HSP - 2017 - UNIT 2 - B.Arch
HSP - 2017 - UNIT 2 - B.Arch
• The situation of a settlement is its position in relation to the surrounding and physical features.
• Situations have impact on the settlement’s type, size and function.
• Many site factors diminish over time as technological advances enable people to overcome difficulties - For eg.
a modern settlement need not be close to a river because drinking water is now piped to homes and waterways
are no longer important for transport.
Vary due to geographical, cultural and economical factors. Settlements can be broadly classified into
• Urban settlements
• Rural settlements
Structure of a Settlement
Dispersed Settlement
Types Of Rural Settlements in India :
Sparsely populated, like a village. Few built-up areas. The inhabitants are engaged in primary activities such as
farming, fishing and mining. The type of rural settlements in India is determined by extent of built-up area and inter-
house distance. They are of 4 types:
1.Clustered, 2. Semi Clustered, 3. Hamleted 4. Dispersed Settlements
Nucleated/Clustered/ Compact / AgglomeratedSettlements
1. Rural settlement where a number of families live in
close proximity to each other, with fields surrounding
the collection of houses and farm buildings.
2. A clustered rural settlement typically includes homes,
barns , tool sheds, and other farm structures along with
religious and school structures.
3. Each person that lives on a clustered rural settlement is
allocated strips of land in the surrounding fields.
4. The strips of land are allocated differently, some people
own or rent the land.
5. When the population of a settlement grows too large
for the capacity of the surrounding fields, new
settlements are established nearby.
6. Homes, public buildings, and fields in a clustered rural
settlement are arranged according to local cultural and
physical characteristics.
7. Clustered rural settlements are often arranged in one of
two types of patterns: circular and linear.
8. Linear settlements: Grouping of houses along a line,
Mostly along roads, railway tracks, coast or river banks
9. Nucleated settlements: Grouping of many houses
together around a centre area, Favourable sites at road
junctions, focal points of an area or junction of rivers.
Semi-clustered / semi nucleated / semi agglomerated
settlements:
Urban settlement - densely populated area, like a town or city, where the inhabitants are engaged in secondary
industry such as manufacturing and tertiary industry such as tourism.
As per Census of India Urban area adopted is as follows:
(a) All statutory places with a municipality, corporation, cantonment board or notified town area committee,
etc.
(b) A place satisfying the following three criteria simultaneously
1. A minimum population of 5,000
2. At least 75 per cent of male working population engaged in non-agricultural pursuits
3. Density of population of at least 400 per sq. km. (1,000 per sq. mile)
Urban population in NSS (National Sample Survey) consumption expenditure surveys have been classified in
three size-class of towns,
1. population less than 50000 -small towns
2. population between 50000 and one million –medium towns
3. population above one million -large towns
Post-independence towns:
4. These towns were developed as administrative
centres such as Chandigarh, Bhubaneswar,
Gandhinagar.
5. Some developed as industrial towns such as
Jamshedpur, Durgapur, Bhilai, Sindri, Barauni.
6. Some old towns also developed as satellite towns
around metropolitan cities such as Ghaziabad,
Rohtak, Gurgaon around Delhi.
Aspects / Factors that determine whether an area is urban or rural:
1. Population : - (Elaborate)
2. Land use-growth pattern : - (Elaborate)
3. Physical planning : - (Elaborate)
4. Infrastructure and services delivery-water supply and sanitation system : -(Elaborate)
5. Health care : - (Elaborate)
6. Education : - (Elaborate)
7. Environmental planning : - (Elaborate)
8. Housing design (kutchha –pucca houses) and construction technology : - (Elaborate)
9. Cultural heritage : - (Elaborate)
10. Administration : - (Elaborate)
11. Occupation : - (Elaborate)
12. Living conditions : - (Elaborate)
13. Community facilities : - (Elaborate)
14. Socio-cultural facilities : - (Elaborate)
15. ----
16. ----
17. ----
18. ----
Difference between settlement types and settlement pattern
Settlement Types Settlement Pattern
Ø It refers to the space / gaps between the Ø It refers to the spatial organization
houses or settlements. (design) which describes the overall shape and
indentation of the settlement of the settlements.
Linear
Usually the result of natural topography which restricts
growth; may also be a transportation spine.
Branch
A linear span with connecting arms.
Sheet
A vast urban area with little or no articulation.
Articulated sheet
A sheet accented by one or more central clusters and several
subclusters.
Constellation
A series of nearly equal sized cities in close proximity
Satellite
Constellation of cities around a main cluster
A theory is an abstract idea that tries to explain why something happens. This means it isn’t easily observed in
reality. It is usually an untested, and if it is tested and shown to be ‘true’ in all situations, it may be referred to as a
law or rule. If it is not ‘true’ in all situations, it remains a theory.
In urban studies, theories are used for many reasons including to explain why cities are found in certain places,
why land use varies in cities, and why different groups of people are found in different parts of the city.
Criticisms :
1. Physical features - land may restrict growth of certain sectors
2. Commuter villages defy the theory, being in the commuter zone but located far from the city
3. Decentralization of shops, manufacturing industry, and entertainment
4. It assumes an isotropic plain - an even, unchanging landscape
Concentric Zone Model_ example _ Early Chicago
2. Hoytt’s Sector model
• Developed in 1939 by Homer Hoyt ,states that a city develops in sectors, not rings
• All land uses except the CBD form sectors around the city centre. Activities in a sector are considered to be
the same throughout the sector because of the purpose/function it serves.
• The land use zones are influenced by radial transport routes.
• High-rental and low-rental areas repel one another.
Criticisms:
1. Applies well to Chicago.
2. Low cost housing is near industry and transportation proving Hoyt’s model
3. Theory based on 20th century and does not take into account cars which make Commerce easier
4. With cars, people can live anywhere and further from the city and still travel to the CBD using their car.
5. Not only do high-class residents have cars, but also middle and lower class people may have cars.
Components of Hoyt Model
CBD – Central Business District is placed at the center. Sectors and the partial rings of land use/activities take place.
This area is often known as downtown and has high rise buildings.
Industry – Industries are represented in the form of a sector radiating out from the center. These forms sector
because of the presence of a transport linkage along which the activities grew. Presence of railway line, river or road
would attract similar activity, and thus a continuous corridor or “sector” will develop. Apart from industries this area
also serves as residential area for lower class workers. Living conditions are bad because of proximity to industries.
Low-Class Residential
Low-income groups reside in this area. Narrow roads, high population density, small houses with poor ventilation
exist in this area. Roads are narrow and often connects to the industries where most of the people in this sector
work. Closeness to industries reduces the travel cost and thus attracts industrial workers. Environmental and living
conditions are often inadequate because of the proximity to factories.
Middle-Class Residential
This area has middle income groups who can afford
more substantial travel cost and want better living
conditions. The activities of people residing in this
area consist of different activities and not just the
industrial work. It has more linkages with CBD along
with some linkages to industries. This area has the
most significant residential area.
High Class residential
This is the outermost and farthest area from the
downtown. Wealthy and affluent people live in this
area. This area is clean, has less traffic, quiet and has
large houses. Corridor or spine extending from CBD
to the edge has the best housing.
The significance of Hoyt Model
• Ecological factors + economic rent concept to explain the land use pattern
• Stress on the role of transport routes in affecting the spatial arrangement of the city
• Both the distance and direction of growth from the city center are considered
• Brings location of industrial and environmental amenity values as determinants in a residential place
• Example: Sectors of high-class residential areas tend to grow towards higher grounds, sites with a better view,
more open space, the homes of influential leaders within the community and existing outlying, smaller
settlements.
• Only Railway lines are considered for the growth of sectors and do not make allowances for private cars.
• It is a monocentric representation of cities; multiple business centers are not accounted for in this model.
• Physical features – physical features may restrict or direct growth along specific wedges
• No reference to out of town development
Disadvantages:
Like the other models of the Chicago
School, the Multiple Nuclei Model does
not recognise several key features of
cities that could affect how the model
applies to reality.
High-rise buildings that could affect
population density are ignored
Each zone is homogenous throughout
(meaning that there is no variation
within each zone)
Government policies are not
considered, e.g. planning laws
The model is hard to apply to non-
Western cities
Monocentric models _ chicago school of thought _ comparison
4. Galactic ( Peripheral) model:
Galactic city model is based on the concept of galaxies in space. Galactic city model is a circular city model that
has a commercial and economic central area which is often called the central business district or CBD is at the
center of the city. The basic concept of this type of city model is high rise buildings in the city center and low rise
homes, residential areas and industrial, recreational and shopping districts surrounding the center of the city.
This is a much planned urban model of cities. The city then expands in a circular fashion around the CBD.
Edge Cities:
Galactic model of cities often has many edge cities on the outskirts beyond the periphery of the main city. Edge
city is a concept of a concentration of commercial and recreational infrastructure outside the city. These edge
cities are often parts of the main city and are far away from the city center. They are often joined to the city center
by highways or main roads. Edge cities have business centers, shopping centers and entertainment destinations
for the residents of the main city.
Office Parks, Service Centers, Employment & Shopping Centers:
Edge cities as described above are often beyond the peripheral edge of a city. Office parks are a concentration of
offices outside the city limits. A good example of this is a software park. To encourage the software industry, a
software park is a type of edge city where there is a concentration of software technology offices outside the city.
Service centers, employment centers, and shopping centers are other types of high-density urban zones nearby
outside the periphery of the galactic city model.
Airports:
Generally, airports are outside city limits and far away from the city center in most cities in the world. An airport in
the galactic city model is also outside the city and it is connected to the city with either the peripheral highways or
the radial highways that are part of this type of city model.
Galactic / peripheral city Model_ example _ detroit
The best example of Galactic model is the city of Detroit in the United States of America. An aerial view of the city
actually showcases how there is a central business district with high rise building and the urban sprawl that
surrounds the central area of the city. Detroit is a city in the United States of America in the state of Michigan. This
city is very well planned with radial roads, city center, historic architecture, modern residential districts and was
known for the expansion of the auto industry in the city.
5. Latin American model
Latin America is the portion of North, Central and South
America. Cities in Latin America have often experienced
rapid industrialisation and population growth since 1950.
This model is often applied to Sao Paulo in Brazil.
Disadvantage:
One of the major policies of the Master Plan has been the development of the District Centers which is a failure .
The reason for this could be that the DDA is only interested in preparing the plan and design with the sole object of
selling the plot. No attention is paid to its location, context and zone of influence.
City of today’s Delhi is seen in three forms-
1.The inner city i.e. The city that existed before the introduction of the Master Plan.
2.The city of planned growth-which evolved between 1962-1982.
3.The new city of the future
It is important to tie the three together to make
Hierarchy of
green spaces
Chandigarh – recreational / leisure spaces
The Leisure Valley is a green
sprawling space extending North-East
to South-West along a seasonal river
Urban Form
Physical layout and design of the city
Spatial imprint of an urban transport system
Adjacent physical infrastructures.
• Based on the book – proposal “ twin city concept” • The CBD lies at the Centre with all major
by Charles Correa, Pravin Mehta and Shirish Patel. commercial, political and social activities
They presented the proposal for constructing new • CBD surrounde by transition zone which has
growth centres across bombay harbour on factories and warehouses.
mainland, to the government • Older residential areas replaced by expanding CBD
• The implementation occured through political and • Next zone had residences for lower income group
bureaucratic channels in 1969 and successive zones for hogher income groups.
• The site was chosen across the harbour from
bombay island.
• The site – a narrow piece of land bounded by residential
western ghats on north, south, east and arabian
sea on west. industries
• CIDCO ( city and industrial development
corporation of maharashtra) was formed to plan CBD
and develop navi mumbai in 1970
Navi Mumbai - Profile:
SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE (SEZ) ENTERTAINMENT ZONE SOFTWARE TECHNOLOGY PARKS OF INDIA
INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION ZONE CONVENTION CENTER HOTELS, SHOPPING MALLS,
INTEGRATED TOWNSHIPS INTERNATIONAL TECHNO PARK STOCK EXCHANGES AND SERVICE UNITS
3. Radial City Form - the Star Form – Case Study - Copenhagen
INtroduction
(Danish: Fingerplanen) is an urban plan from 1947 which provides a strategy for the development of the
Copenhagen metropolitan area, Denmark.
According to the plan, Copenhagen is to develop along five 'fingers', centred on S-train commuter rail lines, which
extend from the 'palm', that is the dense urban fabric of central Copenhagen.
In between the fingers, green wedges are supposed to provide land for agriculture and recreational purposes.
T he metropolitan area has an area of 3,030 km2 (1,170 sq mi) over 34 municipalities
The little finger
The northern suburbs form the little finger of the plan and are
traditionally the wealthiest.T the area is known as "The
Whiskey Belt", although the area is mixed between mansions,
larger houses, garden cities and midsize houses.
The ring finger
The north-northwestern part of the suburbs forms the ring
finger. The area is to a large extent formed by detached
middle-class dwellings, with some exceptions of housing
projects or upper-class areas.
The middle finger
The northwestern suburbs form the middle finger. It consists
of a mixed area of both detached middle-class dwellings,
widespread garden cities and large, low-rise public housing
projects. The area has a Considerable part of the industrial
areas of metropolitan Copenhagen, mostly in the traditional
sectors of manufacturing.
The index finger
The index finger forms the western suburbs, which are those
with the lowest income per capita and the highest crimerate.
The thumb
The southwest suburbs along the coast form the thumb of the
plan. While the central parts of these suburbs are dominated
by high-rise housing projects and low-income inhabitants, the That Extra Mile!
distant part is dominated by detached
middle-class houses. Can this Finger Concept be adopted for
The city’s airport, rail and suburbs are all connected to the our city’s “ Sustainable Urban Forms”
centre by the metro system.
In the city centre, a combination of measures has encouraged If so, what may be the 5 finger aspects?
an increase in walking and cycling and a decrease in privatecar
The transportation system
of Copenhagen
A city block is the smallest area that is surrounded by streets. City blocks are the space for buildings within the
street pattern of a city, and form the basic unit of a city's urbanfabric.
Super blocks contain number of blocks or sectors, in the form of rectangular tracts of land, app ¾ mile long and ½
mile wide.
They accomodate poulation ranging from 15000 t0 25000 people.
They contain 3 to 4 neighbourhood units in each block
Cental continuous greenway passes through the unit, and repeated in next block, allowing pedestrians to walk from
one end of town to another safely without vehicular honderances.
All sectors are self contained units having schools, shops, offices, parks, social centres and places of worship etc.
Example: Chandigargh, Barcelona
Ribbon Development
The development is in the form of a ribbon or a line, i.e., a single row of houses
along the bus stops, bus routes, railway lines, railway stations etc.
Availability of water
The area with enough water attracts more people to settle in those areas compared to arid or dry areas.
Availability of land for agricultural activities
The areas which have fertile land attract people to settle, while infertile land make people move away from it.
Climatic condition
Areas which have adequate rainfall tend to have high growth of settlement due to high agricultural production
while areas which experience low rain fall tend to have low growth of settlement due to shortage of water and
poor agricultural production
Government policy
G overnment can affect the growth of settlement by forcing people to settle in certain area or persuade people to
settle in certain area by supplying social services and other incentives.
Also government policy affect settlement growth through town and land use planning.
End of Unit 2
UNIT – II
PART A – 2 Marks