Ultimate BLAW Slides
Ultimate BLAW Slides
s
Spring -
Milky Way Universe Stars Looking
?????
• WHAT IS LAW?
• MEANING?
• DEFINITION?
• PURPOSE?
• ROLE?
WHY STUDY LAW
• Overwhelmed!...so different from studying accounts,
marketing, economics, IT or HR.
APPROACH:
• Learning relevant legal terminology
• Framework of particular area of law i.e. relevant
legislation
• Application of daily life examples.
MISCONCEPTION:
• Studying law is dull….merely a matter of memorising
and reproducing
WHY STUDY LAW?
• Obvious! Course Requirement.
• Study of law improves powers of reasoning, clarity of
thought and the ability to analyze and express
complicated ideas.
• A greater appreciation of the workings of the system
and the parts that ensure it’s functioning.
• Law forms the foundation on which any civilized
society is based. Nature has its own laws. So does
society.
• Law effects all aspects of life and society and is the
mechanism for change employed by governments
across the globe.From the protection of life and
liberty, through corporate law to international
relations, the law is the central stage.
WHY STUDY LAW?
Contd.
• Bill----Proposal
• Committees of the House
• Approval by the Legislature
• Assent by the President.
1. Rigidity.
2. Conservative
3. Formalism
4. Complex.
JURISPRUDENCE
• Philosophy of law. Study and theory of law.
Different philosophies how law has developed:
Natural Law: The law is based on what is morally correct
and ethical.
Historical: The law consists of social traditions and
customs.
Analytical: The law is shaped by logic
Sociological: The law provides a way to advance certain
goals in the best interests of society.
Command: The law is the set of rules created and enforced
by the governing party.
Critical Legal Studies: Legal rules are unnecessary and
legal disputes should be solved by using rules based on
fairness.
Law and Economics: Promoting market efficiency should
be the key concern of the law.
JURISPRUDENCE...Contd.
Human Behaviour....dominating, historically,
chronogically:
HANDOUT
NATURE OF LAW
HANDOUT
PAKISTAN...LEGAL HISTORY
HANDOUT
COMMON LAW
• Before the Norman Conquest in 1066 each locality
in England was subject to local laws established by
the local ruling Lord or chieftain.
• William the Conqueror and his successors began
to replace the local laws with one uniform system
of law.
• English Common Law was developed over
centuries by judges appointed by the monarch,
who delivered their opinions when deciding cases
brought before court.
• The emphasis of law at that time was legal
procedure over the merit of case.
• Monetary compensation (damages) was the only
remedy available
COMMON LAW...Contd.
• To mitigate limited remedies available and unfair
judgments, under the authority of Lord Chancellor,
Court of Chancery (equity) were established.
• Appeals lay before these courts against the decisions
of Kings Courts.
• The Courts of Chancery would grant appropriate
remedy.
• These remedies were known as equitable
remedies...designed to deal with particular fact
situations.
• Equitable remedies took precedence over the decisions
of the Kings Courts.
• In the 19th century a law passed by the Parliament
merged the two court systems.
ADMINISTRATION
OF JUSTICE
WHAT IS JUSTICE?
The quality of being just; propriety; correctness;
justness; rightfulness; vindication of right; merited
reward or punishment
The act of rendering what is right and equitable
towards one who has suffered a wrong.
TWO TYPES:
1. EXCLUSIVE DEFINITION: Gives a precise meaning
completely replacing ordinary meaning. Excludes all other
meanings. Begins with the word ‘MEANS’
2. INCLUSIVE DEFINITION: Expansive definition. Begins with
‘INCLUDES’. Has both elements
PROVISO:
Normally varies the meaning or operation of a section, sub-
section. Makes an exception to the main provision
EXPLANATION:
Specifies the meaning of a word, term or phrase which is
ordinarily capable of signifying more than one meaning or
interpretation
Cont’d.
• Law divided into PARTS and each deals with a
particular subject e.g. Part II Jurisdiction of Courts.
Part III SECP, Part IV Incorporation of Companies
• Sections
• Sub Sections
• DEFINITIONS: The word or a term specifically
defined has a special meaning assigned to it and
replaces its ordinary meeting. Otherwise have their
ordinary dictionary meaning e.g.
• Proceed in alphabetical order
• Section 2 (7) “Company” means a company formed
and registered under this Ordinance or an existing
Company
THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM OF
PAKISTAN
• On independence, the government of India Act 1935
was retained as a provisional constitution
FEATURES
LITIGATION
PROPOSAL:
Is declaration by the proposer of his
intention to be bound by an obligation if the
offeree fulfills or undertakes to fulfill certain
conditions
A proposal is made when one person
signifies to another his willingness to do or
abstain from doing anything, with view to
obtaining the assent of that other to such act
In order to decide whether an offer has been made,
a court will consider the intentions of the parties,
ascertaining them from the circumstances of the
case. The terms of an offer must be clear and
certain.
PROMISOR:
Person making the proposal.
PROMISEE:
Person accepting the proposal.
The promisor and the promisee must be two
different persons.
The two must exist to constitute a contract.
ACCEPTANCE:
Of an offer is the unconditional agreement to all
the terms of the offer. It is the agreement to the
exact terms of the offer.
PROMISE:
An undertaking by one man with another for
the performance or the non-performance of some
particular thing. A verbal covenant
The technical use is narrower than the
popular use.
The proposal when accepted becomes a promise.
There must only be a proposal but there must be an
acceptance of the proposal by the other side
Every promise is an accepted proposal
CONSIDERATION:
Act, done or promised to be done, at the
desire of the promisor.
• At the desire of the promisor, the promisee or
any other person
• Must have done or abstained from doing, or
•Must do or abstain from doing or
•Must promise to do or abstain from doing
something
• Consideration needs to be contemporaneous
with the promise since it is the price of the
promise and therefore past consideration is no
consideration.
• Acts done in gratitude e.g. giving someone a
reward for finding your wallet does not make
this a contractual transaction
• An agreement without consideration is void.
• Consideration must move from the promisor to
promisee
• It someone else furnishes consideration, the
promisee becomes a stranger to the contract.
AGREEMENT:
• Every promise and every set of promises,
forming consideration for each other.
• An accepted proposal. Result of a proposal
from one side and its acceptance by the
other.
• Regarded as a contract when it is
enforceable by law.
• An agreement that the law will enforce is a
contract.
Cont’d.
When one person signifies to another his
willingness to do or to abstain from doing
anything with a view to obtaining the assent of
that other to such act or abstinence, he is said
to make a proposal. When the person to whom
the proposal is made signifies his assent
thereto, the proposal is said to be accepted. A
proposal when accepted becomes a promise.
The person making the proposal is called the
promisor. The person accepting the proposal is
called the promisee.
WHAT ARE CONTRACTS?
Party B makes an
OFFER TO BUY
(This is not an acceptance)
PERFORMANCE
A contract creates obligations. “Performance of a
Contract” means the carrying out of these
obligations.
• Co-operation of both parties is necessary.
• Parties must either perform or offer to perform
their respective promises, unless such
performance is dispensed with or excused under
the law.
• Deals with time, mode, and order of
performance as also who is bound to perform
and who can demand performance
• The time and place to be considered at which
the contract is to be performed.
• Must be in the manner and at the time in which
the promises were made.
• In case of death binding on legal heirs unless
contrary to it from the contract.
• Within a reasonable time: When promisor to
perform without demand from the promisee and
no time fixed then promisor must perform within
reasonable time (reference to nature of
character of goods dealt, surrounding
circumstances, facts of case)
BY OPERATION OF LAW:
• Merger
• Bankruptcy.
• By BREACH: A contract may be broken. Will
discharge either party from performance.
BREACH
A breach of contract will occur if one party:
• Fails to perform its part of the contract by the
agreed date;
• Makes it impossible for it to perform the
contract;
• Repudiates its liabilities under the contract.
REMEDIES
Where there is a breach of contract on the
part of one party, the injured party becomes
entitled to any one or more of the following reliefs:
• Rescission;
• Suit for damages;
• Suit for specific performance;
• Suit for an injunction;
When two parties have entered into a
contract and one of them has broken his party of
the bargain then it is only natural that the other
should seek remedy.
RESCISSION:
The injured party is freed from all obligations
under the contract;
DAMAGES:
Form of a money payment; usual remedy awarded
by the courts:
Liquidated: Sum is a fixed or ascertainable.
Damages which the parties have agreed when they
made their contract. Paid by the defaulting party in
the event of the contract being broken.
Unliquidated: Assessed by the court and must be
claimed e.g. loss of earnings, damage to car etc.
• Not allowed to make a profit:
• Purpose is to attempt to put the claimant back
into the same position as he would have been in
had the contract been performed.
• Damages are intended as compensation and not
as punishment.
SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE
Order of the court expressly instructing to perform
the contract:
• An equitable remedy
• Discretionary.
• Contempt of court: defiance of a decree of specific
performance is imprisonment or fine.
INJUNCTION
Order of the court to prevent the doing, continuance
or repetition of some wrongful act.
• An equitable remedy; discretionary.
• Not be awarded if damages would adequately
compensate.
An injunction can be:
Interlocutory (temporary) granted before the trial
of the action. Basically in order to preserve the
status quo.
Perpetual (permanent) granted after the trial
when the dispute has been resolved by the court. It
may last forever.
Prohibitory orders that the wrongful act shall not
be done: this is the usual type.
Mandatory orders the doing of a certain positive
act.
Specific performance is used to compel the
performance of a contract which has not been
performed; injunction is used to order the undoing
of something already done in breach of contract.
Contracts and Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU)
• Contracts involve the exchange of promises
• A court will enforce its terms if one of the parties
breaches the contract
• A memorandum of understanding is an agreement
between two or more parties. Unlike a contract,
however, an MOU need not contain legally
enforceable promises.
• Parties to a contract must intend to create a legally
binding agreement, the parties to an MOU may
intend otherwise.
• An MOU is often used to define the expectations and
responsibilities of each of the parties.
CONTRACTS—SPECIAL TYPES
The first six chapters of the Contract Act lay
down the general principles on which all contracts
are based, while the rest of the Act deals with the
most important classes of commercial contracts,
viz, indemnity and guarantee, bailment, agency.
The general principles of contract are applicable
to the special contracts.
CONTINGENT CONTRACT:
A contract to do or not do something unless
such event takes place. A conditional contract and
the condition is of uncertain nature e.g. A
contracts to pay B Rs. 10,000 if B’s house is burnt.
Contracts of insurance, are contingent contracts.
• The uncertainty and futurity of the event to
which the contract is related. Liability of
performance is not absolute but depends
upon the happening or not happening of
certain event
• The event being collateral to the event.
Contingency should relate to a matter
collateral to the main purpose of the
agreement
• The contingency should not depend on the
mere will and pleasure of a party, but must
depend on the act of a party.
CONTRACT OF INDEMNITY
INDEMNITY:
An undertaking to make good monetary or
other loss or damage.
• Loss is to be caused by the conduct of the
promisor himself, or by the conduct of some
other person.
• The loss for which the promisee seeks
reimbursement is really the loss for which the
promisor meant to indemnity him.
• Loss to promisee is essential.
• Unless the promisee has suffered a loss, he
cannot hold the promisor liable.
• Loss must have been occasioned either by the
conduct of the promisor himself or by the
conduct of any other person.
• Loss occasioned by the conduct of the promisee
or an act of God is not covered e.g. A contracts
to indemnify B against the consequences of
any proceeding which C may take against B in
respect of a certain amount.
Scope of indemnity is restricted to those
cases where there is a promise to indemnify
against loss, caused by the (a) promisor himself or
(b) by any other person. Excludes loss from
accidents like fire etc.
Promise of indemnity may be expressed or
implied.
The person (A) who gives the indemnity is called
the indemnifier and the person (B) for whose
protection it is given called the indemnity-holder or
indemnified.
INDEMNITY HOLDER:
The person to whom the indemnity is given i.e.
the promisee acting within the scope of his
authority. His rights:
• Entitled to claim all damages which he may have
been compelled to pay.
• Recover all cost reasonably covered in resisting,
reducing or ascertaining the claim.
• Can compromise a claim on best term he can and
then bring an action on the contract of
indemnity.
CONTRACT OF GUARANTEE
Guarantee is a promise to be answerable for
the debt, default or miscarriage of another.
Contract of Guarantee: to perform the promise,
or discharge the liability of a third person in
case of his default. When a third person
promises to pay debt owed by another in the
event the debtor does not pay a guarantee
relationship is created.
The function of a contract of guarantee is to
enable a person to get a loan, or goods on
credit or an employment
Mutual assent is an essential element of a
contract of guarantee. It is not a unilateral
contract. There must be an offer and acceptance.
Surety: Person who gives the guarantee.
Principal Debtor: Person in respect of whose
default the guarantee is given.
Creditor: Person to whom the guarantee is given.
A takes a loan from B when C guaranteed
repayment of the loan. A is the principal debtor,
B the creditor and C the surety.
• Principal contract between the principal
debtor and the creditor.
• Secondary contract between the creditor and
the surety.
ESSENTIAL FEATURES OF GUARANTEE
1. Principal debt: The purpose of a guarantee
being to secure the payment of a debt, the
existence of a recoverable debt is necessary.
2. Consideration: Should also be supported by
some consideration.
3. Misrepresentation and concealment:
• Guarantee obtained by misrepresentation,
invalid.
• Guarantee obtained by concealment,
invalid.
ESSENTIALS:
• It is a contract
• To perform the promise or
• To discharge the liability
• Of a third person
• In case of his default
• The contract may either be written or oral.
Differences between Contracts of Guarantee
and Indemnity:
1. In case of Guarantee there are 3 parties. In
case of Indemnity 2 parties
2. In case of Guarantee there is a Principal
debtor. In Indemnity an original and direct
engagement; independent of the existence
of the third party
3. Guarantee exists for the security of the
creditor. Indemnity is for reimbursement of
loss
BAILMENT
Bailment from bailler (French) meaning to
deliver. Signifying a contract resulting from
delivery.
A situation in which the personal property of
one person (a bailor) is entrusted to another (a
bailee), who is obligated to return the bailed
property to the bailor or dispose of it as directed.
Bailment implies a sort of relationship in which
the personal property of one person temporarily
goes into the possession of another. The ownership
of the articles or goods is in one person and the
possession in another e.g. leaving a car for repair,
cloth to a tailor, parcel to TCS, goods in a cold
store.
The delivery of goods by one person the bailor to
another the bailee for some purpose, upon a
contract that they shall, when purpose is
accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed
of according to the direction of the person
delivering it.
Formed by the delivery of personal property,
without transfer of title by bailor to a bailee
usually under an agreement. Obligations and
duties arise from the bailment relationship.
CHARACTERISTICS:
1. Delivery of goods. Delivery of possession is
essential. Not transfer of ownership; that would
be sale or exchange. Distinguished from a mere
“custody.”
2. Delivery of possession is temporary but it is
for some purpose. Bailor reserves right to
claim redelivery of goods deposited. Delivery
should be upon contract.
3. Delivery should be upon some purpose:
When the purpose is accomplished goods
will be returned to the bailor or disposed of
according to his mandate. Delivered goods
to be returned according to directions of
bailor when purpose accomplished.
4. Only movable properties can be bailed.
RIGHTS AND DUTIES OF BAILEE and
BAILOR.
DUTIES of BAILEE:
• Take care of the goods entrusted to him –
reasonable.
• Not to make unauthorized use of goods
entrusted to him. Becomes responsible for
any loss.
• Not to mix goods with his own goods
• Not to set an adverse title to the goods
• Return the goods after purpose or period of
bailment is over.
DUTIES of BAILOR:
• To disclose defects of goods bailed
• To bear extraordinary expenses
• Compensate or indemnify for reasons not
entitled to make bailment
AGAINST THIRD PARTIES:
If use or possession wrongfully deprived by third
party bailee can claim damages. Option also with
bailor.
TERMINATION:
• Bailee wrongfully uses or disposes goods.
• Period or purpose of bailment over
• Gratuitous bailment terminated any time by
bailor
• On death of bailor or bailee gratuious bailment.
KINDS:
1. Deposit. Delivery of goods by one man to
another to keep for the use of the bailor.
2. Goods lent to a friend gratis to be used by
him.
3. Hire. Goods lent to the bailee for hire, i.e.,
in return for payment of money.
4. Pawn or Pledge. Deposit of goods with
another by way of security for money
borrowed.
5. Delivery of goods for being transported etc.
or something to be done about them, by the
bailee for reward.
PLEDGE : A special kind of bailment, in which
personal property is turned over to the creditor
as security for the payment of a debt and
retained by the creditor until the debt is paid.
AGENCY:
A legal relationship between a person and
another called the principal for whom he acts.
There must be an authority from the principal,
express or implied.
Is founded upon a contract, either express or
implied, by which one of the parties confides to the
other the management of some business to be
transacted in his name and on his account and by
the other assumes to do business and to render an
account of it.
Agent a person employed to do any act for
another or so represent the other in dealings with
the third person.
Principal the person for whom such act is done
or who is so represented.
In every transaction of agency three persons,
agent, principal and third party to whom such
representation is made, are involved.
Sub Agent a person employed and acting
under the control of the original agent. He is not
responsible for his acts to the principal. He is only
responsible to the agent.
CREATION :
1. By Direct Appointment when agents authority
is expressly given
2. By Implication when agency is inferred from
dealings between two persons.
3. By Necessity when an emergency acts without
authority
3. By Estoppel (a plea in bar, grounded on one’s own act).
Principal induces third person that the acts done by his
agent are by his authority.
4. By Ratification when a previous unauthorised act is
approved and made valid.
TERMINATION:
BY ACT OF PARTIES:
• Lapse of Time: Period for agency relationship expires.
• Purpose Achieved
• Occurrence of Specific Event
• Mutual Agreement
BY OPERATION OF LAW:
• Death or mental incompetence. Automatic and immediate.
Knowledge of death not required.
DUTIES OF PRINCIPAL TO AGENT:
1. Indemnify him against all lawful acts done in
exercise of conferred authority
2. Indemnify for acts done in good faith.
3. Compensate for injury caused by principal’s
neglect
RIGHTS OF AGENTS:
4. Right of retainer out of sums received on
principal’s account
5. Entitled to commission (subject to contract)
6. Entitled to retain property, documents etc.
until commission due received
1. Indemnified by principal for lawful acts
2. Indemnified by principal for acts done in good
faith.
RIGHTS OF PRINCIPAL:
3. Agent to carry out business according to
principal’s directions as a prudent man.
4. Entitled to examine accounts.
5. Agent to obtain instructions from principal
6. Can repudiate transaction if agent carries out
business in his own account.
7. Agent cannot delegate authority without
consent.
V.I.P
R.I.P
PARTNERS
LAW RELATING TO PARTNERSHIP
• In Pakistan for small to medium size business
set ups the common mode of business.
• Advantage of structural flexibility and
formality of relationship between partners.
• Maybe registered or not. Not compulsory
• Registered firms have the advantage of tax
and consequences of litigation.
• Favoured over corporate structure
(companies) as no dividend is levied.
• But partners exposed to greater personal
liability than the shareholders of a company.
PARTNERSHIP LAW IN
PAKISTAN
PARTNERSHIP ACT 1932
Originally it was contained in and formed
part of the Contract Act,1872 (Chap. XI)
which was repealed and in its place was
passed a comprehensive law.
• Is the law governing regulation of
partnerships in Pakistan.
• Law passed by the Indian Legislature in
1932.
• The Governor General of India gave
assent on April 8, 1932.
• No. IX of 1932
• Adopted and followed by the Government
of Pakistan
SCHEME OF LAW:
• Divided into 8 Chapters
• Sections 74
• Schedule 1
CHAPTERS:
1. Preliminary
2. The Nature of Partnership
3. Relations of Partners to One Another
4. Relations of Partners to Third Parties
5. Incoming and Outgoing Partners
6. Dissolution of a Firm
7. Registration of Firms
8. Supplemental
SCHEDULE:
Fees Prescribed
DEFINITIONS
• Intention to economize words
• Does not lay down general principles
• With reference to the whole Act and with
reference to the content
PARTNER:
• One who partakes or shares with another
• An associate
• One who has a share with another or
others in some commercial,
manufacturing or other undertaking
• One who dances with another.
• An associate in a firm. A member of a firm or
partnership.
PARTNERSHIP:
• The state or condition of being a partner
• The association of two or more persons for the
purpose of undertaking and prosecuting
conjointly any business, occupation, or calling
• That which subsists between persons who have
agreed to combine their property, labour skill in
some business and to share the profits thereof
between them
• A type of business entity in which partners share
with each the profits or losses of the business.
FIRM:
Persons who enter into partnership are
collectively called a firm
Persons who enter into partnership with
one another are individually ‘partners’ and
collectively a ‘firm’ and the name under
which their business is carried on is called
the ‘firm name’
Partners may choose any name as their
firm’s name provided it does not go against
the rules relating to trade name or
goodwill----mislead the public into confusing
with a firm already in existence or words
which express or imply sanction, approval or
patronage of the Government
‘BUSINESS’:
• Includes every trade, occupation and
profession.
• Includes and not Means.
• An Inclusive and not Exhaustive definition
• General and vague
• Broadly, any activity which, if successful,
would result in profit
• Must be in existence
• May be temporary or permanent
(indefinite)
PARTNERSHIP:
The relation between persons who have
agreed to share the profits of a business
carried on by all or any of them acting for all
• Persons who have entered into partnership
with one another are individually called
‘partners’ and collectively a ‘firm’ and the
name under which their business is carried
on is called the ‘firm name’
• A voluntary act between two or more
persons.
• Placing their money, effects, labour and
skill, or some or all of them
• In lawful commerce or business
• Understanding that there shall be
communion of profits or thereof between
them.
• Contains the following
elements/essentials
ESSENTIALS:
• Association of two or more persons to
carry on a business
• An agreement entered into by all
concerned
• Agreement must share the profits
• Business must be carried on.
• Carried on by all or any of the persons
concerned acting for all.
• All elements must be present before a
group of persons can be called partners.
Only then a partnership can be said to
come into existence.
• Elements may appear to overlap but are
distinct
• Existence of partnership is a question of
fact.
Association of two or more persons:
• There must be at least two persons who
should join together to constitute a
partnership.
• A group of persons with no legal relations
(no mutual rights and liabilities) not a
partnership
• No existence or responsibility separately
from its partners.
An Agreement:
• Entered into by all persons concerned
• Partnership arises only as a result of an
agreement, express or implied
• Created by a contract, it does not arise
by operation of law e.g. joint operation
(heirs on death )
• Voluntary contractual
• Lawful agreement; founded on good
faith, for lawful object between
competent persons. Fulfill all the
essentials of a valid contract.
• Can even come into being upon an oral
agreement
Sharing Profits:
• Must be an agreement to share profits
arising out of the business
• An essential element of partnership
agreement
• Different from clubs, societies, charitable
associations etc.
• How to be shared left to the parties
themselves
• Sharing of losses not essential.
• Profits refer to net profits.
Carrying of Business:
• ‘Business’ as defined i.e. any trade,
occupation or profession.
• May be temporary or permanent
(indefinite).But must be in existence.
• Agreement to carry on business at a
future time does not result in present
partnership.
• Must be carried on by all or by any
concerned acting for all
• Business must be lawful
• Mutual agency
• True test of partnership.
• Partnership based on the idea of mutual
agency.
• Every partner assumes a dual role i.e.
that of a principal and agent.
• Action of each partner is binding on the
other; agent and principal.
• Liable to account for all.
• Contract in the name of the firm.
PARTNERS....COMPETENT
• Can be entered into by every competent
person
• Attained age of majority
• Of sound mind
• Disqualified from any law to which he is
subject
• Unsound mind
• Married woman is competent
• Minor cannot become a partner but can
be admitted to benefits of partnership.
WORKING PARTNER:
• Not necessarily a partner in business
• Maybe only an employee
• Gets a share in the net profits
• Remuneration for services rendered.
FIRM
Firm:
• Persons who have collectively entered
into partnership with one another is
collectively called a firm
• Name under which business is carried is
Firm Name.
• Business under any name or style
• Taking care of rules like trade name,
goodwill etc.
IMPLIED AUTHORITY:
• Important
• The act of a partner which binds the firm
• This authority of the partner which binds
the firm is his ‘implied authority’
• To exercise implied authority necessary
that:
1. Act must be done in the conduct of
business of the kind carried on by the
firm
2. Must be done in the way which is usual in
such business
3. Must be done in the firm name or in any
other manner expressing or implying an
intention to bind the firms
‘ACT OF A FIRM’
• Binds every one of the partners
• An act in which every one of them had
actually participated
• Gives rise to a right enforceable by or
against the firm
ILLEGAL PARTNERSHIP
• Object of partnership is unlawful. Section
23 of Contract Act
• Number of persons entering into
partnership exceed the permitted.
Companies Law:
1. Business of banking—more than 10
2. Any other business—more than 20
• With an alien enemy (alien friend); enjoys
civil and personal rights as a citizen
• Against international comity.
PARTNERSHIP....DISTINGUISHED
CO-OWNERSHIP
• Akin but different
• Partnership result of an agreement
• Mutual rights and obligations different
• Consent of all trade/business: Examples
• Transfer of interests
CLUB:
• Entirely different
• Club members not liable for acts of other members
• Not liable to be creditor of club
• Liability—extent of Club’s regulations
• No implied authority i.e. bind other members of the
club.
TRADE ASSOCIATION:
• Mutual agency does not exist
COMPANY:
1. Person---Legal
2. Creation– Legal formalities/agreement
3. Transfer of interest
4. Agents of others
Cont’d.....
5. Liability to debts
6. Contract
7. Private arrangements
8. Number
9. Death—Dissolution
10.Property
11.Restrictions
12.Sue and be sued
13.Decree
14.Registration
15.Shareholder
1. PARTNERSHIP is not a distinct legal
person, but is made of the persons
composing it.
COMPANY is a distinct legal person
HOW TO DETERMINE?
• Real relation between the partners
• Mainly a question of fact
• Onus to prove on the appellant
PARTNERS—
RELATIONS TO
ONE ANOTHER
PARTNERS—RELATIONS TO
ONE ANOTHER
• Relations between partners defined
• Freedom to arrange their own affairs
among themselves
• Mutual rights and duties regulated by
contract
Duties and liabilities on a partner:
1. Duty of good faith and common advantage
• Carry on business to the greatest common
advantage
• Just and faithful to each other
• Use knowledge and skill for benefit of firm
• Not personal advantage
• In case of loss to firm by fraud of a
partner---indemnify firm (make good the
loss)
2. Duty to render true accounts and full
information:
• Not to mix with personal business
• Disclose full facts.
• Rights and duties of partners determined
by contract between them.
• Contract varied only by consent of all
partners
• In conduct of business every partner has
RIGHT to:
1. Take part in conduct of business
2. Access, inspect and copy books of
account
3. Express opinion. Majority opinion
• Mutual rights and liabilities. Subject to
contract:
1. Not entitled to any remuneration
2. Entitled to share equally
3. Advance by partner to firm (over and
above capital) entitled to profit (interest)
PROPERTY OF FIRM:
Inclusive definition
1. All property and rights originally brought
to the stock of the firm
2. Acquired by purchase or otherwise
during the course of the business
3. Goodwill of the business
4. Rights and interests acquired with
money belonging to the firm. Deemed.
GOODWILL:
• Not defined
• “The whole advantage, whatever it may be,
of the reputation and connection of the firm”
• Intangible
• Easy to describe, difficult to define
• It is benefit and advantage of the good name,
reputation and connection of a business
• No independent existence
• Cannot subsist by itself
• Attached to business
• Attribute of a business, trade or profession.
APPLICATION OF PROPERTY:
• Shall be held
• Shall be used
• By the partners
• Used by the partners
• Exclusively for purposes of business
• Common benefit of all partners
• One partner cannot use assets for
personal benefits
PERSONAL PROFITS OF PARTNERS
• Subject to contract
• If a partner derives personal profits ----
transaction, use of property or
connection---of the firm. Shall account for
and pay to the firm
• Carries on any business----same structure
and competing with the firm. Shall account
for and pay profits made in that business.
• Cannot carry on competing business during
subsistence of partnership
• In that case pay to firm all profits.
RIGHTS AND DUTIES AFTER CHANGE IN
FIRM
General rules laid down for
determination of rights and duties of
partners. No effect on registration. Three
situations. In case of:
• Change in constitution: Rights and duties
remain the same as immediately before
change
• After expiry of term of firm, remain the
same
• Additional undertakings are carried out
1. CHANGE IN CONSTITUTION
• Partnership not dissolved
• Mutual rights and duties of partners
• Remain same in reconstituted firm
• Same as immediately before
reconstitution
2. AFTER EXPIRY OF TERM OF OFFICE:
• In spite of being constituted for fixed
term carries on business
• Term expired
• Mutual rights and duties remain the same
• Same as before expiry.
3. ADDITIONAL UNDERTAKINGS ARE
CARRIED OUT:
LIABILITIES:
3. Share liable for acts of firm. Within 6
months of majority can sever connection
4. On majority if a member then personally
responsible to third parties
5. Fails to give public notice he becomes a
member after 6 months.
PARTNERS—
INCOMING AND
OUTGOING
PARTNERS—INCOMING AND
OUTGOING
Partnership a contract based on good faith
implies that no new partner can be
introduced without the consent of all the
partners
INCOMING PARTNER:
• Subject to contract between partners
• Introduction subject to consent of all
existing partners
• Not liable to any acts of firm before
coming a partner
• Liability after becoming a partner
• A new partner usually has no personal
liability.
• Unless he expressly agrees
• Liability of a minor on becoming a
member from the time he was admitted to
benefits of partnership
OUTGOING PARTNER:
Leaves the firm. No longer a partner in
the partnership. Subject to contract not
entitled to benefits. Becomes outgoing by:
1. Retirement
2. Expulsion
3. Insolvency
4. Death.
RETIREMENT:
Three rules how a partner can retire:
• With the consent of all partners
• In accordance with an express agreement
by all partners
• Giving written notice to all to all partners
Liability on Retirement
• To third party for acts before retirement;
discharged by an agreement with third
party and reconstituted firm
• Otherwise liability continues until public
notice given
EXPULSION:
• Governed by contract
• Majority cannot expel except in good
faith
• Conferred by express agreement
• If conferred powers then exercised by
majority
Liability on Expulsion:
Same as in case of retirement.
INSOLVENCY:
The condition which marks a person’s
liability to meet full monetary obligations.
Ceases to pay debts in the ordinary course
of business or cannot pay as they become
due
• On being declared an insolvent ceases to
be a partner on the date of order
• Firm not necessarily dissolved depending
on the contract
• Firm automatically dissolved if all
partners (but one)declared insolvent
Liability:
• After insolvency estate not liable to any
act of firm
• Firm not bound by acts of partner
DEATH:
• If by agreement firm not dissolved on
death estate of deceased not liable to any
act of firm
• If by agreement firm dissolved surviving
members responsible till public notice
given
DISSOLUTION OF
FIRM
DISSOLUTION OF FIRM
So far:
1. Formation of partnership
2. Nature of partnership
3. Rights and liabilities of partners
4. Partners inter se third persons.
5. Changes in a firm without dissolution i.e
reconstitution where business continues
as before.
• Literal Meaning:
Breaking Up.
• Of partnership:
The discontinuance of a partnership
from any legal cause. Breaking up or the
extinction which subsisted between all the
partners of the firm. There are various ways
of dissolution of firm. It may take place:
1. AGREEMENT:
By agreement (consent) between all the
partners or according to the contract
amongst themselves
2. COMPULSORY:
Occurrence of events making dissolution
unavoidable e.g.
• Insolvency of all partners or all except
one (when only one remains then no
longer a partnership)
• Unlawful business. When object of
partnership is illegal and carrying on of
business becomes unlawful
3. CONTINGENCIES:
Activities for which firm constituted
coming to an end, it cannot function and
stands dissolved on its own death
• Expiry of the fixed term for which the
firm was constituted
• The undertaking or particular adventure
for which constitutes firm has been
completed
• Death of partner as partnership based on
personal relations
• A partner declared insolvent
4. AT WILL:
Any partner can give notice in writing to
all partners of his intention to dissolve.
Definite term not specified exists only during
pleasure of all partners.
Dissolution from date mentioned in
notice if not then from date of
communication of notice
5. BY COURT
Seven grounds in which the Court on any
can order dissolution on a suit filed by a partner
• Unsound mind: As it is necessary to protect
the interest of the insane and other partners
• Permanent Incapacity: Due to illness, mental
or physical but should be of permanent
nature, incapable of performing duties
• Conduct: Guilty of conduct to effect carrying
of business; moral turpitude, professional
misconduct. Connected with business and
damage it.
• Conduct: Willful and persistent breach of
agreements relating to firm or conduct
e.g. destroying old account books, false
in books of account etc. Mutual
confidence does not exist and
continuance not practical.
• Transfer of share: by a partner of his
whole share to a third party.
• Motive: Business cannot be continued
only at a loss as motive of every
partnership is profit
• Any other ground: just and equitable to
dissolve. Judicial discretion with regard
to circumstances and exigencies.
Liability for acts of partners:
• Liable to third parties until public notice
is given. Not to prejudice and protect
rights of third parties
• Right of business: Apply property of firm
in payment of debts and liabilities of firm.
Surplus to be distributed amongst
partners.
• Authority: of partners binding each other
continue in order to finish unfinished
business and complete dissolution.
Authority to wind up
• Settlement of accounts: Losses first paid
out of profits, then capital and lastly
partners individually on basis of sharing
profit ratio
Assets of firm first debts of third parties,
then partners ratably for advances
(distinguish from capital), followed by capital
and balance if any divided ratably
• Debts: Joint debts paid from property of
firm and separate from separate property of
firm
• Goodwill: It can be included in assets and
can be sold separately or along with
property of firm
PUBLIC NOTICE
PROCEDURE:
1. Application by firm to Registrar of Firms
on prescribed form:
• Name of firm
• Place or principal place of business
• Names of any other place where business
is carried on
• Date on which each partner joined the firm
• Names and permanent address
• Duration of firm
Signed and verified by all partners.
Restriction on use of names like Government,
Jinnah etc.
Sending/submitting the application to the
Registrar of Firms in the area of jurisdiction.
Registration is only of a firm which is in
existence and not which has been dissolved.
Registration takes place after receipt of
statement (application) by Registrar and after
verifying all particulars filed and compliance
made makes an entry in the Register of Firms
Once a firm has been registered further
and subsequent changes like:
• Name and place of business
• Opening and closing of branches
• Name and addresses of partners
• Changes in and dissolution of a firm
Can be made by intimating the Registrar
who shall make an entry in the Register of
Firms
In case of a court order regarding a registered
firm the Registrar shall make consequential
entries in the Register
The Register of Firms is open to
inspection by any person on payment of
prescribed fees
The entries and any subsequent changes
in Register of Firms is conclusive proof of
facts. Original documents filed with the
Registrar shall be the conclusive proof.
NON REGISTRATION:
Mentioned earlier is not mandatory and
does not make a partnership illegal but its
effects:
1. If firm not registered and person suing not
registered as a partner cannot bring a suit
to enforce a right arising from a contract
• Against the firm
• Against any past or present partner of
firm
2. No suit to enforce a right arising from a
contract shall be instituted by or on
behalf of firm against any third party
But this does not effect the right of a
third party to proceed against an
unregistered firm and its partners.
3. Claim to set off and other proceedings to
enforce any right arising from a contract.
BUT Non Registration does NOT effect:
Chapter 1: Preliminary
Chapter 2: Nature of Limited Liability
Partnership
Chapter 3: Registration
Chapter 4: Partners, Partnership and Their
Relations
Chapter 5: Extent of Liability
Chapter 6: Contributions
Cont’d…
Chapter 8: Assignment and Transfer of
Partnership Rights
Chapter 9: Conversion to Limited Liability
Partnership
Chapter 10: Foreign Limited Liability
Partnership
Chapter 11: Compromise, Arrangement or
Reconstruction of Limited
Liability Partnerships
Chapter 12: Winding Up and Dissolution
Chapter 13: Miscellaneous
DEFINITIONS
Body Corporate, includes:
i. Limited liability partnership registered
under this Act;
ii. Limited liability partnership registered
or incorporated outside Pakistan; and
iii. Company, incorporated outside Pakistan,
but does not include sole proprietorship,
cooperative society, any other body
corporate not defined as a company.
Commission:
Securities and Exchange Commission of
Pakistan
Cont’d…
Foreign limited liability partnership:
A limited liability partnership that is
formed, registered or incorporated outside
Pakistan.
Partner:
In relation to a limited liability partnership,
means any person who has been admitted
as a partner in the limited liability
partnership in accordance with the limited
Cont’d…
Separate legal personality:
Limited liability partnership shall be a body
corporate by registration under this Act and
shall be a legal entity separate from its
partners.
• Shall have perpetual succession.
• Any change in the partners of a limited
liability partnership shall not affect the
existence, rights or liabilities of the
Limited Liability Partnership.
• A limited liability partnership shall:
a) sue and be sued;
b) acquire, own hold develop or dispose
Cont’d…
c) have a common seal; and
d) do and suffer such other acts and
things as bodies corporate may
lawfully do and suffer.
Contracts:
On behalf of a limited liability partnership
shall be made in writing under common seal
of the limited liability partnership and any
contract so made shall be effectual in law
and shall bind the limited liability
Cont’d…
Partners, partnership and their
relations:
• Individual or body corporate or company
may become a partner in a limited
liability partnership.
• Shall have at least two partners.
• A person may cease to be:
i. In the event of his death
ii. Event of dissolution of limited liability
partnership; and
iii.In accordance with an agreement
• A limited liability partnership is its agent
Cont’d…
Designated partners:*
• Every limited liability partnership shall
have at least one designated partner:
i. is an individual; and
ii. a resident in Pakistan
*A designated partner shall be responsible
for the doing of all acts, matters and things
as are required to be done by the limited
partnership in respect to compliance of the
provisions of this act including filing any
document, return, statement and the like
report pursuant of the provisions of this act
and as may be specified in the limited
liability partnership agreement.
Cont’d…
Form of contribution:
Decided mutually by the partners and may
consist of moneys, negotiable instruments,
properties including valuable rights,
intangibles, knowledge and skills, etc.
which the partners deem to add value to
partnership.
Financial Disclosures:
• Shall maintain proper book of accounts;
prescribed by SECP
• Prepare a statement of accounts within
four months from the end of the financial
Cont’d…
Conversion:
• From firm to Limited Liability
Partnership, Second Schedule will apply
• From private limited company to Limited
Liability Partnership, Third Schedule will
apply
Registratio
Mandatory Optional
n
Charter
LLP Agreement Partnership deed
document
Perpetual
Yes No
Succession
Audit of
Mandatory Not mandatory
accounts
LEGAL PERSON
• Entity separate from the persons actually
involved in it. This fictional legal person
owns the property of the business, owes
the money that is due to business
creditors and is unchanging even though
the people involved in the business come
and go.
Lifting the ‘Veil of
Incorporation’
• Limited liability: only company is
responsible for its liabilities and its
shareholders are said to be protected by ‘a
veil of incorporation’.
• The shareholders are hidden from view and
protected from incurring liabilities.
• Circumstances were the ‘veil of
incorporation’ will be lifted and the
business treated as if it were being run by
its individual shareholders or directors.
• Lifting the ‘veil of incorporation’ can be
authorized by a court.
Lifting the ‘Veil of
Incorporation’
• Court will look behind the company façade
in a number of different circumstances:
• company being used for a fraudulent
purpose
• evade legal responsibilities
• to ascertain if a company is owned by
an enemy in wartime.
• Corporate structure used to evade
contractual duties and engage business
under a cloak (veil).
KINDS OF COMPANIES
ADVANTAGES OF PRIVATE
COMPANY
(HANDOUT)
FORMATION
OF
COMPANIES
FORMATION OF COMPANIES
Usually it takes a lot of funding and
tons of efforts to establish a business. For a
company to be formally and properly
established several steps need to be
undertaken.
•PROMOTION: in which the promoters of
the company have to formulate and file all
the necessary documents with the Registrar
of Companies
•INCORPORATION: or the carriage of the
formal registration process of the company
that gives it a recognizable status in the
formal business sector.
• RAISING OF CAPITAL: this facilitated by
incorporation as it gives credibility and
makes the company eligible for being
granted loans as capital
• The official start of the business is the end
of the elementary steps of forming a
company but is the beginning of the
company’s interaction with its clientele.
DIRECTORS’ REPORT.
Attach with every Balance Sheet:
2. Recommendation for dividend
3. Re-appropriation of profits
4. Disclose material changes
5. Explanation on any adverse remarks of
auditors.
CHIEF EXECUTIVE
• An individual entrusted with powers to
manage to affairs of the Company
• Subject to control and direction of
directors
• Includes a director or any other person
• First appointment within 15 days of
commencing business by Directors. Hold
office till first AGM
• Subsequent by the BOD within 14 days of
vacancy
• Till successor appointed continues to work
• ‘Conflict of Interest’; directly or indirectly
engage in any business which directly
competes with the business of the Company.
SECRETARY:
• An officer of the Company
• Responsible for the compliance by the
Company of its statutory duties
• Public company must have a company
Secretary
• Prescribed qualifications under the Law
AUDITORS:
• To carry out ‘audit’ an examination of
accounts which may be detailed or
administrative.
• Comply with directions
• Appointed at each AGM
• Hold office till conclusion of next AGM
• Removal through Special Resolution.
• Duties of auditor have been late down…..
Conduct audit on ISA (as adopted by
ICAP)
COMPANY MEETINGS
STATUTORY MEETING
• Every public company with share capital hold
meeting within 180 days from the date entitled
to commence business or within 9 months of
date of incorporation which ever is earlier.
• If first annual general meeting is held earlier
then statutory meeting is not required.
• Held once in a lifetime
• Purpose to put before shareholders all important
facts – shares taken up, monies received,
contracts entered, preliminary expenses
• Furnish particulars for shareholders to discuss
• Management, method and prospects
STATUTORY REPORT: Report submitted by the
directors 21 days before the Statutory Meeting
to every member
INTERNAL AUDIT:
• Listed Company to have internal audit function
• Audit Committee of the BOD
WINDING
UP
WINDING UP
• Artificial Person. ‘Born’ has to ‘die’
• Winding up is the closing up of a
company’s concern, which may be by
reason of insolvency, or otherwise
• Winding up is a proceeding by means of
which the dissolution of a company is
brought about and its assets realised and
applied in payment of its debts, and after
satisfaction of the debts, the balance, if
any, remaining is paid back to the
members in proportion to the contribution
made by them to the capital of the
company
Modes of winding up:
1. Compulsory winding up by the Court e.g.
special resolution by the Company,
defaults (statutory reports etc.), unable to
pay debts, violation of Company’s
Ordinance, Memorandum of Association
etc.
2. Voluntary winding up by:
a) Members
b) Creditors
3. Voluntary winding up under the
supervision of the court
• BANKRUPTCY: In it the whole estate, both
legal and equitable, is taken out of the
bankrupt and is vested in the trustee
• WINDING UP : The estate, legal or equitable,
still remains in the company until its
dissolution
• DISSOLUTION: Puts an end to the existence
of a company i.e. completely wound up or
court feels that official liquidator cannot
proceed with the winding up
• LIQUIDATION: Process of distributing a
bankrupt’s estate i.e. realising the assets and
paying the money over to the creditors.
SALE OF GOODS ACT, 1930
Initially the Sale of Goods Act , 1930
was part of the Contract Act 1872 (Chapter
VII Sections 76 to 123).This Chapter VII was
repealed and a new law Sale of Goods Act
1930 promulgated. Pakistan adopted it in
August 1947.
AUCTION—IMPLIED WARRANTIES:
• Authority to sell.
• No defects in knowledge
• Undertakes to give possession against
price paid
• Possession will not be disturbed.
CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES:
Various statements, commitments and
performance make up a contract. Some are vital to
the contract and others subsidiary. If the parties to
a contract regard the term as essential it is a
condition and if not then it is a warranty.
CONDITION:
A qualification, provision, or clause in a
contract, the occurrence of which creates,
suspends, or terminates the obligations of the
contracting parties.
It is essential to the main purpose of the
contract. Breach of which gives right to treat the
contract as
repudiated. Has option to treat condition as
warranty and claim damages.
WARRANTY:
A stipulation collateral to the main
purpose of the contract, the breach of it gives
rise to claim for damages but not to reject
goods and repudiate the contract.
Conditions and Warranties are either
expressed or implied.
IMPLIED CONDITIONS:
• In case of sale seller has a right to sell
goods. When agreement to sell right when
the property is to pass
• When sale of goods by description then the
goods should correspond with the
description and of merchantable quality
• When description accompanied by sample
then the goods should correspond
accordingly.
• When particular purpose expressed by buyer
then goods should be fit for such purpose
• When sold by sample then bulk should
correspond with sample
IMPLIED WARRANTIES:
• Buyer has right of possession and free from
any encumbrance.
• Quality for particular fitness annexed.
Difference between condition
and warranty
CONDITION WARRANTY
1. Damages
2. Account of profits
Ownership of Copyright
First owner of copyright is the author of the work
and this means the person who created the work. In
case of employer and employee course of this
employment then the employer will own the
copyright. Other case then the author will own the
Cont’d
A copyright may be assigned and this must be
in writing signed by or on behalf of the assignor.
Copyright may be transmitted by testamentary
disposition or by operation of law as in the case of
personal.
THE COPYRIGHT ORDINANCE, 1962
It extends to the whole of Pakistan.
Definitions:
• “Adaptation” means
• “Architectural work
of art”
• “Artistic”
• “Audio-visual work”
• “Author”
• “Book”
• “Cinematographic
work”
• “Copy”
• “Counterfeit copy”
THE COPYRIGHT ORDINANCE, 1962
• “Dramatic work” • “Periodical”
• “Engravings ” • “Photograph”
• “Exclusive licence” • “Plate”
• “Infringing copy” • “Public libraries”
• “Lecture” • “Radio diffusion”
• “Literary work” • “Record”
• “Manuscript” • “Recording”
• “Musical work”
• “Rental”
• “Newspapers”
• “Reproduction”
• “Pakistani work”
• “Work”
• “Performance”
• “Work of joint
• “Performing rights
authorship”
society”
Cont’d
“Copyright” – Meaning and scope. This copyright
relates to the right of printing or publishing to the
exclusion of others. The Copyright Ordinance of
1962 defines copyright and lays down conditions
and circumstances under which the copyright of
foreigner and Pakistani citizen can be preserved
from infringement.
• Sense of the sole and exclusive liberty of printing
or otherwise multiplying copies of any work
already published, of the author before
publication are these the undisputed right to the
manuscripts, he may withhold or communicate it,
such restrictions as he pleases on the use of
author may prevent the publication of work until
he himself has made it public.
Cont’d
Copyright deals with the protection of literary and
artistic works. These include writings, music, and
works of the fine arts, such as paintings and
sculptures, and technology-based works such as
computer programs and electronic databases.
Copyright is a legal instrument that provides the
creator of a work of art or literature, or a work that
conveys information or ideas, the right to control
how the work is used. The intent of copyright is to
advance the progress of knowledge by giving
an .....hor of a work an economic incentive to create
new works.
Copyright includes the following creative
works:
I. Literary works which includes Books,
Cont’d
II. Artistic works like paintings, Maps,
Photographs, Drawings, Charts, Calligraphies,
Sculptures, Architectural Works, Label Designs,
Logos, Monograms and other works alike.
III.Cinematographic works which includes
movies, audio-visual works, documentaries, etc.;
and
IV. Record works which include sound recordings,
musical works etc.
TRADEMARKS