The document discusses the key elements of a valid contract under Nepalese law, including:
1) An offer and acceptance between two or more parties
2) Competent parties who can enter into a contract freely
3) Consideration in the form of lawful obligations on each party
It also explains the differences between an agreement and a contract, noting that while all contracts are agreements, not all agreements satisfy the required elements to be considered an enforceable contract under the law. Specific cases are referenced to illustrate when agreements between spouses or family members may not establish a legal contractual obligation.
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes)
50 views
2.1 Contract
The document discusses the key elements of a valid contract under Nepalese law, including:
1) An offer and acceptance between two or more parties
2) Competent parties who can enter into a contract freely
3) Consideration in the form of lawful obligations on each party
It also explains the differences between an agreement and a contract, noting that while all contracts are agreements, not all agreements satisfy the required elements to be considered an enforceable contract under the law. Specific cases are referenced to illustrate when agreements between spouses or family members may not establish a legal contractual obligation.
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 48
Unit 2.
General Contract
2.1 Law of contract (3 LH)
2.1.1 Meaning and definition of contract 2.1.2 Essential elements of a valid contract 2.1.3 Types of contract 2.1.4 Major provision of Nepal Karar Ain 2056 Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 1 2.1.1 Meaning and definition of contract • Simply, contract means meeting of minds. • In another term contracts refers an agreement between two or more than two person to do or not to do something. • a written or spoken agreement, especially one concerning employment, sales, or tenancy, that is intended to be enforceable by law.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 2
CON… • Salmond "An agreement which creates an obligation or right in-between parties to it.“ • F.Pollock "Every agreement or promise enforceable at law is a contract. • Section 1 of the American Restatement of Contract Act defines a contract as "A promise for breach of which the law gives a remedy.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 3
CON… • By section, 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act 2056, 2(a) a contract is an agreement between two or more person to do or not to do something, which can be enforceable by law.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 4
Con… • Nepalese Supreme court has viewed [Sarki Kami Vs Kanchha Kami (2048 B.S.)] No matter on the title of document/agreement if there are elements of contracts, it should be recognized as contract.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 5
CON… • To sum up, all contracts are an agreement but all agreements are not contract because contract should carry on these factors within it, 1. Should create obligations 2. Should create rights 3. Should be done by two or more than two parties 4. Should be according to contract/laws 5. Enforceable at law Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 6 CON… • However, where an agreement does not create legal obligation, it will not be contract where as it becomes domestic, moral , religions agreement. • For example- 1. Obligation to maintain wife and children, 2. Obligation resulting for judgment of courts even though they are enforceable. • Therefore, these are some differences between contract and agreement. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 7 Contract ? Agreement ? 1. Enforceable by laws 1.May not be enforceable by laws 2. Provides remedy 2.No remedy 3. Lawful objects and 3.May be without lawful object consideration 4.May not have contractual 4. Able parties capacity 5. Legal obligation 5.Does not create legal obligations 6. Free- consent 6.No free consent 7. Defaulter should pay damages 7.No such obligations 8. Difference in 8.No types contract(direct,indirect,conting 9. May not ent, quasi,enforceable 10.All agreements are not uninforceable etc. contracts 9. Creates certain rights 11.Does not show the way to 10.All contracts are agreements fulfill 11.Contract shows the way to fulfill
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 8
CON… • All contracts are agreement but not all agreements are contract. Mrs. Balfour Vs Mr. Balfour (1919) • Balfour v. Balfour Citation. 2 K.B. 571 (Court of Appeal 1919) • Brief Fact Summary. A husband promised to pay his wife a £30 per month allowance. The wife sued her husband to enforce the promise. • Synopsis of Rule of Law. Agreements between husband and wife to provide money is generally not contract because generally the “parties do not intend that they should be attended by legal consequences.” Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 9 CON… • Facts. The Plaintiff and the Defendant were a married couple. • The Defendant husband and the Plaintiff wife lived in Ceylon where the Defendant worked. • In 1915, while the Defendant was on leave, the couple returned to England. • When it was time to return to Ceylon, the Plaintiff was advised not to return because of her health. • Prior to the Defendant returning, he promised to send the Plaintiff £30 per month as support. • The parties’ relationship deteriorated and the parties began living apart. • The Plaintiff brings suit to enforce the Defendant’s promise to pay her £30 per month. • The lower court found the parties’ agreement constituted a contract. • Issue. Does the husbands promise to pay £30 per month constitute a valid contract which can beDr.Saroj suedKumar Timalsina upon? 10 CON… • Held. The court first recognized that certain forms of agreements do not reach the status of a contract. • An agreement between a husband and wife is often times such a form of agreement. • In such agreements, one party is given a certain sum of money on a daily, weekly, monthly, etc.. basis. • This agreement is sometimes termed an allowance. • However, these agreements are not contracts because the “parties did not intend that they should be attended by legal consequences.” • One reason the court is hesitant to treat these agreements as contracts, is that there would not be enough courts to handle the volume of cases. • Thus, here, the husband’s promise did not rise to the level of a contract. • Discussion. The court makes an interesting argument in not enforcing these types of promises. The court argues that if these promises are treated as contracts the flood gates will open.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 11
Elements of valid Contract 1. Plurality of parties 2. Offer and Acceptances [Clause4 (1), Contract law] 3. Competent parties (not below 16 Years) 4. Legal relationship - (aim to est. Legal relation, Get together, cinema hall, To harm anybody is his property, Social, family and domestic agreement are not contract) 5. Free consent (No fraud, Cheat, lure, tempted) 6. Lawful consideration 7. Not expressly declared void (clause 8) [No punishment by law] 8. Written and registered (sale deed) No Registration 9. Possibilities of performance (Accident after breach of court) 10. Certainty (Meaning, Spirit, motive) Folly Vs Clcpsique (1934) 11. In future if the term of contract has to be accepted, it will not be contract. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 12 12. Lawful objective- Not against public interest (Gambling) 1.Offer
• An offer acts as a promise to do or not do something in exchange for
something else. • Your offer should be firm, not ambiguous or vague, and include the duties and responsibilities of each party. • These duties may be explained further in the terms and conditions of the agreement. • An offer doesn’t technically exist until it’s received by the requesting party. When it’s received, the offer can be accepted, altered, revoked, or terminated. • If a counter-offer is made, the original offer is terminated, and the parties will have to enter into negotiation once more. • An invitation to treat, while it looks like an offer, isn’t. • An invitation to treat is an invitation to another party to make an offer and is common in real estate, marketing, and auto sales. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 13 2. Acceptance
• After an offer, acceptance of the offer comes shortly after.
• You can accept the terms of a contract either verbally (also known as an oral contract) or in writing (also known as a written contract), and inaction cannot be considered acceptance. • Most states follow the “mailbox rule,” meaning any offer that’s accepted via email or snail mail is considered “officially accepted” the moment a person sends the email or puts the acceptance letter in the mailbox. • For a valid acceptance to occur, the parties must: 1. Agree to all of the contract’s terms without any changes or conditions. 2. Wait until all the recipients of the offer mutually agree. 3. have the capacity to enter the contract 4. Accept the terms within a reasonable time frame. 5. Understand the risks they’re incurring when they sign
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 14
Con… • Certain vitiating factors can void a contract, so you have to make sure the terms of your contract are agreed upon. • You can streamline this process by doing the following: 1. Check the document for proper grammar and spelling. 2. Restate the terms of your contract and receive a verbal acceptance. 3. Place the acceptance statement at the beginning of the agreement. 4. State verbally what the parties need to do to accept the agreement. 5. Seek help from a law firm that can guarantee everyone’s acceptance. 6. Remember that a written document is more enforceable and clear. It can be referred to if anyone claims to misunderstand the terms of your contract. • Plus, the courts take a contract more seriously when it’s in writing, so opt for a professional document when asking for acceptance. • If you want to implement contract risk management across your company, all of your agreements must be written.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 15
3. Consideration
• To have a valid legal agreement, one party must
exchange something of value with another party. • A contract may offer things like products, protection, property, or services in exchange for money. • Basically, the offer being made has to come with a price tag, or it lacks legality. • In instances where neither party is exchanging money, the parties must ensure the court views what they’re trading (their consideration) as valuable.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 16
4. Meeting of the minds
• At this stage, both parties have recognized the contract
and have agreed to enter into its obligations. • The “meeting of the minds” may also be referred to as a genuine agreement, mutual assent, mutual agreement, or consensus ad idem. • Regardless of what you call it, you can only reach this stage if all parties pass the consideration, acceptance, offer, and identification stages. • Once the meeting of the minds is complete, the contract can only be voided via discharge, vitiating factors, or a mutual amendment. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 17 5. Competency and capacity
• Before entering into a contract, the parties
involved must have the capacity to do so. • Also known as “consideration capacity,” a person who knowingly enters into a contract with a person who doesn’t have the capacity to sign the document could receive legal repercussions.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 18
Con… • The courts may take a “consideration capacity” breach on a case-by-case basis, especially if the person who drafted the contract couldn’t guarantee the signer was incapacitated.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 19
Con… • Examples of this include a person signing a document online while they’re inebriated or under some undue influence. • However, the courts will be less generous if they conclude that a person used the signer’s incapacitated state to coerce one of the parties to sign the document.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 20
6. Legality
• One of the most essential elements of a
contract is its legality. • The whole point of contract law is to protect others from contracts that could be considered unconstitutional or illegal. • Since contracts require all participating parties to take on some degree of risk, it’s vital that the law protect those who mistakenly enter an agreement. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 21 Con… • A person can’t enter into a deal with minors under the age of 18 or break any other laws in the process of forming the contract. • Otherwise, it becomes void. • To protect your own rights, you should always use a written contract and include a dispute resolution clause in case a disagreement arises between the parties.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 22
Types of Contract • Express and Implied Contracts • An express contract has terms that are stated expressly, or openly, in either writing or orally, at the time of contract formation. • These are the kinds of contracts that most people think of when they think of contracts.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 23
Con… • Implied contracts, on the other hand, have terms that must be inferred by actions, facts, and circumstances that would indicate a mutual intent to form a contract.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 24
Con… • Such contracts may be as binding as express contracts, despite their lack of formal agreement, although if a court perceives doubts in minds of the parties as to whether or not a contract existed, it may choose not to enforce such a contract.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 25
CON… • Unilateral and Bilateral Contracts • Unilateral contracts involve only one party promising to take an action or provide something of value. • These are also known as one-sided contracts, and a common example of them is when a reward is offered for something being found: the party to whom the reward is offered is under no obligation to find the lost item, but if they do find it, the offering party is under contract to provide the reward. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 26 Con… • Bilateral contracts, on the other hand, involve both parties agreeing to exchange items or services of value. • These are also known as two-sided contracts, and are the kind of contract that is most commonly encountered.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 27
CON… • Valid: Fulfills all legal requirements imposed by law, and therefore enforced by courts of law • Voidable: Contract is valid, but one party can exercise right to avoid or set aside contracted obligations • Unenforceable: Contract is valid, but not recognized by courts if legal action is sought in courts • Void: Contract is NOT valid, and not recognized by courts of law
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 28
CON… • Classification By Party • Bilateral: Agreement made between two or more people – One party makes an offer (promise) to second party – Second party accepts – Bilateral contract formed • Unilateral: Offer (promise) made by one party to another – One party makes an offer (promise) to a second party, and second party receives the benefit of the promise contingent upon the performance of the offer (promise) Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 29 CON… • Types of Contracts – Based on Validity • Now that you know what a contract is, can you identify the various Types of Contracts? • Proper knowledge of the types of contracts is essential as it will allow you to decide the legal ramifications of an agreement. • Here we will see the different Types of Contracts classified as per their validity.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 30
Con… • Types of Contracts On The Basis Of Validity • Chapter 2 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 discusses the voidable contracts and void agreements. • On the basis of validity or enforceability, we have five different types of contracts as given below.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 31
Con… • Valid Contracts • The Valid Contract as discussed in the topic on “Essentials of a Contract” is an agreement that is legally binding and enforceable. • It must qualify all the essentials of a contract.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 32
CON… • Void Contract Or Agreement • The section 2(j) of the Act defines a void contract as “A contract which ceases to be enforceable by law becomes void when it ceases to be enforceable”. This makes all those contracts that are not enforceable by a court of law as void.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 33
Con… • We have already stated examples of these kinds of contracts in the “Essentials of a Contract”. • Example: A agrees to pay B a sum of Rs 10,000 after 5 years against a loan of Rs. 8,000. • A dies of natural causes in 4 years. • The contract is no longer valid and becomes void due to the non-enforceability of the agreed terms. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 34 CON… • Voidable Contract • These types of Contracts are defined in section 2(i) of the Act: “An agreement which is enforceable by law at the option of one or more of the parties thereto, but not at the option of the other or others, is a voidable contract.” • This may seem difficult to wrap your head around but consider the following example: • Suppose a person A agrees to pay a sum of Rs. 10,0000 to a person B for an antique chair. This contract would be valid, the only problem is that person B is a minor and can’t legally enter a contract. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 35 CON… • So this contract is a valid contract from the point of view of A and a “voidable” contract from the point of view of B. As and when B becomes a major, he may or may not agree to the terms. Thus this is a voidable contract.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 36
Con… • A voidable contract is a Valid Contract. • In a voidable contract, at least one of the parties has to be bound to the terms of the contract. • For example, person A in the above example. • The other party is not bound and may choose to repudiate or accept the terms of the contract. • If they so choose to repudiate the contract, the contract becomes void. • Otherwise, a voidable contract is a valid contract. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 37 CON… • Illegal Contract • An agreement that leads to one or all the parties breaking a law or not conforming to the norms of the society is deemed to be illegal by the court. • A contract opposed to public policy is also illegal. • Several examples may be cited to illustrate an illegal contract. • For example, A agrees to sell narcotics to B. • Although this contract has all the essential elements of a valid contract, it is still illegal. • The illegal contracts are deemed as void and not enforceable by law. • As section 2(g) of the Act states: “An agreement not enforceable by law is said to be void.” Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 38 CON… • Thus we can say that all illegal contracts are void but the reverse is not true. • Both the void contracts and illegal contracts can’t be enforceable by law. Illegal contracts are actually void ab initio (from the start or the beginning). • Also because of the criminal aspects of the illegal contracts, they are punishable under law. • All the parties that are found to have agreed on an illegal promise are prosecuted in a court of law.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 39
CON… • Unenforceable Contracts • Unenforceable contracts are rendered unenforceable by law due to some technical. The contract can’t be enforced against any of the two parties. • For example, A agrees to sell to B 100kgs of rice for 10,000/-. • But there was a huge flood in the states and all the rice crops were destroyed. • Now, this contract is unenforceable and can not be enforced against either party. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 40 Con… • Solved Examples on Types of Contracts • Q1: List the main differences between a void and a voidable contract? • Answer: The following table will illustrate the major differences between a void and a voidable contract. • Void Contract Voidable Contract "A contract which ceases to be enforceable by law becomes void when it ceases to be enforceable”.“An agreement which is enforceable by law at the option of one or more of the parties thereto, but not at the option of the other or others, is a voidable contract.”A contract becomes void if either it lacks the essential elements, the law changes drastically or the terms of the contract change such that it is no longer possible to enforce the contract in a court of law. A contract becomes a voidable contract when at least one of the parties reserves its consent or the consent of one of the parties was not free at the time of the formation of the contract. Void contracts can’t be fulfilled. The validity and enforceability of the voidable contract depend on the choice of the unbound party. If the unbound party decides to repudiate the contract it becomes void. This type of contract can’t grant any rights or considerations to any of the involved parties. The right to rescind a voidable contract is retained by the unbound party.
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 41
Nepalese Contract Act -2056
• Human being needs different transactions
• The law of contract is made to regulate such transactions • Most of the countries have their own contract law. • Nepal has also made its own contract law but its history is not long. • In 1910 BS for the first time, the first written law 'civil code' issued. • Which was based on usages and customs • It has made contractual provision under the chapter of 'creditor and Debtor. • In 1992 BS provision of registration exchange, mortgage • In 2020 BS Civil Code based on equality introduced • It made provision on types of agreements • Contract law introduce in 2023BS • And in 2056 BS New contract law made which replace earlier (2023) One. • Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 42 Major provision of the Nepalese Contract Act 2056 1. The present Nepalese contract act 2056 has 13 chapters and 90 sections. Its major provision is discussed below- 2. Definition:- In section 2, 15, 25, 35, 40, 56, and 65, have defined contract offer, acceptance, contract of guarantee bailment pledge/pawn (collector or deposit) sales of goods agency and carries of goods etc. 3. Consideration: - (not enough problems) 4. Contracting parties- Section 3 has defined the qualification of contracting parties. 5. Autonomy :- Section 4 freedom of selecting subject matter 6. Contract to be dermal to have concluded (section 5) 7. Contract of sales of goods 8. Contract of agency (8 parts) 9. Contract of carriage of goods 10. Time manner and plane for performing custom 11. Performance of contract and obligation arising out there of 12. Breach of contract and remedies 13. Observation of law enforce 14. Observation of law in tree 15. Limitation (void-any time voidable 1year) Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 43 Con… • Place of contract:- Section 6 from the place where the promiser advances on offer expecting consent is deemed the place of making contract. • Offer and acceptances:- Section 7, 8, 9 • Contract according to the offer made to public (Section 10) • Indirect contract (Quasi) (Section 11) • Contingent contract (Section 12) • Void and voidable contract (Section 14) • Contracts of Guarantee, Indemnity and subrogation (Chapter 4) • Contract of Bailment (more than 5000 bailment) • Contract of pledge/person (deposit) (Part 6)
Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 44
POSSIBLE QUESTIONS • Define the term "Contract' in accordance to Contract Act, 2056. • Define contract? Explain five important essential elements of a valid contract? • Cite any three examples of void agreements. • Define valid contract • ? What are the essentials of valid contract? • Give two differences between void and illegal agreements • Define contract and write about the elements of a valid contract. Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 45 Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 46 Dr.Saroj Kumar Timalsina 47 PLEASE WITHOUT HESITATION