SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Worst Practices:
Ten Things I Hate About Bad
Section 106 and NEPA Reviews
Elizabeth Merritt, Deputy General Counsel,
National Trust for Historic Preservation
JULY 17, 2012
Consultation
Logistics and
  Practices


                2
Public Notice Designed to be
      Under the Radar




                               3
Lack of Transparency and Poor
       Communication




                                4
Not Conducive to
Consultation or Dialogue




                           5
Inadequate Telecommunications
      Equipment or Setup




                                6
Too Much Paper Can Actually
 Hide Important Information




                              7
Creating a Climate of
Exclusion and Intimidation




                             8
The Cone of Silence:
Secret Negotiations With NPS or SHPO




                                       9
Secret Negotiations




                      10
Have I Got a Deal For You!




                             11
Political pressure on SHPOs




                              12
Back-stabbing




                13
Crocodile Tears




                  14
Inadequate Tribal Consultation




                                 15
Special Privileges for Concurring Parties




                                            16
Take It Or Leave It!




                       17
Outcomes

           18
Document and Destroy Outcomes




                                19
Winning the Battle But Losing the War:
    Saving a Bridge to Nowhere




                                         20
Statewide PAs with
Little or No Public Consultation




                                   21
22

More Related Content

DOC
Sibling Rivalry in the Upper Midwest (notes)
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Emerging Middle Class in Urban Pittsburgh
preservationcombination
 
PDF
Integrating Historic Preservation into Disaster Planning and Recovery
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Life on the Riverfront: 1800 to 1900
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Starch Grain and Phytolith Evidence of Seed and Tuber Processing
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Identifying and Evaluating Historic Significance of Post-WWII Housing
preservationcombination
 
PPT
PA SHPO's Goals and Guidance for Post-WWII Resources
preservationcombination
 
PPT
The Architecture of Consumerism
preservationcombination
 
Sibling Rivalry in the Upper Midwest (notes)
preservationcombination
 
Emerging Middle Class in Urban Pittsburgh
preservationcombination
 
Integrating Historic Preservation into Disaster Planning and Recovery
preservationcombination
 
Life on the Riverfront: 1800 to 1900
preservationcombination
 
Starch Grain and Phytolith Evidence of Seed and Tuber Processing
preservationcombination
 
Identifying and Evaluating Historic Significance of Post-WWII Housing
preservationcombination
 
PA SHPO's Goals and Guidance for Post-WWII Resources
preservationcombination
 
The Architecture of Consumerism
preservationcombination
 

More from preservationcombination (20)

PPT
Case Study Bridge Relocation Project: Van Wert-Wall Street Bridge
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Speaking of Historic Preservation... Concepts, Terms, and Options
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Legal Framework for Shale Development and Cultural Resources
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Section 106 Review for Energy Projects: Issues and Recommendations
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Section 106 Considerations for Electric Infrastructure Projects
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Engaging Non-Resident Tribes
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Intro to Best Practices
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Historic Metal Truss Bridge Management Plan
preservationcombination
 
PPT
A FHWA National Perspective on Risky Archaeological Practices
preservationcombination
 
DOCX
Integrating Historic Preservation into Disaster Planning and Recovery
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
The Surface Transportation Board
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act and Beyond
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
Funding for Preservation and Transportation
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Our New Transportation Legislation
preservationcombination
 
PPT
Lancaster Central Market
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
Long Range Transportation Planning Partnership
preservationcombination
 
PDF
Lancaster County's Treasured Places
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
Incorporating Heritage Resources into the Lancaster County Long Range Transpo...
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
A Guide to Architectural Terms & Styles
preservationcombination
 
PPTX
Statewide Plan
preservationcombination
 
Case Study Bridge Relocation Project: Van Wert-Wall Street Bridge
preservationcombination
 
Speaking of Historic Preservation... Concepts, Terms, and Options
preservationcombination
 
Legal Framework for Shale Development and Cultural Resources
preservationcombination
 
Section 106 Review for Energy Projects: Issues and Recommendations
preservationcombination
 
Section 106 Considerations for Electric Infrastructure Projects
preservationcombination
 
Engaging Non-Resident Tribes
preservationcombination
 
Intro to Best Practices
preservationcombination
 
Historic Metal Truss Bridge Management Plan
preservationcombination
 
A FHWA National Perspective on Risky Archaeological Practices
preservationcombination
 
Integrating Historic Preservation into Disaster Planning and Recovery
preservationcombination
 
The Surface Transportation Board
preservationcombination
 
Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act and Beyond
preservationcombination
 
Funding for Preservation and Transportation
preservationcombination
 
Our New Transportation Legislation
preservationcombination
 
Lancaster Central Market
preservationcombination
 
Long Range Transportation Planning Partnership
preservationcombination
 
Lancaster County's Treasured Places
preservationcombination
 
Incorporating Heritage Resources into the Lancaster County Long Range Transpo...
preservationcombination
 
A Guide to Architectural Terms & Styles
preservationcombination
 
Statewide Plan
preservationcombination
 
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Hfxfitfidogaidsrixtocgockxifizhuffgoyfodti
WilfredSelorio
 
PDF
Scene from Dawn of the Croods animated series 01
Max Lawson
 
DOCX
The Unseen Guardian_ Why a Sports Safety Helmet is Essential for Every Child'...
Custom Printing Boxes
 
PDF
The Adventures of Master Faridi and Asim &The Secret of Mystery Island
hamid801536
 
PPTX
SAY THE LETTER NOT THE WORD!.powerpointx
JajaPlumaPorton
 
PDF
phylobook.pdf פילוסופייה:מבט מודרני לאוניד לדאטה
Leonid Ledata
 
PDF
RECEPTION PROGRAMME - RECEPTION PROGRAMME
Kweku Zurek
 
PDF
Vocal Remover for Every Creator: How unMix Powers Your Workflow
unMIx VocalRemover
 
PDF
3Below Moon fight sequence which happens on the moon
Max Lawson
 
PDF
japanese style violent manga guts -v01.pdf
vsevolodovichnikolai
 
DOCX
Jumping Jacks_ The Timeless Powerhouse of Fitness.docx
Custom Printing Boxes
 
PPTX
Amanat Mann IPS Solving The Third Key – A Silent Game of Justice.pptx
vijayrahavin
 
PPTX
3rd week continents.pptxsswdewceceededede
EmanEssa14
 
PPTX
Shyrete Behluli alanian njeri slay yayayya
g52ps246s2
 
PPTX
Understanding RCS Communication Features and Benefits_ (1).pptx
Times Mobile
 
PDF
Lucky_mangA chapter 1 Story and Art by Enaji studio
gosinaohuawunwa
 
DOCX
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGCELL DISCOVERY METHOD.docx
JohnPaulCamitan
 
PPTX
Superman Template Design “Superman,” DC Studios’ first feature film to hit th...
timesidiomasaulas
 
PPTX
Module 4 PPT 2.pptx hnfvrinv[rwogvjw]vpno
Alka392097
 
PDF
Alizeh: A Radiant Icon Among Pakistani Clothing Brands for Women’s Ethnic Fas...
Alizeh Fashion
 
Hfxfitfidogaidsrixtocgockxifizhuffgoyfodti
WilfredSelorio
 
Scene from Dawn of the Croods animated series 01
Max Lawson
 
The Unseen Guardian_ Why a Sports Safety Helmet is Essential for Every Child'...
Custom Printing Boxes
 
The Adventures of Master Faridi and Asim &The Secret of Mystery Island
hamid801536
 
SAY THE LETTER NOT THE WORD!.powerpointx
JajaPlumaPorton
 
phylobook.pdf פילוסופייה:מבט מודרני לאוניד לדאטה
Leonid Ledata
 
RECEPTION PROGRAMME - RECEPTION PROGRAMME
Kweku Zurek
 
Vocal Remover for Every Creator: How unMix Powers Your Workflow
unMIx VocalRemover
 
3Below Moon fight sequence which happens on the moon
Max Lawson
 
japanese style violent manga guts -v01.pdf
vsevolodovichnikolai
 
Jumping Jacks_ The Timeless Powerhouse of Fitness.docx
Custom Printing Boxes
 
Amanat Mann IPS Solving The Third Key – A Silent Game of Justice.pptx
vijayrahavin
 
3rd week continents.pptxsswdewceceededede
EmanEssa14
 
Shyrete Behluli alanian njeri slay yayayya
g52ps246s2
 
Understanding RCS Communication Features and Benefits_ (1).pptx
Times Mobile
 
Lucky_mangA chapter 1 Story and Art by Enaji studio
gosinaohuawunwa
 
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGCELL DISCOVERY METHOD.docx
JohnPaulCamitan
 
Superman Template Design “Superman,” DC Studios’ first feature film to hit th...
timesidiomasaulas
 
Module 4 PPT 2.pptx hnfvrinv[rwogvjw]vpno
Alka392097
 
Alizeh: A Radiant Icon Among Pakistani Clothing Brands for Women’s Ethnic Fas...
Alizeh Fashion
 
Ad

Ten Things I Hate About Bad Section 106 and NEPA Reviews