Chapter 5
Chapter 5
Teaching
Reading
and Writing
Developed by
Dr. Marine Milad
Introduction
Getting Started
•The purpose of this chapter is to discuss the teaching of
reading and writing to young learners.
•It will present some of the challenges young learners face in
learning to read and write in English and some approaches to
help them to meet the challenge.
•It will also provide suggestions for a number of activities to
motivate very young and young learners to read and write in
English, to assist them while they are reading and writing, and to
encourage them to do more.
Think about
it
• Can you recall a favorite book that you read and re-read when you
were a child?
• Why was it your favorite?
• What was it about?
• Who were the characters?
• Who read it to you?
Now think about what characteristics will guide your choice of books
to include in your young learners' classes.
• Also, think about the kinds of writing you did as a child. Are there
any that were memorable?
• Why do you think you remember them?
• What were you writing about?
• Who were you writing for? Who were you writing to?
Now think about the kinds of writing that you will include for your
very young learners.
• What will be some of the earliest opportunities?
• In contrast, what kinds of writing might you ask your young
learners to do?
• What are some ways to motivate young learners to read and
write?
• Are there ways in which you can integrate reading and writing
activities?
Discovery • List all the types of reading and writing activities that you
can think of that you might use with both very young (5–
activity 7) and young (8–11) learners.
• What makes a reading or writing activity engaging for
Brainstorming young children?
Chart
Theory, Planning and
Application:
Considerations for Teaching
Reading and Writing
• You may think that when you are reading, you are simply getting
meaning from the text, but actually you are also bringing meaning
with you.
• Reading is an interactive process involving the reader, the text, and
the writer.
• When you are writing, you are likely to read (or even re-read) what
you wrote to make sure you are communicating your intended
meaning to your audience (the reader).
• We are discussing reading and mentioning ways in which reading can
lead to writing.
• We are discussing writing and mentioning ways in which these
writings can serve as texts to be read, not only by the students who
wrote them, but also by others
• Listening and reading are both receptive skills, processing what
others have said or written, but doing so in an active way.
• Speaking and writing are both productive skills, where we take what
we know about the world, about texts, and about language
• to express an idea or opinion, to make an observation, to provide
information, to communicate our thoughts or needs, or to create a
poem, a story, or a song.
• Many listening activities can also be reading activities, and many
speaking activities can become writing activities as well.
Theory, Planning and
Application:
First and Second Language
Reading and Writing
• Learning to read and write is complex and difficult enough in a language the
child already knows; doing it in another language is even more difficult.
• But the good news is that when there is sufficient English language
development, many of the child’s skills and strategies used in reading and
writing in the first language will transfer to another language (Cummins,
1979).
• One only has to become “literate” once. Very young learners are probably still
learning to read and write in the home or first language.
• Older young learners have probably already learned to read and write in their
own language, and when their English proficiency is sufficient, they will be
able to transfer those skills into their reading of English.
• All children, whether first- or second-language readers, go through the same
five initial literacy steps:
• 1. Awareness and exploration
• 2. Experimenting with reading and writing
• 3. Early reading and writing
• 4. Transitional reading and writing
• 5. Conventional reading and writing
• (International Reading Association & the National Association for the
Education of Young Children, 1998)
Theory, Planning and Application:
First and Second Language Reading and Writing
• When children learn literacy skills in the first language, they develop several broad areas of
knowledge that they can access in English. These are:
• ■■ Visual knowledge: about print and text direction
• ■■ Phonological knowledge: about sounds represented by symbols (though children
• will usually think of this as the sounds that symbols make)
• ■■ Lexical knowledge: about words and collocations
• ■■ Syntactic knowledge: about meaning construction and making sense of words
• ■■ Semantic knowledge: about social use of language as discourse (Brewster, Ellis, & Girard,
2004)
• They have learned that reading and writing can be used for different purposes, and they have
likely developed a number of strategies for understanding reading and making themselves
understood through writing.
Has the child learned to read and write in her/his own
language?
Is the child just beginning to learn to read in her/his own
language?
Considera
tions for
Developin Is that language written in the Roman alphabet, another
alphabet, or characters?
g Literacy
How does one read and write a text in that language (from left
to right, right to left, top to bottom)?
What skills and strategies has the child developed in making
meaning from and with text?
Considerations for
Developing Literacy
• According to Geva and Wang (2001) in their review of the differences
in learning to read in different languages, English has a “deep”
orthography, one in which it can be difficult to sound out many
words from the way in which they are written or spelled, in contrast
to Spanish or German, which have “shallow” orthography and more
predictability in how a word sounds based on how it is written.
• Note the number of ways that the sound /i/ in English can be
represented in letters: be, bee, sea, ski, skied, receive.
• Just as there are many ways in which a sound is represented in print
(its spelling), there are many ways of pronouncing the same set of
letters.
• Consider the following: read, bread, break where the “ea” is decoded
as three different sounds!
• The following poem gives some idea of the difficulty of decoding
English.
• Note: You can hear this poem, with all its unusual pronunciation,
being read at:
http://international.ouc.bc.ca/pronunciation/poem01.html
Why Include Reading and
Writing in Young Learner
Classes?
• Although reading and writing “are very demanding and take time and patience
to learn,” they “are extremely important for the child’s growing awareness of
language and their own growth in the language” (Scott & Ytreberg, 1990, p. 5).
EYL teachers need to include reading and writing wherever and as early as
possible, for a number of reasons:
• Reading and writing can reinforce what is being learned orally
• Reading expands the sources of input, and writing helps in remembering that
input
• Writing provides a way to consolidate learning from the other skills, and
reading helps students to see the conventions of writing
• Children enjoy reading and writing if the texts are meaningful and related to
their experiences (including using the many resources of the Internet)
• Reading and writing help link the EYL class with home, as children bring home
writing they have done to share with their families or do homework requiring
reading and writing
• Reading and writing can also link the EYL class with other classes in school,
where written language plays an important part
• Writing provides another means of self-expression and, when read by others,
a sense of confidence and pride (Pinter, 2006; Scott & Ytreberg, 1990
Exemplary
teachers
• As Barone and Xu (2008) state, “In all discussions about
exemplary teachers, especially exemplary teachers of
ELLs [English Language Learners], one central discovery is
that they provide language-rich classrooms where
children have opportunities to talk about and write
about their learning” (p. 17).
• Teachers can make their classrooms especially “print-
rich” by labeling objects in the classroom; posting
calendars, maps, or class birthday charts; creating word
walls as new vocabulary is introduced; engaging the
children in drawing and labeling pictures to post in the
room, and as they write more, to produce class books
that can be read by children during independent reading
time (Curtain & Dahlberg, 2010; Pinter, 2006; Collins,
2004).
• For young learners to become effective and engaged
readers and writers, they must have multiple
opportunities to explore, read, and write a variety of
texts and to talk about what they are going to read or
write or what they have read or written.
Considerations for Teaching
Reading
What Is Reading?
• Reading is a process of relating written symbols to oral language, of constructing meaning
from written text (Goodman, 2005), or “making sense and deriving meaning from the
printed word” (Linse, 2005, p. 69).
• When we read, we interact with the text, bringing our knowledge of the world, of language,
and of discourse or specific text types (a fairytale, newspaper article, poem, essay, or report)
to what we read.
• Our understanding increases or lessens depending on our background knowledge,
knowledge of the language, and our experience with discourse and text structure.
• Those experiences and that back- ground information are known as schemata (plural of
schema). One of the reasons for building units around topics, where language and content
are recycled (as discussed in Chapter 3) is that these help students to develop the
background knowledge, the vocabulary, and the structures (the schemata) to make sense of
written texts.
To be able to read, a child has to:
• Understand the alphabet
• Decode
• Develop sight vocabulary to read fluently (with automaticity)
• Develop strategies to help with comprehension and fluency
• Read texts that match her/his reading level and interests
• Engage in extensive reading (independent reading of a variety of texts)
(Adapted from Lenters, 2004/2005, p. 331)
• Listening is an interpretive/receptive skill, like reading.
• Interpreting language is often broken down into two psycholinguistic
processes: bottom-up and top-down.
Bottom-Up • Bottom-up processing When we read, we activate what we know
and Top-Down about language.
• Top-down processing When we read, we activate what we know
Approaches to about making meaning
• When we are reading to children, we usually begin with context and
Teaching meaning, relating what we read to the children’s lives and
knowledge. Top-down
Reading • From there, we may explain particular words, have fun with
pronouncing some of them (for example, with rhymes or animal
sounds), and attend to the smaller units of a text, e.g. the initial
sound of dog and doll is the same and is represented by the letter
“d,” Bottom-up
• But this is only useful if they know what a dog, or a doll.
• If children do not know how to decode and have not learned the
regular sound–symbol correspondences in English, when confronted
with a new word, they are likely to skip over it, and doing that many
times renders a text meaningless.
Bottom-Up and Top-Down
Reading
Bottom-Up and Top-Down
Reading
• Language experience is an approach that uses learners’ oral language as the basis of a
written story.
• The learners (a class, small group, or individual student) dictate their “story” to someone
who is a more competent writer (usually the teacher, but it may also be an older, more
proficient student), who writes what the learners dictate.
• The language experience story can be
• a summary, an e-mail to the author of a story that the class has read, an invitation to
parents to come to a school event, a thank-you note to someone who has visited the
class, or even a message to a student who has missed an important event
Language Experience
Approach (LEA)
With LEA, young learners follow these steps:
• 1. Participate in a common experience (a field trip, a story, a
celebration, a visitor, a picture that evokes feelings)
• 2. Have a discussion
• 3. Decide what to write, using a brainstorming web or other
graphic organizer
• 4. Dictate the “story” to the teacher, who writes it so all can see
• 5. Read back what the teacher has written (The teacher may
read it first, with students following along, and then they read
it together.)
• 6. Decide if they want to edit anything
• 7. Copy what is written on the board into their notebooks
Language Experience
Approach (LEA)
• At this point, children can engage in a number of follow-up
activities to develop their reading and writing skills, as well as
their vocabulary (and even grammar). They can:
• ■■ Cut up the copied sentences into sentence strips and
sequence them
• ■■ Add new sight words to the class-word wall (an alphabetic
listing of important words that the class has learned) or their
vocabulary notebooks
• ■■ Find rhyming words or words that begin or end with the
same sound (phonics activities)
• ■■ Complete a gap-fill, filling in important words from the story
• ■■ Play vocabulary games such as Concentration or Bingo with
the vocabulary words
• ■■ Create a new ending for the story or text
Language Experience Approach (LEA)
• One question that always emerges with this approach is whether to write
exactly what the children dictate or to correct what they say into “good”
English:
Exact words:
• ■■ Validate the children’s language
• ■■ Make a clear relationship between speech (sound) and print
• ■■ Will not likely lead to other errors or fossilization
A teacher-edited text:
• ■■ Provides a good model
• ■■ Reflects the differences between spoken and written texts
• ■■ May be viewed more positively by parents or administrators
Language Experience Approach (LEA)
The children have fun with rhyme, while they are also noticing the
different ways in which /i/ is spelled in common English words.
Pepperoni Pizza
• Apples and bananas are really, really neat, But
• Pepperoni pizza is our favorite thing to eat.
• Mario eats ice cream while standing on his feet, But
• Pepperoni pizza is our favorite thing to eat.
• Silvia likes hot dogs while sitting in her seat, But
• Pepperoni pizza is our favorite thing to eat.
(The chant continues with other students’ names and ends with:)
• Mr. Greenblatt brought us to his room; he said he had a treat. It
was pepperoni pizza, our favorite thing to eat!
• Following this, the children drew pictures of the various foods
and made their own book, titled, naturally, Pepperoni Pizza.
Effective Reading Activities
Reading strategies
1. Activities for beginning
readers (word level):
• Pointing to or circling initial or final letters in words
• Pointing to or circling words
• Sorting pictures of objects (or the objects) with the same initial sound
• Sorting or matching words that rhyme
• Labeling pictures
• Matching words with pictures, with the same words, or with words with the same initial or
final letters
• Sorting and categorizing words by type of object or similarity of sound
• Guessing a word partially completed (first and last letter, first letter)
• Completing a word or word and picture puzzle
• Playing alphabet or word games
• Noting patterns in songs or chants
• Filling in a missing letter with picture cue (e.g., ca_ with picture of a car)
• Creating words with letters
• Posting words to a word wall
• Creating letter collages
2. Activities for more advanced readers
(from word to sentence and text level):
Arranging words in
Following along with a
Unscrambling words Choosing among proper sequence in Matching texts with
text while listening to it
(What animal words can Filling in word puzzles multiple choice items sentences and sentences similar formats
being read (on CD or by
you find here? Cta, hifs) and pictures in proper sequence in a (schedules, lists, e-mails)
the teacher)
text (sentence strips)
Engaging in jigsaw
Scanning a text for Writing in a reading
Taking notes in a graphic reading, with each group
known word chunks (bus response journal or log
organizer responsible for different
stop, soccer ball) (see p.182)
parts of a short text
Effective Reading Activities
Pre-Task Stage
During Stage
approach
• Filling in blanks
• Completing sentences with picture clues or sentence starters
Pre-Task Stage
During Stage
Story from a
the following steps:
Pre-task stage
Video (25
• Brainstorm ideas (3 minutes): In small groups, students brainstorm ideas for
the story in a web.
• List ideas (2 minutes): In small groups, students order their ideas in a list.
minutes) • Share ideas (5 minutes): With the whole class, students share their ideas
from their list while the teacher writes their ideas in complete sentences on
the board. If students make any grammatical mistakes when expressing their
ideas, the teacher can model the correct sentences as she writes on the
board.
During task stage
• Write sentences (5 minutes): Individually, students write a sentence for each
idea using the teacher’s model on the board.
• Brain break (2 minutes): The teacher leads the whole class in a TPR brain
break. They do the Handshakes three or four times, and then stretch their
hands up high and touch their toes a few times.
• Add details (3 minutes): With the whole class, students discuss what details
to add to make the story more interesting.
• Write story (5 minutes): Individually, students write the story in good
handwriting on a clean sheet of paper.
Post task stage
The teacher can check on progress after each step and tell students to move to
the next step. While students are working in small groups, pairs, and
individually, the teacher can walk around and help students or groups who are
struggling. Then, s/he gives a summative assessment of the task.
Designin
ga
Reading
& Writing
Lesson
Designin
ga
Reading
& Writing
Lesson
Designin
ga
Reading
& Writing
Lesson
Chapter Summary