). Comparative study of major classification schemes retrieved on
5.11.2018 from https://www.slideshare.net/NadeemNazir2/comparative-study-of-major-
classification-schemes?qid=9ae38571-17e6-4cc4-9d4f-
6aa4e9d10b87&v=&b=&from_search=11
The Library Tomorrow (2015). An introduction to Classification retrieved on 5.11.2018 from
https://dallingtonsmithdita14.wordpress.com/tag/analytico-synthetic-classification/
Universal Decimal Classfication . Retrieved on 5.11.2018 from
http://www.udcsummary.info/php/index.php
Library of Congress Classification PDF Files. Retrieved on 5.11.2018 from
https://www.loc.gov/aba/publications/FreeLCC/freelcc.html
Daryl Superio (2013). The Library of Congress retrieved on 5.11.2018 from
https://www.slideshare.net/dlsuperio/the-library-of-congress-classification