RELAY CO-ORDINATION WITH FAULT CALCULATION

RELAY CO-ORDINATION
WITH FAULT CALCULATION
MD. SAROWAR ALAM
ASSISTANT MANAGER (Technical)
SYSTEM PROTECTION AND METERING DIVISION
CHITTAGONG.
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Objectives
To determine proper relay setting
To improve the system reliability
To avoid un-wanted tripping
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Co-ordination of protective relays refers to co-
relating the settings of various relays/protection
systems for harmonious and selective operation.
CO-ORDINATION
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Basic requirements of a good protection
system include selectivity, discrimination,
adequateness, stability, sensitivity, reliability and
time characteristics .To achieve these desirable
requirements proper co-ordination of relay
settings is essential.
CO-ORDINATION
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

CO-ORDINATION
Neighboring protective zones overlap. Hence
there is a need for co-ordinating the time settings
so that only faulty part gets quickly disconnected
without disturbances to healthy part .
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

TYPES OF CO-ORDINATION
1. Current Graded
2. Time Graded
3. Both Current and Time Graded
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

1. Current Graded
Current graded co-ordination means
downstream has lower current setting than
upstream.
Current
I3
I2
I1
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Disadvantage of Current
Graded
Although upstream has higher current setting,
so it causes damage of equipment due to
high current passing for long time.
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

2. Time Graded
Time graded co-ordination means downstream
has lower time setting than upstream.
Time
t3
t2
t1
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Disadvantage of Time Graded
Although upstream has higher time setting, so
when fault occurs near to the bus then high
current pass through equipment for long
time and causes damage of equipment.
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

3. Time and Current Graded
The principle of Both Time and Current
Graded is that higher the current lower the
relay trip time.
Time
Current
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

1. Fault calculation
2. Time grading (Grading Margin)
3. Switching transient current (Inrush)
NECESSARY FACTORS FOR
CO-ORDINATION
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Grading Margin
Operating time difference between two
devices to ensure that downstream device
will clear fault before upstream device trips.
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Grading Margin includes
I. Breaker opening time
II. Allowance for errors
III. Relay overshoot time
IV. Safety margin
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

• Traditional (Grading margin - between relays)
Breaker opening time - 0.10 Sec.
Allowance for errors - 0.15 Sec
Relay overshoot - 0.05 Sec.
Safety margin - 0.10 Sec.
Total - 0.40 Sec
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Fault Calculation Procedure
Two Methods:
I. Per Unit method (100MVA Base)
II. MVA method (No Base MVA)
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
)Z2(Z3
V3
ZZZZZZ
VZ3
I:faultG--
)ZZ(Z3
V3
ZZZ
V3
I:faultG-
I
2
3
ZZ
V3
I:fault-
Z3
V
Z
V
I:fault3
-:equationlfundamentaSome
01
P-P
022101
N-P2
f
021
P-P
021
N-P
f
3f
21
N-P
f
1
P-P
1
N-P
f
+
=
++
=ϕϕ
++
=
++
=ϕ
=
+
=ϕϕ
==ϕ
ϕ
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
ZcktofNo.
)(Z
Z
ZcktofNo.
)(Z
ZZ:LineFor
100MVAXF
MVABase%Z
:rTransformeFor
:ImpedancesP.U.
21.1
100M
11k
:11kV
89.10
100M
33k
:33kV
24.174
100M
132k
:132kV
:Base)(100MVAImpedancesBase
Base
0
0
Base
1
21
2
2
2
×
Ω
=
×
Ω
==
×
×
Ω=
Ω=
Ω=
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
p.u.0.09427T||T
p.u.1855.0
10063
10069.11
100MVAFX
MVABaseZ%
ZZZT
p.u.1917.0
10063
10008.12
100MVAFX
MVABaseZ%
ZZZT
:ImpedanceransformerTkV33/132
p.u.0807.003086.02
24.174kA21.93
kV1323
Z2
ZI3
V3
Z
.u.p03086.0
24.174kA17.143
kV132
ZI3
V
ZZ
:ImpedanceourceS
21
0212
0211
1
BaseG
PP
0
Base3
PP
21
=
=
×
×
=
×
×
===→
=
×
×
=
×
×
===→
=×−
××
×
=−
××
=
=
××
=
××
==
−ϕ
−
ϕ
−
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
p.u.0.248T||T
p.u.495.0
10020
10090.9
100MVAFX
MVABaseZ%
ZZZT
p.u.497.0
10020
10094.9
100MVAFX
MVABaseZ%
ZZZT
:ImpedanceransformerTkV11/33
.u.p38085.0
89.102
295.8
Zcktof.No
Z
Z
.u.p12695.0
89.102
765.2
Zcktof.No
Z
ZZ
:ImpedanceLine3kV3
3231
02132
02131
Base
0
0
Base
1
21
=
=
×
×
=
×
×
===→
=
×
×
=
×
×
===→
=
×
=
×
=
=
×
=
×
==
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
kA73.16
89.10)Z3(Z3
V3
I:faultG--
kA23.15
89.10)Z3(2Z3
V3
I:faultG-
kA1.12I
2
3
I:fault-
kA98.13
89.10)Z(Z3
V
I:fault3
-:FaultBus33kVHalisahar
21
21
21
T||1T1source
P-P
f
T||1T1source
P-P
f
3ff
T||1T1source
P-P
f
=
×+
=ϕϕ
=
×+
=ϕ
==ϕϕ
=
×+
=ϕ
ϕ
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
kA365.4
89.10)Z2ZZ3(Z3
V3
I:faultG--
kA359.5
89.10)ZZ2Z3(2Z3
V3
I:faultG-
kA009.6I
2
3
I:fault-
kA93.6
89.10)ZZ(Z3
V
I:fault3
-:FaultBus33kVRampur
0Line1LineT||1T1source
P-P
f
0Line1LineT||1T1source
P-P
f
3ff
1LineT||1T1source
P-P
f
21
21
21
=
×+++
=ϕϕ
=
×+++
=ϕ
==ϕϕ
=
×++
=ϕ
ϕ
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
kA807.15
21.1)Z3ZZ(Z3
V3
I:faultG--
kA61.12
21.1)Z3Z2Z2(2Z3
V3
I:faultG-
kA088.9I
2
3
I:fault-
kA49.10
21.1)ZZZ(Z3
V
I:fault3
-:FaultBus11kVRampur
323121
323121
323121
T||1T1LineT||1T1source
P-P
f
P-P
f
3ff
P-P
f
=
×+++
=ϕϕ
=
×+++
=ϕ
==ϕϕ
=
×+++
=ϕ
ϕ
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Per Unit method
15.8074.36516.73φ – φ - G
12.6145.35915.23φ - G
9.0886.00912.1φ - φ
10.496.9313.983φ
Rampur 11kV
Bus Fault (kA)
Rampur 33kV
Bus Fault (kA)
Halisahar 33kV
Bus Fault (kA)
Fault Type
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

FEATURES OF THE SOFTWARE
1. Graphical view of single line diagram.
2. Fault Calculation for different configuration.
3. Relay setting flexibility.
4. Curve plotting to cross check the co-ordination
5. Finally shows the settings sheet.
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Diagram-1
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Diagram-2
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Diagram-3
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Diagram-4
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Co-ordination
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Curve Plotting
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

How to use this software ?
Let's have a look => =>
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Setting Sheet
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

THANKS TO ALL
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

Any Question???
Prepared by-
MD. SAROWAR ALAM,
ASSISTANT MANAGER,
SPMD-CTG, PGCB.
08-11-2012

RELAY CO-ORDINATION WITH FAULT CALCULATION

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Viewers also liked (20)

Similar to RELAY CO-ORDINATION WITH FAULT CALCULATION (20)

RELAY CO-ORDINATION WITH FAULT CALCULATION