BAV - UPRT - Instructor Practical Advice BAV2
BAV - UPRT - Instructor Practical Advice BAV2
INSTRUCTOR
PRACTICAL ADVICE
To give some practical advice hove to arrest a flight path divergence and recover to a
stabilized flight path.
Slide 2
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
BASICS
Pay attention to the setting of your seat position and adjust your armrest carefully
Longitudinal control: G-load demand and automatic pitch trim provide longitudinal
stability
Lateral control: Rate of roll demand, automatic turn coordination and Dutch roll
damping provide lateral stability
You only need to perform minor corrections on the sidestick when the aircraft deviates
from its intended flight path
When you sense an over control, you should release the sidestick
Aggressive and opposite flight control inputs must not be applied. Such inputs can lead
to loads higher than the limit and can result in structural damage or failure.
Slide 3
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
BASICS
USE OF RUDDER
Slide 5
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
ABNORMAL ATTITUDE LAW
Slide 6
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
ANGLE OF ATTACK
Slide 7
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
STALL
Slide 8
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
STALL
Slide 9
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
STALL
Slide 10
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
Recommended maximum altitude
The recommended maximum altitude is continuously updated in flight and based on the current gross weight and
outside air temperature.
It provides the aircraft with a 0.3 g buffet margin, a minimum rate of climb 300ft/min at MAX CL thrust, and level
flight at MAX CRZ thrust.
It is limited to the maximum operating altitude (Flight envelope)
Slide 11
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
Recommended maximum altitude
When flying at the maximum altitude, some margins are reaching their required minimum in terms of:
• Thrust
• Airspeed
• Buffet threshold
• Angle of attack, and
• Bank angle, or any other maneuvers.
Any environmental factors such as icing conditions or turbulence could rapidly lead to a slowdown, a
buffet onset, a stall condition and, subsequently, a high altitude upset. be monitored as the performances
will be impacted.
Slide 12
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training Aerodynamics
Power—Drag Curve kind Airspeed Stability
Slide 13
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training Aerodynamics
Power—Drag Curve kind Airspeed Stability
Slide 14
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training Aerodynamics
MAXIMUM DESIGN MANEUVERING SPEED (vA)
Speed above which a single full deflection of any flight control surface should not be attempted
due to a risk of damage to the airplane structure.
Slide 15
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training Aerodynamics
MAXIMUM DESIGN MANEUVERING SPEED (vA)
Slide 16
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
An overview of actions to recover from an upset would encompass the two following basic
activities:
Slide 17
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
Active monitoring
Effective scanning
Startle factor
Communication
Situation analysis
Slide 18
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
ACTIVE MONITORING
Both Pilot Flying (PF) and Pilot Monitoring (PM) engagements combat complacency through
active monitoring.
Active monitoring is the critical element to ensure awareness and avoidance of undesired
airplane states.
An engaged crew is in the best position to cope with undesired airplane states.
Slide 19
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
ACTIVE MONITORING
In the context of undesired airplane states, active monitoring means keeping track of:
The environment
T he airplane's energy state, and
The flight path.
This creates expectations about future airplane state to detect deviations in order to take
timely corrective actions.
Slide 20
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
ACTIVE MONITORING
Therefore, each pilot should:
Know and understand the expected airplane state for the situation
Communicate expectations
Keep track of current airplane state
Detect and communicate deviations from expectations
Assess risk and decide on a response
Update and communicate understanding
Take timely corrective actions
Active monitoring is the responsibility of all crew members to ensure the airplane state is
understood and correct for the situation.
Slide 21
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
EFFECTIVE SCANNING
A review of airplane upsets shows that inattention or neglect of effective scanning can
result in undesired airplane state.
Proper instruments scan and crosscheck must be adequately trained and practiced.
Evidence shows that the Pilot Monitoring (PM) is often in a better position to recognize
adverse trends in airplane state or flight parameters than the Pilot Flying (PF).
Since it is difficult to stay focused on monitoring during low workload periods, it may be
beneficial for pilots to alternate this responsibility.
Slide 22
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
STARTLE FACTOR
Pilots are usually startled when a dynamic upset does occur. even if they are engaged
through actively monitoring. They will nevertheless be better situationally aware to adapt
to the situation.
An un-engaged pilot will need to regain situational awareness in order to identify the
situation.
Only an engaged - and therefore situationally aware - pilot or flight crew can effectively
recover from an upset.
Pilots must overcome the surprise and quickly shift into analysis of what the airplane is
doing and then, implement the proper recovery.
Pilots shall avoid reacting before analyzing what is happening or fixating on one indication
instead of diagnosing the situation.
Pilots continuously monitoring environment, energy state and flight path are less likely to
be startled and, therefore, more likely to deal with the situation with controlled inputs
versus reactive responses.
Slide 23
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
COMMUNICATION
Communication between flight crew members will assist in the recognition and possibly
prepare an early recovery.
At the first indication of a flight path divergence or an undesired airplane state. Both pilots
should announce what is being observed with no restraint.
Slide 24
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
SITUATION ANALYSIS
SITUATION ANALYSIS PROCESS
Slide 25
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
SITUATION ANALYSIS / Assess the energy (energy state and energy rate of change)
Slide 26
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
SITUATION ANALYSIS / Assess the energy (energy state and energy rate of change)
The main airplane performance data to be used are the indicated airspeed, the altitude,
the vertical speed and the thrust. Their trends need also to be analyzed.
Slide 27
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to become situationally aware and analyze the situation
SITUATION ANALYSIS
SITUATION ANALYSIS PROCESS
Assess the energy (energy state and energy rate of change)
Confirm the airplane attitude (pitch and bank angle)
Slide 28
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
There is an infinite number of situations that pilots can experience while flying an airplane.
The techniques that are presented in this section are applicable for most situations.
When the airplane is stalled, it is necessary to first recover from the stalled condition before initiating
upset recovery techniques.
The first actions for recovering from an airplane upset must be effective and timely.
Aircraft can be saved in first 10s after upset.
Slide 29
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
FLIGHT CONTROL INPUTS:
Yaw control
CAUTION
Slide 30
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
FLIGHT CONTROL INPUTS:
Pitch control
When needed, pilots may use the pitch trim sparingly. In the case of lack of a pitch authority,
incremental pitch trim inputs may improve elevator control effectiveness and reduce high pitch control
forces.
WARNING
Excessive use of pitch trim may result in high structural loads, may aggravate the upset situation or
may make the recovery of the upset more difficult.
Slide 31
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
STALL:
Introduction
Follow the Airbus procedure for stall recovery which is a memory item.
A stalled condition can exist at any attitude and may be recognized by continuous stall warning activation
accompanied by one or more of the following:
Loss of pitch authority
Uncommanded roll
Aerodynamic buffeting
Inability to arrest a descent rate.
It is not appropriate to wait until several stall cues are experienced prior to initiating the recovery.
Buffet will likely precede an impending stall on swept wing airplanes and may even occur before the
activation of stall warning devices.
Slide 32
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
STALL:
The thrust
Although the thrust may supplement the recovery, it is not the primary control. The elevator is the
primary control to recover from a stalled condition.
If the engines are at idle, the engine acceleration could be very slow, thus extending the recovery, and,
at high altitudes, available thrust is reduced.
For airplanes with underwing mounted engines, increasing thrust may induce a pitch up moment and
reduce the effectiveness of nose down pitch control.
It may be necessary to limit or reduce thrust to the point where control of the pitch is achieved.
Slide 33
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
STALL:
The airplane configuration
When slats, flaps or landing gear are already extended, it is important to maintain the airplane
configuration until the vertical flight path has been brought back under control.
It is routine to reduce the flaps setting on a standard go—around as a mean of reducing airplane drag.
During a stall event. the increase in angle of attack that occurs as the flaps retract may place the
airplane deeper into the stalled condition.
Landing gear retraction results in a drag increase as the landing gear doors open. In a critical recovery
situation, this drag increase would result in a further unanticipated loss of airspeed.
Slide 34
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
STALL:
Initial flight path recovery
When stall indications have stopped, and when the airplane has recovered sufficient energy, the flight
crew can smoothly recover the initial flight path.
When altitude recovery is attempted prematurely, a secondary stall may occur. That's why, when in
clean configuration and below 20 000 ft, the flight crew must select FLAPS 1. This will increase the
margin above the critical angle of attack.
Slide 35
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
STALL:
Conclusion.
1. The only way to recover from a stall is to reduce the Angle of Attack.
Slide 36
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
UPSET RECOVERY TECHNIQUES :
Two situations
Upset recovery techniques have been classified in only two situations:
Nose high
Nose low
in order to simplify the numerous previous techniques and ease the retention.
This provides the basis for relating the aerodynamic situation to its recovery technique.
Slide 37
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
UPSET RECOVERY TECHNIQUES :
Fly-By-Wire airplanes
FBW airplanes have features that should minimize the possibility of an upset and assist the pilot in
recovery when necessary.
When FBW airplanes are in a degraded flight control mode, the aerodynamic principles are still
applicable.
Slide 38
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
UPSET RECOVERY TECHNIQUES :
Auto Flight Systems
Autopilots (AP) and auto thrust (A/THR) are generally intended to be used when the airplane is within
its normal flight envelope.
If the AP and/or ATHR are responding correctly to a flight path and or energy divergence, it may not be
appropriate to decrease the level of automation.
Unfortunately, if the AP and ATHR are not responding correctly, they must be disconnected.
Slide 39
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
Troubleshooting the cause of the upset is secondary to initiating the recovery. However, the pilot still
must recognize and confirm the situation before a recovery can be initiated. Once again, this means: -
Communicate with the other crew members and say the intentions.
Slide 40
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
Slide 41
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
If the AP and ATHR responses enable to stop the flight path divergence,
the flight crew may keep the AP and ATHR engaged.
Slide 42
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
Slide 43
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
The flight crew must apply as much nose down pitch order as required to obtain a nose down pitch rate.
In the case of lack of pitch down authority, the flight crew may use incremental inputs on the trim (nose down)
to improve the effectiveness of the elevator control.
Caution:
Excessive use of pitch trim may make the upset situation worse
or may result in high structural loads.
Slide 44
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
Slide 45
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
Slide 46
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
Slide 47
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
Slide 48
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
Slide 49
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
Slide 50
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path
H divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
HIG
N O SE
EA S
SA M
Troubleshooting the cause of the upset is secondary to initiating the recovery. However, the pilot still
must recognize and confirm the situation before a recovery can be initiated. Once again, this means: -
Communicate with the other crew members and say the intentions.
Slide 51
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 52
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE HIGH ACTIONS
If the AP and ATHR responses enable to stop the flight path divergence,
the flight crew may keep the AP and ATHR engaged.
I GH
N O SE H
ME AS
SA
Slide 53
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 54
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 55
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 56
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 57
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 58
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
The flight crew should reduce the thrust and/or use the speed brakes to control the speed.
Slide 59
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 60
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
Slide 61
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
How to arrest the flight path divergence and recover to a stabilized flight path
NOSE LOW ACTIONS
SUMMARY OF NOSE LOW ACTIONS
Slide 62
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
END OF MODUL
You are now able to detect, recognize and confirm developing or developed
upset conditions in a timely manner, and
You know and understand how to successfully arrest a flight path divergence
and recover to a stabilized flight path.
Slide 63
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
AIM
To reinforce 3D mental picture in order to recognize and confirm developed upset
situations.
This section is used by instructor on briefing or ground training for demonstration. To
avoid negative training, it is not recommended to use extreme attitude on simulator.
Slide 64
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
LET'S REVIEW THE BASICS
Slide 65
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 66
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
• OBJECTIVES:
• To observe PFD’s displayed for 2 seconds (Altitude between FL100 and FL180)
• To recognize stall conditions, if any .
• To assess the aeroplane energy state and energy rate of change.
• To confirm the aeroplane attitude: Pitch and bank angles .
• To verbalize the situation.
• To determine actions to be performed for an effective recovery.
Slide 67
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 68
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 69
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 70
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 71
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 72
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 73
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 74
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 75
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 76
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 77
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 78
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 79
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 80
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 81
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 82
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 83
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 84
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 85
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 86
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 87
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 88
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
“Stall recovery”
“Confirmed”
Slide 89
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Slide 90
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
Any stall?
Energy state and rate of change?
Aeroplane attitude: pitch and bank?
Which actions for Nose High or Nose Low?
Slide 91
Upset Prevention and
Recovery ground training INSTRUCTOR COURSE
EXTREME ATTITUDE
“Stall recovery”
“Confirmed”
Slide 92