Complicated Grief Presentation
Complicated Grief Presentation
D AND
TRAUMATIC
GRIEF
B R I T T A N Y S T O N E M T- B C , M M , N M T, N I C U -
MT
DEFINITION OF FOCUS:
• Bereavement: the state of having lost through death someone
whom one has had a close relationship. This state includes a
range of grief and morning responses. (DSM-5 2013 818)
– Recognize that it doesn’t say “loving” relationships
HOW DO YOU DEFINE
NOMRAL GRIEF?
• Researchers have tried to define normal/abnormal grief.
– Normal is complicated by diversity in contemporary American culture
– Key element: Specific symptoms & levels of human distress that are
“life-limiting.”
“Yes grief hurts, but when the pain is so severe that it is interfering with a
person’s ability to cope and to heal on their own, we can intervene and
relieve that unnecessary pain and suffering related to traumatic grief. It’s
really a question of knowing when to introduce any professionals, even
grief counselors, during the grief process.”
Shelby Jacobs, The Grief and Healing Newsletter
• Principle One: There is no one right way to grieve.
• Principle Two: You cannot fix or cure grief.
• Principle Three: There is no universal timetable for the grief
journey.
• Principle Four: Every loss is a multiple loss.
– Other losses can be false beliefs we held.
OF GRIEF • Principle Six: We grieve old loss while grieving new loss.
• Principle Seven: We grieve when a loss has occurred or is
BY SHEP threatened.
JEFFRIES
“The human grief reaction is a combination of
thoughts, physical and emotional feelings, and behaviors that
enable us
to survive. It is, therefore, a normal way of reacting whenever we
have
already lost or are afraid we will lose someone or
something important to us.”
Shep Jeffreys (2011) 43
“GRIEF is not an illness to be
treated or cured. It is a healthy response to a
painful reality that one’s world is forever altered,
and will never be the same. Absorbing this loss,
and adapting to all the changes it unleashes, has
its own unique course for every person, and will
not be stilled or stopped by quick fixes or simple
solutions. Death is a life-altering event, but
grief
is not a pathological condition.”
Attig, et. all (2013)
THE DUAL HYPOTHESIS OF LOSS
STROEBE & SCHUT 2001
Restoratio
Loss
n
Orientatio
Orientatio
n
n
ELEMENTS OF AN INTEGRATED GREIF
NIEMEYER, 2013
That most bereaved persons will meet full DSM-5 criteria That some depressed and bereaved patients will heal
for MDD. and recover with "tincture of time."
That we should be starting everyone with bereavement- That anguish and pain are usually experienced in
related MDD on antidepressants! "waves" or "pangs“ rather than continuously as in
MDD.
That grievers typically maintain hope that things will
get better while the clinically depressed patient’s
mood is almost uniformly one of gloom, despair, and
hopelessness -- nearly all day, nearly every day.
That bereaved individuals usually maintain a strong
emotional connection with friends and family and often
can be consoled by them.
That the person suffering a severe MDD is usually too
self-focused and emotionally "cut off" to enjoy the
company/support of others.
That some will benefit from cognitive, supportive, or
grief-oriented psychotherapies.
Suddenness Violence
THE THERESE RANDO SIX
“R” MODEL FOR HEALTHY
ACCOMMODATION:
1. RECOGNIZE the loss(es)
a. Primary. . . Secondary
b. Immediate. . . consequential. . Developmental
2. REACT to the separation
a. Re-experiencing the deceased(s)
b. Sensory intrusions
c. Flashbacks
d. Intense emotions
e. Somatic complaints
f. Nightmares & disturbed sleep patterns
g. Re-activated older ( negative) memories
h. Compulsive re-exposure
i. Avoidance: places, family, people, activities, routines, music, food/eating, etc.
j. Hyper- Arousal: inability to modulate arousal, heightened startle response,
restlessness, hyper-vigilant, sleep difficulties, difficulty concentrating, regression.
k. Cognitive Reorganization : The way the griever explain the world.
3. RECOLLECT & RE-EXPERIENCE the deceased and the relationship
– Hesped: a “balanced” eulogy [Brenner 1993]
– The iceberg factor [Ben Wolfe]
– “Sanctification of the dead” [Lopata 1981]
– Re-scripting the relational narrative
– Polishing “the glittering image” [Susan Howatch]
RESOURCE: A Living Hesped
Positive Negative
A ____________________ _______________________
B ____________________ _______________________
C ____________________ _______________________
D ____________________ _______________________
E ____________________ _______________________
F ____________________ _______________________
4. RELINQUISH old attachments to the deceased & old assumptive world.
– “The “rear view mirror” analogy
5. READJUST to move adaptively into the new world without forgetting the old.
– Building a different kind of relationship with & mourning social orbits.
“While we can’t live in the past, we can’t act as if we had no past. We are not literally
‘holding on.’ What we are dealing with is reconstructing the relationship” or building a
different kind of relationship with the deceased.” Phyllis Silverman, PhD
6. REINVEST
“Grieving is a journey that teaches us how to love in a new way now that
our loved one is no longer with us. Consciously remember those who have
died is the key that opens our hearts,
that allows us to love them in new ways.”
Tom Attig, The Heart of Grief
“You think the dead we loved ever truly leave us? You think that we don't
recall them more clearly than ever in times of great trouble?
Your father is alive in you, Harry, and shows himself plainly
when you have need of him.”
TREATMENT STRATEGIES FOR
TRAUMATIC LOSS
1. Re-telling strategies
a. Restorative narratives
For six years I’ve pushed [my parents] and their death to the fringes of my
heart. That’s all I could tolerate, my focus was on our boys and Steve.
How hideous, that there should be a pecking order in my grief.”
Sonali Deraniyagala (2013) 162
b. Borrowed Narratives
“If I talk long enough, you will say, ‘Oh, that is my history too.”
Maya Angelou (2011 February 1)
“ “There is nothing particularly interesting about one’s own story unless
people can say as they read it, ‘Why, this is like what I have been through.
Perhaps, after all, there is a way to work it out.”
Eleanor Roosevelt (1984) xix
– Ask griever to identify an historical
personage from whom to draw insight and
possibility. “How would [this individual]
2. TAPPING react in your situation?”
INTO “PEOPLE – “How might [this individual] counsel you?”
POTENTIAL” – “What might [this individual] say to you
(W IL LY N W E B B 1 99 9 ) that you would find helpful and
– hopeful?”
– “What would you like to ask [this
individual] about grief?”
3. EFFECTIVE USE OF SELF-DISCLOSURE
A Dozen + 1 Gratitudes
Today/tonight I am grateful for _________________
Today/tonight I am grateful for _________________
c. Making Memoir
“Writing memoir is a way to figure out who you used to be and
how you go to be who you are.” Abigail Thomas, Thinking About Memoir