SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The European PPP market:
trends and developments
Guy Chetrit
OECD, February 2014
Introduction
Objective:
• Overview of PPP market developments in Europe
• Look at new trends for financing PPPs in Europe
• Are institutional investors filling the gap?
Dataset:
• DBFOs / DBFMs (including concessions) for public services
which reach financial close
• Sourced from commercial databases, specialised publications,
EIB and EPEC Members
• Provisional data for 2013
• Far from perfect!
2
The European PPP Market in 2013: out of the crisis?

3
Headlines for 2013
• Increase in aggregate market value: EUR 16.7 billion (EUR 11.7
billion in 2012)
• More deals closed: 80 transactions compared to 68 in 2012
• Average deal value at EUR 208 million (EUR 188 million in 2012)
• 6 large deals (over EUR 500 million) compared to 4 in 2012
• UK, Italy and France account for two thirds of the overall market
value
• 14 countries closed at least one deal (compared to 9 in 2012)
4
The UK still in the lead

5
Incidence of large deals (over EUR 500 million)
• Thameslink rolling stock (EUR 1.9 billion)
• Royal Liverpool hospital (EUR 509 million)
• BreBeMi motorway (EUR 2.3 billion)
• Milan Eastern ring road (EUR 1.8 billion)
A1/A6 motorway Schiphol-Amsterdam-Almere (EUR 1 billion)
Phase 1 of Gebze-Izmir toll road (EUR 1.1 billion)

6
Transport and education as prime sectors
Value

Number of transactions

7
Overall improvements but…
• Weak project pipelines and issues with project quality and
regulatory environments in certain places
• Important PPP policy reviews have been completed / may
feed a wave of ex-post evaluation analyses
• Significant institutional frameworks changes are taking place
in a number of countries (e.g. Cyprus, Portugal)
• Financing appears to be less of an issue (although pricing is
still very high)
• Institutional investors are more active lenders in more
mature markets only
8
Closed PPP deals involving institutional investors
• Something is happening!

• 17 deals over the last two years (out of 116 PPPs closed)
• In 2013, almost 30% of the market
• Over EUR 1.3 billion of investors debt has been secured

• Long-term debt indeed (up to 41 years)
• Large share of debt financing package
• Availability-pay deals
• Very high country concentration
• Many (very) different structures
9
Structures / initiatives involving institutional investors
• Many caveats to our research…
• 21 initiatives, 16 in operation, 5 in preparation (1 closed down)

• Over EUR 15 billion of debt available
• Four main models:
• Direct lending
• Credit enhancement platforms
• Debt funds (asset managers)
• Managed accounts and soft partnerships with banks
• All seek to marry the expertise of banks (or bankers) with the
capital of investors
10
Structures / initiatives involving institutional investors (2)
• A wide range of products (e.g. senior debt, private placements,
junior debt, credit enhancement for bonds)

• Mix of greenfield and brownfield to diversify risks and build an
infrastructure asset class
• Varying risk appetite (construction, post-completion,
availability, demand)

• Typical sectors with important focus on availability-based deals
• Varying degrees of sophistication and transformation into
commercial bank-like debt
• High geographic concentration
11
Some challenges to attract institutional investors debt
• There are real issues for weaker PPP countries (financing
issue remains significant)
• Pipelines!
• Role for the public sector:
• Improve regulatory and institutional frameworks
• Adjust procurement processes to attract investors

• Playing a more active role in refinancing

12
European PPP Expertise Centre
epec@eib.org
www.eib.org/epec
Twitter: @EpecNews
Telephone: +352 4379 22022
Fax: +352 4379 65499

13

More Related Content

PPTX
How to convey your brand through digital investor relations? BT
PDF
EU-CHINA CIA: what do we know and what are the risks
PPTX
REEEP - Infrastructure Finance for Bottom of the Pyramid by Martin Hiller at ...
PDF
GIB2015_Investors Approach to Sustainable Infrastructure_Barben
PDF
World bank group stefan emblad disaster and risk management_27082014
PPTX
PWC - Catalysing Institutional Investment in Climate-Resilient Infrastructure...
PPTX
Innovation and new technologies innovation pipelines from research to market ...
PDF
GIB2015_Public and Private Sector Transit Development_Bustinduy
How to convey your brand through digital investor relations? BT
EU-CHINA CIA: what do we know and what are the risks
REEEP - Infrastructure Finance for Bottom of the Pyramid by Martin Hiller at ...
GIB2015_Investors Approach to Sustainable Infrastructure_Barben
World bank group stefan emblad disaster and risk management_27082014
PWC - Catalysing Institutional Investment in Climate-Resilient Infrastructure...
Innovation and new technologies innovation pipelines from research to market ...
GIB2015_Public and Private Sector Transit Development_Bustinduy

What's hot (20)

PPTX
IFC - Advisory and Financial Instruments by Nebojsa Arsenijevic at GIB Summit
PDF
GIB2015_Instruments for Increasing Capital Flows_von Gunten
PDF
Private sector in infrastructure funding/financing models and role of institu...
PDF
Discussion of “Limits to Arbitrage in Sovereign Bonds” by Loriana Pelizzon, M...
PPTX
SUSI - Energy Learnings from Energy Savings by Patrick Fankhauser at GIB Summit
DOCX
If you are working in the financial industry should you get involved in Block...
PDF
Developing Climate Friendly Economies in Central Asia
PPT
Essential of finance ca1
PDF
Financing Suppportes NAMAs
PPTX
IISD Performance Based Specifications in Public Procurement by Laura Turley a...
PPTX
Meridiam - ESG Approach by Julia Prescot at GIB Summit
PPT
ASOCEU - Lesson 1 - Dana Spinant slides
PDF
GIB2015_Closing Financing Gap in Resilient Infrastructure_Ahoobim
PPTX
Eex montel nordic energy days 2018
PDF
Buerger Energie eG - Innovative Infrastructure Finance by Luise Neumann-Cosel
PPTX
The Gold Standard - GIB Summit 2014 by Adrian Rimmer at GIB Summit
PDF
Asset management in Europe_The case for reform-Digital
PDF
AI in litigation, Ludwing Bull
PPT
The EIB, a catalyst for Long Term Financing - Clément Fourchy - OECD-Risklab-...
PPTX
IT at HSBC Bank
IFC - Advisory and Financial Instruments by Nebojsa Arsenijevic at GIB Summit
GIB2015_Instruments for Increasing Capital Flows_von Gunten
Private sector in infrastructure funding/financing models and role of institu...
Discussion of “Limits to Arbitrage in Sovereign Bonds” by Loriana Pelizzon, M...
SUSI - Energy Learnings from Energy Savings by Patrick Fankhauser at GIB Summit
If you are working in the financial industry should you get involved in Block...
Developing Climate Friendly Economies in Central Asia
Essential of finance ca1
Financing Suppportes NAMAs
IISD Performance Based Specifications in Public Procurement by Laura Turley a...
Meridiam - ESG Approach by Julia Prescot at GIB Summit
ASOCEU - Lesson 1 - Dana Spinant slides
GIB2015_Closing Financing Gap in Resilient Infrastructure_Ahoobim
Eex montel nordic energy days 2018
Buerger Energie eG - Innovative Infrastructure Finance by Luise Neumann-Cosel
The Gold Standard - GIB Summit 2014 by Adrian Rimmer at GIB Summit
Asset management in Europe_The case for reform-Digital
AI in litigation, Ludwing Bull
The EIB, a catalyst for Long Term Financing - Clément Fourchy - OECD-Risklab-...
IT at HSBC Bank
Ad

Viewers also liked (9)

PDF
Managing VfM: a project lifecycle approach - Fernando Crespo Diu, Portugal
PDF
Recent Developments in the Canadian PPP Market - Lisa Mitchell, Canada
PDF
Disclosure and the US P3 Market - Marshall Crawford, United States
PDF
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Peter LIVESEY
PDF
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Gilles ERDOGAN
PDF
Joint UNDP-UNESCAP Initiative: CapacityDevelopment of Local Governments in ...
PPTX
Public private partnership sustainable growth
PDF
Public Private Partnerships (Ppp) And Affordable Housing By David Hoicka
PDF
Russian PPP Week's Presentation 2014
Managing VfM: a project lifecycle approach - Fernando Crespo Diu, Portugal
Recent Developments in the Canadian PPP Market - Lisa Mitchell, Canada
Disclosure and the US P3 Market - Marshall Crawford, United States
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Peter LIVESEY
OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Gilles ERDOGAN
Joint UNDP-UNESCAP Initiative: CapacityDevelopment of Local Governments in ...
Public private partnership sustainable growth
Public Private Partnerships (Ppp) And Affordable Housing By David Hoicka
Russian PPP Week's Presentation 2014
Ad

Similar to OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Guy CHETRIT (20)

PDF
DeA Capital S.p.A. - Milan Star Conference 2014
PPTX
Implications for European Development finance Architecture
PPTX
Designing and implementing synergies; Coordinating investment in Research and...
PPT
Place AGM 2013: Dan Crossley
PPTX
EUROPEAN FUND FOR STRATEGIC INVESTMENTS
PDF
Pw c 2012-06-23-issue-4-a-growing-non-core-asset-market
PDF
AECM Annual Event 2015 - Alessandro Carano
PDF
Dc update mar 13
PDF
European financing schemes under h2020 & cosme - Workshop on Juncker plan - B...
PDF
Ebrd presentation october 2015 innovation bootcamp (1)
PDF
Eurozone Crisis: Policy Responses and Solutions
PPTX
EUR1-EUR2 EBRD.pptx
PPT
Risk sharing/mitigation instrument in the Middle East and North Africa
PPTX
EU Approaches and Instruments to Engage the Private Sector for Sustainable De...
PDF
A new regulatory frame to support a wave of grid investments in the EU?
PDF
Performance & Transparency in the capital budget - Wojciech Zielinski, OECD S...
PDF
Giorgio Anania Investment in Photonics June 2016
PDF
Giorgio Anania presentation on investment in photonics (June 2016)
PPT
South Europe Midcap Event
PPSX
Session 1 Holger.ppsx
DeA Capital S.p.A. - Milan Star Conference 2014
Implications for European Development finance Architecture
Designing and implementing synergies; Coordinating investment in Research and...
Place AGM 2013: Dan Crossley
EUROPEAN FUND FOR STRATEGIC INVESTMENTS
Pw c 2012-06-23-issue-4-a-growing-non-core-asset-market
AECM Annual Event 2015 - Alessandro Carano
Dc update mar 13
European financing schemes under h2020 & cosme - Workshop on Juncker plan - B...
Ebrd presentation october 2015 innovation bootcamp (1)
Eurozone Crisis: Policy Responses and Solutions
EUR1-EUR2 EBRD.pptx
Risk sharing/mitigation instrument in the Middle East and North Africa
EU Approaches and Instruments to Engage the Private Sector for Sustainable De...
A new regulatory frame to support a wave of grid investments in the EU?
Performance & Transparency in the capital budget - Wojciech Zielinski, OECD S...
Giorgio Anania Investment in Photonics June 2016
Giorgio Anania presentation on investment in photonics (June 2016)
South Europe Midcap Event
Session 1 Holger.ppsx

More from OECD Governance (20)

PDF
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
PDF
Session 15: Grzegorz Marecki - AI Innovation for the Permitting Process
PDF
Session 14: Sander Renes - Improving Procedures in practice, through research
PDF
Session 13: John Stewart - The Challenge of Coordinating Many - The Experienc...
PDF
Session 12: Elise Brax - The Grand Paris Express.pdf
PDF
Session 11: Peter Bryant - The Sizewell C Mega Project – Challenges and Oppor...
PDF
Session 10: Thomas Lautsch - Permitting for Nuclear Waster Repository Konrad ...
PDF
Session 7: Rene Queren - Permitting Challenges in the Energy Industry
PDF
Session 6: Claus Dynesen - OECD Network Advancing Infrastructure Governance
PDF
Session 5: Nuno Gil - Escaping the Governance Trap
PDF
Session 4: Zachary Liscow - Getting Infrastructure Built
PDF
Session 3: Ulla Steen - Environmental Permitting of Infrastructure projects
PDF
Session 2: Charles Banner - Independent Review of Legal Challenges to Nationa...
PDF
Session 1: Jonas Ebbesson - Environment protection in infrastructure projects
PDF
OECD Survey on the Drivers of Trust in Public Institutions: 2024 Results
PPTX
Public Integrity Indicators Slides
PDF
Summary of the OECD expert meeting: Construction Risk Management in Infrastru...
PDF
Using AI led assurance to deliver projects on time and on budget - D. Amratia...
PDF
ECI in Sweden - A. Kadefors, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm (SE)
PDF
Building Client Capability to Deliver Megaprojects - J. Denicol, professor at...
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
Session 15: Grzegorz Marecki - AI Innovation for the Permitting Process
Session 14: Sander Renes - Improving Procedures in practice, through research
Session 13: John Stewart - The Challenge of Coordinating Many - The Experienc...
Session 12: Elise Brax - The Grand Paris Express.pdf
Session 11: Peter Bryant - The Sizewell C Mega Project – Challenges and Oppor...
Session 10: Thomas Lautsch - Permitting for Nuclear Waster Repository Konrad ...
Session 7: Rene Queren - Permitting Challenges in the Energy Industry
Session 6: Claus Dynesen - OECD Network Advancing Infrastructure Governance
Session 5: Nuno Gil - Escaping the Governance Trap
Session 4: Zachary Liscow - Getting Infrastructure Built
Session 3: Ulla Steen - Environmental Permitting of Infrastructure projects
Session 2: Charles Banner - Independent Review of Legal Challenges to Nationa...
Session 1: Jonas Ebbesson - Environment protection in infrastructure projects
OECD Survey on the Drivers of Trust in Public Institutions: 2024 Results
Public Integrity Indicators Slides
Summary of the OECD expert meeting: Construction Risk Management in Infrastru...
Using AI led assurance to deliver projects on time and on budget - D. Amratia...
ECI in Sweden - A. Kadefors, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm (SE)
Building Client Capability to Deliver Megaprojects - J. Denicol, professor at...

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
The Blogs_ Hamas’s Deflection Playbook _ Andy Blumenthal _ The Times of Israe...
PDF
Aron Govil on Why America Lacks Skilled Engineers.pdf
PDF
Conflict, Narrative and Media -An Analysis of News on Israel-Palestine Confli...
PDF
Regional Media Representation of Kuki-Meitei Conflict - An Analysis of Peace ...
PPTX
ASEANOPOL: The Multinational Police Force
PDF
4th-president-of-the-Philippines-_20250 812_103637_0000.pdf
DOCX
Memecoin news and insights on memecoinist
PDF
Best 5 Sites for Verified Cash App Accounts – BTC & Instant Delivery.pdf
PDF
Samaya Jyothi Live News Telugu | Breaking & Trusted Updates
PDF
Human Appeal in Gaza – Emergency Aid, Healthcare & Hope for Families.pdf
PPTX
India’s Response to the Rohingya Refugee Crisis: Balancing National Security,...
DOC
BU毕业证学历认证,阿什兰大学毕业证文凭证书
PDF
2025-07-24_CED-HWB_WIPP_ACO000000001.pdf
PDF
The Most Dynamic Lawyer to Watch 2025.pdf
PPTX
Sir Creek Conflict: History and its importance
PDF
KAL 007 Manual: The Russian Shootdoown of Civilian Plane on 09/01/1983
PDF
How India’s First AI-Powered Anganwadi in Nagpur is Changing Education – As F...
DOCX
Memecoin memecoinist news site for trends and insights
PDF
424926802-1987-Constitution-as-Basis-of-Environmental-Laws.pdf
PDF
Mindanao Debate Lecture Presentation Outline 1.General Facts 2.Mindanao Histo...
The Blogs_ Hamas’s Deflection Playbook _ Andy Blumenthal _ The Times of Israe...
Aron Govil on Why America Lacks Skilled Engineers.pdf
Conflict, Narrative and Media -An Analysis of News on Israel-Palestine Confli...
Regional Media Representation of Kuki-Meitei Conflict - An Analysis of Peace ...
ASEANOPOL: The Multinational Police Force
4th-president-of-the-Philippines-_20250 812_103637_0000.pdf
Memecoin news and insights on memecoinist
Best 5 Sites for Verified Cash App Accounts – BTC & Instant Delivery.pdf
Samaya Jyothi Live News Telugu | Breaking & Trusted Updates
Human Appeal in Gaza – Emergency Aid, Healthcare & Hope for Families.pdf
India’s Response to the Rohingya Refugee Crisis: Balancing National Security,...
BU毕业证学历认证,阿什兰大学毕业证文凭证书
2025-07-24_CED-HWB_WIPP_ACO000000001.pdf
The Most Dynamic Lawyer to Watch 2025.pdf
Sir Creek Conflict: History and its importance
KAL 007 Manual: The Russian Shootdoown of Civilian Plane on 09/01/1983
How India’s First AI-Powered Anganwadi in Nagpur is Changing Education – As F...
Memecoin memecoinist news site for trends and insights
424926802-1987-Constitution-as-Basis-of-Environmental-Laws.pdf
Mindanao Debate Lecture Presentation Outline 1.General Facts 2.Mindanao Histo...

OECD, 7th Meeting on Public-Private Partnerships - Guy CHETRIT

  • 1. The European PPP market: trends and developments Guy Chetrit OECD, February 2014
  • 2. Introduction Objective: • Overview of PPP market developments in Europe • Look at new trends for financing PPPs in Europe • Are institutional investors filling the gap? Dataset: • DBFOs / DBFMs (including concessions) for public services which reach financial close • Sourced from commercial databases, specialised publications, EIB and EPEC Members • Provisional data for 2013 • Far from perfect! 2
  • 3. The European PPP Market in 2013: out of the crisis? 3
  • 4. Headlines for 2013 • Increase in aggregate market value: EUR 16.7 billion (EUR 11.7 billion in 2012) • More deals closed: 80 transactions compared to 68 in 2012 • Average deal value at EUR 208 million (EUR 188 million in 2012) • 6 large deals (over EUR 500 million) compared to 4 in 2012 • UK, Italy and France account for two thirds of the overall market value • 14 countries closed at least one deal (compared to 9 in 2012) 4
  • 5. The UK still in the lead 5
  • 6. Incidence of large deals (over EUR 500 million) • Thameslink rolling stock (EUR 1.9 billion) • Royal Liverpool hospital (EUR 509 million) • BreBeMi motorway (EUR 2.3 billion) • Milan Eastern ring road (EUR 1.8 billion) A1/A6 motorway Schiphol-Amsterdam-Almere (EUR 1 billion) Phase 1 of Gebze-Izmir toll road (EUR 1.1 billion) 6
  • 7. Transport and education as prime sectors Value Number of transactions 7
  • 8. Overall improvements but… • Weak project pipelines and issues with project quality and regulatory environments in certain places • Important PPP policy reviews have been completed / may feed a wave of ex-post evaluation analyses • Significant institutional frameworks changes are taking place in a number of countries (e.g. Cyprus, Portugal) • Financing appears to be less of an issue (although pricing is still very high) • Institutional investors are more active lenders in more mature markets only 8
  • 9. Closed PPP deals involving institutional investors • Something is happening! • 17 deals over the last two years (out of 116 PPPs closed) • In 2013, almost 30% of the market • Over EUR 1.3 billion of investors debt has been secured • Long-term debt indeed (up to 41 years) • Large share of debt financing package • Availability-pay deals • Very high country concentration • Many (very) different structures 9
  • 10. Structures / initiatives involving institutional investors • Many caveats to our research… • 21 initiatives, 16 in operation, 5 in preparation (1 closed down) • Over EUR 15 billion of debt available • Four main models: • Direct lending • Credit enhancement platforms • Debt funds (asset managers) • Managed accounts and soft partnerships with banks • All seek to marry the expertise of banks (or bankers) with the capital of investors 10
  • 11. Structures / initiatives involving institutional investors (2) • A wide range of products (e.g. senior debt, private placements, junior debt, credit enhancement for bonds) • Mix of greenfield and brownfield to diversify risks and build an infrastructure asset class • Varying risk appetite (construction, post-completion, availability, demand) • Typical sectors with important focus on availability-based deals • Varying degrees of sophistication and transformation into commercial bank-like debt • High geographic concentration 11
  • 12. Some challenges to attract institutional investors debt • There are real issues for weaker PPP countries (financing issue remains significant) • Pipelines! • Role for the public sector: • Improve regulatory and institutional frameworks • Adjust procurement processes to attract investors • Playing a more active role in refinancing 12
  • 13. European PPP Expertise Centre [email protected] www.eib.org/epec Twitter: @EpecNews Telephone: +352 4379 22022 Fax: +352 4379 65499 13

Editor's Notes

  • #6: Wider deal distribution than beforeMore countries closing dealsItalyNL, significant given the size of the countryGermany: many small dealsCroatia: Zagreb airportPL: Poznan waste, combining EU funds