OER Impact Research
Nov 13, 2019, 12:00 pm PST
Welcome to
image: pixabay.com
Unless otherwise indicated, this presentation is licensed CC-BY 4.0
Agenda
● Introductions
● CCCOER overview
● Access hypothesis
● OER research to-date
● Designing OER impact research
● Q & A
● Upcoming events and announcements
Speakers
Moderator: Nathan Smith
OER Faculty-In-Residence
Houston Community College
Virginia Clinton
Assistant Professor,
Education, Health & Behavior
University of North Dakota
Phillip Grimaldi
Director of Research
OpenStax
Rice University
● Expand awareness & access to high-
quality OER
● Support faculty choice & development
● Inform regional leadership
● Improve student success
CCCOER Mission
Membership Fall 2019
http://cccoer.org/Member
15 State-wide Memberships
New Members:
Trinity Valley
Community College
Texas
Butler Community
College
Kansas
CCCOER Presents: OER Impact Research
Getting to know our guests
What is your research background and how does it now intersect with
OER?
Phillip Grimaldi, OpenStax, Rice University
Virginia Clinton, University of North Dakota
What is the access hypothesis?
● Students who do not have access to course materials will perform
worse than student who do have access.
● Interventions aimed at improving access will help, but only students
who did not have access to begin with.
● Depending on existing access rates, access interventions may not
have any observable effects on the overall population.
What’s the bottom-line conclusion from
over a decade of OER research?
• Open textbooks have equivalent learning outcomes as commercial
textbooks (22 studies, over 100,000 students)
• no differences based on instructor, same assessment, or incorporating
student prior knowledge/achievement
• Courses with open textbooks have lower withdrawal rates than
courses with commercial textbooks (11 studies, over 78,000
students)
Discussion: so what does this all
mean?
How can institutions set up good
OER impact research?
Key research questions
• Cost savings to students
• Outcomes (pass rates, completion rates)
• Usage of OER vs traditional textbooks (print vs digital)
• Perceptions of OER
• Examining specific sub-groups who will benefit most
• Examining specific implementation strategies
• Education, pedagogy, and OER
Other areas: enrollment intensity, persistence, degree completion
Collaborative Projects
• Human Subjects Research issues
• What is this and why does it matter?
• Collaborate with researchers at other institutions
An example:
• HCC and Rice Openstax
• IRB approval
• Data sharing agreement
• Data sharing processes
Links for reading:
1. John Hilton III. “Open Educational Resources, Student Efficacy, and User
Perceptions: A Synthesis of Research Published Between 2015 and 2018.”
Education Tech Research Dev, 6 August, 2019. https://doi.org/10/1007/s11423-
019-09700-4
2. Virginia Clinton and Shafiq Khan. “Efficacy of Open Textbook Adoption on
Learning Performance and Course Withdrawal Rates: A Meta-Analysis.”
American Educational Research Association, 2019, 5 (3), 1-20.
https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858419872212
3. Phillip Grimaldi, Debshila Basu Mallick, Andrew Waters, Richard Baraniuk. “Do
Open Educational Resources Improve Student Learning? Implications of the
Access Hypothesis.” PLOS One 14(3)
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0212508
Also, check out the Open Ed Group
http://openedgroup.org/
Highlights:
• OER Research Toolkit
• OER Adoption Impact Calculator
• The Review Project
Stay in the Loop
● Upcoming Conferences
See our website under “Get-Involved”
● Join our Community Email
○ https://www.cccoer.org/community-email/
● Read our EDI blog posts
○ https://www.cccoer.org
Image: pixabay.com
http://cccoer.org
Fall Webinar Series
(12pm/3pm EST)
Image: pixabay.com
Aug 27 Who/What/Where/Why/How of CCCOER
Sept 18 Copyright and Licensing with OER
Oct 16 Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion in OER
Nov 13 OER Impact Research
Dec 4 Conference Recap and Reflections: OpenEd and OE
Global
Descriptions & Registration: bit.ly/CCCOERfall2019
CCCOER Presents: OER Impact Research
Questions?
Contact Info:
@unatdaly -- unatdaly@oeconsortium.org
@cccoer Liz Yata -- lizyata@oeconsortium.org
Lisa Young -- lisa.young@scottsdalecc.edu
@suetash Sue Tashjian -- stashjian@necc.mass.edu
Thank you!

More Related Content

PPT
2015 Education Faculty: Large classes presentation
PPTX
What are the expectations of disabled learners when participating in MOOCs?
PPTX
School of Law Connect Project
 
PPTX
Application of Significance Tests to Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs)
PPTX
OER Landscape: Zero Textbook Cost Degrees
PDF
PolicyOptions.org Network- Planning Next Steps with Local Bureaus
PPT
International collaboration in learning and teaching- Higher Education
PPTX
ITHAKA The Next Wave 2017: Jade Winn - Student Success Research: Information ...
 
2015 Education Faculty: Large classes presentation
What are the expectations of disabled learners when participating in MOOCs?
School of Law Connect Project
 
Application of Significance Tests to Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs)
OER Landscape: Zero Textbook Cost Degrees
PolicyOptions.org Network- Planning Next Steps with Local Bureaus
International collaboration in learning and teaching- Higher Education
ITHAKA The Next Wave 2017: Jade Winn - Student Success Research: Information ...
 

What's hot (18)

PDF
Students as researchers - Jenni Carr
PPT
Conference teaching and_learning_entrepreneurship_what_works (1)
PPT
Pedagogical change
PPTX
The Punishment for Dreamers - Adam Murray
PPTX
Decolonising DMU: Building the Anti-Racist University
PDF
The Next 25 Years: Bonner's Commitment to Access & Engagement
PPTX
Toward a science of honors education
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Culture Shift to Academic Freedom
PPTX
Kate Brown and Rita Ieshu - Guelph Accessibility Conference - Presentation Sl...
PDF
Kilgore & AraĂşjo: Improving Student Equity with Great Instructional Design
PPTX
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning): embedding information lite...
PPTX
The Impact of Open Textbooks in the USA and South Africa: When? Why? How?
PPT
Introduction to LEAP
PDF
Participedia.net Teaching and Learning from Cases (webinar)
PPT
Distance Learning for Health Workshop: Public Health Online Courses - Jessica...
 
PDF
Empowering Students as Colleagues: New Ideas and Examples from the Field
PPTX
SD DL Academy 2017 - Best Practices in Blended and Distance Learning in Canada
Students as researchers - Jenni Carr
Conference teaching and_learning_entrepreneurship_what_works (1)
Pedagogical change
The Punishment for Dreamers - Adam Murray
Decolonising DMU: Building the Anti-Racist University
The Next 25 Years: Bonner's Commitment to Access & Engagement
Toward a science of honors education
CCCOER Presents: Culture Shift to Academic Freedom
Kate Brown and Rita Ieshu - Guelph Accessibility Conference - Presentation Sl...
Kilgore & AraĂşjo: Improving Student Equity with Great Instructional Design
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning): embedding information lite...
The Impact of Open Textbooks in the USA and South Africa: When? Why? How?
Introduction to LEAP
Participedia.net Teaching and Learning from Cases (webinar)
Distance Learning for Health Workshop: Public Health Online Courses - Jessica...
 
Empowering Students as Colleagues: New Ideas and Examples from the Field
SD DL Academy 2017 - Best Practices in Blended and Distance Learning in Canada
Ad

Similar to CCCOER Presents: OER Impact Research (20)

PPTX
Introduction to OER with CCCOER
PPTX
Transforming Learning with Open Educational Practices and Pedagogy
PPT
what-is-critical-thinking.ppt
PPTX
Reducing Equity Gaps & Creating Reliency with OER
PPTX
Collaborating with Students on OER Advocacy
PPTX
College Textbook Affordability Student Survey Findings
PPTX
Collaborating in the development of information literacy - Baume, Secker, Wol...
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Fall 2019 Open Education Conferences Recap
PDF
The Context for Civic Learning and Engagement in Higher Education Today
PPTX
Collaborating in the development of learning literacies
 
PPTX
Ontario Ministry of Education: CCCOER Presentation
PPTX
Tools and resources to empower meaningful partnerships with students / Caitri...
PPTX
Systematic Review And Environmental Scan On Digital Learning At Minority Serv...
PPTX
Pedagogy in Public: Open Education for Transformational Teaching
PPTX
Science of Team Science 2013: Regional Networks to Stimulate Multi-directiona...
PDF
Collective Case Study of LGU Leadership on Retention of Students with Learnin...
PPT
Institutionalization of American Democracy Project
PDF
Engaged Signature Work: Presentation for Rutgers University New Brunswick
PPTX
Social Media used as part of Co-Created Undergraduate Learning
PPTX
Introduction to Open: Plymouth State CETL Presentation
Introduction to OER with CCCOER
Transforming Learning with Open Educational Practices and Pedagogy
what-is-critical-thinking.ppt
Reducing Equity Gaps & Creating Reliency with OER
Collaborating with Students on OER Advocacy
College Textbook Affordability Student Survey Findings
Collaborating in the development of information literacy - Baume, Secker, Wol...
CCCOER Presents: Fall 2019 Open Education Conferences Recap
The Context for Civic Learning and Engagement in Higher Education Today
Collaborating in the development of learning literacies
 
Ontario Ministry of Education: CCCOER Presentation
Tools and resources to empower meaningful partnerships with students / Caitri...
Systematic Review And Environmental Scan On Digital Learning At Minority Serv...
Pedagogy in Public: Open Education for Transformational Teaching
Science of Team Science 2013: Regional Networks to Stimulate Multi-directiona...
Collective Case Study of LGU Leadership on Retention of Students with Learnin...
Institutionalization of American Democracy Project
Engaged Signature Work: Presentation for Rutgers University New Brunswick
Social Media used as part of Co-Created Undergraduate Learning
Introduction to Open: Plymouth State CETL Presentation
Ad

More from Una Daly (20)

PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Models for Transforming Cassrooms to be Equitable and Antira...
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Professional Development Resources for OER Adoption and Crea...
PPTX
K-12 and Community Colleges Collaborations on OER
PPTX
Open for AntiRacism: The Math Equity Toolkit
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Inclusive Course Design and Materials
PPTX
Integrating Antiracist Pedagogy into Your Classroom
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Navigating the Virtual Open Education Conferences
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Decolonizing The Course
PPTX
California ZTC Degrees Panel: Past, Present, and Future
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: User Friendly OER Course Design for Remote and F2F Learning
PPTX
Open Education Resilience in Crisis and Beyond
PPTX
Faculty and Students Share about Open Pedagogy
PPTX
Open Education Week: Students and OER Advocacy
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Regional Leaders of Open Education
PPTX
Beginning to Open Up: Ideas for Colleges Early in their OER Journey
PPTX
Arizona OER Summit: Connections to Sustain and Grow Open Education
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Attributions. Authoring, and OER Platforms
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion in OER
PPTX
CCCOER Presents: Copyright and Open Licensing Panel
PPTX
CCCOER: Who What Where Why How of OER
CCCOER Presents: Models for Transforming Cassrooms to be Equitable and Antira...
CCCOER Presents: Professional Development Resources for OER Adoption and Crea...
K-12 and Community Colleges Collaborations on OER
Open for AntiRacism: The Math Equity Toolkit
CCCOER Presents: Inclusive Course Design and Materials
Integrating Antiracist Pedagogy into Your Classroom
CCCOER Presents: Navigating the Virtual Open Education Conferences
CCCOER Presents: Decolonizing The Course
California ZTC Degrees Panel: Past, Present, and Future
CCCOER Presents: User Friendly OER Course Design for Remote and F2F Learning
Open Education Resilience in Crisis and Beyond
Faculty and Students Share about Open Pedagogy
Open Education Week: Students and OER Advocacy
CCCOER Presents: Regional Leaders of Open Education
Beginning to Open Up: Ideas for Colleges Early in their OER Journey
Arizona OER Summit: Connections to Sustain and Grow Open Education
CCCOER Presents: Attributions. Authoring, and OER Platforms
CCCOER Presents: Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion in OER
CCCOER Presents: Copyright and Open Licensing Panel
CCCOER: Who What Where Why How of OER

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Macbeth play - analysis .pptx english lit
PDF
Environmental Education MCQ BD2EE - Share Source.pdf
PPTX
ELIAS-SEZIURE AND EPilepsy semmioan session.pptx
PDF
MICROENCAPSULATION_NDDS_BPHARMACY__SEM VII_PCI Syllabus.pdf
PDF
M.Tech in Aerospace Engineering | BIT Mesra
PPTX
What’s under the hood: Parsing standardized learning content for AI
PDF
Farming Based Livelihood Systems English Notes
PDF
LEARNERS WITH ADDITIONAL NEEDS ProfEd Topic
PDF
MA in English at Shiv Nadar University – Advanced Literature, Language & Rese...
PPTX
2025 High Blood Pressure Guideline Slide Set.pptx
PDF
Myanmar Dental Journal, The Journal of the Myanmar Dental Association (2013).pdf
PDF
MBA _Common_ 2nd year Syllabus _2021-22_.pdf
PDF
LIFE & LIVING TRILOGY - PART - (2) THE PURPOSE OF LIFE.pdf
PPTX
Thinking Routines and Learning Engagements.pptx
PDF
Journal of Dental Science - UDMY (2020).pdf
PDF
English-bài kiᝃm tra tiếng anh cƥ bản.pdf
PDF
LIFE & LIVING TRILOGY - PART (3) REALITY & MYSTERY.pdf
PDF
Fun with Grammar (Communicative Activities for the Azar Grammar Series)
PDF
fundamentals-of-heat-and-mass-transfer-6th-edition_incropera.pdf
PDF
The TKT Course. Modules 1, 2, 3.for self study
Macbeth play - analysis .pptx english lit
Environmental Education MCQ BD2EE - Share Source.pdf
ELIAS-SEZIURE AND EPilepsy semmioan session.pptx
MICROENCAPSULATION_NDDS_BPHARMACY__SEM VII_PCI Syllabus.pdf
M.Tech in Aerospace Engineering | BIT Mesra
What’s under the hood: Parsing standardized learning content for AI
Farming Based Livelihood Systems English Notes
LEARNERS WITH ADDITIONAL NEEDS ProfEd Topic
MA in English at Shiv Nadar University – Advanced Literature, Language & Rese...
2025 High Blood Pressure Guideline Slide Set.pptx
Myanmar Dental Journal, The Journal of the Myanmar Dental Association (2013).pdf
MBA _Common_ 2nd year Syllabus _2021-22_.pdf
LIFE & LIVING TRILOGY - PART - (2) THE PURPOSE OF LIFE.pdf
Thinking Routines and Learning Engagements.pptx
Journal of Dental Science - UDMY (2020).pdf
English-bài kiᝃm tra tiếng anh cƥ bản.pdf
LIFE & LIVING TRILOGY - PART (3) REALITY & MYSTERY.pdf
Fun with Grammar (Communicative Activities for the Azar Grammar Series)
fundamentals-of-heat-and-mass-transfer-6th-edition_incropera.pdf
The TKT Course. Modules 1, 2, 3.for self study

CCCOER Presents: OER Impact Research

  • 1. OER Impact Research Nov 13, 2019, 12:00 pm PST Welcome to image: pixabay.com Unless otherwise indicated, this presentation is licensed CC-BY 4.0
  • 2. Agenda ● Introductions ● CCCOER overview ● Access hypothesis ● OER research to-date ● Designing OER impact research ● Q & A ● Upcoming events and announcements
  • 3. Speakers Moderator: Nathan Smith OER Faculty-In-Residence Houston Community College Virginia Clinton Assistant Professor, Education, Health & Behavior University of North Dakota Phillip Grimaldi Director of Research OpenStax Rice University
  • 4. ● Expand awareness & access to high- quality OER ● Support faculty choice & development ● Inform regional leadership ● Improve student success CCCOER Mission
  • 5. Membership Fall 2019 http://cccoer.org/Member 15 State-wide Memberships New Members: Trinity Valley Community College Texas Butler Community College Kansas
  • 7. Getting to know our guests What is your research background and how does it now intersect with OER? Phillip Grimaldi, OpenStax, Rice University Virginia Clinton, University of North Dakota
  • 8. What is the access hypothesis? ● Students who do not have access to course materials will perform worse than student who do have access. ● Interventions aimed at improving access will help, but only students who did not have access to begin with. ● Depending on existing access rates, access interventions may not have any observable effects on the overall population.
  • 9. What’s the bottom-line conclusion from over a decade of OER research? • Open textbooks have equivalent learning outcomes as commercial textbooks (22 studies, over 100,000 students) • no differences based on instructor, same assessment, or incorporating student prior knowledge/achievement • Courses with open textbooks have lower withdrawal rates than courses with commercial textbooks (11 studies, over 78,000 students)
  • 10. Discussion: so what does this all mean?
  • 11. How can institutions set up good OER impact research?
  • 12. Key research questions • Cost savings to students • Outcomes (pass rates, completion rates) • Usage of OER vs traditional textbooks (print vs digital) • Perceptions of OER • Examining specific sub-groups who will benefit most • Examining specific implementation strategies • Education, pedagogy, and OER Other areas: enrollment intensity, persistence, degree completion
  • 13. Collaborative Projects • Human Subjects Research issues • What is this and why does it matter? • Collaborate with researchers at other institutions An example: • HCC and Rice Openstax • IRB approval • Data sharing agreement • Data sharing processes
  • 14. Links for reading: 1. John Hilton III. “Open Educational Resources, Student Efficacy, and User Perceptions: A Synthesis of Research Published Between 2015 and 2018.” Education Tech Research Dev, 6 August, 2019. https://doi.org/10/1007/s11423- 019-09700-4 2. Virginia Clinton and Shafiq Khan. “Efficacy of Open Textbook Adoption on Learning Performance and Course Withdrawal Rates: A Meta-Analysis.” American Educational Research Association, 2019, 5 (3), 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858419872212 3. Phillip Grimaldi, Debshila Basu Mallick, Andrew Waters, Richard Baraniuk. “Do Open Educational Resources Improve Student Learning? Implications of the Access Hypothesis.” PLOS One 14(3) https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0212508
  • 15. Also, check out the Open Ed Group http://openedgroup.org/ Highlights: • OER Research Toolkit • OER Adoption Impact Calculator • The Review Project
  • 16. Stay in the Loop ● Upcoming Conferences See our website under “Get-Involved” ● Join our Community Email ○ https://www.cccoer.org/community-email/ ● Read our EDI blog posts ○ https://www.cccoer.org Image: pixabay.com http://cccoer.org
  • 17. Fall Webinar Series (12pm/3pm EST) Image: pixabay.com Aug 27 Who/What/Where/Why/How of CCCOER Sept 18 Copyright and Licensing with OER Oct 16 Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion in OER Nov 13 OER Impact Research Dec 4 Conference Recap and Reflections: OpenEd and OE Global Descriptions & Registration: bit.ly/CCCOERfall2019
  • 19. Questions? Contact Info: @unatdaly -- [email protected] @cccoer Liz Yata -- [email protected] Lisa Young -- [email protected] @suetash Sue Tashjian -- [email protected] Thank you!