SlideShare a Scribd company logo
TECHNOLOGY SELECTION AND
PRELIMINARY DESIGN OF CSO
FLOATABLES CONTROL STRUCTURES
CHA Consulting | November 20, 2014
Today’s Presentation
•Background
– City of Terre Haute
– Long-Term Control Plan
– Preliminary Design
•Preliminary Design Challenges
– Technology Selection
– Owner Concerns
TECHNOLOGY SELECTION AND PRELIMINARY DESIGN OF CSO FLOATABLES
CONTROL STRUCTURES
Terre Haute, Indiana
TERRE HAUTE: COMBINED SEWER BASIN SYSTEM
TERRE HAUTE: CSO 009 / CSO 010 SEWER BASIN SERVICE
AREAS
SPRUCE STREET CSO 010 – EXISTING SITE
108 IN BRICK SEWER
PROPOSED
SITE
CSO
OUTLET
48 IN RCP
INTERCEPTOR
SPRUCE STREET CSO 010 – EXISTING FACILITIES
SPRUCE STREET CSO 010 – EXISTING DIVERSION STRUCTURE
SPRUCE STREET CSO 010 – TECHNOLOGY SELECTION EARLY STEPS
ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Removed Screenings Maintenance is Labor Intensive
Simple Process Dispose of Bags @ Landfill
Below Ground Facilities Continuous Material Costs for Bags
SPRUCE STREET CSO 010 – TECHNOLOGY SELECTION CHALLENGES
TECHNOLOGY SELECTION MATRIX
SELECTION MATRIC EVALUATION PARAMETERS
SELECTION MATRIX WEIGHTING/SCORING
TECHNOLOGY EVALUATION
ROMAG CLEAN-FLO SCREEN
TECHNOLOGY EVALUATION
GRANDE ACU-SCREEN
TECHNOLOGY EVALUATION
JOHN MEUNIER ROTARY DRUM SCREEN
TECHNOLOGY EVALUATION
VERTICAL BAR SCREENS – MAHR & DUPERON
PRELIMINARY FCS AND SITE LAYOUT
ALTERNATE FCS AND SITE LAYOUT
SELECTION MATRIX – RECOMMENDED TECHNOLOGY
SELECTED TECHNOLOGY AND PRELIMINARY LAYOUT
SNEAK PEEK OF NEXT YEAR’S PRESENTATION
Technology Selection Prelim Design Terre Haute

More Related Content

PDF
S&L Digital Signage - Case Study - APN Digital Gantry Signs Relocation
Tim Webb
 
PDF
Ck21 presentation team 5
Campus
 
PDF
Team 5 mep presentation
Campus
 
DOC
Resume
Karen Greve
 
PDF
CDEC Mining
Julia Fawkes
 
PPTX
Scotts Run and Carderock Sluice Gate Rehabilitation and Odor Control Project
Fairfax County
 
PDF
Scaffold Point V2
Julia Fawkes
 
PDF
Valrea,Valorem - expert on construction wind power plants
Svyatoslav Zhmutskyy
 
S&L Digital Signage - Case Study - APN Digital Gantry Signs Relocation
Tim Webb
 
Ck21 presentation team 5
Campus
 
Team 5 mep presentation
Campus
 
Resume
Karen Greve
 
CDEC Mining
Julia Fawkes
 
Scotts Run and Carderock Sluice Gate Rehabilitation and Odor Control Project
Fairfax County
 
Scaffold Point V2
Julia Fawkes
 
Valrea,Valorem - expert on construction wind power plants
Svyatoslav Zhmutskyy
 

Viewers also liked (19)

PPTX
Raab future proof marketing automation in 2012
draab
 
PPT
Software Selection
guest117c0f
 
PDF
How to successfully engage enterprise software vendors – software selection
John Cachat
 
PPTX
8. software selection
Haa'Meem Mohiyuddin
 
PDF
Top 10 Tips for Smart Software Selection Success Before the Search
WebLink International
 
PPTX
CRM Implementation
TechSoup Canada
 
PPTX
Erp selection steps
anilbele
 
PPTX
Process of software selection
Dag Håkon Baardsen
 
PPT
Software Selection Best Practice
David Watson
 
PDF
Perfect Fit Erp Selection Approach
Eric Kimberling
 
PPTX
Software selection
Brogi & Pittalis srl
 
PPTX
Content Management System Selection Best Practices
edynamic
 
PDF
Erp selection ensuring alignment and value
Expertia Consulting Group España
 
PDF
A Smarter Path to ERP Selection
Kingfin Enterprises Limited
 
PPT
Making CRM Implementation Successful
Andrey Dovgan
 
PPTX
Factors for Technology Selection
Albin Caibog
 
PPT
Steps For Success of ERP Selection
Calvin Hewitt
 
PPTX
Selection of ERP vendor
AIMS Education
 
PDF
CRM Strategy and Implementation
Loaded Technologies
 
Raab future proof marketing automation in 2012
draab
 
Software Selection
guest117c0f
 
How to successfully engage enterprise software vendors – software selection
John Cachat
 
8. software selection
Haa'Meem Mohiyuddin
 
Top 10 Tips for Smart Software Selection Success Before the Search
WebLink International
 
CRM Implementation
TechSoup Canada
 
Erp selection steps
anilbele
 
Process of software selection
Dag Håkon Baardsen
 
Software Selection Best Practice
David Watson
 
Perfect Fit Erp Selection Approach
Eric Kimberling
 
Software selection
Brogi & Pittalis srl
 
Content Management System Selection Best Practices
edynamic
 
Erp selection ensuring alignment and value
Expertia Consulting Group España
 
A Smarter Path to ERP Selection
Kingfin Enterprises Limited
 
Making CRM Implementation Successful
Andrey Dovgan
 
Factors for Technology Selection
Albin Caibog
 
Steps For Success of ERP Selection
Calvin Hewitt
 
Selection of ERP vendor
AIMS Education
 
CRM Strategy and Implementation
Loaded Technologies
 
Ad

Similar to Technology Selection Prelim Design Terre Haute (20)

PDF
Nkululeko Ncube CV.doc ABRIDGED
Nkululeko Ncube
 
DOC
Kenneth Ezeukwu CV-3(2) Updated
Kenneth Ezeukwu
 
PPTX
Armtec Engineering's Top Picks - Case Studies and Design Review
Communications Branding
 
PPT
Infrastructure projects
AHMED NADIM JILANI
 
PPT
Infrastructure projects
AHMED NADIM JILANI
 
PDF
rup-20151016-part-1-item07-victoria-station-upgrade
Robert Lee - CEng, MICE, PMP
 
PPTX
Drew Whitney Final Presentation
Drew Whitney
 
PPTX
Dr shirish naik - Decentralized wastewater treatment systems
promediakw
 
PPT
CSA s250 Mapping of Underground Utility Infrastructure
Bob Gaspirc
 
PDF
3.17.15 commercial solar_design_training
melanie_bissonnette
 
PDF
Fort Bragg Small Business Outreach Event_March 18, 14
NC Military Business Center
 
PDF
930DickWardTetraTechnologies.pdf
RaviNobleseas
 
PDF
108 barreras&accesos función justificaciónseleccióncomportamiento puerto...
Sierra Francisco Justo
 
PDF
Bay-Delta Conservation Plan -- Infrastructure Review, Jan. 9, 2014
San Diego County Water Authority
 
PDF
KCI Company Presenation Oil & Gas
Jan Willem van Bloois
 
PDF
Manhattan Small Scale Mining Plants
manhattancorp
 
PPTX
Large Diameter Sanitary Sewer Condition Assessment Package 4
Fairfax County
 
PPT
Utility Work within Public Right of Way
2014 Florida Public Works Expo
 
PDF
West Station Reference Concept Design Online Consultation
Crosstown TO
 
PPTX
AKASH_AUDA_SITE_YEARLY_REPORT_ENGIN.pptx
RajParmar915359
 
Nkululeko Ncube CV.doc ABRIDGED
Nkululeko Ncube
 
Kenneth Ezeukwu CV-3(2) Updated
Kenneth Ezeukwu
 
Armtec Engineering's Top Picks - Case Studies and Design Review
Communications Branding
 
Infrastructure projects
AHMED NADIM JILANI
 
Infrastructure projects
AHMED NADIM JILANI
 
rup-20151016-part-1-item07-victoria-station-upgrade
Robert Lee - CEng, MICE, PMP
 
Drew Whitney Final Presentation
Drew Whitney
 
Dr shirish naik - Decentralized wastewater treatment systems
promediakw
 
CSA s250 Mapping of Underground Utility Infrastructure
Bob Gaspirc
 
3.17.15 commercial solar_design_training
melanie_bissonnette
 
Fort Bragg Small Business Outreach Event_March 18, 14
NC Military Business Center
 
930DickWardTetraTechnologies.pdf
RaviNobleseas
 
108 barreras&accesos función justificaciónseleccióncomportamiento puerto...
Sierra Francisco Justo
 
Bay-Delta Conservation Plan -- Infrastructure Review, Jan. 9, 2014
San Diego County Water Authority
 
KCI Company Presenation Oil & Gas
Jan Willem van Bloois
 
Manhattan Small Scale Mining Plants
manhattancorp
 
Large Diameter Sanitary Sewer Condition Assessment Package 4
Fairfax County
 
Utility Work within Public Right of Way
2014 Florida Public Works Expo
 
West Station Reference Concept Design Online Consultation
Crosstown TO
 
AKASH_AUDA_SITE_YEARLY_REPORT_ENGIN.pptx
RajParmar915359
 
Ad

Technology Selection Prelim Design Terre Haute