Oil Prices and the Global Economy: Is It Di¤erent This Time Around?
- 1. Oil Prices and the Global Economy: Is It Di¤erent This Time Around? Kamiar Mohaddes (University of Cambridge & ERF) & Hashem Pesaran (USC Dornsife INET & Trinity College, Cambridge) Arab Oil Exporters: Coping with a New Global Oil Order Arab Fund for Economic and Social Development November 26-27, 2017
- 2. Motivation I The recent plunge in oil prices has, however, brought into question the generally accepted view that lower oil prices are good for the US and the global economy. I It has been argued that near-zero interest rates in most industrialized economies, and the fact that the US has started to export crude oil, have altered the traditional channels through which the bene…t of lower oil prices gets transmitted to the real economy (Obstfeld et al. 2016). I Moreover, it has been suggested that the positive correlation between oil prices and equity markets in the past few years provides evidence of a slowdown in global economic activity, as a softening of global aggregate demand has reduced …rms’pro…ts and demand for oil (Bernanke 2016). I Therefore, it is argued that the decline in oil prices this time around is not good news for the US economy, and by implication for the rest of the industrialized global economy.
- 3. Motivation I But the net overall outcome for the global economy is far more complicated and depends on domestic political economy considerations and the feedback e¤ects of oil price changes on global energy demand, interest rates, …nancial markets and world trade. I Given that there are many channels through which oil prices can a¤ect economic activity (both real and …nancial) in the US and elsewhere, one could for instance use the GVAR modelling approach to capture the complicated patterns of global economic interactions; taking into account not only the direct exposure of countries to the shocks but also the indirect e¤ects through secondary or tertiary channels. I The GVAR is a multi-country framework which links country-speci…c models in a coherent manner using time series and panel data techniques and has been used in bank stress testing, the analysis of China’s emergence on the rest of world economy, international transmission of real and …nancial shocks, and forecasting.
- 4. Analyzing the Oil Market Using a Multi-Country Model I Firstly, the disaggregated nature of the GVAR-Oil model allows one to identify country-speci…c shocks and answer counterfactual questions regarding the possible macroeconomic e¤ects of oil supply disruptions in speci…c geographical areas on the global economy. I This is in contrast to most of the literature that focuses on the identi…cation of global supply shocks, rather than shocks to a speci…c country or region. I Secondly, it allows one to deal with inherent heterogeneities that exist across countries. I For instance, in terms of oil reserves and production capacities. I Thirdly, it allows one to take into account the economic interlinkages and spillovers that exist between di¤erent regions. I Thereby enabling a study of the global economy in a coherent manner as opposed to undertaking country-by-country analysis.
- 5. Analyzing the Oil Market Using a Multi-Country Model GVAR VARX (1) VARX (2) ... VARX (26) VARX (27) 1- GDP 2- Inflation 3- Interest rate 4- Bond yields 5- Equity prices 6- Exchange rate 1- GDP* 2- Inflation* 3- Interest rate* 4- Bond yields* 5- Equity prices* 6- Exchange rate* * Trade Weights Global Oil Market Impulse Response Analysis Shocks
- 6. E¤ects of Lower Oil Prices on the Global Economy Global Real Equity Prices Global Long-Term Interest Rates Global Real GDP Oil Prices Notes: Figures show median impulse responses to a one-standard-deviation decrease in oil prices, with 95 percent bootstrapped con…dence bounds. The horizon is quarterly.
- 7. E¤ects of Lower Oil Prices on Long-Term Interest Rates United States Euro Area United Kingdom Japan Notes: Figures show median impulse responses to a one-standard-deviation decrease in oil prices, with 95 percent bootstrapped con…dence bounds. The horizon is quarterly.
- 8. E¤ects of Lower Oil Prices on In‡ation United States Euro Area China United Kingdom Japan Notes: Figures show median impulse responses to a one-standard-deviation decrease in oil prices, with 95 percent bootstrapped con…dence bounds. The horizon is quarterly.
- 9. E¤ects of Lower Oil Prices on Real GDP United States Euro Area China United Kingdom Japan Notes: Figures show median impulse responses to a one-standard-deviation decrease in oil prices, with 95 percent bootstrapped con…dence bounds. The horizon is quarterly.
- 10. Analyzing the Oil Market Using a Multi-Country Model I We …nd that the fall in oil prices tends to lower interest rates and in‡ation in most countries, and increase global real equity prices, with these e¤ects showing up relatively quickly, typically within two quarters. I However, the positive real output e¤ects, both at the global level and at the country levels, take longer to materialize following an oil price fall, with the positive median impulse responses generally manifesting themselves in the medium-term, around four quarters after a negative oil price shock. I Thus the empirical evidence based on the GVAR-Oil model supports the view that an oil price fall is good news for the US, the other major economies, as well as for the global economy.
- 11. Focusing on the Impacts of the U.S. Oil Supply Revolution (Mohaddes and Raissi, 2016) I The results indicate that while oil importers typically face a long-lived rise in economic activity (ranging between 0.04% and 0.95%) in response to a U.S. supply-driven fall in oil prices, the impact is negative for energy-exporters (being on average 2.14% for the GCC, 1.32% for other MENA oil exporters, and 0.41% for Latin America), mainly because lower oil prices weakens domestic demand as well as external and …scal balances in these countries. I Negative growth e¤ects (albeit smaller) are also observed for energy-importers which have strong economic ties with oil exporters, through spillover e¤ects. I In particular, for most oil-importers in the MENA region, gains from lower oil prices are o¤set by a decline in external demand/…nancing by MENA oil-exporters given strong linkages between the two groups through trade, remittances, tourism, foreign direct investment and grants. These economies on average experience a fall in real output of about 0.28%. For this group, low pass-through from global oil prices to domestic fuel prices limits the impact on disposable incomes of consumers and pro…t-margins of …rms, and thereby contains the positive e¤ect on economic growth in these countries.
- 12. Impact of the U.S. Oil Supply Revolution on Real Output Source: Mohaddes and Raissi (2016). Notes: Figures are median (blue solid) and median target (black long-dashed) impulse responses to a one standard deviation fall in the price of oil, equivalent to an annualized drop of 51% in year 1 and 45% in year 2, together with the 5th and 95th percentile error bands. The impact is in percentage points and the horizon is quarterly.
- 13. Impact of the U.S. Oil Supply Revolution on Equity Markets Source: Mohaddes and Raissi (2016). Notes: Figures are median (blue solid) and median target (black long-dashed) impulse responses to a one standard deviation fall in the price of oil, equivalent to an annualized drop of 51% in year 1 and 45% in year 2, together with the 5th and 95th percentile error bands. The impact is in percentage points and the horizon is quarterly.
- 14. Analyzing Oil Price Changes Using Monthly Data I To evaluate the e¤ects of recent falls in oil prices, we need to investigate the output-oil price relationship over a number of sub-periods, including the episode of oil boom and bust since 2008. I Unfortunately, however, quarterly macro series that exist are not su¢ ciently long for a reliable analysis of output-oil price relationship over di¤erent sub-periods, particularly the post-2008 crisis period. I We cannot therefore make use of the GVAR-Oil model, but instead we consider bivariate relationships between oil prices, equity prices and dividends (as a proxy for real economic activity).
- 15. Analyzing Oil Price Changes Using Monthly Data I In what follows we shall mainly focus on the e¤ects of lower oil prices on the US economy for three reasons: I Firstly, the US economy has not been dependent on oil imports as much as other industrialized economies, with oil production having …rst peaked in 1971 (before the shale oil revolution). I The US started to export crude oil in January 2016 after a 40-year ban. I Secondly, the US oil and gas sector attracted signi…cant investment over the past decade, including small …rms issuing large amounts of debt (estimated over $350 billion just between 2010 and 2014). I As a result, the losses for US investors in equity and bond markets have been substantial following the recent fall in oil prices, with valuations of US energy companies falling dramatically and the number of gas and oil companies in the US …ling for bankruptcy soaring, which could have indirect e¤ects on the US economy through secondary or tertiary channels.
- 16. Analyzing Oil Price Changes Using Monthly Data I Thirdly, thanks to advances in hydraulic fracturing and directional drilling, oil production has signi…cantly expanded in the US over the past 10 years. I US oil production has risen from 5 million barrels per day (b/d) in January 2008 to 9.2 million b/d in January 2016, around 84% increase. 4000 6000 8000 10000 1946M1 1963M9 1981M5 1999M1 2016M6 Data sources: United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 17. Real Oil Prices and Real US Equity Prices (S&P 500), 1946M1-2016M3 0 50 100 150 1946M1 1963M8 1981M3 1998M10 2016M3 0 1000 2000 3000 Real Oil Prices ($/b) Real Equity Prices (right scale) Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA)
- 18. Correlations between Changes in Real Oil Prices, Equity Prices and Dividends Period Real Oil and Real Oil Prices Equity Prices and Dividends Full Period 1946M2–2016M3 0.008 (0.035) -0.105 (0.034) Sub-Periods 1960M1–1980M12 0.018 (0.063) -0.071 (0.063) 1981M1–2000M12 -0.139 (0.064) -0.163 (0.064) 2001M1–2016M3 0.199 (0.073) -0.252 (0.072) Sub-Sub-Periods 2001M1–2007M12 -0.144 (0.109) -0.088 (0.110) 2008M1–2016M3 0.404 (0.093) -0.329 (0.096) Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 19. Has the Relationship Between Real Oil and Equity Prices been Stable Over Time? I To conduct a more robust statistical analysis we use rolling regressions of the rate of change of real equity prices on the rate of change of real oil prices, estimated with 10-year windows. I The coe¢ cients were not statistically di¤erent from zero before 1990, became negative in 1991 and initially falling (being statistically signi…cant from 1991 to 2001), and then eventually rising and becoming positive since the 2008 …nancial crisis (being statistically signi…cant from 2012). I It is then perhaps not surprising that there is no consensus in the literature on the relationship between oil and equity prices (Jones and Kaul 1996 and Wei 2003). I Overall, the empirical evidence suggests that the relationship between real oil and stock prices is not stable over time. As such, the recent perverse relationship between equity returns and oil price changes should not be taken as evidence that lower oil prices are bad for the real economy.
- 20. Rolling Estimates of the E¤ects of Changes in Oil Prices on Equity Prices -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 1980M1 1989M2 1998M3 2007M4 2016M3 Notes: Rolling estimates of the coe¢ cient of the rate of change of real oil prices and its two standard error bands. Dependant variable is the rate of change of real US equity prices (S&P 500). The window size is 120 months. Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 21. Has the Relationship Between Real Oil and Equity Prices been Stable Over Time? I A signi…cantly positive relationship between oil and equity prices has emerged since the global …nancial crisis in 2008, which has been discussed extensively by the media as well as by prominent economists. I See Bernanke’s blog at Brookings on February 2016 and Obstfeld et al.’s IMF blog on March 2016. I The question is why is this the case? I Firstly, while markets are generally e¢ cient and therefore equity prices re‡ect the fundamentals, there are also episodes when real equity prices do not re‡ect the state of the economy. I In such periods any evidence of a perverse relationship between real equity and oil prices could be due to the disconnect between equity markets and economic fundamentals and not necessarily any breaks in the relationship between oil prices and the real economy.
- 22. Has the Relationship Between Real Oil and Equity Prices been Stable Over Time? I Secondly, Sovereign Wealth Funds (SWFs) accumulated large assets during the most recent oil boom (2002-2008) and they have come to play a major role in reserve management of oil revenues. I The prominent examples are: I Norway’s Government Pension Fund ($830), I Abu Dhabi Investment Authority ($773), I Saudi Arabia’s Fund (SAMA) ($685), I Kuwait Investment Authority ($592), I Qatar Investment Authority ($256). With the exception of Norway all …gures refer to June 2015.
- 23. SWF Portfolio Allocation On average 65% of SWF assets are held in public and private equities (61% Norway; 72% SAMA; 65% Kuwait; 68% Qatar; 62% Abu Dhabi–…gures based on 2014).
- 24. Has the Relationship Between Real Oil and Equity Prices been Stable Over Time? I During periods of rising oil prices, these funds are topped up with equity purchases. I However, when oil prices are falling most major oil exporters withdraw money from the funds in order to maintain, for instance, their welfare expenditure. I The equity transactions of SWFs in turn induce an unintended positive correlation between oil and equity prices. I Whilst it is true that such e¤ects might not be that large, they could trigger larger e¤ects due to known market over-reactions. See also Blanchard (2016).
- 25. Are Lower Oil Prices Bene…cial for the US and the World Economy? I Ideally we need to consider how oil prices and real activity are related (as opposed to equity markets). I However, quarterly GDP series that exist are not su¢ ciently long for a reliable analysis of output-oil price relationship over di¤erent sub-periods, particularly the post-2008 crisis period. I While a number of investigators have used monthly measures of US manufacturing output, this is not su¢ ciently representative of an economy such as that of the US. I Instead we use real dividends on S&P 500 as a proxy for economic activity. I In the long run there has to be a relationship between real dividends and the economic climate.
- 26. Real Oil Prices and Real Dividends (S&P 500), 1946M1-2016M3 0 50 100 150 1946M1 1963M8 1981M3 1998M10 2016M3 0 10 20 30 40 50 Real Oil Prices ($/b) Real Dividends (right scale) Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 27. Correlations between Changes in Real Oil Prices, Equity Prices and Dividends Period Real Oil and Real Oil Prices Equity Prices and Dividends Full Period 1946M2–2016M3 0.008 (0.035) -0.105 (0.034) Sub-Periods 1960M1–1980M12 0.018 (0.063) -0.071 (0.063) 1981M1–2000M12 -0.139 (0.064) -0.163 (0.064) 2001M1–2016M3 0.199 (0.073) -0.252 (0.072) Sub-Sub-Periods 2001M1–2007M12 -0.144 (0.109) -0.088 (0.110) 2008M1–2016M3 0.404 (0.093) -0.329 (0.096) Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 28. Rolling Estimates of the E¤ects of Changes in Oil Prices on Real Dividends -0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0.00 1980M1 1989M2 1998M3 2007M4 2016M3 Notes: Rolling estimates of the coe¢ cient of the rate of change of real oil prices and its two standard error bands based. Dependant variable is the rate of change of real dividends (S&P 500). The window size is 120 months. Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 29. Are Lower Oil Prices Bene…cial for the US and the World Economy? I The coe¢ cient of real oil price changes on dividends have been negative over the whole sample period, and statistically signi…cantly negative for most of the period. I The bene…cial e¤ects of lower oil prices on dividends have become even much stronger over the more recent episodes, with the rolling estimates becoming particularly large and statistically signi…cant post 2009. I The rolling estimates give a clear indication of the changing nature of the relationships between oil prices, equity prices, and dividends, but do not allow for changing dynamics between these variables. I Therefore, to check the robustness of the results to the dynamics of adjustments between oil price changes and the economy, we also estimated ARDL models, one with the rate of change of real equity and oil prices and another with the rate of change of real dividends and oil prices.
- 30. Estimates of the Long-run Coe¢ cients of Real Oil Prices based on Various ARDL Regressions and Sub-samples 1970M1 1970M1 1990M1 2008M1 2016M4 1989M12 2007M12 2016M4 (a) ARDL Model with Real Equity Prices Oil Price Coe¢ cient 0.159 0.176 0.185 0.202 (0.073) (0.100) (0.039) (0.118) ARDL Order (6, 12) (2, 12) (1, 1) (4, 4) (b) ARDL Model with Real Dividends Oil Price Coe¢ cient 0.016 0.046 0.092 0.111 (0.017) (0.014) (0.043) (0.048) ARDL Order (1, 3) (2, 1) (5, 0) (1, 0) Notes: Symbols ***, **, and * denote signi…cance at 1%, 5%, and 10% levels, respectively. Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 31. Estimates of the Long-run Coe¢ cients of Real Oil Prices based on Various ARDL Regressions and Sub-samples 1970M1 1970M1 1990M1 2008M1 2016M4 1989M12 2007M12 2016M4 (c) ARDL Model with Industrial Production Oil Price Coe¢ cient 0.053 0.084 0.019 0.098 (0.025) (0.029) (0.014) (0.075) ARDL Order (12, 11) (2, 11) (3, 3) (12, 10) (d) ARDL Model with Manufacturing Production Oil Price Coe¢ cient 0.075 0.116 0.022 0.067 (0.027) (0.036) (0.017) (0.063) ARDL Order (3,11) (2, 11) (3,3) (12,8) Notes: Symbols ***, **, and * denote signi…cance at 1%, 5%, and 10% levels, respectively. Data sources: Robert Shiller’s online database, Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), and United States Energy Information Administration (EIA).
- 32. Are Lower Oil Prices Bene…cial for the US and the World Economy? To summarize: I There is no stable relationship between real oil prices and equity returns over the last 71 years I The perverse response of equity markets to oil price changes should not be taken as evidence that lower oil prices are no longer bene…cial for the US and the world economy. I In fact, using relatively long time series on dividends and oil prices we show that, as in previous episodes of falling oil prices, lower oil prices improve pro…t opportunities and dividends in the oil importing economies which is overall good for the world economy. I This supports the …ndings from the GVAR-Oil model. I However, due to uncertainties over the Brexit negotiations, economic and trade policies under the new US administration, the threat of terrorism, and the surge in …nancial market volatility (to mention but a few), it is likely that there will be a delay in the materialization of any economic bene…ts of lower oil prices for the global economy as a whole.
- 33. Are Lower Oil Prices Bene…cial for the US and the World Economy? I Nevertheless, the fall in oil prices has hit the major oil exporters the hardest. I It is not surprising therefore that the fall in oil prices has forced oil exporters to cut back on their welfare programs, withdraw from their oil funds, and attempt to diversify their economies. I At the world level, however, we would expect the increase in spending by oil importers to exceed the decline in expenditure by oil exporters (given their di¤erent marginal propensities to consume/invest), and so eventually lower oil prices should also be bene…cial for the world economy. I This was also clearly illustrated within the GVAR-Oil framework I This in turn implies that demand for energy is going to start to rise, which will put upward pressure on oil prices in the medium term, and the equilibrating process starts to take place.
- 34. Strong Oil Demand and Supply Growth in 2015 I Overall, despite falling oil prices, oil production has continued to rise world-wide, with OPEC and non-OPEC contributing to the rise, almost equally in 2015.
- 35. Strong Oil Demand Growth in 2016 I As with all markets, lower oil prices will eventually lead to higher demand and lower supplies. ed o t for asing han a ear. ely Mb/d) trong Mb/d) . s uch Oil market in 2015 and 2016 Consumption Production -0.5 2005-15 Global growth 2015 2016 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 Annual change, Mb/d -0.5 2005-15 OPECExporters Importers Non- OPEC 2015 2016 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0
- 36. Do Global Oil Supplies Respond to Lower Oil Prices? I There is an important analogy between the Ricardian theory of rent on agricultural land and modelling of oil prices. I Ricardo (1817) observed that rent rises as land of lower quality are brought under cultivation in conditions of rising demand for agricultural products. In the same way, pro…t from productive oil …elds rise as costlier …elds are brought into production. I With signi…cant heterogeneity of breakeven production costs across …elds in di¤erent parts of the world, as well as across di¤erent types of oil …elds within a given region, it is not surprising that it is the production of the high cost unconventional oil that is …rst to be negatively a¤ected by lower oil prices.
- 37. Concluding Remarks I As with all markets, lower oil prices will eventually lead to higher demand and lower supplies. I The bene…cial income e¤ects of lower oil prices will show up in higher oil demand by oil importers including the US, while the loss of revenues by oil exporters will act in the opposite direction, but the net e¤ect is likely to be positive. I This means that oil markets equilibrate, but very slowly. I Oil prices are likely to ‡uctuate within a wide range, the ceiling being the marginal cost for US shale oil producers (around $60 per barrel). I This episodic process gets further accentuated by new reserve discoveries, technological advances in oil production and alternative energy sources.
- 38. Concluding Remarks Share Author alerts Print Clip Gift Article Comments A July 14, 2016 10:22 am Kamiar Mohaddes and M Hashem Pesaran The old view is largely correct, say two experts re low oil prices good for the world economy? A decade ago that question would have been met with an unbridled “yes” from most investors, who were used to seeing stock markets rise when energy prices fell, or struggle when oil got too hot. But in recent years oil prices and equity markets have started to move in tandem, leading prominent Click here to try our new website — you can come back at any time Is cheap oil really good for the global economy? ©Reuters