Globalization - Key Issues - SC
Globalization - Key Issues - SC
1
What is Globalization?
First usage of this concept in 1961, Websters
Dictionary: “The beginning of an explicit recognition
in the contemporary period of the growing
significance of world-wide connectedness of social
events and relationships.”
It can be defined as the “set of social consequences
which derive from the increasing rate and speed of
interactions of knowledge, people, goods, and capital
between states and societies.”
2
Five aspects of Globalization
Social globalization: It is a process whereby the population of
the world is increasingly bonded into a single society.
Cultural globalization: It is a process producing a singular,
homogenized version of modernity based on dominant Western
patterns.
Political globalization: It is not only the increasing
participation of people to the networks of global governance
but also to the spread of more widely shared political values
around the world.
Geographical globalization: It is a process breaking down
boundaries, shrinking distances and in which places lose its
significance.
Economic globalization: It is the process with which
capitalism became the only economic system of the world and
all economies were interconnected with each other.
3
History of Globalization
100.000-40.000 B.C –
Movement of human
beings all over the globe.
1000 B.C – 300 A.C –
Babylonian and Roman
Empires – long distance
trade and interconnected
economies.
15th – 16th centuries: First
wave of globalization –
geographical explorations.
4
History of Globalization
19th century – Second Wave of Globalization
Consolidation of nation-state system, increasing
interconnectedness between Europe, Asia and American
continents
Increasing number of bilateral and multilateral agreements
Development of international humanitarian regimes (1840
World Anti-Slavery Convention)
Emergence of international exhibitions (First world fair in
London in 1851)
Emergence of first international organizatizations (1815 Rhine
Commission) and first international NGOs (1863 Red Cross)
Increasing communication (introduction of telegraph,
telephone and radio)
Increasing economic interconnectedness (gold standard system)
5
History of Globalization
1914-1970 Period Second Wave of Globalization Cont’d
Globalization of warfare (Two World Wars)
Emergence of global international organizations (League
of Nations/United Nations)
Decolonization and globalization of nation-state system.
Emergence of global icons (McDonalds in 1955)
Increasing importance of human rights (Holocaust,
Hiroshima/Nagazaki and Universal Declaration of Human
Rights)
6
History of Globalization
1970 onwards – Third Wave of Globalization
Globalization of communication: Satellites, internet,
etc.
Globalization and digitalization of economics:
strengthening of MNCs, international economic
organizations, fully electronic stock exchanges
(NASDAQ)
Disintegration of Soviet Union and end of Cold War.
Emergence of global problems (poverty, hunger,
environment, terrorism)
7
Political Globalization
Globalization and the eradication of borders:
Transforming states
Increasing sub-state actors roles/civil society
Increasing regionalization attempts
Globalization creates;
Successful integration projects such as the EU
Problems in adaptation to changes in weak states;
Weak states/failed states: Bad economy, no coherent
community, lack of state institutions
8
Political Globalization – Change in
the Statehood
Quasi-states: States which are internationally
recognized but failed to meet the basic needs of their
populations (Sudan)
Failed-states: States which are unable to govern
their societies without external support. (Somalia)
Security paradox: Weak states do not have any
external threat, they are a threat to themselves and
their regions and to whole international society.
Instability
9
Social Globalization
Cosmopolitan vs. communitarian divide in global
politics
Cosmopolitans argue for demise of borders and
emergence for a globalized international society.
They argue for a “global humanity” instead of
national identity, which transcends all boundaries.
Communitarians argue for the maintenance of
borders and respect for national/local identities.
10
Economic Globalization
Globalization of finance is a process which means
transnationalization of financial markets through the
worldwide integration of capital flows. Globalization, thus,
implies the growth of a single, unified world market.
After World War II, financial flows exceeded the volume of
world trade and the gap widens. Each day over a trillion dollars
flows around the world and this amount is sixty times higher
than the volume of daily world trade.
The digitalization of world economy lowered the costs and
increased the speed of transactions; hence increased the
financial flows dramatically.
Globalization of trade is also very important. The volume of
world trade increased tremendously.
Is the capitalism ultimate economic system or not?
11
Cultural Globalization
Homogenization of culture (global culture): Western
consumerist culture (pop culture)
Eradication of local cultures and values.
Increasing significance of media for homogenization.
Increasing significance of global icons (Coca Cola,
Levis, McDonalds, Kardashians)
Increasing localization – the process of
g-localization.
12
Three Scenarios with Regard to
Globalization
Francis Fukuyama – The
End of History thesis
Triumph of liberalism –
end of history
Older alternatives to
liberalism (fascism and
communism)
New threats to liberal
triumph (nationalism and
fundamentalism)
13
Three Scenarios with Regard to
Globalization
Samuel Huntington – Clash of
civilizations thesis
Civilizations as the main unit of
analysis
Civilizational identity replacing
national identity
West vs. the rest argument
Clash of civilizations between
Christianity and
Islam/Confucianism
14
Three Scenarios with Regard to
Globalization
Edward Luttwak – Geo-economics thesis
Interim period (globalization vs. nation-
state)
Three significant transformations:
From security based approaches to economy
based approaches
From military to trade
From world politics to world economics
From geopolitics to geoeconomics
Geoeconomics: continuation of logic of
conflict within the grammar of commerce.
15
Three Scenarios with Regard to
Globalization
Luttwak Huntington Fukuyama
Dominant form of
Religious
Main threats
fundamentalism
Economic Cultural conflicts
and nationalism
Economically
New Fault-lines Christianity vs. Nation-states and
powerful states and
Conficuanism/Isla religious
economically weak
m communities
states
16
Global Problems
Environmental Problems
Environmental Problems
Sea pollution: Oxygen-starved dead zones that cannot sustain
life now cover an area roughly the size of the state of Oregon.
Air pollution: Only 1% of China’s 560 million city residents
breathe air that is considered safe by the European Union.
Water pollution: Less than 1% of the world’s freshwater is
readily available for human use. 87% of freshwater resources are
used for agriculture, as much of 60% of that is wasted due to
inefficient watering systems.
Increasing population: The human population on earth has
grown more in the last 50 years than it did in the previous 4
million years
17
Global Problems
Environmental Problems
Environmental Problems
Extinction of species: One in four mammals is at
risk of extinction.
Rainforest degradation: At least 50 million acres of
rainforest are lost every year, totaling an area the size
of England, Wales and Scotland combined.
Greenhouse gas emissions: Average temperatures
will increase by as much as 12 degrees Fahrenheit by
the end of the 21st century if greenhouse gas
emissions continue to rise at the current pace.
18
Global Problems
Environmental Problems
Debate between modernists and ecoradicals
Modernists argue that we should continue improving
scientific knowledge and technological capacity because
they will enhance our capability to protect the
environment
Ecoradicals claim that ecosystem has a limited carrying
capacity so if we continue to push further; we can exceed
this limit and reach the point of no return. They argue
that population rise should be strictly controlled and
measures should be taken to adopt a more environmental
friendly and less consumption oriented way of life.
19
Global Problems
Increasing Insecurity
Increasing insecurity (sub-state level insecurity
and international terrorism)
Minority problems (ex-Yugoslavia wars)
States failing to provide security of their citizens
(failed states)
States attacking on their own citizens (genocidal
states)
Global networks of terrorist organizations (al-Qaeda,
Islamic State)
20
Global Problems
Increasing Insecurity
Different views on international terrorism
Realists tend to link terrorism with other states\ the
way of resolving international terrorism is using military
force and dealing with the states that sponsoring terrorism
Liberals International cooperation is necessary to deal
with international terrorism. The best way to respond
international terrorist networks is to establish networks of
cooperating government agencies
Critical Terrorism Studies Mainstream theories are
too closely associated with governments. This limits their
analytical capability. We should focus not to actors but to
discourses on terrorism.
21
Global Problems
Cultural Imperialism?
Disappearance of local cultures, anti-
globalization movement.
Homogenization and disappearance of local cultures.
Western cultural imperialism: Adopting Western
notion of modernity
473 out of 6,909 living languages are about to
extinct.
Grassroots NGOs for anti-globalization.
22
Global Problems
Health Problems
Globalization of health problems (AIDS, SARS, bird flu,
Ebola, Covid- 19 etc.)
Quicker spread of epidemics because of increasing
mobility.
2009 Influenza epidemic – 15000 people (global)
2010 Cholera epidemic – 8500 people (mostly in Haiti)
2013-2015 Ebola epidemic – 10000 people (mostly in
Africa)
2019 – Coronavirus pandemic. By 21/01/2020 – over 96
million cases, 2.06 million deaths.
Because of the power of the internet some dangerous and
unscientific ideas can spread quickly such as anti
vaccination campaign.
23
Global Problems
Health Problems
Corona-virus disease (Covid-19) pandemic unearthed
some problems in international politics.
The size of the economic and political gap between
underdeveloped and developed countries.
Fragility of capitalist economic system
Nation states are still main reference point for people
in nationwide/worldwide crises.
Authoritarian regimes possess a risk for global human
security. Chinese officials hid facts from WHO.
24
Global Problems
Economic inequality
Increasing economic inequality and poverty
The richest 1% of adults alone owned 40% of global assets in the
year 2000, and that the richest 10% of adults accounted for 85%
of the world total. In contrast, the bottom half of the world
adult population owned barely 1% of global wealth.
The richest 85 people across the globe share a combined wealth
of £1tn, as much as the poorest 3.5 billion of the world's
population.
Some 925 million people in the world do not have enough food
to lead a healthy active life. That's about one in eight people on
earth.
The vast majority of the world's hungry people live in
developing countries, where 13.5 percent of the population is
undernourished
25
Human Rights
Human rights are rights that all individuals possess
by virtue of being human, regardless of their status as
citizens of particular states or members of a group or
organization. These rights are, accordingly, universal
and apply to all humans equally.
The acceptance of The Universal Declaration of
Human Rights (1948) by United Nations General
Assembly human rights have become both a part of
the international law and a norm in international
politics.
26
Human Rights
Because of differing legal traditions, domestic
political regimes and institutions, and philosophies,
states often have different interests in human
rights.
Even though human rights are by definition
universal, states do not necessarily have the same
interests in promoting the same rights to the
same extent.
That is why human rights are a controversial issue in
international politics.
27
Human Rights
Governments ;
28
Human Rights
Critics of human rights;
1. Human rights and especially The Universal
Declaration of Human Rights (1948) is a Western
Project.
2. The debate over what rights individuals have.
3. Human rights have not been internalized as norms in
all societies and governments; and it is almost
impossible to do so.
4. There is no authority to implement human rights law
29
Human Rights
Why do states violate human rights?
Incapacity
National Security reasons
Preserving the incumbent government’s rule
Type of government
30
Human Rights
Why do states sign human rights agreements?
To lock in domestic political reforms
For rewards such as joining an international
organization, foreign aid etc.
Moral and philosophical motivations
Self interest motivations
31
Human Rights
States take action on human rights
When there is domestic pressure to “do something” to
stop human rights abuses.
When doing so serves larger geopolitical interests.
When the gap between the principle of sovereignty and
international human rights law can be bridged.
32
33