Assessment
Assessment
Assessment
Rosetta G. Palma
1
Social Work Case Study
2
Case Study
Goal: to describe as accurately as
possible the fullest, most complete
description of the case
3
Keep in mind:
A good case study
is a product of
good
assessment.
4
intake interview
1. Involve self
2. Establish communication
3. Clarify client’s presenting problem
4. Obtaining basic information about the client
5. Focus on building professional relationship:
– clear purpose
– commitment to meeting client’s needs
– ethical standards of practice
– demonstration of warmth, genuineness and empathy
6. Elicit client’s expectation of the helping process
7. Clarify nature of the helping relationship
8. Clarify role expectations
9. Establish eligibility; review agency’s criteria for service
with client and clarify eligibility
10. Construct a data base
11. Case history write up
5
Assessment
7
About Assessment
8
Key Determinants of Assessment
1. The social worker 2. The client’s situation
a) Theoretical repertoire a) Nature of the problem(s)
(diversity) b) Strengths
c) Nature of the person
b) Professional lens d) Nature of the social environment
① Selective use of theory 3. Risks of and to client
② Worldviews, ideology, a) Of clients to others
personal values of b) Of clients to self
c) Of intervention to client
worker
4. The workplace
③ Interpretation of social ① Fields of practice/ types of service
work values and ② Agency
ideology ① Mandate
④ Practice wisdom; ② Relevant social policy
③ Agency policy
experience gained over
④ Agency procedures
time
⑤ Social worker’s culture
and life experiences
Tuula Heinonen and Len Spearman 9
Social worker’s Theoretical Repertoire (Diversity)
Selectively draws upon broad-based knowledge and theoretical
diversity to:
– understand the client and situation
– set goals
– Plan for interventions
Use and interpretation of wide knowledge base is influenced by factors
such as worker’s:
– Personal culture, life experience, worldview, ideology, and personal
interpretation of professional values
– Note: practice knowledge differs from worker to worker in varying degrees
– Own preferences and favorite sources of knowledge
– We learn from a wide range of knowledge sources but engage in
assessment through a lens with many filters = referred to as the
WORKER’S PROFESSIONAL LENS
11
Tuula Heinonen and Len Spearman: Determinants of Assessment
Important areas of the client’s story
Person: Environment and connection
Health and mental health with environment
Emotional functioning and coping
Wants and needs
Reason for service: includes precipitating Material circumstances such as
events income and assets
Social skills Available support systems and
Past experiences as relevant to current
resources
situation Shelter
Client understanding and perspective on
Safety of surrounding community
problems
Strengths Salient aspects in cultural
Coping efforts background
Obstacles Family relationships and family life
Effects of age and life stage
Gender issues
cycle
Experiences of stigma,
Spirituality
Ideology and worldview discrimination, marginalization,
Individual identity and/or oppression
13
Goals of Assessment
1. Understand need, problem or situation
2. Recognize client’ s strengths, assets, skills, abilities
3. Describe the client system
4. Understand client system’ s interaction w/ other systems
5. Identify all relevant (or any missing) info to understand the
situation
6. Pull all information together
– make judgments (partializing and prioritizing)
– choose best approach (from micro, mezzo, or macro
perspective or a combination of these
14
ASSESSMENT ACTIVITIES
appraisal of a situation and the people involved in it
identification of presenting problem
identifying problem and needed resources to resolve it
eligibility determination
data gathering and analysis (client’ s problem in relation to the
agency’ s priorities)
identifying possible actions and services
identifying possible professionals involved in the case
management
evaluation of the application for services
15
Assessment Perspectives
1. Focus on transactions
– Looks at the nature of transactions between and among
clients, family members, friends, and other systems in
the environment
16
Assessment Perspectives
Example:
Challenges of childhood and adolescence present
different potential problems than does adulthood or
the aging process
17
Assessment Perspectives
18
Assessment Perspectives
4. Focus on techniques and assessment methods
19
About Assessment
Client involvement is essential
Involves making judgments
- decide what is relevant or not
- prioritize what is important to pursue
Involves strengths
Considerations: micro-mezzo-macro dimensions
of a client situation and human diversity
Single problem definition may not exist
Continuous activity
20
Scope of Assessment
appraisal of a situation and the people involved in it
21
Practice Guidelines for Assessment
22
Foundation for Generalist Practice
Knowledge
Skills
Values and Ethics
Engagement
Assessment
Step 1
Identify client
Micro _________________________________________________________________
Mezzo ________________________________________________________________
Macro ________________________________________________________________
Diversity Aspects _________________________________________________
23
Step 1: identify your client
24
Establishing basic information about the person:
26
Step 2: Assess the client-in-situation from different
perspectives; Identify issues
Micro aspects—explore micro Lina is a single , pregnant teenager
who expressed fear and anxiety over
aspects of the situation: her unplanned pregnancy. She is also
afraid should her family discover her
predicament she will be thrown out of
– What is Lina’ s most critical their home. Her parents will no longer
problem? What things about give their support especially her
studies. She is also afraid she will
Lina contribute to her problem? cause them hurt feelings and definitely
What are her strengths..? her present situation will disappoint
them. She is seeking help for her
– Worker explores both unborn child. Her boyfriend is a high
biological and psychological school student and is ambivalent to
inform his parents about their situation.
aspects of her situation i.e. her- She is motivated to comply with
health, her feelings about her agency protocols hoping that worker
will be able to help her.
situation
27
Step 2: Assess the client-in-situation from different
perspectives; Identify issues
Mezzo aspects—Lina’ s Lina is a single , pregnant teenager who
family/immediate relatives; friends, expressed fear and anxiety over her
unplanned pregnancy. She is also afraid
other support systems, affiliations
should her family discover her predicament
with reference groups, availability,
she will be thrown out of their home. Her
accessibility, nature of relationships,
parents will no longer give their support
especially her studies. She is also afraid she
Macro aspects—services, facilities, will cause them hurt feelings and definitely
community resources and support her present situation will disappoint them.
networks She is seeking help for her unborn child. Her
boyfriend is a high school student and is
ambivalent to inform his parents about their
Diversity aspects—range of situation. She is motivated to comply with
differences in terms of race, age, agency protocols hoping that worker will be
ethnicity, geography, values, able to help her.
orientations, sexist biases, etc./
discriminatory aspects,
28
Step 3: Cite information about client’ s problems and needs
29
Important considerations
Be aware of the types/categories of problems clients typically have or
encounter: know what to look for and what areas to assess
Categories not necessarily distinct from each other; usually presented as
combination of several problem situations
Micro, mezzo, macro aspects of practice are intertwined
– Example: a client addicted to alcohol:
30
Types of Problems
Interpersonal conflict - individuals having difficulty relating to each other
Dissatisfaction in social relations - feeling unable to get close to others
Problems with formal organizations
Difficulties in role performance - feeling inadequate in playing one’s role
Problems of social transition - difficulty in handling major change in life i.e., divorce,
having a baby, moving to a new locale, etc.
31
Types of Problems
Psychological and behavioral problems -
broad gamut of emotional upheavals and inappropriate,
self-defeating, criminal, or uncontrollable behavior
Inadequate resources - deprivation of basic needs;
lack of or unavailable resources or services
Problem in decision making - emotional dilemmas,
loss of objectivity, irrational choices due to crisis situations
Cultural conflicts - discrimination
and oppression by majority groups
32
The Presenting Problem
What client states as problem
33
Presenting problem
interviewer should ask the client for the presenting problem. This
is usually accomplished through general or open inquiry, such as
“Please tell me what brought you here to see me today,” or “How
can I help you today?”
REMEMBER:
34
Presenting Problems
35
Other Descriptions or Terms for Presenting
Problem
History of presenting problem
Background information on the presenting
problem
History of the problem
37
Exercise: The Presenting Problem
Lina 18-year old, single mother looked troubled with her baby clad in unkempt
baby clothes when she came to see the worker.
“ I would like to inquire how I could apply for help for my baby. I plan to give her
up for adoption. My husband left me and I have no work nor a place to stay. I was
thrown out of my husband’ s house by his parents with whom I used to stay while
we were still living together. I do not want to give up my baby but I don’ t have
any choice. I only survive by begging since I gave birth. I feel guilty to see my
baby suffer from being exposed to extreme poverty.
40
Exercise: From Presenting Problem to Problem Definition
(Lina’s case)
She could not support or provide for her From the client situation identify
baby’s needs (buy her milk, bring her to the following:
the doctor, feed her daily) . She is
1. Unmet need or lack that is
worried about her baby should child causing the client’s
stays with her care in the streets. She problem
does not have anybody to help her 2. Blocks that prevent client
from meeting his / her
support her child. Her live-in partner need or lack
abandoned her…partner’s family 3. Client’s capacity (bio-
refused to accept her back…. She is psycho-social-spiritual)
including level of
thinking of giving up her baby for motivation (attitudes) for
adoption She expressed she does not change; weaknesses and
want to give up her baby but she feels limitations may be cited as
well
she has no choice
You are now ready to formulate
your problem definition
41
Writing The Problem Definition
Lina is worried she could not provide for her child: need for
child’s medical check-up, buy milk for her baby (unmet
need); jobless (block) and has no other source of support
(lack); She does not have anybody to turn to for their daily
subsistence (lack); her live-in partner abandoned her
(block); partner’s family with whom she used to live
refused to accept her back (block). She is thinking of giving
up her baby for adoption; expressed she does not want to
give up her baby but she feels she has no choice (capacity,
motivation, attitude etc.).
42
The Problem in 3 Frames of Reference
1. Immediate problem - client is most concerned
about; causes the current difficulty; client perceives
the need for help
43
Exercise: Identify the immediate, underlying, and working
problem using Lina’s case
She expressed she could not
support her baby’s needs.
She is worried she could not
Immediate problem client is provide for her child . ..and could
most concerned about; causes not bring her to the doctor. She
the current difficulty; client does not have anybody to turn to
perceives the need for help
for their daily subsistence ….She
Underlying problems - what
could not even buy milk for her
created and tends to perpetuate
baby…..her live-in partner
the immediate problem
abandoned her…partner’s family
Working problem -
refused to accept her back….
contributory factors that hinder
both remedy and prevention; She is thinking of giving up her
must be dealt with if change is baby for adoption She expressed
to take place she does not want to give up her
baby but she feels she has no
choice
44
Exercise: Identifying Immediate,
Underlying, and Working Problems
She is worried she could not provide for her child: need
for child’ s medical check-up, buy milk for her baby
(immediate); jobless (underlying) and has no other
source of support (underlying); She does not have
anybody to turn to for their daily subsistence
(underlying); her live-in partner abandoned her
(underlying); partner’ s family with whom she used to
live refused to accept her back underlying). She is
thinking of giving up her baby for adoption; expressed
she does not want to give up her baby but she feels she
has no choice (working problem).
45
Data Collection
46
Data Collection Principles
47
Fact vs. Assumption
Skill—distinguish between fact and asumption
Caution—interpretation of what is heard or seen
may be influenced by social worker’s frame of
reference, past experiences, values, needs, and
impressions
Facts answer the question: is it true or false?
Assumptions because they are not based on
facts may either be true or false
– Missing information is taken for granted
48
Exercise :
A woman was leaving the office when a man appeared at the door and
demanded money. The secretary opened a drawer. The contents were
scooped up, and the man sped away.
49
Discussion: Fact versus Assumption
All statements contain assumptions except for #3, which is false, and
#6 which is true. The assumptions that cannot be substantiated by the
words of the story are the ff.:
Note: The assumptions could be correct but they could be incorrect also
50
Basic Categories for Data Collection
The persons
The environment
51
Basic Categories for Data Collection:
(1) PROBLEM
The problems is:
– the need, concern, issue, or difficulty that has been
– identified for study and action by
– by both social worker and client system
52
Skill in Reflecting a Problem
Demonstrate to clients that you understand their view of an
identified problem
Reflecting a problem: a form of active, empathic listening and
responding
Precede problem reflection with reflections of feelings, content,
or feeling and meaning to show you understand clients’
experience
Communicate your understanding of the nature of the problems
of concerns as the clients see them
– Conveys your intent to help them address the problems they
wish to address
– Confirms to them that their view of the problem is legitimate
– Communicates respect for them as person and for their right
to self-determination
53
Format for Reflecting a Problem
As you see it, one of the problems you’ d like to address in our
work together is__________
EXAMPLE:
CLIENT: My wife left me—sure, for very good reasons—but I’ m really
down about it. She has left me before but always came back. This time I
know she won’ t. She’ s gone for good, and I don’ t know what to do. I can’ t
go on the way things are. I’ m so sad and lost without her.
WORKER: (Reflecting a problem) As you see it, there are 2 major problems
you’ d like to address in our work together. First, you feel terrible. You ’ re
lonely and depressed, and you find it hard to function well when you feel
that way. Second, you’ re unsure of how to get on with your life without
your wife
54
Exercise: Reflecting a Problem
Your task:
Write the words you would use in reflecting a problem Mrs.
P sees it
55
Sharing Your View of a Problem
56
Sharing Your View of a Problem
57
Suggested Format for Sharing Your View of a Problem
58
Suggested Format for Sharing Your View of a Problem
Example:
CLIENT: (Lisa, partner in a lesbian relationship) We fight all the time. Virtually
every single day we knock-down, drag-out fight. Ever since we moved in
together 2 months ago, we have fought like cats and dogs. We were great
together before we decided to live together. We don’t hit each other, but there
sure is a lot of yelling and screaming.
WORKER: (Sharing her view of a problem) As we’ve talked about your relationship
and how moving in together has affected it, I’ve been wondering about the
question of roles and expectations. It seems to me that moving from a dating
relationship represents a very significant change—one that might leave each of
you uncertain about what the other wants and needs in this new relationship.
What do you think? Might the uncertainty about expectations now that you
live together be an issue we should address too?
59
Exercise: Sharing Your View of a Problem
You are interviewing Mrs. P. a 40-year old widow who lives alone in a
small makeshift shelter. She says, “Most of the time, I feel I can
manage my life alone. But lately I’m beginning to worry that these
dizzy spells and headache attacks might be signs of a serious
illness”. I have been very preoccupied with a lot of things. My son
has not visited me and he even stopped sending me some small
amount for my daily provisions. I am disappointed with him. I used
to earn for my own a living but somehow lately I couldn’t get my
self to work because of my worrying. What if something happens
to me or to my son?
YOUR TASK:
Assume you are the social worker handling this case. Write the words
you would say in sharing your view of a problem.
60
Specifying Problems for Work
The first definitive indication that you and the client have agreed to work
together toward resolving certain problems
Derived from problems that clients have identified, those worker have
defined, or negotiated with the client
The problem for work=identified problem= the primary focus of the work
worker and client will undertake together
61
Suggested Format for Specifying Problems for Work
62
Exercise: Specifying Problems for Work
You are interviewing Mrs. P. a 40-year old widow who lives alone in a
small makeshift shelter. She says, “Most of the time, I feel I can
manage my life alone. But lately I’m beginning to worry that these
dizzy spells and headache attacks might be signs of a serious illnes
s”. I have been very preoccupied with a lot of things. My son has
not visited me and he even stopped sending me some small
amount for my daily provisions. I am disappointed with him. I used
to earn for my own a living but somehow lately I couldn’t get my
self to work because of my worrying. What if something happens to
me or to my son?
YOUR TASK:
Write the words you would say in specifying the problems for work, feel
free to be creative in preparing your response.
64
Deciding on which problem to work on:
(the “target problem”)
1. Identify with the client the range of problems that are
most significant to the client
65
Deciding on which problem to work on: (the
“ target problem” )
3. Prioritize problems in order of their importance to the client
– May also indicate that more than one problem can be addressed at
the same time
66
Translate Problems Into Needs
67
Translate Problems Into Needs
(some examples)
Identified Problems Related Needs
Child abuse Stop abuse, emotional control, child
management techniques
Unemployment Employment
Homelessness Place to live
Grief at death of loved Grief management
one
Misbehavior of children Improve parental control of children, child
management techniques
Poor performance in Improve school performance, motivation,
school family stability
68
Basic Categories for Data Collection:
(2) PERSONS
The Environment –that surrounds the persons and the problems / needs
under study.
– What is there in the environment that could be relating to this person-
problem-environment situation
Ecological-systems perspective looks into
– the necessity and potential for transactions between persons and their
environments
– factors, qualities or systems that may be present that could serve as
resources and supports
– Formal and informal resources and barriers to their use
– Systems or circumstances in the environment that may have negative
influence on the person or that may be a contributing factor to the
problem
70
Assessment Statement
Indicate the nature of the client’s presenting problem
How the problem relate to client’s needs
Is presenting problem the main problem or are there other problems
that contribute to the presenting problem
Who in the client’s environment are part of the presenting problem
Etc. data should be sufficient enough to describe the actual scope and
cause of the problem and need
71
Assessment Statement
72
CONTRACTING
73
the first step in improving----
admit a deficiency!