Action Research Pped2261
Action Research Pped2261
OF TEACHERS’
EDUCATION
ACTION RESEARCH FOR PREPRIMARY EDUC
PPED 2261/A,R,P,IN P EDU2272/2/
CR.2
2016
YOSEF DENBU
The Concept of a Research
• is “careful, systematic, patient study and investigation in some
field of knowledge,
• conducted to find facts or principles”.
• human effort to extend his understanding about the world in
which he/she lives.
• It is a quest for knowledge.
• To find what is really happening, the costs and benefits of a
certain program.
Con…
• To make judgments and make best decisions about the
program and able to justify these decisions to anyone seeking
information.
• Different writers defined
• According to Coul (1984) `` Research is the application of
scientific method in the study of problems.
• `` For Kerlinger (1973) `` Research is systematically controlled
scientific method of testing hypothesis which focuses on the
relationship of phenomena.``
Con…
• Jacobs and Razayieh (1990) the application of scientific approach to
the study of problems for determining useful and reliable information
and it is designed to find solution to meaning full researchable
questions through the application of scientific procedures.
Generally research follows scientific approach in order to solve the
problems in systematic and controlled manner.
• Research is generally considered as a systematic inquiry involving a
series of interdependent and systematic steps.
• Educational Research is the systematic application of scientific method
for solving for solving educational problem.
• Research is simply a process of arriving at dependable solutions
to problems through the planned and systematic collection,
analysis, and interpretation of data.
• Research is a more systematic activity that is directed toward
discovery and development of an organized body of
knowledge.
• It does not include the routine activities of applying what is
already known but is reserved for activities designed to
discover facts and relationships that will make the educational
process more effective.
• Research is oriented towards the discovery of the relationships
that exist among the phenomena of the world in which we live.
Sources of Acquiring Knowledge
Knowledge: is a body of truth of information, facts,
principles & laws gained by humankind about phenomena.
Faith/Belife/
common sense,
Logic/reason/
tradition
experience
the scientific method.
Scientific Approach
Schools are complex social environment with different groups of people coming
from different background experiences and with varieties of needs and interests.
In addition to this complex nature, schools are also parts of dynamic, ever
changing environment of the world that demand updating, and improving of the
school working system in general and the classroom instruction in particular.
Complexities and challenges of classroom situations are solved through action
research endeavours.
Con…
Educational research provides a vast landscape of knowledge on
topics related to teaching and learning, curriculum and assessment,
students’ cognitive and affective needs, cultural and socio-economic
factors of schools, and many other factors considered viable to
improving schools.
Major Characteristics of Educational Research:
• It is highly purposeful.
• It is precise, objective, scientific and systematic process of
investigation.
• It attempts to organize data quantitatively and qualitatively to
arrive at statistical inferences.
• It discovers new facts in new perspective.
• Is directed towards the solution of educational problems.
Con…
• Involves gathering of new data from primary of secondary
sources using existing data for a new purpose.
• Is based upon observable experiences or empirical evidence.
It demands accurate observation and description.
• Generally employs carefully designed procedures and
rigorous analysis
• It depends on the researchers ability, ingenuity and
experience for its interpretation and conclusions.
• Emphasizes the development of generalizations, principles
or theories that will help in understanding, prediction and
control of educational variables
Classification of Research in Education
1.Classification by Methods
A. Historical Research
Historical research has been defined as the systematic and objective
location, evaluation and synthesis of evidence in order to establish facts
and draw conclusions about past events.
The common methodological characteristics include
(i) identifying a research topic that addresses past events,
(ii) review of primary and secondary data,
Con…
• (iii) systematic collection and objective evaluation of data
related to past occurrences with the help of techniques of
criticism for historical searches and evaluation of the
information and
• (iv) synthesis and explanation of findings in order to test
hypotheses concerning causes, effects or trends of these
events that may help to explain present events and anticipate
future events.
The Purpose of Historical
Research
Conducting historical research in education can serve several purposes as
follows:
1. It enables educationists to find out solutions to contemporary problems
which have their roots in the past. i.e. it serves the purpose of bringing
about reforms in education.
2. It throws light on present trends and can help in predicting future
trends. If we understand how an educationist or a group of educationists
acted in the past, we can predict how they will act in future.
3. It emphasizes and analyzes the relative importance and the effect of the
various interactions in the prevailing cultures.
4. It enables us to understand how and why educational theories and
practices developed.
B.Descriptive Research
process of research?
At any time the researcher ends up his/her investigation in a certain logical step
that enables readers suggest what the next step would be. Dissatisfaction with
research findings lasts the researchers to plan another so as to fill the gap in the
problem area. Thus it is possible to design a research problem from one’s reading
of research works (literatures)
The research problems driven from literature are recommended to investigation
for over all generalization. But problems for action research are prompt in a sense
that they are set for searching a solution for an immediate problem. Thus,
literature is not convent source of action research problem.
II. Reconnaissance /scouting
/investigation/
• Here the researchers are expected to describe, explain and analyze the nature,
characteristics and causes of the problem. The researchers must formulate the
procedures of the research process and the possible solutions that they think
are best to alleviate the problem. Say for example if the research problem is ``
How can improve classroom participation of students? ``
Con…
• Before going deep in a researching process, one has to specify the problem and the area the problem
• Population is a group of people, objects or events that have common characteristics with regard to what
is going to be researched.
• Example can be all colleges of teacher education in Hawassa town, all female students of Hawassa Tabor
Senior Secondary School or all mathematics teachers of primary schools in Hawassa town.Now, assume
that you want to conduct research on classroom management problems in mathematics classes of
primary schools. Can you contact all mathematics teachers mentioned above to collect data for your
study? This seems practically impossible and therefore you have to try to go a sample population.
Con…
Usually three steps are involved in the process of selecting samples for a study. They are
called the universe, to be studied or where the study is conducted. The population
B. Determining the sample frame. The complete list of the members is known as
They are:
Availability of informants:- Some cases are easy to locate but others are not.
Financial constraints:-The cost of conducting study limits the number of subject to
be contacted
Importance of result:- Willingness to tolerate large margin of error for example in an
exploratory research
Accuracy needed-the higher the sample size the higher the will be the confidence
The nature of population;-Homogeneous populations need small sized sample
compared to heterogeneous population.
Sampling Techniques
• Considering the above determinant factors, researchers make decisions on the
method of sampling and size of sample.
Con…
Decision, on the method takes one of the two types:
A. probability sampling and
B. non-probability sampling.
Probability sampling
A type of sampling where every member of population has equal chance to be included in the sample.
Has many methods of selection of individuals for the sample in probability sampling. These are:
A) Simple Random sampling:-
Individuals are drawn from the defined population randomly.
The chance of selection is independent of selection of other member.
• Suppose there is an assignment given to a group of 10 students & finally to be presented by two student at the end of a
week.
If You choose two student from member to present it is not random sampling but
write the names of the 10 student roll them and take a draw out for two students turn by turn this is what is called random
sampling; there is no any external bias.
Steps to be followed in suing simple random sampling
have all the names of population members written on tickets
determine the size of sample
Roll that tickets on which names are written, mix the tickets.
2) Systematic Sampling
This is a technique of sampling which is a little bit systematic. The following steps are followed to
apply the technique of systematic sampling.
1.Get the complete list of population members, i.e., their names or type of identification
ordered in some way, say in alphabetical order. Represent this with N (size of the population).
2.Determine the number of members to be included in the sample.
This is represented by n (size of the sample).
3.Determine the sampling fraction by dividing N by n, that is, divide the total population to the
required sample size. Let us represent this fraction by k. Then Hence every kth individual in
the name list will be selected.
Thus, in systematic sampling only the first unit is selected randomly and the remaining
individuals of the sample are selected at fixed intervals.
Exercise
Show the steps you followed, to samples selected for the following given data.
• Given- Number of population 24 Needed sample size – 8
3. Stratified Sampling
Stratified Sampling:- is a technique of sampling applied when the nature of population (when there are different
subordinations in the population.
For example: If the problem being studied is regarding the academic difference (fast learner average & slow learner) of
students of a given school the researcher may consider this difference and applies the technique of stratified sampling. He
may proportionally select individuals for the three different categories of fast learners, show learners, & average students.
Steps to be followed
1. Count members from each stratum (category)
Fast learners – 10 Average -230 Slow learners 60 N = 300
2. Determine the proportion n/N. Let the sample size n is 60. The
Proportion will be 60/300== 1/5==0.2
3. Multiply the quantity of each stratum by the proportion
The resulting contribution of each .stratum to the sample will be:
Fast learners = 2 Average learners = 46 Slow learners = 12
Now, the question is which 2 students out of 10, which 46 students out, of
230, and which 12 students out of 60 are going to the included in the
sample? To determine this researcher is expected to again apply the simple
random' or the systematic random sampling" technique to each stratum.
4. Cluster sampling:
This technique is applied when it is suitable to group population in to different
clusters due to their natural geographic occurrence or the greater number of the
members. For example, it is possible to cluster students by grade levels FROM 1 to
8. A person who wants to study the study /working habit of students can:
First define cluster in terms of grade levels 1st, 2nd, 3rd,... ,8th
Then randomly select one cluster for example 5th grade
If members in the selected cluster are not manageable in size the researcher may
further apply the simpler and or systematic sampling technique.
B. The Non Probability Sampling
There for non probability sampling technique is less strict and makes no 'claim for
representativeness. It is up to the researcher to decide on the sample units to be
chosen for the study. There are four types of non-probability sampling procedures.
The procedures do not use rules of probability theory and do not indicate
representatives, and are used for exploration and qualitative studies. Each type of
1) Accidental Sampling
When this sampling method is used, all units for the study that a researcher
accidentally (incidentally) come into contact with a certain period of time are given
attention.
Example: Standing at a certain corner, a researcher interviews a
certain number of respondents passing by, between, say 9:30-11:30 on
Wednesday and Friday, or A medical Doctor when used his or her out patients who
came to the hospital on Monday morning, or A teacher using his or her student
who came to the school on Saturday morning, etc are good examples of accidental
sampling.
2) Purposive Sampling.
• In this sampling procedure the researcher aims at selecting subjects who in his
or her opinion is thought to be relevant to the study. It is more of judgmental in
making decisions with regard to the sample.
Example: To conduct a study on the relevance of health education to be taught as
an independent or integrated subject, the researcher purposefully selects
• Science teachers
• Home-economics teachers
• Members of Red Cross and anti-aids clubs, and.
3) Quota Sampling
: In this _technique, the researcher sets a "quota" of subjects to be selected form
specific population groups by defining the basis of choice (e.g. gender, martial
status education, etc) and determining its size, That is, choosing sample units
according to their proportion in the target population. It is a non-random
Proportional stratified sampling procedure.
Example: Suppose a school teacher may attempt to study "the effect of gender on
language acquisition and its product" .
• Let the number .of female and male pupils in the school is 400and
680,'espectively.
• Let 10% from each group is included in the study (i.e 40 and 68 for the
respective groups)
• The total sample numbers 108.
• In the selection process the subjects do not have equal chance of being selected.
4) Snowball Sampling:
• In this type of sampling, the researcher begins the study
with the few subjects who are available to him/her.
• He/she subsequently asks these subjects recommend
any other persons who meet the criteria of the research
and who might will to participate in study. This process
continues until the sample is saturated.
2.7. Data Collection Methods
The investigation has been carried out to provide evidence which will answer the
research question and therefore explain why the change have or have not achieved
the postulated improvement in the teaching learning situation.
• There are no formal or universal rules for which a researcher may follow in
organizing the data in various units, patterns, or categories.
• However, data collected by means of questionnaire interviews, diaries or any
other method mean very little until they are analyzed and evaluated.
• Hence, raw data taken from various sources need to be recorded,
analyzed and interpreted.
• Analysis means to break something down into its component parts so
that it can be understood. In action research, data are analyzed and
organized in to categories so that others might come to understand the
reality you are trying to represent.
• For this, the researcher is constantly looking for similarities and
differences, for groupings, patterns and items of particular significance.
• In this regard, the following are key words or constructs to consider;
• Themes - i.e. the consistent idea which emerged;
• Incidence i.e. now often something occurred or that the number of questionnaire replies
which said the same thing.
• Patterns i.e. the liming of the occurrences whether they are in single or in cluster;
• Trends i.e. the frequency of the patterns.
• It is only by comparing the data which emerged over several episodes that these can be
identified and tallied and as a result the explanations and claims be justified.
• What instruments were used: questionnaire, interview, observation checklist, document
analysis, field notes, focus group discussion, tests, etc?
• What was the nature of instruments used?
• What was the number of items/questions included in the questionnaire? By whom they
were produced; by the researcher or adapted from other authors should be discussed.
Data Collection Procedures
• The time and place of the data collected
• By whom were they collected; by the researcher or by assistants?
• Were the subjects instructed how to provide the data?
2.8. Data Collecting Instruments
Data collecting instruments are tools that are used to collect information related to
your study problem any researcher is required to collect data or information in order
to reach to feasible findings. The information he or she collected will enable him to
understand current situation of his study problem
1) QUESTIONNAIRES
• Self report data collection instrument filled out by research participants is known as
a questionnaires Researchers can get information about the thoughts, feelings
attitudes, beliefs, Values, perceptions, personality and behavioral intentions of
research participants.
• Advantage of Questionnaire
• Simple to administer
• Easy and to complete
• Provide opportunity to direct response
• Provide wide coverage of data
Disadvantages
• Give chance for probing
• Response may not be truthful
• give no room to motivate the respondents
• Time consuming to prepare good ideas
• cannot be used effectively with children
2) OBSERVATION
• A description of where and when the event occurred and the people
concerned
• Enough back ground information to give the context of the event
• An account of the event (it should be written in a narrative form,
important statements, answers, questions made by the main
participants should be quoted exactly in order to retain authenticity and
immediacy of the situation.
• Field Notes:-Are the written observing of what you see taking place in
your classroom. Field notes help you notice details you might not other
wise have noticed. And as you make many observations over time,
3) INTERVIEW
The interview is in a sense a questionnaire.
Instead of writing the response, the subject or interviewee
gives the needed information orally and face - to fact (or via
the telephone).
Interview can be used in both quantitative and qualitative
research.
With a skillful interview, the interview is often superior to
other data gathering tools. One reason is that people are
usually more willing to talk than to write.
Advantages of Interview
• Interviewer can explain more explicitly the investigation is purpose and what information
he/she wants,
• Misinterpretations of the interviewee, immediately avoided with clarifying questions.
• Truth fullness of information's could be checked in various ways. During interview session.
• Exploration of significant areas not anticipated in the original plan of investigation is
possible.
• People are usually more willing to talk than to write.
Disadvantage of Interview
1) It is a very expensive method
2) There is the possibility of the bias of interviewer as well as that of the respondents
3) Certain types respond such as important officials or executives or people in high income
groups may not be easily approachable.
4) This method is relatively more time consuming
5) The presence of the respondent, responding false information to please the interviewer.
Types of Interview Questions
The aim of an interview is to learn from one or more people what you do
I. Structured Interview:- is one in which the procedure to be followed is
standardized and is determine in advance of interview.
•It involves the use of a set of predetermined questions and of highly standardized
recording techniques. In other words, in this method of data collection, the same
type questions are presented in the same order to each interviewee, and wording of
instructions to the interviewees is specified.
•.
II. Unstructured Interview:-
•is characterized by a flexibility of approach to questioning. Although the series
of questions to be asked and the procedure to be followed are decided up on
beforehand, the interviewer is largely free to arrange the form, order and timing
of the questions. He can thus rephrase the questions, modify them, and add some
new questions to his /her list. Some writers label unstructured interview as
unfocused "in-depth and non- directive.
Unstructured interview is found to be very important technique of data
collection in case of exploratory research studies.
• not yet knew, but consider being important
4. DIARIES
The Mean
Find the mean of 5, 8, 9, and 2.
The Median
3 5 7 8 15
4 5 7 8 14 15
Find the mode and range.
5 7 8 9 9 9 10 11 11 12
2) Inferential l statistics
Objectives
• After successful completion of this unit, you are expected to:
• be familiar with the techniques of writing action research proposal
• Develop appropriate research tools for action research proposal
• Identify researchable problems
• Devise a research proposal
• Conduct an action research project
3.1. Components of Action
research
Identifying proposal
the Research Problem
• Selecting a topic for investigation is more difficult than it seems at first, however,
you may be given a topic to research, in which case the decision is always taken
for you, but in most cases you will be asked to select a topic from a list or to
decide on a topic yourself.
• Since action research emanates from reflection and analysis of current practice,
the researcher focuses on a "problem "which needs to be explained. This may
mean Re-examining established ways of teaching or class room procedures, or if
there is a gap in present practice, trying something for the first time.
• Anyway, the topic should be a particular area of interest that you would like to
explore.
• Consult the librarian or try to get what has been written on similar topics and
talk to your colleagues and fellow students.
1. Background of the study
• This part may not be included in some action research project, if the
action research is small scale
• Assesses the background of the problem
• World context, if any
• Country context, if any
• The specific context, mandatory
2. Objective of the study
• After formulating the research question, the critical question becomes the
issue of "what action(s) can stake together evidence to answer the
research question.
• That means when you have decided on a topic refined it and specified
objectives, you will be in a position to consider how to collect the evidence
you require.
• 'What do I need to know and why? 'Only there you ask, 'What is the best
way to collect information? 'When I have this information, what shall I do
with it There, decisions have to be made about which methods are best
for particular purposes and then data collecting instruments must be
designed to do the job.
• Action research needs to be planned in the same systematic way as
any type of research, and the methods selected for gathering
information will depend on the nature of the information required.
• Whatever procedures for collecting data is selected, it should always
be examined initially to assess to what extent it is likely to be reliable
and valid
Reliability:
Phase 4: completion
Writing the research report
Editing and proof reading
Submitting the first draft Resubmitting the final draft
9.COST BREAKDOWN
1 Stationery materials .
2 Transportation
3 Per diem
4 Secretary
5 Compiling
7 Total
Unit Four
Writing Action Research Report
A research report is the only concrete evidence of your research, and the
quality of the research may be judged directly by the quality of the writing and
how well you convey the importance of your findings.
Fortunately, action research reports, which are similar to research articles,
technical reports, lab reports, formal reports, or scientific papers (to name a
few), have a fairly consistent format that will help you to organize your
information clearly.
Contents to be included in an action research report.
1. Preliminary Parts
I. Title Page /Inner Page/
• It is important to take your audience into account when developing a
title for your action research report.
• It is a good idea to develop a "working title" for your project as you
draft your report initially, but be open to change your title after you
have finished writing to accurately reflect your project.
The title page of the research report normally contains five main pieces
of information:
the report title,
the name of the researcher,
the institution to which the research report to be submitted
the date of submission
the place of submission (city or town)
II. Acknowledgements
• Acknowledgement is a research report section where you express your
gratitude to those individuals who assisted you in the process of your
investigation. Acknowledgements must be simple and restricted to those
who had significant contribution in the course of the study.
Activities
• Whom do we acknowledge in a research report?
• Is it always necessary to acknowledge somebody?
• Why do we acknowledge people?
III. Table of Contents
• Most reports will contain a Table of Contents that lists the report's
contents and demonstrates how the report has been organized. You
should list each major section in your Table of Contents.
• Sometimes you may want to use additional descriptive headings
throughout your report and for your Table of Contents.
• IV. Abstract
• An abstract is an accurate representation of the contents of a
document in an abbreviated form. An abstract can be the most
difficult part of the research report to write because in it you must
introduce your subject matter, tell what was done, and present
selected results, all in one short paragraph.
2. Main Body
Part I
I. Background of the study
• This part may not be included in some action research project, if the
action research is small scale
• Assesses the background of the problem
• World context, if any
• Country context, if any
• The specific context, mandatory
• The rationale for conducting the study
• The magnitude (how wide spread and important) of the problem
• Leading research question and/or hypothesis
II. Objective of the Study
• What is going to be done in the course of the study?
• What are the tasks of the researcher as the study in progress?
III. Significance of the study
• The why of the study, what is/are the relevance(s) or importance(s) of studying
that problem?
• To whom is the study significant: forteachers, students, curriculum designers,
parents or what? How?
IV. Definitions of Important terms (concepts)
• Operational definitions may be appeared by the researcher him/herself; not
necessarily dictionary or encyclopedia definitions
Part II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
• Discussing the theoretical background of the study and related
research works.
• Note that: in some action research style review literature may not be
included. So you should not worry if you don't have the review
literature section.
Activities What is the purpose of review of related literature in
research? Discuss
Part III
Data Collection and Analysis
I. Defining population and Determine sample Size
Target population and sample of the study
• Who are the subjects of the study?
• What is their total number?
• How many individuals are going to be included in the study?
• How are the samples going to be selected? Randomly or purposely?
II. Data Collection Methods
• What instruments were used: questionnaire, interview, observation checklist, document analysis,
field notes, focus group discussion, tests, etc?
What was the nature of instruments used?
• What was the number of items/questions included in the questionnaire? By whom they were
produced; by the researcher or adapted from other authors should be discussed.
III. Data Collection Procedures
• The time and place of the data collected
• By whom were they collected; by the researcher or by assistants?
• Were the subjects instructed how to provide the data?
IV. Data Analysis Techniques
• If the data were qualitative, present in narrative manner
• If the data were quantitative use different statistical techniques:
mean, standard deviation, correlation coefficient, t-test, ANOV A,
regression analysis, etc.
Analyze Data
• Indicate systematically the major findings of the study against the leading
research question and/or hypotheses
• Use statistical techniques mentioned in the design part appropriately
• Present the data systematically and analysis thoroughly and relate the
results with those literature mentioned in the literature review part.
• If tables and figures are used, do they have numbers and titles that
clearly explain the contents of the tables and figures?
Part IV
Discussions
I. Proposed Action /Strategy/ Used
On the basis of the data analyzed,
• on the bases of your finding ,indicate what actions were taken to alleviate the problem
under study
II. Implemented Action
• On the basis of the proposed action, briefly describe your implementation of the
proposed actions. What did you implemented should be narrated.
III. Evaluated Action
• Based on the action taken, indicate whether you found what you planned. evaluate the
extent action taken brought the desired result
IV. Conclusions and Recommendations
• On the basis of the evaluation, list possible solutions for the problem(s) encountered.
• Questionnaires, formulas, interview questions, or any other materials should be
Generally, an action research report will include the
following sections:
• Title page/cover page/
• Inner Page
• Acknowledgements
• Abstract
• Table of contents
• Statement of the problem
• Basic questions /hypothesis
• Purpose of the study
• Significance of the study
• Definition of technical terms
• Review of related literature
• Methodology Analysis and Discussion
• Findings/results Summary and conclusion
• Recommendations
• List of References
3. End Parts