Jim is accused by his ex-girlfriend's mother, Sara, of sexually molesting his 4-year-old daughter Katie. Sara says Katie told her that "my daddy do that" when touching herself. Jim denies the allegations. On the Dr. Phil show, Jim takes a lie detector test and Sara and Latia, Jim's ex-girlfriend, confront him on stage. Latia admits she has no proof but believes her daughter, though she has never seen Jim harm Katie. The discussion becomes heated as Jim maintains his innocence.