TK3
TK3
• Knowledge base which is developed by indigenous, local or native community has been preserved and passed on to generations, so much so, that it becomes the identity of such community.
• Traditional knowledge can be found in variety of concepts such as calculation of time, food article, plant properties, spice uses, yoga practices etc. The most essential factor of Traditional
TK in the narrow sense refers to knowledge as such, in particular the knowledge resulting from intellectual activity in a traditional context, and includes know-how, practices, skills, and
innovations.
TRADITIONAL KNOWLEDGE AND INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY
• Unlike other categories of intellectual property rights, India has no substantive act or
law to protect traditional knowledge but other IP acts contain provisions with respect to
traditional.
• Under the Copyright Act, 1957, there is no specific mention of protecting traditional
cultural, literary or artistic work or folklore but Section 31A provides for protection of
unpublished Indian work, on the other hand Copyright protection in for a limited time
period and also demands certain criteria to be fulfilled, therefore under this IP as well
protection of traditional knowledge doesn't have much scope.
• Past few years it has been seen that India has actively participated in TK conferences
and has made efforts to protect its TK at international level. Access to Indian TK is
available at USPTO United States Patent and Trademark Office and EPO European
Patent Office and CSIR Council of Scientific and Industrial Research is day by day
improving the efficiency of TK database.
The statement accurately reflects the current state of the Copyright Act, 1957, in India. While the
Act doesn't clearly mention protecting traditional cultural, literary, or artistic works or
folklore, Section 31A does provide protection for unpublished Indian works. This section allows
for compulsory licenses for such works if the author is deceased, unknown, or cannot be traced,
enabling anyone to publish or translate them after giving notice.
Here's a more detailed explanation:
Lack of clear Protection:
The Copyright Act, 1957, primarily focuses on protecting original literary, dramatic, musical, and
artistic works, as well as cinematograph films and sound recordings. It does not have specific
provisions dedicated to safeguarding traditional knowledge or cultural expressions.
Section 31A: Compulsory Licensing:
Section 31A of the Act addresses compulsory licenses for unpublished or published works. It
allows anyone to apply to the Copyright Board for a license to publish or communicate such a
work to the public if the copyright owner is unknown or cannot be found.
Protection of Unpublished Works:
Section 31A provides a specific mechanism for protecting unpublished Indian works by enabling
compulsory licensing when the author is deceased, unknown, or untraceable.
Limitations:
While Section 31A offers some protection, it is not a comprehensive solution for safeguarding
traditional knowledge and cultural expressions. Copyright protection is time-limited and requires
specific criteria to be met.
Other Relevant Sections:
While not clearly about traditional knowledge, other sections of the Copyright Act, like Section
57 (moral rights) and Section 38 (performer's rights), can be used to protect certain aspects of
traditional cultural expressions, such as artistic demonstrations or performances.
TRADITIONAL KNOWLEDGE DIGITAL LIBRARY (TKDL)
• There has been an increasing demand of Sui Generis system of Protection for traditional
knowledge since IP protection has its own benefits and loopholes. Sui Generis is a Latin
word meaning 'of its own kind' A person or thing that is unique, in a class by itself.
• Several countries, including India, Peru, and some in the Pacific Islands region, have
developed sui generis systems for protecting traditional knowledge, plant varieties, or
geographical indications.
• Sui generis instrument shall provide legal framework of protection of TK, enforcement of
right of indigenous communities, prevent misuse and control of TK, provisions of ABS
(access and benefit sharing) system etc.
• In addition to TKDL system, India can work towards a more active approach, foremost to
create awareness and understanding among people who are till date completely unaware or
have very limited knowledge on Intellectual Property Rights as well as the term 'traditional
Types of Traditional Knowledge
1. Indigenous Knowledge: Knowledge held by indigenous peoples, often passed down
through generations.
Examples: Medicinal plants, agricultural practices, spiritual beliefs.
2. Folk Medicine: Traditional healing practices and remedies passed down through
generations.
Examples: Herbal remedies, spiritual healing, traditional rituals.
3. Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK): Knowledge about the natural environment,
including ecosystems, species, and conservation practices.
Examples: Wildlife management, forest conservation, sustainable agriculture
4. Cultural Knowledge: Knowledge about cultural practices, traditions, and values.
Examples: Language, art, music, dance, storytelling.
5. Traditional Agricultural Knowledge: Knowledge about traditional farming practices,
including crop selection, soil management, and irrigation.
Examples: Crop rotation, organic farming, agroforestry.
6. Spiritual Knowledge: Knowledge about spiritual beliefs, practices, and rituals.
Examples: Rituals, ceremonies, spiritual leaders, sacred sites.
7. Traditional Craft Knowledge: Knowledge about traditional crafts, including textiles,
woodworking, pottery.
Examples: Weaving, woodcarving, pottery-making. These types of traditional knowledge
are valuable and often interconnected, reflecting the holistic nature of traditional
knowledge systems
Contexts/Conditions of Traditional Knowledge Development
Physical Contexts:
1. Geographical location: Traditional knowledge is often tied to specific geographical
locations, such as forests, mountains, or coastal areas.
2. Climate and ecosystem: Traditional knowledge is influenced by the local climate and
ecosystem, including the types of plants and animals that are present.
3. Natural resources: Traditional knowledge often involves the use and management of natural
resources, such as water, soil, and minerals.
Social Contexts:
1. Community and culture: Traditional knowledge is often embedded in the culture and
traditions of a community, including their language, customs, and values.
2. Family and kinship: Traditional knowledge is often passed down through family lines and
kinship networks.
3. Spiritual and ritual practices: Traditional knowledge may be tied to spiritual and ritual
practices, including the use of sacred sites and objects.
4. Social organization: Traditional knowledge may be influenced by the social organization of
a community, including their leadership structures and decision-making processes.
Interplay between Physical and Social Contexts:
5. Adaptation to environment: A community's adaptability to its physical surroundings is
frequently reflected in its traditional knowledge.
6. Cultural expression: Traditional knowledge is often expressed through cultural practices,
such as art, music, and storytelling.
7. Community resilience: In situations of social and environmental difficulties, traditional
wisdom can help communities become stronger against change.
Historical Impact of Social Change on Traditional Knowledge Systems
Colonization:
1. Suppression of traditional practices: Colonization often led to the suppression of traditional
practices and knowledge systems.
2. Burden of Western knowledge: Western knowledge systems were imposed on indigenous
communities, leading to the devaluation of traditional knowledge.
Globalization:
1. Loss of traditional knowledge: Globalization has led to the loss of traditional knowledge
as younger generations adopt modern ways of life.
2. Cultural homogenization: Globalization has contributed to cultural homogenization,
threatening the diversity of traditional knowledge systems.
Urbanization:
3. Migration from rural areas: Urbanization has led to migration from rural areas, resulting in
the loss of traditional knowledge and practices.
4. Changes in lifestyle: Urbanization has brought about changes in lifestyle, leading to the
adoption of modern practices and the decline of traditional knowledge.
Modernization:
5. Adoption of new technologies: Modernization has led to the adoption of new technologies,
which can replace traditional practices and knowledge.
6. Shift to modern education: Modern education systems have often prioritized Western
knowledge over traditional knowledge.
Cultural homogenization
Cultural homogenization refers to the process where dissimilar cultures come together
towards a more uniform global culture, often driven by globalization and the spread of
Western (particularly American) media and consumer goods.
Examples of this include the dominance of Western media, the global popularity of certain
sports, and the spread of common fashion trends.
•Global Sports:
Sports like football (soccer) and basketball have become globally popular, with major
events like the World Cup attracting massive audiences worldwide.
•Homogeny of Practices:
Businesses may adopt standardized business practices and organizational cultures, regardless
of their location.
•Hybridization:
While cultural homogenization can occur, globalization also leads to cultural hybridization,
where different cultures blend and create new hybrid forms of art, music, and other cultural
expressions.
Here's a more detailed breakdown of the steps involved:
2. Community-Based Approaches:
Community-Led Initiatives:
Empower local communities to take ownership of their cultural heritage and implement
preservation strategies that are relevant to their needs and values.
Capacity Building:
Provide training and support to local communities to develop their skills and knowledge in
cultural preservation and management.
Sustainable Tourism:
Promote responsible tourism that benefits local communities and preserves cultural heritage
sites and traditions
3. Leveraging Digital Technologies:
Documentation and Digitization:
Use digital technologies to document and preserve cultural heritage, making it accessible
to a wider audience and protecting it from damage or loss.
Digital Preservation:
Safeguard cultural heritage from natural disasters and other emergencies through digital
archives and backup systems.
6. Stakeholder Involvement:
Partnerships: Involve all relevant stakeholders, including governments, local communities,
private sector tourism companies, NGOs, and other relevant organizations, in cultural
preservation efforts.
Importance of Prevention:
1. Protects community rights: protects the rights of communities to their traditional
knowledge and genetic resources.
2. Prevention of biopiracy ensures fair benefit sharing between communities and those
who use traditional knowledge.
3. Supports sustainable development: Biopiracy prevention supports sustainable
development and equitable use of genetic resources.
Importance:
1. Sustainable use of resources: Traditional knowledge promotes sustainable use of
natural resources, contributing to sustainable development.
2. Environmental conservation: Traditional knowledge often includes practices that
conserve and protect the environment.
3. Community well-being: Protection of traditional knowledge can contribute to
community well-being and sustainable livelihoods
4. Holistic approach: Traditional knowledge often takes a holistic approach to
development, considering social, economic, and environmental factors.
5. Innovative solutions: Traditional knowledge can provide innovative solutions to
development challenges, particularly in areas such as agriculture, health, and natural
resource management.
6. Community-led development: Protection of traditional knowledge can support
community-led development initiatives
Recognition of Community Rights:
1. Community ownership: Protection of TK recognizes community ownership and
rights over TK.
2. Fair benefit sharing: Protection promotes fair benefit sharing between communities
and those who use TK.
3. 1. Community-led decision-making: Recognition of community rights enables
community-led decision-making regarding traditional
4. Protection from exploitation: Recognition of community rights protects traditional
knowledge from exploitation and misappropriation.
5. Promotes equity: Recognition of community rights promotes equity and fairness in
the use of traditional knowledge.
Value of Traditional Knowledge in the Global Economy
Economic Benefits:
1. Innovation: TK can lead to innovative products, services, and processes.
2. Competitive advantage: Companies that incorporate TK into their products or services can gain
a competitive advantage.
3. New markets: TK can help companies tap into new markets and customer segments.
4. Sustainable development: TK can contribute to sustainable development by promoting
environmentally friendly practices.
5. Community development: TK can contribute to community development by generating income
and promoting cultural heritage.
6. Global market access: TK can provide access to global markets, enabling communities to
benefit from their knowledge
Examples:
7. Pharmaceuticals: Many modern medicines are derived from TK of medicinal plants.
8. Agriculture: TK of crop rotation, irrigation, and pest management can improve agricultural
productivity.
9. Cosmetics: TK of natural ingredients can lead to the development of new cosmetics and
personal care products.
Challenges:
10. Intellectual property protection: TK is often not protected by intellectual property laws, making
it vulnerable to exploitation.
11. Biopiracy: Unauthorized use of TK can lead to biopiracy, where companies profit from
traditional knowledge without compensating the original knowledge holders.
12. Cultural appropriation: TK can be culturally appropriated, leading to loss of cultural heritage
and identity.
Role of Government in Harnessing Traditional Knowledge
By
1. Documentation: Governments can support the documentation of TK through databases,
registries, and archives.
2. Preservation: Governments can work to preserve TK by supporting cultural heritage initiatives
and protecting traditional practices.
3. Intellectual Property Protection: Governments can establish laws and regulations to protect TK
from misappropriation and unauthorized use.
4. Promotion: Governments can promote TK through various initiatives, such as cultural festivals,
exhibitions, and educational programs.
5. Benefit Sharing Mechanisms: Governments can establish benefit sharing mechanisms to ensure
that TK holders receive fair compensation for the use of their knowledge.
6. Community Engagement: Governments can engage with local communities to develop benefit
sharing agreements and ensure that traditional knowledge is used in a way that respects
community rights on, protection, and promotion.
7. Research Support: Governments can support research into traditional knowledge and its
applications, while ensuring that research is conducted in an ethical and respectful manner.
8. Development of New Products: Governments can facilitate the development of new products
and services based on traditional knowledge, while ensuring that benefits are shared with TK
holders.
9. Policy and Legislation:
Policy Framework: Governments can develop policy frameworks that recognize and protect
traditional knowledge.
Legislation: Governments can enact legislation that provides for the protection and promotion of
traditional knowledge.
Government Initiatives to Harness Traditional Knowledge
India:1.
Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL): A database of traditional Indian
medicine and knowledge, aimed at preventing biopiracy and promoting research.
Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act, 2001: Recognizes farmers'
rights to traditional knowledge and provides for benefit sharing.
Australia:
1. Indigenous Knowledge Database: A database of indigenous knowledge and
cultural heritage, aimed at preserving and promoting indigenous knowledge.
2. Native Title Act, 1993: Recognizes indigenous rights to traditional knowledge and
land.
Brazil
3. National Policy on Traditional Knowledge: A policy framework for protecting
and promoting traditional knowledge, particularly in the context of biodiversity
and indigenous communities.
4. Medicinal Plants Program: A program aimed at promoting the use of traditional
medicinal plants and supporting local communities.
South Africa:
5. Indigenous Knowledge Systems Policy: A policy framework for recognizing and
protecting indigenous knowledge.
6. South African National Biodiversity Institute: Works to document and promote
traditional knowledge related to biodiversity.
Examples of Indian Government Initiatives to Harness Traditional Knowledge
Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL):
1. Database of traditional knowledge: A comprehensive database of traditional Indian medicine and
knowledge.
2. Preventing biopiracy: TKDL helps prevent biopiracy by providing a prior art database for patent
examiners.
Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act, 2001:
3. Recognizing farmers' rights: The Act recognizes farmers' rights to TK and provides for benefit
sharing.
4. Protection of plant varieties: The Act provides protection for new plant varieties and promotes the
conservation of genetic resources.
National Innovation Foundation (NIF):
5. Documenting traditional knowledge: NIF documents and promotes traditional knowledge and
innovations from grassroots innovators.
6. Supporting grassroots innovators: NIF provides support to grassroots innovators, including funding
and technical assistance.
Ayurveda, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, and Homoeopathy (AYUSH):
7. Promoting traditional medicine: The Ministry of AYUSH promotes traditional Indian medicine
systems, including Ayurveda, Yoga, and Siddha.
8. Research and development: AYUSH supports research and development in traditional medicine,
including the development of new products and therapies
Other initiatives:
9. National Biodiversity Mission: Aims to conserve and sustainably use biodiversity, including
traditional knowledge associated with it.
10. CSIR's Traditional Knowledge Database: A database of traditional knowledge, including medicinal
plants and other traditional practices
International Union for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants. This
international organization, established in 1961, provides a system for protecting
plant breeders' rights through intellectual property, encouraging the development
of new plant varieties.
Some Key Organizations And Bodies Involved In This Area
WIPO plays a crucial role in bridging the gap between international IP law and
the need to respect and protect traditional knowledge. By fostering dialogue
and developing legal frameworks, WIPO aims to ensure that the rights of
communities holding traditional knowledge are recognized and that they can
benefit from the use of their knowledge in various domains, including
commerce, research, and cultural preservation
2. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO):
This international treaty aims to conserve biological diversity and includes provisions for
the protection of traditional knowledge related to biodiversity, especially in relation to
genetic resources.
In the Mohawk language, Akwe:kon means "all of us." The spirit of this word is
reflected in the inclusiveness that Akwe:kon offers to its residents and the wider
community Guidelines provide a framework for the development of processes and
criteria for the fair and equitable sharing of benefits. They encourage countries to take
into account the rights of indigenous peoples over their traditional knowledge.
4. International Indigenous Forum on Biodiversity (IIFB):
The IIFB was formed in 1996 during the Third Conference of the Parties (COP3) to the
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) in Buenos Aires, Argentina. Today Indigenous
Peoples and local communities from seven regions of the world are part of the IIFB:
Africa; Asia; Central and South America and the Caribbean (LAC); the Arctic; Eastern
Europe, Russian Federation, Central Asia and Transcaucasia; North America and the
Pacific.
8. Cultural Survival:
This non-profit organization advocates for Indigenous peoples' rights and works to support
the cultural traditions, languages, and traditional knowledge of Indigenous communities
worldwide.
Elements of culture
What is cultural heritage?
Cultural Heritage is an expression of the ways of
living developed by a community and passed on from
generation to generation, including customs,
practices, objects, artistic expressions and values.
Indian Knowledge Systems: It comprises of Jnan, Vignan, and Jeevan Darshan that
have evolved out of experience, observation, experimentation, and rigorous analysis.
For E.g., Yoga, Ayurveda, etc.
Indian folk culture: It is vibrant mixture of traditions, art forms, and customs
passed down through generations continuously from Indus Valley Civilization.
It encompasses diverse regional practices, including intricate handicrafts, and
lively music and dance. For e.g., Lavani dance of Maharashtra, Madhubani
painting of Bihar, etc.
Languages and Scripts: India is a linguistically diverse nation with over 1,600
languages spoken. The Constitution recognizes 22 official languages. Each state
has its own official language(s).
Social and cultural practices: India is unlike any other major civilization in its
complexity and diversity; in fact, it is more akin to a region as diverse as Europe
than a nation-state.
Rituals related to marriage, birth, death, and religious ceremonies are different
in different part of India.
3. What is the role of India's cultural heritage in national development?
Understanding our cultural heritage gives us a better sense of our personal identity.
It plays an essential role in our society by linking the past, the present and the future
generation, as a basis for building a strong nation and national identity. Main role
played by cultural heritage are:
Economic Impact:
Heritage economics is an evolving field with enormous potential in terms
of sustainable development.
Heritage items, such as historic buildings, are classified as cultural capital as they
may not only have a potential sale price as real estate, but also have other
significance that cannot be expressed in monetary terms, such as an ancient
engineering concept. like the International Day of Yoga exemplify India’s cultural
influence.
Job Creation: Heritage-related services, such as guided tours, restoration, and
cultural events, create employment opportunities.
For e.g., Iconic heritage sites like the Taj Mahal, Ajanta Caves,
and Khajuraho Group of Monuments attract millions of visitors annually.
Craftsmanship, handlooms, and indigenous arts generate employment and
income for artisans and communities.
For e.g., Toy industry is a labour-oriented industry based on master
craftsmanship and creative designing.
Cultural exports, including music, dance, and handicrafts, enhance India’s
global presence and contribute to foreign exchange earnings.
Education and Innovation: Ancient texts like the Vedas, Upanishads, and
Bhagavad Gita offer profound knowledge and ethics, while Yoga and Ayurveda
provide holistic health.
Cultural heritage fosters creativity, innovation, and interdisciplinary thinking .
Environmental Conservation: India's cultural heritage, intertwined with
natural landscapes like the Ellora Caves, Sundarbans National Park and
Sacred groves, promotes ecosystem protection and embeds sustainable
practices in traditions.
India has suffered over the ages, with its heritage not only plundered but
also destroyed irrevocably, many a times, by foreign invaders. In the
present time there are threats such as
Issues with the present legal framework
Registration of Antiquities: The AAT Act, 1972, provided that the
Central Government may specify those antiquities which should be
registered under the Act. As per the extant provisions, registration of
the artefacts was not mandatory.
Further, the registration process was not based on scientific testing
but relied on discretion. Hence, its accuracy may be ambiguous
and subject to disputes.
Digitisation and documentation of Art objects: Documentation of
art heritage is a gaping hole in efforts to preserve and safeguard
heritage.
Repatriation of artifacts: The ASI stated that the restitution of the
objects which were taken out of the country prior to the enforcement of
the Act was not within its control.
Hence they had to depend on the goodwill of other countries for
their restitution.
Lack of integrated planning: Many archaeological sites have been
destroyed or explored due to developmental activities, emphasizing the
need for cultural resource management.
For instance, in 2020, evidence of the Ochre Coloured Pottery
(OCP) culture (2100-1900 BCE) emerged in Chandayan, Uttar
Pradesh. However, due to the land still being under cultivation,
the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has been unable to
commence excavation.
Issue with ASI: According to parliamentary standing committee, ASI
working is plagued by lack of centralised monitoring of excavation
activities, lack of action plans, and insufficient budget allocation.
Lack of Coordination: Inadequate coordination between central and
state bodies impairs heritage conservation efforts. For instance,
the Elephanta Caves have faced neglect and deterioration.
Natural Disasters and changing climate: India's tropical climate
leads to extreme temperatures, humidity, air conditions, and
contaminants which is changing due to rise in temperature
For e.g. red fort was flooded recently due to flood in Yamuna
river, effects of pollution in Taj mahal, etc.
Treats to performing art: Financial constraints, a lack of institutional
support, and waning enthusiasm among the younger generation are
hampering preforming art such as Tamasha, thali ki Ramayana, etc.
Illicit trafficking of cultural property driven by greed and lack of
heritage appreciation, deprive nations of their heritage and impede
archaeological research.
For example, Bronze Nataraja statues smuggled from Tamil Nadu
temples are linked to organized crimes, money laundering, and
terrorist financing.
6.
What are the measures required to preserve and celebrate India’s cultur
al heritage?
India's cultural heritage is a vast and diverse treasure that requires concerted
efforts to preserve and celebrate. A comprehensive approach to safeguarding
this heritage involves several key measures:
Revamping ASI: It can be provided with better funding and ensure that all
the conservation processes employed at the Centrally protected monuments
are backed by well-documented scientific research.
National Database: Collaboration between ISRO and the Ministry of
Culture should lead to a comprehensive, GIS-based national database of
heritage sites, ensuring efficient preservation.
An overarching management plan is required to revive the heritage
structures with creating a National Archaeological Database at the
outset.
Use of Technology: Implement advanced technologies
like Photogrammetry, 3D Laser scanning, LiDAR, Block chain
technology and Satellite Remote Sensing Surveys in documentation,
surveys, excavation, and conservation efforts.
Excavation and Exploration of Archaeological Sites: Draft of Excavation
and Exploration Policy to be finalized and adopted after public discussion
and Archaeology to be recognised as a separate Cadre as suggested by
Heritage Tourism and Education: Promote heritage tourism to preserve
cultural and historic resources while creating economic opportunities and
raising awareness. The guidelines of the National Conservation
policy(given below )need to be implemented vigorously.
An archaeological site should be subjected to minimum - whilst
only necessary - interventions so as to maintain its authenticity and
integrity.
Conservation should be treated as a multi-disciplinary
enterprise that focuses on developing holistic solutions
Disaster Management Plan should be made as an important pre-
requisite of the Conservation Plan for a monument.
Funding: From ‘crowd funding’ to ‘community funding’, new funding
models can be explored. Also, The ASI or State Archaeology
Departments need to identify projects that could be carried out in rural
areas with MNERGA funds.
Dissemination of cultural heritage information to the Citizens: A
national campaign like the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan can be started
to leverage behavioural economics in changing the perception of
citizens and instilling a sense of pride towards our composite heritage.
Involvement of private sector: National level, State level,
District level competitions focusing on culture can be promoted
regularly.
Private sector can also be encouraged to promote culture
through their CSR programs.
Preserving performing arts: Developing the idea of a specific
museum (Living Home) of live performing arts at the regional
level is needed.
Documentation and the establishment of a performing
arts council at the regional level to ensure the substantial
existence of the art form.