Early Attempts of Classification of Elements - Gr11
Early Attempts of Classification of Elements - Gr11
Class XI
Classification is the grouping of similar elements together and separating them from dissimilar ones.
In order to make the study of the elements known to us easy , the elements have been divided into
groups in such a way that those that have similar properties are placed in the same group.
Early attempts of the classification of elements:
Lavoisier
Lavoisier divided elements into two main types – metals and non metals.
But soon with the discovery of more elements it became clear that this classification was not enough.
Dobereiner’s Triads
• Dobereiner (1829) arranged certain elements with similar physical and chemical properties in groups
of three called triads.
• The basis of the arrangement was the atomic mass of the elements.
• In a particular triad, he showed that when the elements were arranged in the order of increasing
atomic masses, the atomic mass of the middle element is approximately the arithmetic mean of the
other two.
Triad of Li, Na and K
• The atomic mass of sodium (Na) is arithmetic mean of first element lithium (Li) and third element
potassium (K).
Triad of Ca, Sr and Ba
Mean of the atomic masses of the calcium (Ca) and barium (Ba) is almost equal to atomic mass of
strontium (Sr).
Arithmetic mean of atomic masses of calcium (Ca) and barium (Ba) =(40+137)/2=88.5
Actual atomic mass of the strontium (Sr) = 87.6
Triad of Cl, Br and I
Dobereiner could identify only three triads from the elements known at that time.
As a result, this system of classification did not gain importance and was considered mere coincidence.
However, this indicated that properties of elements are related to their atomic masses.
De Chancourtois - Telluric Helix (1862)
• He found that every eighth element had properties similar to the first. Thus there was a resemblance
in the properties of the first and the eighth, second and ninth, third and tenth and so on.
• He compared this to the octaves found in music and called it the Law of octaves.
When elements are arranged in order of increasing atomic masses, there is a repetition of the
properties of every eighth element as compared to the first.
Limitations of Newland’s Law of Octaves
i) The law was found to be successful only up to the element calcium (atomic mass 40). After that every
eighth element did not have the same properties. For e.g Cu was placed below K in the same group.
ii) Newlands placed two elements in the same slot to fit elements in the table. For e.g Co and Ni were
placed in the same slot. Similarly La and Ce were placed in the same slot.
iii) When new elements were later discovered, their properties did not fit into the law of octaves.
iv) When the noble gases were discovered later, their inclusion in the table disturbed the entire
arrangement.
Thus Newland’s Law of Octaves worked well with lighter elements only.
Lothar Meyer (1869)
• Classification in the form of a curve.
• He calculated the atomic volumes of the known elements by applying
the formula: Atomic volume =
• Mendeleev was a Russian chemist who made significant contribution in the formation of periodic table.
• The repetition of similar properties after a definite gap of atomic masses is called periodicity in
properties.
Description of Mendeleev’s periodic table
• The 63 known elements were arranged in order of increasing atomic masses in vertical columns and
horizontal rows.
• There were 6 horizontal rows called Periods and a total of 8 vertical columns called Groups.
• Groups I to VII are subdivided into A and B subgroups. Group VIII did not have any subgroups.
• Elements with similar properties were placed in a Group. The formulae of the hydrides and oxides
formed by an element were treated as one of the basic properties for classification.
• All the elements in a particular group show regular gradation in their physical properties and chemical
reactivities.
Achievements of Mendeleev’s Periodic Table
1. Elements with similar properties were grouped together which made a systematic study of their
chemical and physical properties easier.
2. In some places elements with higher atomic masses had to be placed before those with lower atomic
masses. E.g. Co was placed before Ni and Te before I so that elements with similar properties could be
grouped together.
3. Atomic masses of some elements like Be (beryllium), Au (gold), In (indium) were corrected based on
their positions in the table. For example, the atomic mass of beryllium was corrected from 13.5 to 9.
4. Mendeleev predicted the existence and properties of some elements that had not yet been discovered,
on the basis of their position in his periodic table. He even named them by prefixing Eka (Sanskrit
numeral meaning one) to the name preceding the element in the same group. Scandium, Gallium and
Germanium were discovered later and their properties matched very closely with the predicted
properties of Eka - boron, Eka – aluminium and Eka – silicon respectively.
5. When the noble gases were discovered later, they could be placed easily in a new group without
disturbing the existing order.
Limitations of Mendeleev’s Periodic Table
1. Hydrogen resembles both the alkali metals and the halogens in properties.
Like the alkalis it combines with halogens, oxygen and sulphur and forms compounds having similar
formulae. E.g HCl and NaCl, H2O and Na2O, H2S and Na2S.
However like halogens it exists as diatomic molecules ( H2, Cl2)
So, Mendeleev could not justify its position.
2. Isotopes were discovered later and posed a challenge to the Mendeelev’s periodic law.
3. Atomic masses do not increase in a regular manner for e.g Cobalt (Co) has higher atomic weight but
was placed before Nickel (Ni) in the periodic table, similarly Te (Tellurium)was placed before I. This was
not explained by Mendeleev.
Modern Periodic Table
The periodicity or the repetition of similar chemical properties of elements is because of the repetition
of the same valence shell electronic configuration.
• Elements are arranged in order of increasing atomic numbers.
• Groups:
The elements in a group are separated by definite gaps of atomic numbers (8, 8, 18, 18, 32).
The elements in a group have the same number of valence electrons and valency.
The physical properties and the chemical reactivities show a regular gradation within the group.
• Periods:
There are 7 horizontal rows or periods.
In a period, the number of valence electrons increases by 1 unit as we move from left to right.
The number of elements in a period is based on how the electrons are filled into various shells.
Second and Third periods have 8 elements each and are called Short Periods.
Fourth and Fifth Periods have 18 elements and are called Long Periods.
Sixth and seventh periods have 32 elements and are also called Long Periods.
14 elements ( Z = 58 to Z = 71) belonging to the 6 th and 14 elements (Z= 90 to Z= 103) belonging to
the 7th Periods are placed at the bottom of the periodic table. These are known as Lanthanoids and
Actinoids respectively.
Advantages of the modern periodic table:
• The position of the elements in the periodic table makes it easy to predict and compare
their properties, and explains the reason for their specific position in the periodic table.
• It gives explanation for the periodicity of elements and tells the reason why all elements
in a group have similar properties, which differ from those of other groups.
• One position for all isotopes of an element is justified since isotopes have same atomic
number.
• The positions of some elements which were misfits in the Mendeleev’s periodic table are
now justified because it is based on atomic numbers and not atomic masses.
Names of some Groups