SlideShare a Scribd company logo
bullshit
Why follower count is
@MACKFOGELSON
and a whole lot of reasons why you should be 

measuring social media success differently.
Ω
Ω
For the last two years I’ve been building
a following on Twitter.
@MACKFOGELSON
alright
That’s a total of

24 months
104 weeks
728 days
17,472 hours
not including leap year.
@MACKFOGELSON
It has not been easy.
@MACKFOGELSON
Allow me to share a few of

the things I’ve been doing.!
This is just some of the stuff that has 

helped me to build an audience.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
I wrote 14 blog posts on .
@MACKFOGELSON
At 3,500 words per post, 

that’s like an encyclopedia.

(Remember those?)
!
P.S. has one of the largest and most
respected search marketing communities
in the world.
!
Millions of people visit their blog each month.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
I wrote 25 blog posts on the
Mack Web blog .
@MACKFOGELSON
I also wrote 5 more posts on
other respected blogs.

(I know. I get around.)
!
There’s more than the writing of 

the blog posts.
@MACKFOGELSON
hang on
@MACKFOGELSON
I read, curated, and shared
more than 3,000 posts.

(On social media that is.)
!
I attended 7 conferences.
I spoke at 5 of them.
That’s one solid week of work 

per conference once you’ve researched, 

written, slide-decked, and practiced your talk.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
Plus all of the live-tweeting
and in person stuff, too.

(The online really doesn’t work without the offline.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
We also did some other stuff
as a company.

(We wrote a book on community building. There’s llamas in there.)
!
After doing all of that work, 

guess how many followers I earned?
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
1582,
That’s right.

All of that work
and I only earned
2,851 followers.
(sigh)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Thing is, if I used follower
count to calculate the ROI 

of all my efforts over 

the last two years,!!
I’d consider myself a failure.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
And I’d probably be living in a
van down by the river.

(With Chris Farley, RIP.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
But what my
follower count
doesn’t tell
you over there
is that there’s been
all kinds of crazy
success going on
over here.
@MACKFOGELSON
Each year for the last
two years, Mack Web
has experienced
40%
revenue
growth
The traffic to our

website has increased
by more than
1,300%
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
We are starting to become
recognized as industry leaders.

(It’s quite flattering.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
This recognition has awarded
me speaking opportunities.

(All over the world.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
This exposure sends more than
enough leads to our company.

(Makes us feel like we’re kind of a big deal.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Most valuable
to me are all of
the friends
and mentors
who have helped
me to grow the
business and stay
reasonably sane.
The sad thing is

that you can’t tell
any of this stuff if
you’re only looking
at follower count.
So quit doing that.
@MACKFOGELSON
You can still have numbers.
They’re just different ones.!!
What I want you to hear is, there’s a better
way to gauge your success on social media.
@MACKFOGELSON
to measure the right things.
@MACKFOGELSON
work
Follower count is easy to measure,

but it doesn't mean anything.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
There are 3 metrics that you
should be measuring by now.

(But in case you missed the memo…)
!
Conversation
@MACKFOGELSON
Amplification Applause
1 2 3
@MACKFOGELSON
Conversation communicates
that you’re human.

(And that people want to talk to you.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Amplification communicates
that you’re interesting.

(And that people want to share you with their friends.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Applause communicates 

that you’re likable.

(And people either like you or they don’t.)
!
You can calculate all of this stuff using
TrueSocialMetrics or Sprout Social.
@MACKFOGELSON
You can also calculate true engagement

based on your community size. Read this.


(http://bit.ly/true-engagement)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
will help you determine

whether you’re actually making a difference.
@MACKFOGELSON
engagement
Rather than just measuring 

how many followers you’re adding.
@MACKFOGELSON
But if you want to experience
real growth on social media, 

it can’t operate in a silo.!!
It takes more than social to build an audience.
@MACKFOGELSON
You also need to

embrace integrated
marketing and
employ channels
other than social.
Social likes help.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
Channels like:
Content
Email
Search
Offline
(and stuff)
@MACKFOGELSON
That way you
can measure
how both social
media and
other channels
are working
together to help
you accomplish
the goals for your
whole business.
And then you can measure all kinds of stuff
that goes way beyond follower count.
@MACKFOGELSON
Like…
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
Once they get to your website 

are they downloading stuff?

(Make sure you’re properly setting up goals in Google Analytics.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Are they signing up for your
email marketing?

(Measure your increase in subscriptions.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Are they staying longer and
coming back?

(Track bounce rate, time on page, page depth and return visits.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Are they remembering 

your brand?

(Pay attention to increase in branded traffic and mentions.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Are unexpected opportunities

coming your way?

(Like speaking and blogging gigs that bring exposure.)
!
You’ve got to measure all of it.
@MACKFOGELSON
Because the thing is…
@MACKFOGELSON
Social media

may not be the
perfect match
for things like
direct conversions
if you’re a B2B company.
@MACKFOGELSON
But it may be the perfect
match for supporting and
increasing micro conversions.!
Like email signups, downloads, lead forms, 

and other things (like reading your blog) that
you really want people to do on your site.
@MACKFOGELSON
All of these things lead to
business growth.
@MACKFOGELSON
(We’re living proof.)
@MACKFOGELSON
But none of these things can be
measured using follower count.
@MACKFOGELSON
So remember, kids…
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
Real growth on social media
will take some time.

(I started two years ago.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
Measure social in context with
other integrated efforts.

(It’s fun. You’ll like it.)
!
@MACKFOGELSON
And don’t equate success with
follower count.

(You’ll be better for it.)
!
That’s all I have to say about that.
@MACKFOGELSON
@MACKFOGELSON
read the Mack Web blog
http://mackwebsolutions.com/blog
!
download our
community building guide
http://bit.ly/community-building-guide
!
connect with us
http://mackwebsolutions.com/connect

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

PPTX
13 New Inbound Marketing Hacks You Should Try Immediately
Kelvin (KC) Claveria
 
PDF
We've Been Failing on Social Media for 2 Years. Here's What We Think It Means.
Buffer
 
PDF
Snap: 7 Deadly Sins of Social Media Marketing
Franco De Bonis
 
PDF
What the Internet of Things Really Means - For Marketers and Digital Agencies
Zach Pousman
 
PPTX
Want Links from Time, Wired and Upworthy? Build This Team.
Fractl - Content Marketing Agency
 
PDF
Webstock Workshop: Creating Simple
Daniel Burka
 
PPT
Intro To Social Media Slideshow
Heavybag Media
 
PDF
Conversation by Design
David Armano
 
PDF
Top 10 Myths About Content Marketing (That Are Costing Your Business Money)
Anna Wickham
 
PDF
10 Ways to Ignite Your Content
Mark Schaefer
 
PDF
The History of SEO
HubSpot
 
PDF
Storytelling in 2014
Gary Vaynerchuk
 
PPTX
The Changing Face of Content Promotion [Pubcon 2013]
Fractl
 
PDF
Using Analytics To Solve The Right Problems
Hiten Shah
 
PDF
Recipe for Better Marketing @ChrisBennett
97th Floor
 
PDF
The Evolution of SEO - 2014 and Beyond
Joe Griffin
 
PPT
Social Media PPT presentation #mdbrand
Rob Pene
 
PDF
21 Actionable Growth Hacking Tactics
Jon Yongfook
 
PDF
Infographics for Fun and Profit - Chris Bennett #df13
97th Floor
 
PPTX
Can't Buy Me Love
Rand Fishkin
 
13 New Inbound Marketing Hacks You Should Try Immediately
Kelvin (KC) Claveria
 
We've Been Failing on Social Media for 2 Years. Here's What We Think It Means.
Buffer
 
Snap: 7 Deadly Sins of Social Media Marketing
Franco De Bonis
 
What the Internet of Things Really Means - For Marketers and Digital Agencies
Zach Pousman
 
Want Links from Time, Wired and Upworthy? Build This Team.
Fractl - Content Marketing Agency
 
Webstock Workshop: Creating Simple
Daniel Burka
 
Intro To Social Media Slideshow
Heavybag Media
 
Conversation by Design
David Armano
 
Top 10 Myths About Content Marketing (That Are Costing Your Business Money)
Anna Wickham
 
10 Ways to Ignite Your Content
Mark Schaefer
 
The History of SEO
HubSpot
 
Storytelling in 2014
Gary Vaynerchuk
 
The Changing Face of Content Promotion [Pubcon 2013]
Fractl
 
Using Analytics To Solve The Right Problems
Hiten Shah
 
Recipe for Better Marketing @ChrisBennett
97th Floor
 
The Evolution of SEO - 2014 and Beyond
Joe Griffin
 
Social Media PPT presentation #mdbrand
Rob Pene
 
21 Actionable Growth Hacking Tactics
Jon Yongfook
 
Infographics for Fun and Profit - Chris Bennett #df13
97th Floor
 
Can't Buy Me Love
Rand Fishkin
 

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
10 Ways to be a Marketing Genius Like Lady Gaga
Jesse Desjardins - @jessedee
 
PDF
Congratulations Graduate! Eleven Reasons Why I Will Never Hire You.
Mark O'Toole
 
PDF
Work Rules!
Laszlo Bock
 
PDF
You Suck At PowerPoint! by @jessedee
Jesse Desjardins - @jessedee
 
PDF
How Google Works
Eric Schmidt
 
PDF
How I got 2.5 Million views on Slideshare (by @nickdemey - Board of Innovation)
Board of Innovation
 
PDF
10 Insightful Quotes On Designing A Better Customer Experience
Yuan Wang
 
PDF
40 Tools in 20 Minutes: Hacking your Marketing Career
Eric Leist
 
PDF
5 Storytelling Lessons From Superhero Stories
HighSpark | Visual Storytelling Agency
 
PDF
Design Your Career 2018
Slides That Rock
 
PDF
Pixar's 22 Rules to Phenomenal Storytelling
Gavin McMahon
 
PDF
The Search for Meaning in B2B Marketing
Velocity Partners
 
PDF
Crap. The Content Marketing Deluge.
Velocity Partners
 
PDF
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
HubSpot
 
PDF
How to Master Difficult Conversations at Work – Leader’s Guide
Piktochart
 
PDF
4 Biggest Challenges for Creative Teams
Wrike
 
PDF
10 Dead Simple Ways to Improve Your Company Culture
Bonusly
 
PPTX
How to think like a startup
Loic Le Meur
 
PDF
10 Things your Audience Hates About your Presentation
Stinson
 
PPTX
WTF - Why the Future Is Up to Us - pptx version
Tim O'Reilly
 
10 Ways to be a Marketing Genius Like Lady Gaga
Jesse Desjardins - @jessedee
 
Congratulations Graduate! Eleven Reasons Why I Will Never Hire You.
Mark O'Toole
 
Work Rules!
Laszlo Bock
 
You Suck At PowerPoint! by @jessedee
Jesse Desjardins - @jessedee
 
How Google Works
Eric Schmidt
 
How I got 2.5 Million views on Slideshare (by @nickdemey - Board of Innovation)
Board of Innovation
 
10 Insightful Quotes On Designing A Better Customer Experience
Yuan Wang
 
40 Tools in 20 Minutes: Hacking your Marketing Career
Eric Leist
 
5 Storytelling Lessons From Superhero Stories
HighSpark | Visual Storytelling Agency
 
Design Your Career 2018
Slides That Rock
 
Pixar's 22 Rules to Phenomenal Storytelling
Gavin McMahon
 
The Search for Meaning in B2B Marketing
Velocity Partners
 
Crap. The Content Marketing Deluge.
Velocity Partners
 
What Would Steve Do? 10 Lessons from the World's Most Captivating Presenters
HubSpot
 
How to Master Difficult Conversations at Work – Leader’s Guide
Piktochart
 
4 Biggest Challenges for Creative Teams
Wrike
 
10 Dead Simple Ways to Improve Your Company Culture
Bonusly
 
How to think like a startup
Loic Le Meur
 
10 Things your Audience Hates About your Presentation
Stinson
 
WTF - Why the Future Is Up to Us - pptx version
Tim O'Reilly
 
Ad

Similar to Why Follower Count is Bullshit (20)

PPTX
Monitoring & measuring success
kbconway
 
PDF
Social Media Capacity Development
Marshal Ekere
 
PPT
Social media marketing 2
Evert Bopp
 
PDF
Measuring social media efforts nh
heartyhenry
 
PPTX
December Slides - How Social Media Management Drives Business Growth (1).pptx
jamespit799
 
PPT
Measuring and Tracking Your Social Media Efforts
Hall_
 
PPT
Measuring social-media-update
Hall Internet Marketing
 
PPT
Keep Social Simple
Jaclyn Mullen
 
PPTX
3 Easy Steps to Social Media Success: How Social Media Brought in a $170,000 ...
Tony Zayas
 
PPT
Measuring Social Media
Hall Internet Marketing
 
PPTX
Session13 measurement
Demetrio Maguigad
 
PDF
Deep Dive: 2018 social media trends to save you time and improve your ROI
MeetEdgar
 
PDF
Part 1 - Making Social Media a Business Asset
Joel Arndt
 
PPT
Keys to successful social media
Margarita Stoimenova
 
PDF
Social media tips, tricks, and myths
Rebecca Joy Borough, MSSE
 
PPTX
Building Your Social Media Following: Tips and Tricks
Debbie Goetz Media Connections, LLC
 
PDF
Why 1 Million Social Media Followers Sucks, WebCongress May 2014
Erica McGillivray
 
PDF
Social Media Marketing Mistakes Even Experts are Committing - FloTape
FloTape
 
PPTX
Data Driven Social Media Webcast
Argyle Social
 
PPT
Branding Your Company Socially
Expand Socially, LLC
 
Monitoring & measuring success
kbconway
 
Social Media Capacity Development
Marshal Ekere
 
Social media marketing 2
Evert Bopp
 
Measuring social media efforts nh
heartyhenry
 
December Slides - How Social Media Management Drives Business Growth (1).pptx
jamespit799
 
Measuring and Tracking Your Social Media Efforts
Hall_
 
Measuring social-media-update
Hall Internet Marketing
 
Keep Social Simple
Jaclyn Mullen
 
3 Easy Steps to Social Media Success: How Social Media Brought in a $170,000 ...
Tony Zayas
 
Measuring Social Media
Hall Internet Marketing
 
Session13 measurement
Demetrio Maguigad
 
Deep Dive: 2018 social media trends to save you time and improve your ROI
MeetEdgar
 
Part 1 - Making Social Media a Business Asset
Joel Arndt
 
Keys to successful social media
Margarita Stoimenova
 
Social media tips, tricks, and myths
Rebecca Joy Borough, MSSE
 
Building Your Social Media Following: Tips and Tricks
Debbie Goetz Media Connections, LLC
 
Why 1 Million Social Media Followers Sucks, WebCongress May 2014
Erica McGillivray
 
Social Media Marketing Mistakes Even Experts are Committing - FloTape
FloTape
 
Data Driven Social Media Webcast
Argyle Social
 
Branding Your Company Socially
Expand Socially, LLC
 
Ad

More from Mackenzie Fogelson (16)

PPTX
Building High Performing, Self-Managed Teams
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PPTX
Evolve or Die: How Purpose and Authenticity are the Future of Brands
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PPTX
Why Content Strategy Isn't Enough
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Establishing Focused Marketing Goals - WistiaFest 2015
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Conversion Optimization Beyond The Landing Page - Unwebinar
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
The Measurement Behind Your Integrated Marketing Strategy
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Growing Your Business Through Community and Integrated Marketing
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Building Your Business on Meaning and Purpose - 3 Steps to Building an Authen...
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
An Integrated Approach to Video
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
The Integrated Marketing KPIs of Using Video to Build Your Brand
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
The Essentials of Community Building by Mack Fogelson
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
A Community Collaboration Framework
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Are We There Yet? A 12-Month Community Building Case Study
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Build a Better Business with Digital Marketing
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
PDF
Content Balance: Sharing Value vs. Self-Promotion
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
KEY
Guide to-google+-and-your-business
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Building High Performing, Self-Managed Teams
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Evolve or Die: How Purpose and Authenticity are the Future of Brands
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Why Content Strategy Isn't Enough
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Establishing Focused Marketing Goals - WistiaFest 2015
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Conversion Optimization Beyond The Landing Page - Unwebinar
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
The Measurement Behind Your Integrated Marketing Strategy
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Growing Your Business Through Community and Integrated Marketing
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Building Your Business on Meaning and Purpose - 3 Steps to Building an Authen...
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
An Integrated Approach to Video
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
The Integrated Marketing KPIs of Using Video to Build Your Brand
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
The Essentials of Community Building by Mack Fogelson
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
A Community Collaboration Framework
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Are We There Yet? A 12-Month Community Building Case Study
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Build a Better Business with Digital Marketing
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Content Balance: Sharing Value vs. Self-Promotion
Mackenzie Fogelson
 
Guide to-google+-and-your-business
Mackenzie Fogelson
 

Recently uploaded (9)

PDF
Creative Social Media Campaign Strategies That Inspire Action.pdf
revathimsr06
 
PPTX
Top Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Social Media Agency in Chicago
Moz Web Media
 
PPTX
Social Media & Research Dissemination - REPORT IN PUBLICATION.V2.pptx
arvielobos1
 
PDF
Pride Month 2025: Engagement, Sentiment & Digital Silence
PRophet
 
PDF
SAMPLING AND PROCEDURE AND THE SAMPLE RESEARCH
WencyCastaneda
 
PDF
un mundo lleno de datos que lo cambia todo
JorgeSilesCabrera1
 
PDF
2025’s Best Posting Schedule for Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn & More.pdf
ManojNegi
 
PDF
the concept and the pdf of a seo course.pdf
r62544400
 
PPTX
How Discursive Alliances Shift: A Longitudinal Analysis of Australian Climate...
Axel Bruns
 
Creative Social Media Campaign Strategies That Inspire Action.pdf
revathimsr06
 
Top Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Social Media Agency in Chicago
Moz Web Media
 
Social Media & Research Dissemination - REPORT IN PUBLICATION.V2.pptx
arvielobos1
 
Pride Month 2025: Engagement, Sentiment & Digital Silence
PRophet
 
SAMPLING AND PROCEDURE AND THE SAMPLE RESEARCH
WencyCastaneda
 
un mundo lleno de datos que lo cambia todo
JorgeSilesCabrera1
 
2025’s Best Posting Schedule for Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn & More.pdf
ManojNegi
 
the concept and the pdf of a seo course.pdf
r62544400
 
How Discursive Alliances Shift: A Longitudinal Analysis of Australian Climate...
Axel Bruns
 

Why Follower Count is Bullshit