This case report discusses a 53-year-old man with castrate-sensitive prostate cancer who developed right sixth nerve palsy due to a solitary petroclival lesion. Initially suspected to be metastatic prostate cancer, further investigation revealed it to be a grade I meningioma after a biopsy. The case highlights the diagnostic challenges and the need for thorough investigation of solitary skull lesions in prostate cancer patients, as alternative diagnoses may significantly differ in management and prognosis.