Presenters
Presenters
• ECONOMIC BENEFITS:
1. Drives Economic Growth
2. Increases Productivity
3. Enhances Competitiveness
4. Attracts Investment
5. Fosters Innovation
• ECONOMIC BENEFITS:
1. Drives Economic Growth
2. Increases Productivity
3. Enhances Competitiveness
4. Attracts Investment
5. Fosters Innovation
• NATIONAL BENEFITS:
1. Strengthens National
Competitiveness
2. Enhances Global Reputation
3. Supports National Security
4. Fosters Sustainable Development
5. Encourages Innovation and
Progress
• INDIVIDUAL BENEFITS:
1. Increases Earning Potential.
2. Enhances Career Opportunities.
3. Improves Quality of life.
4. Supports Personal Growth.
5. Fosters Entrepreneurial Spirit
Why Human Capital Matters?
1. Human capital is a key driver of
economic growth and development.
2. It is essential for innovation,
entrepreneurship, and competitiveness.
3. Human capital is critical for addressing
social and economic challenges.
4. It is a key factor in determining a
nation's global reputation.
5. Human capital is essential for
sustainable development.
• REDUCED ECONOMIC
GROWTH:
This can slow down industries
that are vital for economic growth.
A reduced workforce limits
industrial expansion, lowers GDP,
and decreases the tax base, leading
to slower economic development.
III. EFFECTS OF BRAIN DRAIN
• DECREASE IN INNOVATION
AND RESEARCH:
Industries fail to innovate without
adequate research, remaining
dependent on foreign technologies.
Innovation stalls, limiting progress in
science, technology, and industry,
affecting competitiveness in the
global market.
• NEGATIVE IMPACT ON
NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT:
Industries fail to innovate
without adequate research,
remaining dependent on foreign
technologies. Innovation stalls,
limiting progress in science,
technology, and industry,
affecting competitiveness in the
global market.
IV. TYPES OF BRAIN DRAIN
• PERMANENT • TEMPORARY
BRAIN DRAIN BRAIN DRAIN
(EMIGRATION) (EXPATRIATION)
The country of origin There is a temporary
permanently loses the loss of talent, this
talent and expertise can sometimes have a
of these individuals, positive effect if
which negatively expatriates return
affects the availability with enhanced skills,
of skilled knowledge, and
professionals in networks that can
critical sectors like benefit their home
healthcare, country in the long
technology, and run.
education.
IV. TYPES OF BRAIN DRAIN
• INTERNAL VIRTUAL
BRAIN DRAIN BRAIN DRAIN
(URBAN-RURAL (REMOTE
WOR)
MIGRATION) These individuals may
Rural areas suffer remain in their home
from a loss of skilled country, their
professionals, leading intellectual capital
to stagnation in and productivity
development, poor serve foreign
service delivery (e.g., economies rather
healthcare and than contributing
education), and directly to the
widening regional development of their
disparities.. nation. This
represents a "virtual"
“COUNTRIES
MOST
AFFECTED BY
BRAIN
DRAIN”
• INDIA
• PHILIPPIN
ES
• MEXICO
• NIGERIA
• GREECE
• ROMANIA
• LEBANON
• PAKISTAN
• IRAN
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
1. ECONOMIC GROWTH
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
Influx of highly skilled Skilled migrants
professionals can boost might lower wages
innovation and
productivity, leading to
for native
economic growth in professionals in
sectors like technology, certain industries,
healthcare, and particularly if there
education. This
strengthens industries is an oversupply of
and supports a more labor in a specific
competitive economy. field.
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
2. INNOVATION &
TECHNOLOGY
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
Many destination
countries, especially
in the West, have In some cases, excessive
reliance on foreign
benefited from
talent may reduce the
immigrant talent in
motivation to develop
research, local skills and
engineering, education systems.
medicine, and
technology.
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
3. DEMOGRAPHIC BENEFITS
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
This is particularly
important in
A rapid influx of
countries like
professionals can
Canada, Germany,
lead to urban
and Japan, where
overpopulation,
birth rates are low,
increased demand for
and there’s a need
housing, and strain
for a younger
on social
workforce to support
infrastructure if not
economic growth and
managed well.
social security
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
5. HEALTHCARE SECTOR
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
Destination countries
The arrival of highly
may become overly
trained healthcare
workers (e.g., doctors, dependent on
nurses) from countries healthcare
like the Philippines, professionals from
India, and Nigeria can abroad, potentially
alleviate staff shortages leading to ethical
in destination countries. concerns if the
This is especially crucial
source country is
in places with aging
populations.
facing its healthcare
crisis.
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
6. INCREASED TAX
REVENUES
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
Immigrants, particularly
While most skilled
skilled professionals,
migrants contribute
contribute to the
positively to the tax
economy by paying
base, if too many people
taxes and consuming
depend on public
goods and services.
services without
Their higher earnings
contributing equally
lead to greater
(e.g., due to
contributions to the
unemployment or
public coffers, which
underemployment), it
can help fund public
may strain social
services like healthcare
welfare systems.
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
7. COMPETITION IN JOB
MARKET
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
Increased
Most skilled migrants
competition from
contribute positively
highly qualified
to the tax base, if too
immigrants can drive
many people depend
productivity and
on public services
encourage a more
without contributing
competitive job
equally (e.g., due to
market. This can
unemployment or
foster innovation and
underemployment), it
efficiency in
may strain social
industries that are
V. CONSEQUENCES FOR THE
DESTINATION COUNTRIES:
NEGATIVE NEGATIVE
Not all skilled immigrants The migration of talent
find jobs in their field of from developing countries
expertise. In some cases, to wealthier nations can
they are underemployed, exacerbate global
meaning their inequalities. Wealthy
qualifications are not fully destination countries gain
utilized, often due to skilled professionals at the
challenges with credential expense of source
recognition, language countries, which may be
barriers, or lack of local left without enough talent
experience. This "brain to support essential
waste" can result in services and development.
economic inefficiencies
VI. SOLUTIONS TO
MITIGATE BRAIN DRAIN:
1. SOCIAL SOLUTIONS: 2. ECONOMICAL SOLUTIONS:
• Promote Good Governance • Increase Salaries
• Enhance Security • Offer health insurance, housing, and
flexible hours
• Ensure Equal Opportunities
• Invest in growth sectors like tech and
• Promote Social Justice: Support healthcare
initiatives against discrimination.
• Support Startups
• Invest in Education • Improve Infrastructure
• Enhance Training Programs • Better Workplace Policies
• Improve Healthcare Services • Stabilize the Economy
• Promote Cultural Inclusive • Reduce dependency on volatile sectors
• Support Freedom of Expression • Invest in training and upskilling programs.
VI. SOLUTIONS TO
MITIGATE BRAIN DRAIN:
3. PERSONAL SOLUTIONS: 4. PROFESSIONAL SOLUTIONS:
• Enhance Living Standards • Increase Funding
• Improve Infrastructure • Enhance Infrastructure
• Support Family Programs • Invest in Technology
• Encourage Local Community • Tech Partnerships
• Promote Individual Rights • Streamline Bureaucracy
• Support Civic Engagement
• Combat Corruption
• Encourage Cultural Exchange
• Encourage Decision-Making
• Support Multicultural Initiatives
• Support Risk-Taking
• Foster Local Opportunities
• Promote Positive Culture
• Promote Travel: Offer grants for local
exploration • Employee Feedback
“BRAIN DRAIN
IN PAKISTAN”
• A SHOCKING and concerning report, released
at the end of 2023, showed that over 0.7
million people, mostly youngsters, migrated
from Pakistan for greener pastures to various
Gulf and European countries. According to the
report released by the United Nations, 64
percent of Pakistan’s population is aged
below 30 years. Those who left Pakistan in
“BRAIN DRAIN 2023 were mostly trained youth. The
IN PAKISTAN” emigrating educated youth included 5,534
engineers, 18,000 associate electrical
engineers, 2,500 doctors, 12,000 computer
experts, 6,500 accountants, 2,600 agriculture
experts, 1,600 nurses and as many as 21,517
technicians. Moreover, more than 445,000
students graduate from various universities
every year across Pakistan, and over 31pc of
them are left unemployed, with the rest
either doing odd jobs or leaving the country
in search of a better life.
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
1. Lack of research opportunities: Limited
research funding, inadequate infrastructure, and
lack of collaboration with international institutions.
“BRAIN DRAIN -70% of Pakistani researchers have limited access to
IN PAKISTAN” research funding (Higher Education Commission,
2020).
- Pakistan ranks 99/131 in the Global Innovation Index
(2022).
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
2. Limited job security: Limited job security:
Uncertainty, contract-based employment, and lack of
benefits.
“BRAIN DRAIN - 40% of Pakistan's workforce is employed in the
IN PAKISTAN” informal sector (ILO, 2020)
- 25% of Pakistanis aged 15-24 are unemployed (World
Bank, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
3. Low Salaries: Uncompetitive salaries, limited
benefits, and high cost of living.
-The average monthly salary in Pakistan is PKR 45,000
“BRAIN DRAIN (~ USD 280) (Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, 2020)
IN PAKISTAN” - 60% of Pakistanis earn less than PKR 20,000 (~ USD
125) per month (Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
4. Poor working conditions: Inadequate
infrastructure, lack of resources, and unfavorable work
environment.
“BRAIN DRAIN -50% of Pakistani workers face poor working conditions
IN PAKISTAN” (ILO, 2020)
-30% of Pakistan's workforce lacks access to social
security (ILO, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
5. Limited career development: Few
opportunities for professional growth, lack of
training, and limited promotions.
“BRAIN DRAIN -50% of Pakistani workers face poor working conditions
IN PAKISTAN” (ILO, 2020)
-30% of Pakistan's workforce lacks access to social
security (ILO, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
6. Corruption and lack of autonomy: Nepotism,
favoritism, and bribery in hiring and promotions. Limited
decision-making power, micromanaging, and lack of
“BRAIN DRAIN independence.
IN PAKISTAN” - Pakistan ranks 108/180 in the Corruption Perceptions
Index (Transparency International, 2020)
- 60% of Pakistanis perceive corruption as widespread
(Transparency International, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
7. Economic instability: Inflation, poverty,
unemployment, and economic uncertainty.
- Pakistan's inflation rate averaged 7.5% over the past 5
“BRAIN DRAIN years (State Bank of Pakistan, 2020)
IN PAKISTAN” - 30% of Pakistanis are unemployed or underemployed
(World Bank, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
8. Political instability: Government changes,
instability, and lack of policy continuity.
-Pakistan has had 3 government changes in the past 5
“BRAIN DRAIN years (Pakistan Today, 2020)
IN PAKISTAN” - 50% of Pakistanis are dissatisfied with the current
government (Gallup Pakistan, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
9. Security concerns: Terrorism, violence, and law
and order issues.
- 10,000 Pakistanis died in terrorist attacks between
“BRAIN DRAIN 2015 and 2020 (Pakistan Institute for Conflict and
IN PAKISTAN” Security Studies)
- 30% of Pakistanis feel insecure (Gallup Pakistan, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
10.Health care: Shortages of skilled healthcare
professionals compromise healthcare quality and
delivery.
“BRAIN DRAIN -Pakistan spends 1.3% of GDP on healthcare (World Health
Organization, 2020)
IN PAKISTAN” - 40% of Pakistani healthcare facilities lack basic equipment (Wor
Health Organization, 2020)
- 10,000 doctors left Pakistan between 2015-2020 (Pakistan
Medical Association)
- 25% shortage of healthcare professionals (World Health
Organization, 2020)
I. CAUSES OF BRAIN
DRAIN IN PAKISTAN:
11.Weak education system: Inadequate
infrastructure, and poor teaching quality.
- 30% of Pakistani children are out of school (UNICEF, 2020)
“BRAIN DRAIN - Pakistan ranks 127/148 in the Global Talent Competitiveness
Index (2020)
IN PAKISTAN”
SOME OTHER CAUSES:
1. Brain drain of family members: Relatives 3. Cultural and social attractions: Desire for
emigrating, leading to family separation. cultural diversity, social freedom, and
international exposure.
• Educational Reforms
Higher Education Commission (HEC)
initiatives to enhance higher education
quality
Funding for research, scholarship programs,
and international university partnerships -
Scholarship Programs
Local and international scholarships for
students pursuing higher education
Emphasis on returning skilled professionals
• Scholarship Programs
Local and international scholarships for
students pursuing higher education
Emphasis on returning skilled professionals.
IV. GOVERNMENT INITIATIVES TO
ADDRESS BRAIN DRAIN IN
PAKISTAN:
• Job Creation Initiatives
Entrepreneurship support for startups and small
businesses
Favorable environment for young professionals
• Research and Development
Support
Increased funding for innovation projects
Retain talent with an innovative environment
• Public Awareness Campaign
Highlighting local career opportunities and
quality of life
Changing perceptions about staying in Pakistan
V. Reverse Brain Drain: Encouraging Overseas
Pakistanis to Return
1. Incentives and Economic Opportunities
Tax Breaks and Financial Incentives:
Offering tax incentives, subsidies, or
relocation packages to returning
professionals can make returning to Pakistan
more attractive. This includes easing the
reintegration process with housing schemes,
tax exemptions, or financial aid for startups.
Creation of Special Economic Zones:
Establishing zones where returning
professionals are given incentives to start
businesses, particularly in IT, healthcare, and
education sectors, can encourage their
return.