SlideShare a Scribd company logo
www.elixir-europe.org/excelerateELIXIR-EXCELERATE is funded by the European
Commission within the Research Infrastructures programme
of Horizon 2020, grant agreement number 676559.
TeSS: The ELIXIR Training Portal
Niall Beard
Carole Goble, Teresa Attwood, Susanna Assunta-Sansone
Finn Bacall, Milo Thurston
ELIXIR Webinar series
2pm GMT - 15th February 2017
ELIXIR Platforms
+ Use Cases
ELIXIR: A (very) distributed infrastructure for
Life science information
Institutions and organization providing training
materials, courses, and eLearning
+ many, many, many more
Training discovery platform v0.0.1
Aka, Google it
Great discovery tool…
•If you know the specific name of the thing you’re looking for
(e.g. ‘EuBIC Winter School’).
•Not so great if you just want to see what proteomics related
events are available
The Long Tail of Training Resources
Number of websites
Volumeofmaterials Large institutions and repositories
>30 training resources
Significant online presence
Favoured by search engines
Smaller websites
<30 training resources
Often buried in search results
Quick TeSS Overview
• Aggregation and registration of training events and
materials
• Tools to filter, search, and discover
• Users can organize into packages and training workflows
• Interlinking with other ELIXIR registries
• ELIXIR Node ‘shop window’ view
• https://tess.elixir-europe.org
TeSS Materials index page
Filter By:
Content Provider
Scientific Topic
Tool
Standards
Policies
Target Audience
Keyword
Difficulty Level
Author
Contributor
Licence
ELIXIR Node
Search for text and
order results
Link to other resources
(from ELIXIR registries
and other)
Subscribe to calendar feeds
Embed in your sites using iAnn widget
Visual Workflows
• Developing workflows to represent typical
data analyses.
• Attaching tools, training, and other
resources to each stage.
Registry integration
• Associate TeSS resources
with bio.tools and
Biosharing.org resources.
• Search for all training
materials about a specific
tool, standard operating
procedure, database etc.
• Tool-centric search
Usage statistics
•From 33 Content Providers
• 244 Upcoming Events
• 5900 Past Events
• 569 Materials
•1 completed workflow (EMBER)
• Construction of 3 new workflows underway
• Many existing workflows being converted to TeSS format soon
•541 users in past month
• 4,704 since analytics began Jan 2016
•Workshop feedback surveys have reported some attendees
discovered the event through TeSS
TeSS summary
•Primarily Aggregated + some registered Materials and Events
• Search and Filter features to help discovery
• Training workflows to help educate and navigate
• Subscription services to consistently keep people updated
• iAnn events widgets to expose in other websites
• Integration with bio.tools and biosharing.org
• ELIXIR node views to show what
•Upcoming:
• More curation tools community aided annotation, automated
• Collaboration with BD2Ks training portal
• More integrations with other information services
•Datasets, Containers, VMs
Aggregation – Not a very API situation
Medium/Small sites -
Manual entry
HTML scraper
• Difficult to write.
• - Every site is unique
• - Some have more treacherous HTML
• Very susceptible to change
• - Fixing is re-implementing.
• - Build up of technical debt
http://cdn2.bigcommerce.com/server100/367cc/p
<p>Mon, 27 Feb 2017, 12:00 –</p>
Enter: Schema.org
Metadata model
ie. Recipe type
ELIXIR Webinar: Introducing TeSS
<div itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Recipe">
<div itemprop="nutrition” itemscope
itemtype="http://schema.org/NutritionInformation">
Nutrition facts:
<span itemprop="calories">144 kcal</span>,
</div>
Ingredients:
- <span itemprop="recipeIngredient">800g small new potato</span>
- <span itemprop="recipeIngredient">3 shallot</span>
. . .
<script type="application/ld+json">
{
"@context": "http://schema.org",
"@type": ”Recipe",
"name": ”Potato Salad",
“NutritionInformation”: {
"calories”: “144 kcal”,
"recipeIngredient”: “800g small new potato”,
"recipeIngredient”: “3 shallot”
. . .
ELIXIR Webinar: Introducing TeSS
Tools to parse
Tools to parse
Mark up using schema.org – Google Markup Helper
Mark up using schema.org –Google Markup Helper
TeSS can then parse the schema.org structured data
Other ways
•By hand
•By one of the many CMS extensions
•Many online tools
What is Bioschemas
• Developing schema.org
specifications to work for Life
sciences
• Proposing amendments and
new schemas to be able to
describe Life science
resources.
• Events and CreativeWork
(materials). Also for tools,
data, data repositories
Image: http://bioschemas.org/
Minimum information
Controlled vocabula
Cardinality
Data model
New properties
Bioschemas
compliant
Bioschemas
compliant
API
API
Special thanks to TeSS and Bioschemas’
collaborators, our guinea pigs, and community
TeSS Team
Finn Bacall
Milo Thurston
Aleksandra Nenadic (past member)
Susanna-Assunta Sansone
Teresa Attwood
Carole Goble
Thanks to
The ELIXIR Training Co-ordinators
Rafael Jiminez
Martin Cook
Premysl Veselyk
Gabriella Rustici
Dominique Batista
Christof De Bo
Alex Botzki
+ Many more
https://tess.elixir-europe.org and http://bioschemas.org

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (20)

PPTX
Control flow in_elixir
Anna Neyzberg
 
PDF
Spring IO for startups
Alex Fruzenshtein
 
PDF
Flowex: Flow-Based Programming with Elixir GenStage - Anton Mishchuk
Elixir Club
 
PPTX
Phoenix: Inflame the Web - Alex Troush
Elixir Club
 
PDF
GenStage and Flow - Jose Valim
Elixir Club
 
PDF
Distributed system in Elixir
Changwook Park
 
PPTX
Proteome array - antibody based proteome arrays
saraswathi rajakumar
 
PDF
Elixir & Phoenix 推坑
Chao-Ju Huang
 
PDF
Bottleneck in Elixir Application - Alexey Osipenko
Elixir Club
 
PPTX
Anatomy of an elixir process and Actor Communication
Mustafa TURAN
 
PDF
Build Your Own Real-Time Web Service with Elixir Phoenix
Chi-chi Ekweozor
 
ODP
Elixir basics
Ruben Amortegui
 
PDF
Play vs Rails
Daniel Cukier
 
PDF
Professional Programmer (3 Years Later)
Gabriele Lana
 
PDF
Embedded Erlang, Nerves, and SumoBots
Frank Hunleth
 
PDF
Elixir and Dialyzer, Types and Typespecs, using and understanding them
Dan Janowski
 
PDF
How Elixir helped us scale our Video User Profile Service for the Olympics
Emerson Macedo
 
ODP
Elixir basics-2
Ruben Amortegui
 
PDF
Elixir – Peeking into Elixir's Processes, OTP and Supervisors
Benjamin Tan
 
Control flow in_elixir
Anna Neyzberg
 
Spring IO for startups
Alex Fruzenshtein
 
Flowex: Flow-Based Programming with Elixir GenStage - Anton Mishchuk
Elixir Club
 
Phoenix: Inflame the Web - Alex Troush
Elixir Club
 
GenStage and Flow - Jose Valim
Elixir Club
 
Distributed system in Elixir
Changwook Park
 
Proteome array - antibody based proteome arrays
saraswathi rajakumar
 
Elixir & Phoenix 推坑
Chao-Ju Huang
 
Bottleneck in Elixir Application - Alexey Osipenko
Elixir Club
 
Anatomy of an elixir process and Actor Communication
Mustafa TURAN
 
Build Your Own Real-Time Web Service with Elixir Phoenix
Chi-chi Ekweozor
 
Elixir basics
Ruben Amortegui
 
Play vs Rails
Daniel Cukier
 
Professional Programmer (3 Years Later)
Gabriele Lana
 
Embedded Erlang, Nerves, and SumoBots
Frank Hunleth
 
Elixir and Dialyzer, Types and Typespecs, using and understanding them
Dan Janowski
 
How Elixir helped us scale our Video User Profile Service for the Olympics
Emerson Macedo
 
Elixir basics-2
Ruben Amortegui
 
Elixir – Peeking into Elixir's Processes, OTP and Supervisors
Benjamin Tan
 

Similar to ELIXIR Webinar: Introducing TeSS (20)

PPTX
ELIXIR TeSS And Bioschemas: An aggregated portal and an aggregation tool
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
TeSS @ ISMB/ECCB 2017, Prague
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
TeSS: ELIXIR Training Portal (Eubic Winter School 2017)
Niall Beard
 
PDF
The ELIXIR UK training portal (TeSS) by Carole Goble
ELIXIR UK
 
PPTX
EADTU Conference - UKOER Technology Challenges
Lorna Campbell
 
PPTX
TeSS ELIXIR All Hands Rome 2017
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
Trust and identity
Jisc
 
PPTX
Bioschemas for Aggregating ELIXIR Events - Comms Webinar
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
TeSS training eSupport System
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
NDS Relevant Update from the NIH Data Science (ADDS) Office
Philip Bourne
 
PPTX
Bioschemas Workshop
Niall Beard
 
PPT
ELIXIR TCG update
Rafael C. Jimenez
 
PDF
Open Data Initiatives – Empowering Students to Make More Informed Choices? - ...
Terminalfour
 
PPTX
TLC2016 - A search engine for Blackboard Learn, the impossible made possible.
BlackboardEMEA
 
PPTX
Online data sources and information exposure
University of Southampton
 
PPTX
THOR Ambassador Webinar
Maaike Duine
 
PPT
Metadata-powered dissemination of content
Nikos Manouselis
 
PDF
#OSSPARIS19 : Comment ONLYOFFICE aide à organiser les travaux de recherches ...
Paris Open Source Summit
 
PPTX
Jisc learninganalytics hepsa-workshop 2018
Paul Bailey
 
PPT
Why are e-Infrastructures useful from a small business perspective?
Nikos Manouselis
 
ELIXIR TeSS And Bioschemas: An aggregated portal and an aggregation tool
Niall Beard
 
TeSS @ ISMB/ECCB 2017, Prague
Niall Beard
 
TeSS: ELIXIR Training Portal (Eubic Winter School 2017)
Niall Beard
 
The ELIXIR UK training portal (TeSS) by Carole Goble
ELIXIR UK
 
EADTU Conference - UKOER Technology Challenges
Lorna Campbell
 
TeSS ELIXIR All Hands Rome 2017
Niall Beard
 
Trust and identity
Jisc
 
Bioschemas for Aggregating ELIXIR Events - Comms Webinar
Niall Beard
 
TeSS training eSupport System
Niall Beard
 
NDS Relevant Update from the NIH Data Science (ADDS) Office
Philip Bourne
 
Bioschemas Workshop
Niall Beard
 
ELIXIR TCG update
Rafael C. Jimenez
 
Open Data Initiatives – Empowering Students to Make More Informed Choices? - ...
Terminalfour
 
TLC2016 - A search engine for Blackboard Learn, the impossible made possible.
BlackboardEMEA
 
Online data sources and information exposure
University of Southampton
 
THOR Ambassador Webinar
Maaike Duine
 
Metadata-powered dissemination of content
Nikos Manouselis
 
#OSSPARIS19 : Comment ONLYOFFICE aide à organiser les travaux de recherches ...
Paris Open Source Summit
 
Jisc learninganalytics hepsa-workshop 2018
Paul Bailey
 
Why are e-Infrastructures useful from a small business perspective?
Nikos Manouselis
 
Ad

More from Niall Beard (11)

PPTX
Concept Maps in TeSS
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
Bioschemas Adoption Meeting: Training materials and Events
Niall Beard
 
PDF
schema.org - Simple Structured Data for the Web
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
TeSS trcg meeting nov16
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
Bioschemas - TeSS Integration @ Rothamsted Hackathon 2016
Niall Beard
 
PPT
Bioschemas presentation at ECCB 2016, The Hague
Niall Beard
 
PPT
ISMB BioSchemas Presentation
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
RDA Web service discoverability workshop
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
Lightningtalk BioSchemas
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
TeSS Lightning Talk - cw16
Niall Beard
 
PPTX
The Biodiversity Catalogue and support for Web Map Services - TDWG 2015
Niall Beard
 
Concept Maps in TeSS
Niall Beard
 
Bioschemas Adoption Meeting: Training materials and Events
Niall Beard
 
schema.org - Simple Structured Data for the Web
Niall Beard
 
TeSS trcg meeting nov16
Niall Beard
 
Bioschemas - TeSS Integration @ Rothamsted Hackathon 2016
Niall Beard
 
Bioschemas presentation at ECCB 2016, The Hague
Niall Beard
 
ISMB BioSchemas Presentation
Niall Beard
 
RDA Web service discoverability workshop
Niall Beard
 
Lightningtalk BioSchemas
Niall Beard
 
TeSS Lightning Talk - cw16
Niall Beard
 
The Biodiversity Catalogue and support for Web Map Services - TDWG 2015
Niall Beard
 
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
PLANNING FOR EMERGENCY AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT ppt.pptx
PRADEEP ABOTHU
 
PPTX
SYMPATHOMIMETICS[ADRENERGIC AGONISTS] pptx
saip95568
 
PPTX
How to Manage Wins & Losses in Odoo 18 CRM
Celine George
 
PDF
Quiz Night Live May 2025 - Intra Pragya Online General Quiz
Pragya - UEM Kolkata Quiz Club
 
PDF
Andreas Schleicher_Teaching Compass_Education 2040.pdf
EduSkills OECD
 
PDF
Wikinomics How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything Don Tapscott
wcsqyzf5909
 
PPTX
How to Add a Custom Button in Odoo 18 POS Screen
Celine George
 
PPTX
Ward Management: Patient Care, Personnel, Equipment, and Environment.pptx
PRADEEP ABOTHU
 
PDF
DIGESTION OF CARBOHYDRATES ,PROTEINS AND LIPIDS
raviralanaresh2
 
PDF
Lesson 1 - Nature of Inquiry and Research.pdf
marvinnbustamante1
 
PPTX
How to Configure Refusal of Applicants in Odoo 18 Recruitment
Celine George
 
PDF
Cooperative wireless communications 1st Edition Yan Zhang
jsphyftmkb123
 
PPTX
Parsing HTML read and write operations and OS Module.pptx
Ramakrishna Reddy Bijjam
 
PDF
Indian National movement PPT by Simanchala Sarab, Covering The INC(Formation,...
Simanchala Sarab, BABed(ITEP Secondary stage) in History student at GNDU Amritsar
 
PPTX
week 1-2.pptx yueojerjdeiwmwjsweuwikwswiewjrwiwkw
rebznelz
 
PPTX
How to Setup Automatic Reordering Rule in Odoo 18 Inventory
Celine George
 
PPT
21st Century Literature from the Philippines and the World QUARTER 1/ MODULE ...
isaacmendoza76
 
PPTX
Comparing Translational and Rotational Motion.pptx
AngeliqueTolentinoDe
 
PDF
Genomics Proteomics and Vaccines 1st Edition Guido Grandi (Editor)
kboqcyuw976
 
PDF
Lesson 1 : Science and the Art of Geography Ecosystem
marvinnbustamante1
 
PLANNING FOR EMERGENCY AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT ppt.pptx
PRADEEP ABOTHU
 
SYMPATHOMIMETICS[ADRENERGIC AGONISTS] pptx
saip95568
 
How to Manage Wins & Losses in Odoo 18 CRM
Celine George
 
Quiz Night Live May 2025 - Intra Pragya Online General Quiz
Pragya - UEM Kolkata Quiz Club
 
Andreas Schleicher_Teaching Compass_Education 2040.pdf
EduSkills OECD
 
Wikinomics How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything Don Tapscott
wcsqyzf5909
 
How to Add a Custom Button in Odoo 18 POS Screen
Celine George
 
Ward Management: Patient Care, Personnel, Equipment, and Environment.pptx
PRADEEP ABOTHU
 
DIGESTION OF CARBOHYDRATES ,PROTEINS AND LIPIDS
raviralanaresh2
 
Lesson 1 - Nature of Inquiry and Research.pdf
marvinnbustamante1
 
How to Configure Refusal of Applicants in Odoo 18 Recruitment
Celine George
 
Cooperative wireless communications 1st Edition Yan Zhang
jsphyftmkb123
 
Parsing HTML read and write operations and OS Module.pptx
Ramakrishna Reddy Bijjam
 
Indian National movement PPT by Simanchala Sarab, Covering The INC(Formation,...
Simanchala Sarab, BABed(ITEP Secondary stage) in History student at GNDU Amritsar
 
week 1-2.pptx yueojerjdeiwmwjsweuwikwswiewjrwiwkw
rebznelz
 
How to Setup Automatic Reordering Rule in Odoo 18 Inventory
Celine George
 
21st Century Literature from the Philippines and the World QUARTER 1/ MODULE ...
isaacmendoza76
 
Comparing Translational and Rotational Motion.pptx
AngeliqueTolentinoDe
 
Genomics Proteomics and Vaccines 1st Edition Guido Grandi (Editor)
kboqcyuw976
 
Lesson 1 : Science and the Art of Geography Ecosystem
marvinnbustamante1
 

ELIXIR Webinar: Introducing TeSS

  • 1. www.elixir-europe.org/excelerateELIXIR-EXCELERATE is funded by the European Commission within the Research Infrastructures programme of Horizon 2020, grant agreement number 676559. TeSS: The ELIXIR Training Portal Niall Beard Carole Goble, Teresa Attwood, Susanna Assunta-Sansone Finn Bacall, Milo Thurston ELIXIR Webinar series 2pm GMT - 15th February 2017
  • 3. ELIXIR: A (very) distributed infrastructure for Life science information
  • 4. Institutions and organization providing training materials, courses, and eLearning + many, many, many more
  • 5. Training discovery platform v0.0.1 Aka, Google it
  • 6. Great discovery tool… •If you know the specific name of the thing you’re looking for (e.g. ‘EuBIC Winter School’). •Not so great if you just want to see what proteomics related events are available
  • 7. The Long Tail of Training Resources Number of websites Volumeofmaterials Large institutions and repositories >30 training resources Significant online presence Favoured by search engines Smaller websites <30 training resources Often buried in search results
  • 8. Quick TeSS Overview • Aggregation and registration of training events and materials • Tools to filter, search, and discover • Users can organize into packages and training workflows • Interlinking with other ELIXIR registries • ELIXIR Node ‘shop window’ view • https://tess.elixir-europe.org
  • 9. TeSS Materials index page Filter By: Content Provider Scientific Topic Tool Standards Policies Target Audience Keyword Difficulty Level Author Contributor Licence ELIXIR Node Search for text and order results
  • 10. Link to other resources (from ELIXIR registries and other)
  • 12. Embed in your sites using iAnn widget
  • 13. Visual Workflows • Developing workflows to represent typical data analyses. • Attaching tools, training, and other resources to each stage.
  • 14. Registry integration • Associate TeSS resources with bio.tools and Biosharing.org resources. • Search for all training materials about a specific tool, standard operating procedure, database etc. • Tool-centric search
  • 15. Usage statistics •From 33 Content Providers • 244 Upcoming Events • 5900 Past Events • 569 Materials •1 completed workflow (EMBER) • Construction of 3 new workflows underway • Many existing workflows being converted to TeSS format soon •541 users in past month • 4,704 since analytics began Jan 2016 •Workshop feedback surveys have reported some attendees discovered the event through TeSS
  • 16. TeSS summary •Primarily Aggregated + some registered Materials and Events • Search and Filter features to help discovery • Training workflows to help educate and navigate • Subscription services to consistently keep people updated • iAnn events widgets to expose in other websites • Integration with bio.tools and biosharing.org • ELIXIR node views to show what •Upcoming: • More curation tools community aided annotation, automated • Collaboration with BD2Ks training portal • More integrations with other information services •Datasets, Containers, VMs
  • 17. Aggregation – Not a very API situation
  • 19. HTML scraper • Difficult to write. • - Every site is unique • - Some have more treacherous HTML • Very susceptible to change • - Fixing is re-implementing. • - Build up of technical debt http://cdn2.bigcommerce.com/server100/367cc/p <p>Mon, 27 Feb 2017, 12:00 –</p>
  • 23. <div itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Recipe"> <div itemprop="nutrition” itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/NutritionInformation"> Nutrition facts: <span itemprop="calories">144 kcal</span>, </div> Ingredients: - <span itemprop="recipeIngredient">800g small new potato</span> - <span itemprop="recipeIngredient">3 shallot</span> . . .
  • 24. <script type="application/ld+json"> { "@context": "http://schema.org", "@type": ”Recipe", "name": ”Potato Salad", “NutritionInformation”: { "calories”: “144 kcal”, "recipeIngredient”: “800g small new potato”, "recipeIngredient”: “3 shallot” . . .
  • 28. Mark up using schema.org – Google Markup Helper
  • 29. Mark up using schema.org –Google Markup Helper
  • 30. TeSS can then parse the schema.org structured data
  • 31. Other ways •By hand •By one of the many CMS extensions •Many online tools
  • 32. What is Bioschemas • Developing schema.org specifications to work for Life sciences • Proposing amendments and new schemas to be able to describe Life science resources. • Events and CreativeWork (materials). Also for tools, data, data repositories Image: http://bioschemas.org/
  • 35. Special thanks to TeSS and Bioschemas’ collaborators, our guinea pigs, and community TeSS Team Finn Bacall Milo Thurston Aleksandra Nenadic (past member) Susanna-Assunta Sansone Teresa Attwood Carole Goble Thanks to The ELIXIR Training Co-ordinators Rafael Jiminez Martin Cook Premysl Veselyk Gabriella Rustici Dominique Batista Christof De Bo Alex Botzki + Many more https://tess.elixir-europe.org and http://bioschemas.org

Editor's Notes

  • #3: ELIXIR is a pan-european infrastructure for life science information. Broadly, it’s goals are to comprising of 22 national nodes, plus a node for the EBI, and a special Hub node that aims to help connect and provide support for nodes. Like a spoke and hub system. Each node has many institutions associated with them, there are over 100 altogether which yield a complicated distributed architecture. Resources are being produced in each institution or across a selection of institutions in huge quantities. Tools, training, compute infrastructure, datasets etc. all exist on heterogenous collections of websites. Some in global repositories, some on country wide repositories, some on institutional, some on personal. There’s humongous diversity in the landscape these resources. ELIXIR hopes to aggregate and present uniformly distriibuted resources in order to improve their findability. The oft-cited FAIR Principles states guidelines for data stewardship should be Findable Accessible Interoperable and Reproducible. As such ELIXIR attempts to improve findabiity through discovery portals. And as you’ll see, certainly keep the AIR in mind. --0
  • #5: New providers and developments of old ones - each a unique challenge Proud to collect so many 500 Materials + 120 upcoming events + 4 thousand archived, looking forward to collecting more
  • #9: Distributed Research Infrastrtucture. Developing training opportunities across 20+ member nodes Collect and harmonize. Feture rich environment. Connected outwardly to complimentary projects. Promote ELIXIR nodes and keep access to data open to be utilized
  • #12: Once we have the data in TeSS we can implement novel and useful features. Subscription service for example. Plans to extend this to a subscription service – input twitter, email and other social media handles and receive notifcations as and when other events that meet your criteria appear.
  • #14: Navigational tools. Give context to training materials in real scientific processes. Agile dev so no complete, but we have a usable iteration. Hosting workshop in UK before March next year. Create content and review mechanism. Details to be announced. Implementation study for training workflows. Prioritised by training platform, waiting on tools platform. Led by Frederick Coppens from Belgium very capable guy
  • #15: Important to connect with other ELIXIR data with Biotools and Biosharing can improve usefulness of content
  • #22: Collection of schemas can be used to describe online objects
  • #33: Plugin to the Bioschemas spec development activities Driving events and training specifications. Prime example for other specifications. Slower going pathing the way but lots of good lessons for future implementations. Early on would write HTML scrapers if necessary. Now drawing a strong line under that. In last resort situations it will be put on the issue tracker with low priority. Development resources too expensive and maintenance is practically - repeat.