Managerial Decision Making Modified 8 Aug 2018
Managerial Decision Making Modified 8 Aug 2018
Decision Making
Authority
Authority
Research
Research &
&
Analysis
Analysis
Experiments
Experiments
2. Determine Workable
Solutions
2. Determine Workable
Solutions
Advantages
3. Identify Key Disadvantages
Uncertainties Uncertainties
Risks
Timing
4. Gather Data
2. Determine Workable
6. Choose a Solution
Solutions
2. Determine Workable
6. Choose a Solution
Solutions
3. Identify Key
7. Take Action
Uncertainties
8. Follow-up
4. Gather Data
On Decision
Feelings Facts
logic
Cause/ effect
Thinking Feeling feelings
values
Weigh practicality of each Determine “fit” with personal and/or
alternative organizational values
Examine consequences of Assess effects on self and relationships
actions Determine how to win self and others to
Weigh gains /losses solution
Decide on course of actions.
Act on it.
Evaluate the process.
1/9
9 9/9
Good Neighbor
8 Eye-to-Eye Decision
Concern for Commitment
2- Is team commitment
Y N Y N
important to the decision?
A1
3- Do you have enough
information to make the Y N Y N
decision on your own? A1
4- Is the problem Y N Y N
well-structured? C2
5- If you made the decision yourself, Y N Y N Y N Y N
would the team support it ? A2
C2 A1 G2
6- Does the team share Y N Y N Y N Y N Y N
organizational goals? C2 G2 C2 A2
G2 C2 A2
7- Is conflict amongst the team
Y N Y N Y N
over the decision likely?
C1 A2 G2 C2 C1 A2
39 Managerial Decision Making
Exercise
(Factory)
?
what we spent?
Is this the
right time? How much
will we make?
Are we better off
doing nothing?
Is it worth spending “X”
What are the risks? amount of money for
Short term? the expected returns?
Long term?
What else can we do
Is this project a with money we
sure thing? intend to spend?
42 Managerial Decision Making
Break-even
analysis
This technique is used to determine how many units of
the product or service must be sold,
and at what price for the producer or service provider to
at least break-even.
The Formula:
(FC)
BEP (units) = ---------------
(SP) – (VC)
FC =Total Fixed Costs
SP = Selling Price Per Unit
VC =Variable Cost Per Unit
• Suppose a 1 3 2.73
business makes 2 4 3.31
an estimate of 3 5 3.76
the amount of
4 3 2.05
money it would
receive as the 5 2 1.24
result of an T= 17 T= 13.09
investment.
High LowDemand
Low Demand
HighDemand
Demand
Low
LowDemand
Demand HighDemand
High Demand
Build a Build a
small plant large plant
How much will demand increase.
This is an area of uncertainty.
Action There is some chance the increase
in demand could be high and
some chance it could be low.
55 Managerial Decision Making
DECISION TREE
Example:
• You are a restaurant owner and are trying to decide which of
the following two properties to lease:
– Property A allows seating of 100 customers per meal and costs 1800
L.E. per month to lease.
– Property B seats 150 and leases at 2700 L.E. per month.
• The estimates for three levels of seating are: high (150 people),
medium (100 people), and low (75 people).
• Estimate the relative probabilities for the three levels.
• Also, assume that each seat will generate revenues of 10 L.E.
per night above all other costs.
MANAGEMENT Responsibility for Performance,
Peter Hess and Julie Siciliano, Copyright 1996.
56 Managerial Decision Making
DECISION TREE
Action Decision Estimat Probability Consequences
e
H 150 0 % 30x10x150x0.00= 00.00
Property
M 100 70 % 30x10x100x0.70=21000
A
L 75 30 % 30x10x 75x0.30= 6750
--------
TR 27750
Action Less leas- 1800
--------
NR 25950
Property H 150 20 % 30x10x150x0.20= 9000
B M 100 50 % 30x10x100x0.50= 15000
L 75 30 %30x10x 75x0.30= 6750
--------
TR 30750
Less leas - 2700
--------
NR 28050
Enjoyment 5 30 0.08
Sum 360 1.0
61 Managerial Decision Making
Ranking &Weights Method
STEP (5): Swing Weights
Flexibility of work
(0.28) 60 = 16.8 (0.28) 0 = 0 (0.28) 100 = 28
schedule
Business skill
(0.14) 0 = 0 (0.14) 100 = 14 (0.14) 80 = 11.2
development
Annual Vacation
(0.06) 100 = 6 (0.06) 50 = 3 (0.06) 0 = 0
days
Weight of Alternatives
Objectives Car A Car B Car C Car D
Price 2 1 4 2
Capacity
(C.C.) 1 4 2 2
Air
2 2 1 2
Condition
Facilities 2 4 1 2
Kilometers 2 1 4 3
Model 1 2 3 4
Swap
Objectives Car A Car B Car C
Price 35000 30000 40000
35700 31000 40000
Capacity
(C.C.)
Air
Condition
Radio ----- All
Facilities
All All All
Kilometers
Model
Swap
Objectives Car A Car B Car C
Price 35700 31000 40000
38000 33000 40000
Capacity
(C.C.)
Air N.A. N.A. Available
Condition Available Available Available
Kilometers
Model
Swap
Decision
Decision Transaction
Transaction
Support
Support Processing
Processing
System
System System
System
(DSS)
Automatically:
(DSS) (TPS)
For tasks that involve a large number of
(TPS)
Searches, highly similar transactions such as:
Analyzes, Tracking customer orders,
Summarizes, and Developing,
Reports Information Storing,
Needed sending invoices, and
Tracking employee work day
73 Managerial Decision Making
Things to Remember in
Decision Making
Have your goals clearly in mind or in written
form before you proceed to formulate your
options
Establish your priorities so that every decision
contributes towards goal achievement
Be as creative as possible. Look for groups of
ideas or seemingly illogical ideas
74 Managerial Decision Making
Things to Remember in
Decision Making
Each decision has the potential of causing a chain of
reactions. Consider the decision in light of the following:
What can go wrong with this decision?
How serious would each of the situations be?
Can the decision be modified to lessen the
possible impact of any errors?
What is the estimated expenditure to minimizing
the possible mistakes?
How long should the proposed decision remain in
effect?