Research Methods in Education Refined - Copy
Research Methods in Education Refined - Copy
Chapter One:
The Nature of Research
1.1. Meanings of research and its
importance
1.1. sources / Approaches to Knowledge
The sources /approaches to knowledge commonly known as:
Intuition/common sense: Just I know it. It is the act or process
of coming to direct conclusions without reasoning or inferring.
Culture /tradition : Eg. Fairytale, Gada system leadership philosophy.
Authority: the word of experts. It is an approach to acquiring
knowledge represents an acceptance of information or facts stated
by another because that person is a highly respected source.
Eg. Plato, aristotile, preist or sheik
Reason/ logic (Rationalism): the intellect can capture truth and
knowledge directly. This approach uses reasoning to arrive at
knowledge and assumes that valid knowledge is acquired if the
correct reasoning is used.
Reasoning can be: Deductive and inductive reasoning.
Experience (Empiricism): personal testing and experience through what
we see, hear, taste, smell, and touch.
• Therefore, facts that occur with experience are accepted, and those
are not tested through experience are rejected. Eg. Aklilu Lema
Revelation: Knowledge from super-power. Eg. Prophet
Some basic concepts to be known in research:
Science:
the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic
study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world
through observation and experiment.
is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the
form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe.
a systematically organized body of knowledge on a particular subject.
Body of knowledge comprising of measurable or verifiable facts
acquired through application of the scientific method.
Con…
Theory:
a coherent tested general propositions, commonly regarded as
correct, that can be used as principles of explanation and
prediction.
a set of principles on which the practice of an activity is based.
Eg. Paithagoras theorem.
a supposition or a system of ideas intended to explain something.
a set of inter-related constructs and propositions that specify
relations among variables to explain and predict phenomena.
belief or assumption about how things relate to each other – often
used for cause and effect statements.
provide order to facts and a framework of generalization.
should be simple, consistent with observed relationships, tentative
and verifiable.
Con…
Theory:
hypothesis and
Testing of the hypothesis by making
observations (collecting data).
What is research?
A systematic search for information and new knowledge.
A systematic process of collecting and logically analyzing
information (data).
Any honest attempt to study a problem systematically to add
to man’s knowledge of a problem.
An inquiry into the nature, the reasons, and the consequences
of any particular set of circumstances, whether these
circumstances are experimentally controlled or recorded just
as they occur.
Research is a scientific inquiry aimed at learning new facts,
testing ideas, solving problems, etc.
Con..
Research is a process of steps used to
collect and analyze information to increase
our understanding of a topic or issue.
It is a finding of answers to questions in an organized,
logical and systematic fashion.
At a general level, research consists of three
steps:
1. Pose a question.
2. Collect data to answer the question.
3. Present an answer to the question
( Cresswell,2012).
Con…
Until we have subjected our problem to rigorous
scientific scrutiny, our 'knowledge' remains little more
than guesswork or at best, intuition.
Quality research is the lifeblood of any scientific
discipline.
Without research, disciplines would stagnate and
failing to advance understanding.
(Wann 1997
p.17)
Importance of research
1. Research Adds to Our Knowledge
Adding to knowledge means that educators undertake research to
contribute to existing information about issues.
Researchers are much like bricklayers who build a wall brick by
brick, continually adding to the wall and, in the process, creating a
stronger structure.
Eg: Sir Isac Newton by posing a very elementary question;
i.e. ,” why things fall down; why not they go up as they fall
down?”, he formulated “ the Law of Gravity”. By so doing
he added to our knowledge of gravity in the Universe.
Con…
2. Research Improves Practice
suggests improvements for practice.
Armed with research results, teachers and other educators
become more effective professionals.
This effectiveness translates into better learning for kids.
Offers practicing educators new ideas to consider as they go
about their jobs.
Helps practitioners evaluate approaches that they hope will
work with individuals in educational settings.
Con…
3. Research Informs Policy Debates
Provides information to policy makers when they research and
debate educational topics.
Offers results that can help them weigh various perspectives.
When policy makers read research on issues, they are informed
about current debates and stances taken by other public officials.
To be useful, research needs to have clear results, be
summarized in a concise fashion, and include data-based
evidence.
E.g.: The current Education Road Map
1.2. CHARACTERISTICS OF RESEARCH
It should be researchable and specific:
1. Survey research:
It determines and reports the way things are.
It involves collecting numerical data to test hypotheses
or answer questions about the current status of the
subject of study.
One common type of survey research involves assessing
the preferences, attitudes, practices, concerns, or
interests of a group of people.
Con…
In survey research the investigator selects a
sample of subjects and administers a
questionnaire or conducts interviews to collect
data.
Surveys are used frequently in educational
research to describe attitudes, beliefs, opinions,
and other types of information.
Usually the research is designed so that
information about a large number of people (the
population) can be inferred from the responses
obtained from a smaller group of subjects (the
sample).
Surveys are used for a wide variety of purposes.
Con…
2. Correlational Research
It involves collecting data to determine whether,
and to what degree, a relation exists between two or
more quantifiable variables.
A variable is a placeholder that can assume any
one of a range of values; for example, intelligence,
height, and test score are variables.
At a minimum, correlation research requires
information about at least two variables obtained
from a single group of participants.
The purpose of a correlation study may be to
establish relations or use existing relations to
make predictions.
Its rate of relationship can be between -1 & 1.
Eg. The impact of class size on students academic
achievement.
Con…
3. Causal–Comparative Research
Causal–comparative research attempts to
determine the cause, or reason, for existing
differences in the behavior or status of groups of
individuals.
The cause is an event/reason that influence some
other behavior or characteristic. Cause – is IV.
The change or difference in a behavior or
characteristic that occurs as a result is, the effect
—is known as the DV.
Put simply, causal–comparative research attempts
to establish cause–effect relations among
groups.
Con..
For example, suppose a researcher wanted to
answer an important question concerning the effect
of malnutrition on the cognitive development of
children.
A research who wishes to study such problem cannot
expose children for hunger by depriving food. That is
morally unacceptable. What the researcher can do,
he/she takes children who are from the well-to-do
families where lack of nourishment is not a problem
and other children from poor families who are
already exposed to lack of food.
Then he/she gives the two groups of subjects the
same tests to see whether those who are from the
well to do families differ significantly from children
who lack proper nourishment.
Con…
4. Experimental Research
In experimental research, at least one
independent variable is manipulated, other
relevant variables are controlled, and the effect
on one or more dependent variables is observed.
True experimental research provides the strongest
results of any of the quantitative research
approaches because it provides clear evidence for
linking variables.
As a result, it also offers generalizability, or
applicability of findings to settings and contexts
different from the one in which they were obtained.
Unlike causal–comparative researchers, researchers
conducting an experimental study can control an
independent variable.
Con…
5. Single-Subject Research
Rather than compare the effects of different treatments
(or treatment versus no treatment) on two or more groups
of people, experimental researchers sometimes compare
a single person’s behavior before treatment to behavior
exhibited during the course of the experiment.
They may also study a number of people together as one
group, rather than as individuals.
Single-subject experimental designs are those used to
study the behavior change that an individual or group
exhibits as a result of some intervention or treatment.
Eg. Investigating the attitude of one person on family planning
before offering training and after training about family planning.
In these designs, the size of the sample —the individuals
selected from a population for a study—is said to be one.
Con…
con…
1.Narrative Research
Narrative research is the study of how different humans
experience the world around them;
It involves a methodology that allows people to tell the
stories of their “storied lives.”
The researcher typically focuses on a single person and
gathers data by collecting stories about the person’s life.
The researcher and participant then construct a written
account, known as a narrative, about the individual’s
experiences and the meanings the individual attributes to
the experiences.
Because of the collaborative nature of narrative research,
it is important for the researcher and participant to
establish a trusting and respectful relationship.
Con…
2.Ethnographic Research
Ethnographic research, or ethnography, is the study of the cultural
patterns and perspectives of participants in their natural settings.
Ethnography is an in-depth, analytical description of a
specific cultural situation, in the broad meaning of culture.
Put into the context of education, we can define ethnographic
research as the process of providing scientific descriptions of
educational systems, processes, and phenomena within their
specific contexts. Eg. Indigenous education.
Typically the researcher is at a selected site for a lengthy
period in order to fully understand the subjects and
phenomena being studied.
Eg. Dr. Asmerom’s research on Geda system in
Borena.
The ethnographic researcher avoids making interpretations and
drawing conclusions too early in the study.
Con…
Ethnographic research relies heavily on
observation (both participant and non-
participant), interviews, document and artifact
analysis, description, and qualitative judgments
or interpretations of whatever phenomena are
being studied.
It takes place in the natural setting and focuses
on processes in an attempt to obtain a holistic
picture.
Often, ethnographic research does not have a
strong theoretical base, and few hypotheses are
specified before the research is conducted.
Theory and hypotheses are generated as the
research proceeds.
Con…
Historical True-designs
Cross-Sectional
Meta-Analyses
Longitudinal
Statistical-
Correlational designs
Summary of Unit One
Among the research methods or approaches
which one is the best method ?
Well, “it all depends” on the research to be
conducted.
In short, there is no one best method or
approach; the best depends on the research to
be conducted.
Quiz (10%)
I. Say true or false
1. Qualitative research is expressed in numerical forms.
2. A type of research that tries to uncover subtle, less overt
and personal understandings is quantitative research.
3. Narrative research is qualitative research type that
allows people to tell their stories.
4. The results of the study can be generalizable to other
similar settings in quantitative research.
5. Qualitative research is done to determine relationships,
effects, and causes.
6. There is one best approach or method in conducting
research.
7. __________is a branch of philosophy that study about
knowledge in relation to research.
8. List at least three types of qualitative research.
UNIT TWO:
The Research Problem and
Preparation of the research
Steps in a Research Process
1. Identifying a Research
Problem/Introducing
2. Reviewing the Literature
3. Selecting Design and Methods
4. Collecting Data
5. Presenting, Analyzing and Interpreting
Data
6. Summary, Conclusion, Recommendation
7. Reporting the Research
Identifying a Research Problem
1. Study Title/Research Problem
The Topic
The opening sentences of a “statement of the problem/ introduction
section need to encourage readers to continue reading, to generate
interest in the study, and to provide an initial frame of reference for
understanding the entire research topic.
Given these factors, it makes sense to start with a broad topic that
readers can easily understand.
In this way, you bring readers into a study slowly and encourage
them to read beyond the first page.
An educational topic is the broad subject matter that a researcher
wishes to address in a study and that creates initial interest for the
reader.
Researchers state the topic in the title and introduce it in the first
sentences.
Con..
First sentence -a narrative hook.
It serves the important function of drawing the reader
into a study.
Good narrative hooks have these characteristics:
• cause the reader to pay attention,