Olney 2016 ehfp evaluation presentation_re_sakss_conference_final2
Download as PPTX, PDF0 likes245 views
The evaluation of Helen Keller International’s Enhanced Homestead Food Production (EHFP) program in Burkina Faso demonstrated significant improvements in maternal and child nutritional status and women’s empowerment. Key findings highlighted decreases in rates of stunting, wasting, and anemia among children, alongside improved decision-making and social capital for women. Recommendations for further enhancements include longer intervention periods and addressing additional factors contributing to undernutrition such as water, sanitation, and hygiene.
Olney 2016 ehfp evaluation presentation_re_sakss_conference_final2
- 1. Lessons Learned from the Evaluation of Helen Keller international’s Enhanced Homestead Food Production (EHFP) Program Presented by: Deanna Olney, PhD* October 19, 2016 * Olney, Dillon, Ruel, Nielsen. Lessons learned from the evaluation of Helen Keller International’s Enhanced Homestead Food Production Program. AOTR
- 2. Background • The agriculture sector can improve nutrition especially through integrated agriculture and nutrition programs. • Consistently improve agriculture production and dietary diversity (Leroy et al. 2008, Girard et al. 2012). • Also posited to improve nutrition outcomes by simultaneously addressing the direct and underlying causes of undernutrition (Ruel et al. 2013). • However, limited documented evidence exists about their impacts on nutrition outcomes and how impacts are achieved. • Rigorous, comprehensive evaluations that include impact and process evaluations are needed to generate this evidence.
- 3. Increase production Enhanced-Homestead Food Production (EHFP) program in Burkina Faso Establish Village Model Farms Provide agriculture training Provide nutrition and health- related training Establish home gardens Distribute agriculture and zoological inputs Program enhancements: • Targeted to mothers with children 3-12 mo of age • Increased focus on women • Improved behavior change communication (BCC) strategy Increase income & assets Increase consumption Improve nutrition, health and hygiene practices Improve maternal & child health & nutrition outcomes
- 4. Study design for HKI’s EHFP program in Burkina Faso 20092010 Feb.-May 443 households 400 women 395 children 55 eligible villages (water + population criteria) 15 villages randomly assigned Older Women Leader (OWL) BCC 512 baseline households 15 villages randomly assigned Health Committee (HC) BCC 514 baseline households 25 villages randomly assigned Control group 741 baseline households 15 Villages 75 Women 60 KI 2011 Apr.-May 441 households 407 women 376 children 15 villages 75 Women 75 Men 75 KI 14 Villages 70 Women 58 KI 14 Villages 70 Women 70 Men 58 KI 597 households 565 women 511 children 15 Villages 75 Women 15 Villages 75 Women 75 Men 2012 Mar.-June
- 5. What impact did the EHFP program have on children’s and women’s nutritional status and women’s empowerment?
- 6. 2 y impact on children’s stunting, wasting and diarrhea * P<0.01, ** P<0.05 Olney et al., Journal of Nutrition 2015 Diarrhea prevalence, children aged 3-12 mo at baseline 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 0 2 Diarrhea(%) Survey time point, y Control villages Older women leader villages Health committee villages -15.9 pp ** -9.8 pp * 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 0 2 Wasting(%) Survey time point, y Control villages Older women leader villages Health committee villages -8.8 pp** Wasting prevalence, children aged 3-12 mo at baseline 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 0 2 Stunting(%) Survey time point, y Control villages Older women leader villages Health committee villages ** Stunting prevalence, children aged 3-12 mo at baseline
- 7. 2 y impact on children’s anemia 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 0 2 Anemia(%) Survey time point, y Control villages Older women leader villages Health committee villages -14.6 pp** Anemia prevalence, children aged 3-5.9 at baseline 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 0 2 Anemia(%) Survey time point, y Control villages Older women leader villages Health committee villages Anemia prevalence, children aged 3-12.9 at baseline * P<0.01, ** P<0.05 Olney et al., Journal of Nutrition 2015
- 8. 2 y impact on mother’s underweight and body mass index (BMI) ** P<0.05 for DID estimates, * P<0.10 for interaction. Olney et al., Journal of Nutrition 2016 Change in the prevalence of underweight among women1 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 0 2 Underweight(%) Survey time point, y Control Intervention -8.7 pp** Change in women’s body mass index (BMI) by underweight status at baseline1 17 18 19 20 21 22 0 2 MeanBMI Survey time point, y Underweight BL, control Underweight BL, intervention Not underweight BL, control Not underweight, intervention 0.52*
- 9. 2 y impact on women’s overall empowerment, decision- making and social capital ** P<0.05 for DID estimates. Olney et al., Journal of Nutrition 2016 0 10 20 30 0 2 Survey time point, y Overall score (0-37) Control Program 3.1** • Significant impacts on meeting with other women, purchasing and health care decisions • No impact on spousal communication, social support, family planning decisions or infant and young child feeding decisions.
- 10. How did the EHFP program work to improve children‘s and women’s nutritional status and women’s empowerment?
- 11. Production – consumption pathway: What worked? • Process evaluation • Improved knowledge of optimal agriculture practices and adoption of some key practices • Perceived increases in production of chickens, eggs and vegetables • Impact evaluation • Beneficiary women owned more chickens • Beneficiary women produced more micronutrient-rich foods
- 12. Production – consumption pathway: What needed improvement? • Process evaluation • Water constraints • HKI worked to decrease water constraints through a variety of methods such as creating new wells and boreholes, repairing existing water sources, using drip irrigation kits, etc. • Perceived inadequacies in supplies • Motivation and compensation of local implementers • Timing and duration of the program • Impact evaluation • Impact on household level production
- 13. Production – income pathway: What worked? • Process evaluation • Positive changes in men’s and women’s opinions about women’s ability to own and use land changed • Beneficiary women maintained control over their gardens, food produced and income generated • Impact evaluation • Beneficiary compared to non-beneficiary women: • Owned more agriculture assets • Owned more chickens • Produced more micronutrient-rich foods
- 14. Knowledge – adoption of optimal health and nutrition practices pathway: What worked? • Process evaluation • Knowledge of some optimal health, hygiene and nutrition practices improved • Impact evaluation • Knowledge and adoption of some key practices improved • Mothers’ intake of micronutrient-rich foods increased • Children’s dietary diversity increased
- 15. Knowledge – adoption of optimal health and nutrition practices pathway: What needed improvement? • Process evaluation • Home visit frequency • Motivation of local level program implementers • Technical abilities and quality of program implementation by OWLs • Understanding of BCC topics related to prevention and treatment of anemia • HKI retrained nutrition trainers and in turn beneficiaries in the topics related to the prevention and treatment of anemia • Impact evaluation • Further improvements in knowledge and adoption of some of the promoted practices
- 16. Conclusions • The EHFP program improved child and maternal nutritional status and maternal empowerment • Further reductions in anemia, diarrhea and stunting are needed • Possible ways to achieve this are: • Intervening earlier and for longer • Improving delivery and utilization of some program components • Re-examining issues related to motivation and compensation of program implementers • Including additional interventions designed to address some of the other causes of undernutrition such as water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) interventions or the provision of a fortified complementary food for children 6-24 mo of age
- 17. Acknowledgements • Study participants in Burkina Faso • Helen Keller International (HKI) • HKI Burkina Faso: Abdoulaye Pedehombga, Marcellin Ouedraogo, Hippolyte Rouamba, Olivier Vebamba, Ann Tarini, Dr. Jean Celestin Somda and Fanny Yago-Wienne • HKI headquarters: Victoria Quinn, Jennifer Nielsen • Local implementing non-governmental organizations (NGOs) • Burkina Faso - Association d'Appui et de Promotion Rurale du Gulmu (APRG) • Research team at the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) and Michigan State University • IFPRI and Michigan State: Andrew Dillon • IFPRI: Marie Ruel, Mara van den Bold, Elyse Iruhiriye, Lilia Bliznashka, Julia Behrman, Esteban Quiñones and Jessica Heckert • Funding: • The Office of U.S. Foreign Disaster Assistance (OFDA) of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) • Gender, Agriculture, and Assets Project (GAAP), supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation • European Commission (EC) • CGIAR Research Program on Agriculture for Nutrition and Health (A4NH) led by the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
- 18. THANK YOU!!
Editor's Notes
- #16: HC members more knowledgeable about anemia and more likely to elicit support from other family members to support adoption of optimal practices Beneficiaries in HC villages also tended to feel more supported in adopting new practices compared to those in OWL villages