Module 2.2 organization in securities market
Module 2.2 organization in securities market
Exchange Membership
Major Types of Orders
Exchange Market Makers
Exchange Membership
Specialist
Commission brokers
◦ Employees of a member firm who buy
or sell for the customers of the firm
Floor brokers
◦ Independent members of an exchange
who act as broker for other members
Registered traders
◦ Use their membership to buy and sell
for their own accounts
Major Types of Orders
Market orders
◦ Buy or sell at the best current price
◦ Provides immediate liquidity
Limit orders
◦ Order specifies the buy or sell price
◦ Time specifications for order may vary
Instantaneous - “fill or kill”, part of a
day, a full day, several days, a week,
a month, or good until canceled (GTC)
Major Types of Orders
Short sales
◦ Sell overpriced stock that you don’t
own and purchase it back later (at a
lower price)
◦ Borrow the stock from another
investor (through your broker)
◦ Can only be made on an uptick trade
◦ Must pay any dividends to lender
◦ Margin requirements apply
Major Types of Orders
Special Orders
◦ Stop loss
Conditional order to sell stock if it drops
to a given price
Does not guarantee price you will get
upon sale
Market disruptions can cancel such orders
◦ Stop buy order
Investor who sold short may want to limit
loss if stock increases in price
Margin Transactions
On any type order, instead of paying
100% cash, borrow a portion of the
transaction, using the stock as collateral
Interestrate on margin credit may be
below prime rate
Regulations limit proportion borrowed
◦ Margin requirements are from 50% up
Changes in price affect investor’s equity
Margin Transactions
Buy 200 shares at $50 = $10,000
position
Borrow 50%, investment of $5,000
If price increases to $60, position
◦ Value is $12,000
◦ Less - $5,000 borrowed
◦ Leaves $7,000 equity for a
◦ $7,000/$12,000 = 58% equity position
Margin Transactions
Buy 200 shares at $50 = $10,000
position
Borrow 50%, investment of $5,000
If price decreases to $40, position
◦ Value is $8,000
◦ Less - $5,000 borrowed
◦ Leaves $3,000 equity for a
◦ $3,000/$8,000 = 37.5% equity position
Margin Transactions
Initial
margin requirement at least 50%.
Set up by the Fed.
Maintenance margin
◦ Requirement proportion of equity to
stock
◦ Protects broker if stock price declines
◦ Minimum requirement is 25%
◦ Margin call on undermargined account
to meet margin requirement
◦ If margin call not met, stock will be sold
to pay off the loan
Exchange Market Makers
U.S. Markets
Specialistis exchange member
assigned to handle particular stocks
◦ Has two roles:
◦ Broker to match buyers and sellers
◦ Dealer to maintain fair and orderly market
Specialist has two income sources
◦ Broker commission, without risk
◦ Dealer trading income from profit, with risk
Exchange Market Makers
Tokyo Stock Exchange
(TSE)
Regular members
◦ Several employees allowed on trading floor
◦ Trading clerks for customers accounts
◦ Buy and sell for own accounts
Saitori member
◦ Hundreds of employees on trading floor
◦ Intermediary clerks
◦ Brokers among members
◦ Maintain limit orders
TSE Membership
Membership requires corporate license
Four types of license are available and
may be combined
◦ 1. Trade securities as a dealer
◦ 2. Trade as a broker
◦ 3. Underwrite new securities on secondary
offerings
◦ 4. Handle retail distribution of securities
Capital requirements vary by license
London Stock Exchange
Brokers trade on behalf of their
customers
Jobbers buy and sell as principals
Membership based on experience
and competence
Membership fee 1% of gross
revenues
Changes in the Securities
Markets
Since 1965, the growth of trading by
large financial institutions has had
many effects
◦ Negotiated (competitive) commission rates
◦ Influence on block trades
◦ Impact on stock price volatility
◦ Development of National Market System
(NMS)
Negotiated Commission
Rates
NYSE minimum commission schedule
prohibited price cutting since 1792
No price break for large orders
◦ Initial reaction was “give-ups” paid to a
designated firm - soft dollars paid for
market research
◦ Third market competed with flexible
commissions and grew
◦ Fostered development of the fourth market
Negotiated Commission
Rates
In1970 SEC began phasing in
negotiated commissions
◦ Commission rates have fallen
◦ Discount brokerage firms compete
openly
◦ Many brokerage and research firms
have merged or liquidated
The Impact of Block
Trades
Number and size of block trades has
increased
This strains the exchange specialist
system
◦ Capital - 10,000 share or larger blocks
◦ Commitment - large risk with large blocks
◦ Contacts - Rule 113 prohibited direct contact
to offer blocks to another institution
The Impact of Block
Trades
Block houses are investment firms that
help institutions locate other institutions
interested in buying or selling blocks of
stock
A good block house has
1. The capital required to position a large
block
2. The willingness to commit this capital to a
block transaction, and
3. Contacts among institutions
Institutions and Stock
Price Volatility
Empirical studies have not supported
the theory that institutional trading
increases price volatility
Where trading is dominated by
institutions, actively involved
institutions may provide liquidity for
one another and noninstitutional
investors
National Market Systems
(NMS)
NMS has been advocated by financial
institutions to provide greater efficiency,
competition, and lower cost of transactions
NMS is expected to have:
◦ 1. Centralized reporting of all transactions
◦ 2. Centralized quotation system
◦ 3. Centralized limit order book (CLOB)
◦ 4. Competition among all qualified market
makers
1. Centralized Reporting
Should record all transactions of
a stock, regardless of location
NYSE started a central tape in
June 1975 covering all NYSE
stocks traded on other
exchanges and OTC
2. Centralized Quotation
System
Listquotes for a stock from all market
makers on the national exchanges,
regional exchanges, and OTC
Brokers would complete trades on the
market with the best quote
Intermarket Trading System (ITS)
developed by American, Boston,
Chicago, New York, Pacific, and
Philadelphia Stock Exchanges and
NASD
3. Centralized Limit Order
Book
Should contain all limit orders from
all markets
Should be visible to all traders
All market makers and traders could
fill orders on it
Technology exists, but NYSE
specialists fill most limit orders and
oppose CLOB because they do not
want to share this lucrative business
4. Competition Among All
Qualified Market Makers (Rule
390)Market makers compete on OTC
market
Competition reduces bid-ask spread
NYSE opposes competition and
argues that central auction results in
best market and execution
NYSE Rule 390 requires members to
obtain permission of the exchange
before trading a listed stock off the
exchange, forcing transactions to the
exchange to create a central market
New Trading Systems
Daily trading volume has
increased from 5 million shares to
over a billion shares
NYSE routinely handles days with
volume over a billion shares
Technology has allowed the
market process to keep pace
Super DOT
Electronic order-routing system
Member firms transmit market
and limit orders in NYSE
securities to trading posts or
member firm’s booth
Report of execution returned
electronically
85% of NYSE market orders enter
through Super DOT system
Display Book
Electronic workstation
that keeps track of all limit
orders and incoming
market orders, including
incoming Super Dot limit
orders
Opening Automated Report
Service (OARS)
Pre-opening market orders for Super
Dot system
OARS automatically and continuously
pairs buy and sell orders
Presents imbalance to the specialist
prior to the opening of a stock
Helps determine opening price and
potential need for preopening call
market
Market Order Processing
Super Dot’s postopening market
order system is designed to
accept member firms’
postopening market orders up to
3 million shares
Rapid execution and reporting of
market orders
In 2000, orders executed and
reported in 15-16 seconds on
average
Limit Order Processing
Electronically files orders to be
executed when and if a specific
price is reached
Updates the Specialist’s Display
Book
Good-until-cancelled orders that
are not executed are stored until
executed or cancelled
Global Market Changes
NYSE Off-hours trading
◦ Crossing Session I provides for
trading stocks at NYSE closing prices
after the regular session from 4:15
PM to 5:00 PM
◦ Crossing Session II provides for
trading a collection of at least 15
NYSE stocks with a market value of
at least $1 million from 4:00 PM to
5:15 PM
London Stock Exchange
October 27, 1986 Big
Bang
Brokers can act as market makers
Jobbers can deal with the public and
institutions
Commissions are negotiable
Gilt market was restructured like U.S.
government securities market
Trades reported on Stock Exchange
Automated Quotations (SEAQ)
Effects of the Big Bang
Competitive market makers &
SEAQ reduced number of people
on the trading floor
More activity in the system, but
profit margin has reduced from
competition
Many firms have merged or been
acquired by foreign firms
Tokyo Stock Exchange
(TSE)
1998 brought TSE its own Big
Bang introducing more
competition in trading
commissions and competition
among market participants
Paris Bourse
The big brokerage house
monopoly on stock trading has
been opened up to French and
foreign banks
Investment firms are merging
with banks to acquire capital
needed to trade in world market
Continuous auction market
introduced to replace call market
Future Developments
Continuing consolidation of security
exchanges
More specialized investment companies
Changes in the financial services
industry
◦ Financial supermarkets
◦ Financial boutiques
Advances in technology
◦ Computerized trading
◦ 24-hour market of the future may be
floorless, global, and highly automated