Margaret Talbot's article "Best in Class" discusses the debate around choosing a valedictorian. Some argue the traditional highest GPA method is unfair, as it doesn't account for other factors. The article profiles a school that switched to a new selection process, sparking controversy among students and parents. While opponents claim the change is unfair, supporters believe a student's character is just as important as grades. The article examines arguments on both sides of this complex issue around honoring academic achievement.